You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The left and Jewish people


Page 5 of 22 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
legaleagle Flag 27 Apr 16 6.47pm

Anti semitism unfortunately lurks at times between the cracks on all sides of the political spectrum,from elements of "The Right" right through to elements of the Labour left.Interestingly,when a public opinion survey was done last year on the topic,it revealed anti-semitic attitudes were most prevalent around the centre of the spectrum amongst Lib Dem voters.

Which is not a good reason not to condemn Naz Shah unconditionally for making some dodgy remarks, and shame on Corbyn for not taking a forceful position at the earliest opportunity,which no doubt he would have done had an MP made dodgy remarks about people of pakistani heritage for example,like Naz Shah.

 

Bert the Head Flag Epsom 27 Apr 16 6.55pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

More anti semitism from a Labour member holding office:

[Link]

When is the left going to recognise that the 'anti Israel' lobby has mutated into rabid anti semitism & do something about it?


Over the past few months the mainstream media have been awash with stories of anti semitism whether in the Labour Party, on student campuses, or within the Muslim community. Although these stories have highlighted a number of incidents of real anti semitism many have conflated anti semitism and anti Zionism or equated criticism of Israel and activism for the Palestinians with anti semitic views.

These accusations are part of a systematic attempt to close down debate and to shield Israel from criticism and political action in response to its treatment of Palestinians.

Please follow this link to an excellent article by Ben White which exposes this agenda [Link]


 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 27 Apr 16 6.56pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

Anti semitism unfortunately lurks at times between the cracks on all sides of the political spectrum,from elements of "The Right" right through to elements of the Labour left.Interestingly,when a public opinion survey was done last year on the topic,it revealed anti-semitic attitudes were most prevalent around the centre of the spectrum amongst Lib Dem voters.

Which is not a good reason not to condemn Naz Shah unconditionally for making some dodgy remarks, and shame on Corbyn for not taking a forceful position at the earliest opportunity,which no doubt he would have done had an MP made dodgy remarks about people of pakistani heritage for example,like Naz Shah.

How many Conservative MP's have made similar comments recently? Or Tory councillors?

It looks far more like a Labour/left problem to me at the moment and Labour should address it.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 27 Apr 16 7.01pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head


Over the past few months the mainstream media have been awash with stories of anti semitism whether in the Labour Party, on student campuses, or within the Muslim community. Although these stories have highlighted a number of incidents of real anti semitism many have conflated anti semitism and anti Zionism or equated criticism of Israel and activism for the Palestinians with anti semitic views.

These accusations are part of a systematic attempt to close down debate and to shield Israel from criticism and political action in response to its treatment of Palestinians.

Please follow this link to an excellent article by Ben White which exposes this agenda [Link]


I think you're the only one with an agenda, berty.
Drivel.

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

matt_himself Flag Matataland 27 Apr 16 7.08pm

Originally posted by Bert the Head


Over the past few months the mainstream media have been awash with stories of anti semitism whether in the Labour Party, on student campuses, or within the Muslim community. Although these stories have highlighted a number of incidents of real anti semitism many have conflated anti semitism and anti Zionism or equated criticism of Israel and activism for the Palestinians with anti semitic views.

These accusations are part of a systematic attempt to close down debate and to shield Israel from criticism and political action in response to its treatment of Palestinians.

Please follow this link to an excellent article by Ben White which exposes this agenda [Link]


If a right wing blog wrote an article defending islamophobia in the same manner that that blog appears to excuse anti semitism, you would be up in arms, denouncing the actions of the 'neo liberal elite'.

You don't half read some bollocks, Bertie.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Jamesrichards8 Flag 27 Apr 16 7.08pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Correct me if I am wrong but was it not some of those on the Right who nearly wiped the entire Jewish race off the face of the earth and neo-groups of similar persuasion keep that warped fantasy alive?

As for the councillor - she should be prosecuted and jailed if she has broken any law and I hope she has.

