You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works
November 22 2026 1.19am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Austerity Works


Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Stuk Flag Top half 05 Feb 16 5.00pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

What is it about what she said that you disagree with?

How is an interview about a book about austerity tenuous to a thread about austerity?

Edited by nickgusset (05 Feb 2016 4.44pm)

I already informed you that I haven't looked at it, and I won't be doing so.

Finding anything on a site like Russia today to support your argument is called clutching at straws.

This one isn't actually that tenuous but you would post a link to the dictionary definition of the word just to bump this thread yet again. It's very dull to keep seeing your propaganda threads reappear as soon as they've dropped off/gone quiet.

I'm going to guesstimate that you have bumped over 100 times between this thread, look what you've done and Corbyn. And I've pointed this out to you before.

I'd quite like the mods to lock them all as it's that predictable.

 


Optimistic as ever

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Feb 16 5.05pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I already informed you that I haven't looked at it, and I won't be doing so.

Finding anything on a site like Russia today to support your argument is called clutching at straws.

This one isn't actually that tenuous but you would post a link to the dictionary definition of the word just to bump this thread yet again. It's very dull to keep seeing your propaganda threads reappear as soon as they've dropped off/gone quiet.

I'm going to guesstimate that you have bumped over 100 times between this thread, look what you've done and Corbyn. And I've pointed this out to you before.

I'd quite like the mods to lock them all as it's that predictable.

[Link]

[Link]

Rather than coming out with your non argument - 'I didn't read it', why don't you enlighten us as to why you think austerity is working.
Do you not think the fact that austerity isn't working is important, or are you flippantly dismissing the evidence because it goes against your own opinions.

BTW, the 2 links above are from more 'esteemed' sources. Worth a read and fully backed up with evidence and data.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 05 Feb 16 5.12pm

A billy blog is an esteemed source to you is it?

And I use today's news, not last April's.

 


Optimistic as ever

matt_himself Flag Matataland 05 Feb 16 5.43pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I already informed you that I haven't looked at it, and I won't be doing so.

Finding anything on a site like Russia today to support your argument is called clutching at straws.

This one isn't actually that tenuous but you would post a link to the dictionary definition of the word just to bump this thread yet again. It's very dull to keep seeing your propaganda threads reappear as soon as they've dropped off/gone quiet.

I'm going to guesstimate that you have bumped over 100 times between this thread, look what you've done and Corbyn. And I've pointed this out to you before.

I'd quite like the mods to lock them all as it's that predictable.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 05 Feb 16 6.12pm

Originally posted by Stuk

I already informed you that I haven't looked at it, and I won't be doing so.

Finding anything on a site like Russia today to support your argument is called clutching at straws.

This one isn't actually that tenuous but you would post a link to the dictionary definition of the word just to bump this thread yet again. It's very dull to keep seeing your propaganda threads reappear as soon as they've dropped off/gone quiet.

I'm going to guesstimate that you have bumped over 100 times between this thread, look what you've done and Corbyn. And I've pointed this out to you before.

I'd quite like the mods to lock them all as it's that predictable.

In the past you've moaned that I've started a new thread when 'there already is one'.
Make your mind up!
If you don't like what I've posted, state why with counter arguments. If not STFU moaning.

 

-TUX- Flag Alphabettispaghetti 05 Feb 16 7.17pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

In the past you've moaned that I've started a new thread when 'there already is one'.
Make your mind up!
If you don't like what I've posted, state why with counter arguments. If not STFU moaning.

Maybe 'Stuk' just can't handle the fact that 'austerity measures' also costs him money, just like 99% of us.
It's Friendly Friday, so go easy on the blinkered.

 


Time to move forward together.

crystal balls Flag The Garden of Earthly Delights 05 Feb 16 9.53pm

Of course "austerity" doesn't work; it was never going to and I don't believe that Osborne thought for a minute that it would. It was simply a way of implementing ideological policies to shrink the role of government and let the private sector take over.

The national debt has doubled and not one target set by the chancellor has been met. But who cares, the NHS is now ripe for privatisation and will be left to go the way of care homes, energy and transport, in private hands but still costing the taxpayer billions.

