This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Sooooo many words Jamie, soooooo many
My username has nothing to do with my religious beliefs |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 25 Feb 2015 4.04pm
Quote reborn at 25 Feb 2015 3.53pm
Quote Catfish at 21 Feb 2015 9.41pm
Well done Jamie. I really could not be bothered knocking down this creationist tosh. I admire your patience. There really is no point trying to start a sensible conversation with people who believe in magic floods, talking snakes, levitation and Giants. It is a bit like believing in Harry Potter.
It's your prerogative to think Creationism is fairy tales, but the science behind Darwin's theory is flawed and has massive holes in it. The fossil record simply does not back it up The fossil record - in defiance of Darwin's whole idea of gradual change - often makes great leaps from one form to the next. Far from the display of intermediates to be expected from slow advance through natural selection many species appear without warning, persist in fixed form and disappear, leaving no descendants. Geology assuredly does not reveal any finely graduated organic chain, and this is the most obvious and gravest objection which can be urged against the theory of evolution.” (Almost Like a Whale, p. 252)
Grow up FFS..... do you still believe in Santa Claus? It doesn't, those are irrelevant to scientific models. Evolution simply is about random selection within environmental influences. Evolution actually allows for God creating humans from a shared chimpanzee ancestor (or rather several species of humans from that ancestor), provided God occurred through scientifically plausible means. As this cannot be demonstrated then the aspect of random determinism through environmental fitness which has been demonstrated time and again, fits better. That's the beauty of science, it isn't about truth, its about what you can show to be probable and the most probable outcome. There is room for a or many Gods (or goddesses), you just have to reasonably demonstrate a need for god, or the existence of god. The problem is that people assume that science and religion are about what is true, rather than being about trying to construct models for understanding the experience of existence.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote reborn at 25 Feb 2015 4.58pm
Sooooo many words Jamie, soooooo many Simple answers, are usually wrong. I believe that the more you understand and express as subject the closer you get to the 'truth' (for want of a better word). Whether that's god, evolution, science, its all really about the resolution of discourses in society. The more we learn, think and interact, the greater our experience of existence becomes. The greater our experience, the more we understand. I don't disbelieve in god, gods or goddesses, so much as think they're products of the knowledge of their times. When the Sumer started to write, and probably created the first written language used by 'modern humans', the events in the Old Testament would have been passed through countless generations orally and developed in the telling. The past is both true and fiction, at the same time, even in the modern age, different generations will adapt stories and events towards their own 'exitential' being, without realizing it. I always thought that the most prophetic statement in the old testament is the idea that existence begins, with a word. That language, which is the centre of all human experience, is the means by which existence begins and comes around. Thousands of years later, there is a truth there, that language is more important than almost anything else in human existence, and it is also unique to humans (more or less). Its something we take for granted, and overlook. But for that person, who first wrote that phrase, they were onto something, which even as an atheist, gets my skin tingling, something that is so sublime, and yet so simple, whilst being incredibly complicated. It can explain what you had for dinner, or how to construct a means by to split atoms.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
As for the rapid appearance of new species in the fossil record, this isn't necessarily disproval of evolution either, it would be kind of what you would expect to see when there was significant 'environmental changes', which would see the more rapid development of species with traits that are now beneficial. Remember that a species and its traits are not fixed, and traits develop randomly, provided they are not detrimental, they survive in a species. You can see this in the 'Dinosaur extinction'. The rapid drop in surface temperatures, made large, cold blooded reptiles poorly suited to the now sparse, rapidly cooling environment (Mammals expend about 60% of their energy from food maintaining a body temperature - where as reptiles rely on external heat). Where as small mammals were now much 'fitted', allowing them to rapidly develop due to the accelerating demise of the reptile species that previously dominated. Consequently the population of mammals expands rapidly, and variations in these now benefical traits spreads throughout the species, combining with other traits in the species (a species that has reduced predators and increased dominance of food sources breeds rapidly). Remember that a lot of species, like the mammals of the pre-ice age eras, were further down the food chain and one of the most prevalent means of combating the 'Your for Dinner effect' is to produce off spring in numbers and rapidly - which has to be evolved out of the species itself (slow birth traits as they become benefical proliferate). You'd expect to see this to some degree in any kind of environmental factor (bursts of development, rather than a slow and steady progress). Changes in the factors outside the species are as important, if not more important than the development of traits. Evidence for this can be seen in how species of animals population rates change in accordance to environmental factors. Remember the fastest cheetah isn't necessarily the best cheetah. Likewise, the fastest strongest hunter is largely rendered irrelivent by the bloke who thinks of farming.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Hoof Hearted at 26 Feb 2015 9.48am
Quote reborn at 25 Feb 2015 4.32pm
Quote Hoof Hearted at 25 Feb 2015 4.04pm
Quote reborn at 25 Feb 2015 3.53pm
Quote Catfish at 21 Feb 2015 9.41pm
Well done Jamie. I really could not be bothered knocking down this creationist tosh. I admire your patience. There really is no point trying to start a sensible conversation with people who believe in magic floods, talking snakes, levitation and Giants. It is a bit like believing in Harry Potter.
It's your prerogative to think Creationism is fairy tales, but the science behind Darwin's theory is flawed and has massive holes in it. The fossil record simply does not back it up The fossil record - in defiance of Darwin's whole idea of gradual change - often makes great leaps from one form to the next. Far from the display of intermediates to be expected from slow advance through natural selection many species appear without warning, persist in fixed form and disappear, leaving no descendants. Geology assuredly does not reveal any finely graduated organic chain, and this is the most obvious and gravest objection which can be urged against the theory of evolution.” (Almost Like a Whale, p. 252)
Grow up FFS..... do you still believe in Santa Claus? Childish response, but it beggars the question, why are you so angry?
I'm angry that billions of people waste their time believing this rubbish, and worse... killing each other in the name of religion because they cannot agree which is the true faith....... Mindless! They'd be killing each other in the name of something else, whether it was democracy, access to natural resources and so on. Its also not generalization that's applicable to all religion either. People kill one another, fight wars and commit genocide for any number of very reasons. Don't mistake stupidity and gulliability as being the exclusive fault of religion. Wars are almost always about resources, economic power and geo-political power (often about maintaining an existing power basis, or removing a threat to power). We don't fight wars for religion per se, we tend to divide the factions along convenient lines of difference. Islamism, isn't really about Muslims and Islam, its about political power not religion.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
The religious are innately inferior.
|
|
|
Outside the laws of physics everything is just an opinion.
The mountains are calling & I must go. |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Ouzo Dan at 28 Feb 2015 1.12am
Outside the laws of physics everything is just an opinion. Even inside, quantum theory postulates probable models.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.