Quote derben at 03 Jun 2015 12.48pm
Quote serial thriller at 03 Jun 2015 12.39pm
Quote derben at 03 Jun 2015 12.31pm
Quote serial thriller at 03 Jun 2015 12.05pm
Quote derben at 01 Jun 2015 8.24am
Certainly Capitalism is characterised by boom and bust, it is a sort of Darwinian survival of the fittest. The profit motive makes for efficiency and is geared to supplying people with what they want, not what a government says they should want. Socialism is characterised by bust and bust, telling people what they want and restricting personal freedom.
I would say all of the East European ex-Communist countries are better off now, in particular compare Albania then and now. Hold a referendum in all those countries and ask them if they would like to return to the old system - you would have record percentages of votes saying 'no'.
Cuba is a family run dictatorship with crumbling building and ancient jalopies on the streets, with a significant part of the population engaged in 'illegal' economic activities because the state bans them and tries to carry them out in hopelessly inefficient ways via the state sector.
In Laos a third of the population lives below the international poverty line. Laos has one of the lowest annual incomes in the world. In 2013, Laos ranked in 138th place on the Human Development Index. Laos ranks as the 25th hungriest nation in the world out of the list of the 56 nations with the worst hunger situations. Laos has had a poor human rights record, especially with their acts of genocide towards its Hmong population.
Venezula would certainly have ups and downs under Capitalism with oil being a key to their economy. But once again, they will just have downs under a Socialist economy.
Captialism tends to be two steps forward and one back. Socialism tends to be one step forward and two back.
Apologies I've been out of the conversation for a while, but I couldn't miss out on putting a few of these things right 
Capitalism as 'survival of the fittest': Darwin himself was keen to stress that his theory of natural biology shouldn't be adapted for more generalised political point-scoring. It's similar to the 'Capitalism is human nature' argument, a sign of such total indoctrination in a belief system that you begin to suppose there can be no other way, just as Romans believed the Roman Empire to be divinely supported and sent to free the world. Capitalism is only about 300 years old though, whereas humans are millions of years old. Why didn't cavemen start seizing the means of production from workers if Capitalism is so innate?
And who exactly are the 'fittest' in Capitalist society? A Russian oligarch who bribes, money launders and murders his way to billions? A CEO of an oil company who massacres tribes in the rainforest, pollutes the environment and silences criticism to make sure he keeps hold of his fortune? Or maybe a banker who rigs financial rates, speculates away billions of public money and spends their squillions on coke and whores? If that's the cream of the crop, I don't really wanna be in the crop!
It confuses me as well why you so willingly disregard the positive social benefits which socialism can bring. Look at the rates of absolute poverty in Venezuela before and after Chavez, look at literacy rates in Cuba in contrast to its neighbours, look at how Nicaragua promoted women's rights (before the Americans got involved). As I have said, these places aren't perfect, but your rose-tinted view on these societies is as bad as someone on the left unanimously defending them, and fails to comprehend that many in Venezuela, Cuba, Uruguay etc. support the socialist governments.
Wealth has never been more concentrated, nor society so economically unequal, as it is today. We continue to rely on slavery to drive our cheap-commodity economy, we have resource wars developing across the globe and environmental exploitation is perpetuating all of this, while killing millions in the poorest countries on earth. Don't kid yourself that Capitalism will do anything other than bring civilisation to its knees.
Your rose-tinted view of Cuba makes me laugh, as I said before, a family run dictatorship with crumbling building and ancient jalopies on the streets, with a significant part of the population engaged in 'illegal' economic activities because the state bans them and tries to carry them out in hopelessly inefficient ways via the state sector. Have a referendum there asking them if they would like a Capitalist economy and democracy. Uruguay and Venezuela are democratic and of course not fully Socialist, they would of course go downhill and cease to be democracies if they were.
Capitalism "killing millions in the poorest countries on earth", "Capitalism will do anything other than bring civilisation to its knees". I think Pol Pot had a good go at the latter. China and the USSR managed to kill millions upon millions of their own people.
Why don't you tell us how much the North Koreans love their leader?
I have said it a couple of times already but I guess I'll have to say it again. I DON'T SUPPORT CUBA. They have a woeful policy on the lgbt community, are brutal to dissidents and their politics, from the little I know of it, is riddled with corruption. BUT there are dozens of capitalist countries in every single continent on the globe where the same can be said, and what I'm trying to make you do is to view all states, regimes and governments as having both positive and negative traits, rather than all Socialist societies being bad, and all capitalist ones being good.
And why is Cuba 'fully socialist' but Venezuela and Uruguay aren't?
I sadly don't have the necessary money or willpower to carry out these referendums you ask of me, but I do want to ask you one question: what would your criticism be of a non-authoritarian socialist society, like the Paris commune, revolutionary Catalonia or the Kurds in Syria?
And I haven't said all Capitalist countries are great or successful or democratic; although the more democratic they are, the more successful they tend to be. The Paris Commune lasted a couple of months didn't it - and that was spent fighting, how can anyone judge its worth? Revolutionary Catalonia the same, in a chaotic war (with the left inflicting as much damage on each other as the Fascists did - read Orwell's Homage to Catalonia). Kurds in Syria - again in a chaotic war.
Cuba is more Socialist than Uruguay and Venezuela because Cuba has practically everything under state control, with the inevitable inefficiencies, empty shelves etc, Uruguay and Venezeula still have lots of private (Capitalist) businesses, the fruits of which pay for their Socialist policies.
'The more democratic they are, the more successful they tend to be'. That just couldn't be further from the truth. China is the most successful Capitalist country on the planet and it has next to no democratic apparatus. America's highest growth rates were when it could deploy slavery in the 19th century, even aside from global powerhouses, Italy's fastest growing spell under Capitalism was in the 70s, when it was totally riddled with corruption, same with Greece. In contrast, attempts at truly configuring democracy have often been repressed and destroyed. The Nicuraguan revolution attempted to enact radical democracy but faced massive dissent from American-funded contras. Similar story in the examples I listed. Even going back to Athens, the most famous example of democracy, their democratic system lasted about 150 years before Alexander the Great came along. Democracy has never been able to withstand imperialism, as we are seeing in Venezuela.
Your final point is almost as ridiculous. Nowhere in all of Marx's writings will you find any connection between Socialism and authoritarianism. Communism itself is a word suggestive of localised government, and as I have pointed out there are many examples of Socialism in practice being far more libertarian than any Capitalist society on the planet.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4
|