I'm only reading this now. But Kermit, I'm embarrassed for you. This is a cringeworthy argument.

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

legaleagle Flag 27 Apr 16 7.47pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

How many Conservative MP's have made similar comments recently? Or Tory councillors?

It looks far more like a Labour/left problem to me at the moment and Labour should address it.

That could be because you are viewing the matter through a partisan anti-left bias,Matthew.

Have a look at UKIP (the party you support,no?) before getting too smug in your self-righteousness about this being only a left problem.You support a party whose London Chairman was expelled from the party last month for an anti semitic utterance..

Or the former UKIP parliamentary candidate exposed in 2015 for being an anti semite

Or the UKIP candidate exposed in 2013 who said the second world war had been engineered by the jews (the same tosh that appears in the Hamas charter).

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

 

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 27 Apr 16 8.51pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

That could be because you are viewing the matter through a partisan anti-left bias,Matthew.

Have a look at UKIP (the party you support,no?) before getting too smug in your self-righteousness about this being only a left problem.You support a party whose London Chairman was expelled from the party last month for an anti semitic utterance..

Or the former UKIP parliamentary candidate exposed in 2015 for being an anti semite

Or the UKIP candidate exposed in 2013 who said the second world war had been engineered by the jews (the same tosh that appears in the Hamas charter).

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

Now they're out of work Labour can acquire their services. They'd fit nicely into that Palestinian/terrorist loving, Jew hating bunch of loonies.

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 27 Apr 16 9.03pm

Originally posted by legaleagle

That could be because you are viewing the matter through a partisan anti-left bias,Matthew.

Have a look at UKIP (the party you support,no?) before getting too smug in your self-righteousness about this being only a left problem.You support a party whose London Chairman was expelled from the party last month for an anti semitic utterance..

Or the former UKIP parliamentary candidate exposed in 2015 for being an anti semite

Or the UKIP candidate exposed in 2013 who said the second world war had been engineered by the jews (the same tosh that appears in the Hamas charter).

[Link]

[Link]

[Link]

So no Tories then, which was my question.

UKIP has said it has a zero tolerance in such unacceptable behaviour and acts accordingly

[Link]

Your view seems to be, and this is a prevailing one on here from the lefties, that it doesn't really matter. UKIP are viewed as having anti Semites and therefore having a sizeable number in Labour doesn't matter. Well that is wrong. Labours attitude stinks over this issue and highlights one of Corbyn's major failings, which is to publicly denounce and expel those who spread this evil. I bet this doesn't sit comfortably with you but you, like the rest of pinkos on here, feel the need to defend it by attacking the opposition. That is weak and is unforgivable.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 27 Apr 16 9.08pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

So no Tories then, which was my question.

UKIP has said it has a zero tolerance in such unacceptable behaviour and acts accordingly

[Link]

Your view seems to be, and this is a prevailing one on here from the lefties, that it doesn't really matter. UKIP are viewed as having anti Semites and therefore having a sizeable number in Labour doesn't matter. Well that is wrong. Labours attitude stinks over this issue and highlights one of Corbyn's major failings, which is to publicly denounce and expel those who spread this evil. I bet this doesn't sit comfortably with you but you, like the rest of pinkos on here, feel the need to defend it by attacking the opposition. That is weak and is unforgivable.

You're right it does stink. Of course Labour have always had these views but now they're becoming increasingly brazen about it.Jeremy Corbyn is very friendly with Palestinian terrorist groups so their attitude towards this comes as absolutely no surprise.

 

legaleagle Flag 27 Apr 16 9.27pm

Originally posted by matt_himself

So no Tories then, which was my question.