Energy costs are double in the UK what they are in Germany, we are less productive than we were 6 years ago and the economy is still massively unbalanced. Nice one Gideon, you knob!

 


I used to be immortal

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 06 Feb 16 12.09am

Originally posted by crystal balls

Of course "austerity" doesn't work; it was never going to and I don't believe that Osborne thought for a minute that it would. It was simply a way of implementing ideological policies to shrink the role of government and let the private sector take over.

The national debt has doubled and not one target set by the chancellor has been met. But who cares, the NHS is now ripe for privatisation and will be left to go the way of care homes, energy and transport, in private hands but still costing the taxpayer billions.

Energy costs are double in the UK what they are in Germany, we are less productive than we were 6 years ago and the economy is still massively unbalanced. Nice one Gideon, you knob!

Very well put. It is refreshing to read an informed comment.

Unfortunately I will be dead when the historians are writing that Thatcher, the woman elected to make Britain great again, become popular by retrieving an island that her incompetence lost in the first place,
then set in track neo-liberal policies that ended with the Scots leaving the Union for Europe and turned Great Britain into little England.


Edited by Bert the Head (06 Feb 2016 12.21am)

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 14 Feb 16 12.04am

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Quote DanH at 16 Dec 2015 10.29am

Given that 7 years ago we entered the biggest clusterf*ck of a recession since the war and we're still not fully recovered now I'd hardly say that's that remarkable or anything to do with austerity.


The recession in the 70s was far worse.

The recession of the 70s was far worse for everyone. It was about the middle east countries agreeing a deal to hike up oil prices. The west was on the receiving end. This time the high earners have been untouched. Its been good for them. So luxury goods have boomed. Its middle lower incomes have felt it.


 

Hoof Hearted 14 Feb 16 11.13am

Originally posted by Bert the Head

Very well put. It is refreshing to read an informed comment.

Unfortunately I will be dead when the historians are writing that Thatcher, the woman elected to make Britain great again, become popular by retrieving an island that her incompetence lost in the first place,
then set in track neo-liberal policies that ended with the Scots leaving the Union for Europe and turned Great Britain into little England.


Edited by Bert the Head (06 Feb 2016 12.21am)

..... And no one will be writing about you Bert and your blinkered views... Epsom's Citizen Smith... LOL

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 14 Feb 16 11.33am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

..... And no one will be writing about you Bert and your blinkered views... Epsom's Citizen Smith... LOL

I'd say that Bert has his eyes open to what is happenening and you sir are the one wearing blinkers.

 

Hoof Hearted 14 Feb 16 11.37am

Originally posted by nickgusset

I'd say that Bert has his eyes open to what is happenening and you sir are the one wearing blinkers.

Mandy Rice-Davies style response to you Gusset ....... "Well you would say that, wouldn't you?"

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 17 Feb 16 9.58pm

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

..... And no one will be writing about you Bert and your blinkered views... Epsom's Citizen Smith... LOL

No they wont be. But I never thought I was in that league tbh.

They will be writing about how Great Britain became little England, though. That was my point. Why not address that instead of the abuse stuff. I don't mind abuse either when its original and funny and not some antiquated "you is a red what is in the bed you is Nana nanana" Daily Express stuff.

Why not do yourself a favour and read something more challenging. I suggest Chomsky. Honest, Hoofy -by Chapter 2 of anything he has written - you'll be on the virtual Barricades with me. Just have a little peek at `World Order, Old and New', or `Deterring Democracy' or `Failed States' and see for yourself. Did you actually know that Maggie supported Pol Pot after he did the genocide stuff? All those people killed and she routing for him. Imagine that! Its fact. Not reported much because its kind of awkward and unless its Corbyn the press don't do foreign policy awkward much. Its a power thing. Read Chomsky and you'll realize that that Daily Express is messing with your head; or more straight-forwardly being economical with the truth to you - who else said that?


Edited by Bert the Head (17 Feb 2016 10.28pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 18 Feb 16 11.23am

Originally posted by Bert the Head

No they wont be. But I never thought I was in that league tbh.

They will be writing about how Great Britain became little England, though. That was my point. Why not address that instead of the abuse stuff. I don't mind abuse either when its original and funny and not some antiquated "you is a red what is in the bed you is Nana nanana" Daily Express stuff.

