Quote sydtheeagle at 21 Sep 2015 1.47pm
Quote The Sash at 21 Sep 2015 1.30pm
Pretty much yes - England still lack balance and real consistent quality for me. Like I said they are decent, good on their day but have a mental fragility that very good sides don't have.
I think Lancaster has done a good job on the whole in steadying a sinking ship from the disasters of the last regime and has taken them forward but ultimately is a bit limited as a coach.
His selections at times are baffling and the not picking players outside of the Premiership is ridiculous. English players bettering themselves in France like Armitage, getting plaudits all round for their performances in arguably the strongest league in Europe and he wont get in...
I fancy the Aussies to do well as well and do expect them to win the group.
Sash -- Bomber is still a case of two steps forward, one step back. Our problems as I see it are:
1. Still don't have a fetcher 7. Robshaw isn't an openside (and nor is Tom Wood) and it shows. (You are so right about Fatty Armitage).
2. Hartley is massive loss. Tom Youngs may be useful in the loose but he can't hook and he can't scrummage. Both are useful qualities for a hooker.
3. Lawes ditto the above. Massive tackler in the loose, but underpowered in the engine room.
4. Barritt may be an excellent defensive organiser but he offers absolutely nothing else. Stop and count to 10 once the ball gets beyond Ford.
5. Burgess took about two minutes to get caught out of position defensively. God knows what will happen when he faces someone like SBW who will target him. Fine, he's useful with the ball in hand but he's not a (union) rugby player.
6. Ford has a future but he's not a world-cup winning 10 right now. Ditto Faz: why is daddy still bringing him to work?
7. If we're really honest, we have no depth at 9. Youngs can't play every minute of every game and Wrigglesworth was simply miles behind the play when he came on on Saturday. He was getting to the breakdown so late that the quality of his passing became almost irrelevant.
ABs did not really impress on Sunday but then they didn't really need to. Comfortably the side to beat, which is not to say they will win it. Agree with you about the Wobs...they finally have a pack to go with their ability behind the scrum. France can't be predicted but if they show up in the knock-out stages, they may be in the conversation. Which the Bokke aren't and never were.
I think we have a slim chance...certainly not no chance but not a good chance either. Look for one of the hookers to "get injured" this week or next and Hartley, now his suspension is over, to come back in by the way.
Don't disagree with any of that Syd to be honest...just to add my two penneth
1. We do get shown up by not having that specialist 7 - Open side is a bit of an art and we continue to make do.
2. Tom Youngs is a good ball carrier as you say but on top of his scrummaging limitations every line out is a disaster waiting to happen
3. Courtney's a lump and athletic for a lock but does his best work defending rather than going forward for me. Word class locks do both.
4. BB is a defensive centre and has absolutely none of the go forward or flair you need - Burrell must be spitting.
5. How Burgess got in I am still scratching my head - 5 minutes of Union and he's and international ????
6. I honestly think Forde is overrated at the moment, ditto OF - England arguably haven't had a good one since JW
7. Yep - Wiggly is not an international scrum half end of.
Its not that England are a bad side, they aren't, they just lack that extra bit which says 'champions' and I mean of anything, World Cup or 6N
The biggest bright spot recently is that they have finally stopped Johnny May from running sideways very fast and pointed him in the right direction.
Edited by The Sash (21 Sep 2015 2.03pm)
As far as the rules go, it's a website not a democracy - Hambo 3/6/2014
|