UKIP has said it has a zero tolerance in such unacceptable behaviour and acts accordingly

[Link]

Your view seems to be, and this is a prevailing one on here from the lefties, that it doesn't really matter. UKIP are viewed as having anti Semites and therefore having a sizeable number in Labour doesn't matter. Well that is wrong. Labours attitude stinks over this issue and highlights one of Corbyn's major failings, which is to publicly denounce and expel those who spread this evil. I bet this doesn't sit comfortably with you but you, like the rest of pinkos on here, feel the need to defend it by attacking the opposition. That is weak and is unforgivable.

Matthew,try not to do knee jerk responses sometimes.

If you read my posts on this thread,I think a reasonable person might have a difficult time concluding I'm not highly critical of anti semitism where it appears on the left.

Thing is,I'm equally critical of it on the right.Why not? The post of mine earlier this evening you responded to was about how the ugly cancer of anti semitism appears to me to pop up at times across the whole spectrum from right (UKIP are probably on the right,no?)to left.I pointed out how Lib Dem supporters (in the centre) seemed to be the worst.

Only someone with considerable bias could conclude I am somehow defending anti semitism on the left by posting about it also appearing on the right.Only someone who doesn't even read my posts on this thread could think I don't think anti semitism on the left "matters".

So when I post as I did tonight:

"(I)condemn Naz Shah unconditionally for making some dodgy remarks, and shame on Corbyn for not taking a forceful position at the earliest opportunity,which no doubt he would have done had an MP made dodgy remarks about people of pakistani heritage for example,like Naz Shah."

...its as if you don't even read it before composing a critical response aimed at what you perceive as posters on the HOL from the left.

You might have more objective credibility if you could be seen to be a bit more even handed rather than tunnel visioned. The thread you started here is a valid one for debate.I look forward to seeing you instigating one and contributing to it with equal vigour when (not if) the next incidence of anti semitic sentiments emanating from someone on the right of the political spectrum emerges.

Edited by legaleagle (27 Apr 2016 9.41pm)

 

matt_himself Flag Matataland 28 Apr 16 5.57am

Originally posted by legaleagle

Matthew,try not to do knee jerk responses sometimes.

If you read my posts on this thread,I think a reasonable person might have a difficult time concluding I'm not highly critical of anti semitism where it appears on the left.

Thing is,I'm equally critical of it on the right.Why not? The post of mine earlier this evening you responded to was about how the ugly cancer of anti semitism appears to me to pop up at times across the whole spectrum from right (UKIP are probably on the right,no?)to left.I pointed out how Lib Dem supporters (in the centre) seemed to be the worst.

Only someone with considerable bias could conclude I am somehow defending anti semitism on the left by posting about it also appearing on the right.Only someone who doesn't even read my posts on this thread could think I don't think anti semitism on the left "matters".

So when I post as I did tonight:

"(I)condemn Naz Shah unconditionally for making some dodgy remarks, and shame on Corbyn for not taking a forceful position at the earliest opportunity,which no doubt he would have done had an MP made dodgy remarks about people of pakistani heritage for example,like Naz Shah."

...its as if you don't even read it before composing a critical response aimed at what you perceive as posters on the HOL from the left.

You might have more objective credibility if you could be seen to be a bit more even handed rather than tunnel visioned. The thread you started here is a valid one for debate.I look forward to seeing you instigating one and contributing to it with equal vigour when (not if) the next incidence of anti semitic sentiments emanating from someone on the right of the political spectrum emerges.

Edited by legaleagle (27 Apr 2016 9.41pm)

Why did you feel the need to highlight some three year old UKIP stories? The overwhelming feeling is that whilst you pay lip service to the Naz Shah situation, you and the majority of lefties on here, really don't see it as a problem in Labour and by deflecting to UKIP matters of the past, you are brushing the matter under the carpet as a normal, almost acceptable, part of political activity.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

legaleagle Flag 28 Apr 16 9.43am

sigh......

So,in your reasoned and knowledgeable opinion ,I don't see anti semitism on the left as a problem and just pay lip service to condemning it?