Why not do yourself a favour and read something more challenging. I suggest Chomsky. Honest, Hoofy -by Chapter 2 of anything he has written - you'll be on the virtual Barricades with me. Just have a little peek at `World Order, Old and New', or `Deterring Democracy' or `Failed States' and see for yourself. Did you actually know that Maggie supported Pol Pot after he did the genocide stuff? All those people killed and she routing for him. Imagine that! Its fact. Not reported much because its kind of awkward and unless its Corbyn the press don't do foreign policy awkward much. Its a power thing. Read Chomsky and you'll realize that that Daily Express is messing with your head; or more straight-forwardly being economical with the truth to you - who else said that?


Edited by Bert the Head (17 Feb 2016 10.28pm)


I recommend having a read of this... [Link]


Also in the news. Biggest annual rise in deaths for 50 years. [Link]

This austerity lark is going well... More detail here. [Link]


 

silvertop Flag Portishead 18 Feb 16 12.20pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head

No they wont be. But I never thought I was in that league tbh.

They will be writing about how Great Britain became little England, though. That was my point. Why not address that instead of the abuse stuff. I don't mind abuse either when its original and funny and not some antiquated "you is a red what is in the bed you is Nana nanana" Daily Express stuff.

Why not do yourself a favour and read something more challenging. I suggest Chomsky. Honest, Hoofy -by Chapter 2 of anything he has written - you'll be on the virtual Barricades with me. Just have a little peek at `World Order, Old and New', or `Deterring Democracy' or `Failed States' and see for yourself. Did you actually know that Maggie supported Pol Pot after he did the genocide stuff? All those people killed and she routing for him. Imagine that! Its fact. Not reported much because its kind of awkward and unless its Corbyn the press don't do foreign policy awkward much. Its a power thing. Read Chomsky and you'll realize that that Daily Express is messing with your head; or more straight-forwardly being economical with the truth to you - who else said that?

And apartheid, and Pinochet and just about every other despot who was not on the left.

As I have said, I am conflicted about that woman. The world that existed before her was awful. The 70s were a worse recession because the left had screwed this country up so badly. Maggie was necessary... And then she was ghastly too.

I envy those who can say they categorically love or detest a woman who justifies both reactions.

On topic, you can look at austerity in two ways. On one level, the reaction of the worlds financial markets suggest that it represents prudence and good order - a safe pair of hands. We are able to secure cheap long term credit and our economy has experienced constant growth, albeit subject to an underlying weak base. Moreover, is shrinking the public sector really that bad? The NHS is simply unsustainable with a growing population depending on a shrinking working population. The same applies elsewhere in the state sector. I work in local government and have seen our office space reduced by half along with the workforce with all but no substantive impact on front line services. It needs trimming. However, I suspect we have now reached tipping point. Central government want us to shrink even further. There are only so many money generating schemes and piling of increasing work on fewer staff who have not even received a cost of living raise in wage since the recession. As always, the Tories have the right idea but go too far.

Which brings me to the other way of viewing things. It is the financial sector that screwed us up. Not the public sector. Not the workforce. Not even the unions! Eye-watering sums of taxpayers money have been channeled into propping that sector up. Some of that money will come back. Most will not even though the financial sector has recovered well as a consequence of state intervention. How is the funding gap filled? Austerity cuts. That is, the poor are being compelled to support the rich.

This reverse Robin Hood is not some namby-pamby lefty liberal nonsense, it is borne out in government statistics that evidence a widening gap between rich and poor. You can see it in every day life. An affluent part of bristol is clifton. For generations huge Victorian houses have been split into flats. Now there is a tendency for single wealthy persons to acquire a whole block and covert back to a single dwelling.

So what's my position? Given this country would collapse without the financial sector it is obvious it had to be done. The state sector has been in mission creep since Bevan - Lord knows it needed paring down. However, there needs to be intelligence and balance. Not everything can be done by the private sector. And I fear we may be falling victim to ideological Tory hatred of the public sector, informed more by its history of conflict with them than by a genuine desire to see that the population receive the best possible service from scarce resources.