Being Jewish myself ,it just conceivably might be that I take anti-semitism somewhat more seriously than you do, wherever it rears its ugly head along the political spectrum (right,centre and left), and condemn and oppose it more vigorously,but don't let facts get in the way of political prejudice,Matthew

Edited by legaleagle (28 Apr 2016 10.18am)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 28 Apr 16 9.49am

And now Rupa Huq has put her size 6s in it

[Link]

Edited by Y Ddraig Goch (28 Apr 2016 9.50am)

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Apr 16 9.54am

Originally posted by fed up eagle

Now they're out of work Labour can acquire their services. They'd fit nicely into that Palestinian/terrorist loving, Jew hating bunch of loonies.

Its debatable whether they actually are terrorists, given that the UN allows for resistance to occupation. 'Attacks' by Palestinian Terrorists seem to result in far less civilian casualties than 'Just Reprisals' from the Israeli state. Until it became a political necessity to do so, the US State Department did not regard acts of political violence in the occupied territories, or against the Israeli state as acts of terrorism.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

matt_himself Flag Matataland 28 Apr 16 10.30am

Originally posted by legaleagle

sigh......

So,in your reasoned and knowledgeable opinion ,I don't see anti semitism on the left as a problem and just pay lip service to condemning it?

Being Jewish myself ,it just conceivably might be that I take anti-semitism somewhat more seriously than you do, wherever it rears its ugly head along the political spectrum (right,centre and left), and condemn and oppose it more vigorously,but don't let facts get in the way of political prejudice,Matthew

Edited by legaleagle (28 Apr 2016 10.18am)

One can only judge you on what you write.

You were very keen to bring UKIP into a thread titled 'the left and Jewish people'. As this is a (mostly) anonymous message board, people won't know your background. The manner in which this came across was that you were politically driven and looking to drag elements of other political persuasions into the debate to placate your own leftish sensibilities.

If you want a broader debate on anti semitism in politics, go ahead and create a thread. I completely agree it is unacceptable in all forms and must be addressed as such.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

matt_himself Flag Matataland 28 Apr 16 10.31am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Its debatable whether they actually are terrorists, given that the UN allows for resistance to occupation. 'Attacks' by Palestinian Terrorists seem to result in far less civilian casualties than 'Just Reprisals' from the Israeli state. Until it became a political necessity to do so, the US State Department did not regard acts of political violence in the occupied territories, or against the Israeli state as acts of terrorism.

Total bollocks. They are terrorist attacks and make no mistake about it.

 


"That was fun and to round off the day, I am off to steal a charity collection box and then desecrate a place of worship.” - Smokey, The Selhurst Arms, 26/02/02

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 28 Apr 16 10.58am

So how far are we allowed to criticise violent and hawkish Israeli policy at home and certain elements' within their society theft of other peoples land before being branded anti-semitic?

I don't really go in for defending civilian and child-killers you see but if I'm thought of as some kind of Nazi for speaking out against it then i'd better watch my goose-step.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


npn Flag Crowborough 28 Apr 16 11.04am

Ah, the good old race card!

Criticising Israel and its actions is no more ant Semitic than criticising Saudi and its actions is anti Islamic.

There is, of course, a line to be trod carefully, that criticism of states doesn't spill over into criticism of peoples. In the same way that "Saudi behaviour is barbaric" is acceptable, "Muslims are barbaric" is not.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 28 Apr 16 11.14am

Originally posted by npn

Ah, the good old race card!

Criticising Israel and its actions is no more ant Semitic than criticising Saudi and its actions is anti Islamic.

There is, of course, a line to be trod carefully, that criticism of states doesn't spill over into criticism of peoples. In the same way that "Saudi behaviour is barbaric" is acceptable, "Muslims are barbaric" is not.

We stupid Westerners all squabble over what you can and can't say, meanwhile the religious nutters of this world continue to murder and maim.
But as long as we are all PC it will all be alright.

 

Page 5 of 22 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > The left and Jewish people