Edited by Bert the Head (17 Feb 2016 10.28pm)

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 18 Feb 16 12.30pm

Originally posted by nickgusset

I'd say that Bert has his eyes open to what is happenening and you sir are the one wearing blinkers.

I'd suggest that everyone on here has their eyes well and truly open...its just they simply choose to see what they want.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 18 Feb 16 12.32pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head

No they wont be. But I never thought I was in that league tbh.

They will be writing about how Great Britain became little England, though. That was my point. Why not address that instead of the abuse stuff. I don't mind abuse either when its original and funny and not some antiquated "you is a red what is in the bed you is Nana nanana" Daily Express stuff.

Why not do yourself a favour and read something more challenging. I suggest Chomsky. Honest, Hoofy -by Chapter 2 of anything he has written - you'll be on the virtual Barricades with me. Just have a little peek at `World Order, Old and New', or `Deterring Democracy' or `Failed States' and see for yourself. Did you actually know that Maggie supported Pol Pot after he did the genocide stuff? All those people killed and she routing for him. Imagine that! Its fact. Not reported much because its kind of awkward and unless its Corbyn the press don't do foreign policy awkward much. Its a power thing. Read Chomsky and you'll realize that that Daily Express is messing with your head; or more straight-forwardly being economical with the truth to you - who else said that?


Edited by Bert the Head (17 Feb 2016 10.28pm)

How did we become Great Britain in your eyes? Exploiting others, countries and slavery in order to kick start the Industrial revolution on their collective backs (?)

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 18 Feb 16 11.48pm

Originally posted by Lyons550


How did we become Great Britain in your eyes? Exploiting others, countries and slavery in order to kick start the Industrial revolution on their collective backs (?)


I think the term "Great Britain" comes from the fact that it is a big Island and Ireland "Little Britain" was smaller. I understands it goes back to Roman times.
So I think that's really how we become Great Britain.

But we certainly made a lot of money out of slavery or some of us did.

I'm more concerned about recent history, for example our role in over throwing a democratic government in Iran in 1953, supporting the nascent Islamic terrorists in Afghanistan in the 1980s; supporting Saddam Hussein and arming him with chemical weapons and supporting evil murderers like Pinochet and Pol Pot.

Basically I am kind of proud to be British and this stuff isn't supposed to be what we are about. Maybe I believe in a silly myth that doesn't stand up to scrutiny. But it's worth keep pushing for. Isn't it?


 

Stirlingsays Flag 19 Feb 16 1.40am

Originally posted by Bert the Head


I think the term "Great Britain" comes from the fact that it is a big Island and Ireland "Little Britain" was smaller. I understands it goes back to Roman times.
So I think that's really how we become Great Britain.

But we certainly made a lot of money out of slavery or some of us did.

I'm more concerned about recent history, for example our role in over throwing a democratic government in Iran in 1953, supporting the nascent Islamic terrorists in Afghanistan in the 1980s; supporting Saddam Hussein and arming him with chemical weapons and supporting evil murderers like Pinochet and Pol Pot.

Basically I am kind of proud to be British and this stuff isn't supposed to be what we are about. Maybe I believe in a silly myth that doesn't stand up to scrutiny. But it's worth keep pushing for. Isn't it?


Which country didn't make a lot of money out of slavery?

Slavery existed in every single country in the world. Money was made by the elites in every country. You appear to be complaining because western countries shipped their slavery between countries and industrialized it.

Slavery is slavery.

Britain was the first to outlaw it in the world.

The self important but 'self hating' left...... They moan like feck about historical privilege but the ones I've known grab every little opportunity for advantage that they can out of life.....the hypocrisy is lost on them.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Sportyteacher Flag London 19 Feb 16 7.38am

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

[Link]

Unemployment lowest for 10 years at 5.2%

Surely readers are not so gullible to believe this drivel. Factor in zero-hour contract positions; reappointed part-time positions that were previously full-time; apprenticeships that don't eventually deliver upon publicised employment etc.

It is both past and present Government ministerial practice to publish contrived data to convince the gullible electorate that policy decision-making IS working. Next, we'll start believing in the manipulated crime figures that are routinely peddled out. The trouble is that the electorate fails to properly scrutinise the methodology employed to produce such statistics.

 

Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Austerity Works