You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.
November 16 2026 11.44am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle fan- I come in peace.


Page 5 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 15 Aug 16 4.57pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

What difference does it make to you, of course you came here to gloat and say I told you so But we are a premiership club and you are losing at home to Huddersfield.

The only reason I don't want you to go down again is that you have Gayle, who was well liked here, even if he was deemed not quite up to the job for us.

Pardew or no Pardew, your fans are deluded and your posts on here show that nothing has changed.

You have had 3 managers since Pardew and yet here you are. Do you hope to achieve some sort of closure by posting on here.

I'm sure there is some sort of support group you could go to to get help or just go down the pub and try to forget.

I'm thinking a more appropriate name may have been Goldstone B. Ender - thinking about that I may have to start a new NSC account.

 


Red and Blue Army!

est1905 Flag 15 Aug 16 5.46pm

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

Not here to gloat or laugh or say we told you so.
But been reading palace fans on twitter and watching their games mainly via MOTD, nut really history is repeating.
The long winless runs, the baffling subs, the dreadful football, alienation of players (usually due to inability to man manage), the absolute spin "we play good attacking football" yet his teams are toothless.
At palace as at Newcastle, and his other clubs starts off well, gets his feet under the table then it all goes wrong.
It's down to his brilliance when the team win, but its bad luck, conspiracies, bad refs, the transfer window etc etc when it goes badly.

This man will ruin everything that's enjoyable about supporting your club. He'll divide the squad, divide the support and make it a pain in the arse to attend games because it's so dull.

I can see it has already started by skimming through this board. Don't fall into the trap of battered wife syndrome "well who else is better". Get out while you can

No mate, you want West Ham's message board and you're a bit late Alardyde is now the England manager. He left them a year ago.

 

TheFish Flag 16 Aug 16 3.13pm

Originally posted by Mr Palaceman

What difference does it make to you?

Newcastle fans were roundly derided for saying Pardew was a limited manager and an awful person. The "difference it makes" is that, despite it transpiring that Newcastle fans were right, there's been no acknowledgement of that.

Pardew escaped Newcastle with little blame for the situation at St James'. Ashley is a bad owner, no doubt, but Pardew contributed to the malaise at the club and certainly shoulders the majority of the responsibility for poor selections, substitutions, tactics and performances. A responsibility that friends in the media helped him avoid.

 

bodge Flag 16 Aug 16 4.33pm

Fans are unrealistic Palace are a small club with poor infrastructure and staying up is no easy task getting to a cup final was a bonus. Newcastle were under funded sold their best players and not only stayed up they finished in Europe doing very well in that comp. Take a look at the championship and you will see many teams who wanted a step up and got a step or two down.

 

Murray's the man Flag round ear 16 Aug 16 4.38pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

They do though they didnt have £44m of new signings on the pitch though.

Well that shows you don't need to spend millions to be a success. We got up running a tight ship and stayed up - its only since we've gone big time that we slip up.

Doesn't work for clubs like us. Never has

 


Johnny will return

Part Time James Flag 16 Aug 16 4.52pm

Am I the only one here that doesn't feel particularly cross when a supporter of a soon to be League One club comes on here to tell us our club is being run badly?

 




jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 16 Aug 16 4.55pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Newcastle fans were roundly derided for saying Pardew was a limited manager and an awful person. The "difference it makes" is that, despite it transpiring that Newcastle fans were right, there's been no acknowledgement of that.

Pardew escaped Newcastle with little blame for the situation at St James'. Ashley is a bad owner, no doubt, but Pardew contributed to the malaise at the club and certainly shoulders the majority of the responsibility for poor selections, substitutions, tactics and performances. A responsibility that friends in the media helped him avoid.

Presumably because the team was doing quite well. They were patchy. They also did do some very good business.

His substitutions, selections and tactics were so bad they were sitting in a good position for a top ten finish, and had some good campaigns.

Pardew is a good manager at the level of clubs like ours. But then Newcastle fans turn on all their managers very rapidly - Allerdyce anyone?

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

SussexShrew Flag Brighton 16 Aug 16 4.59pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3039372]

Huddersfield look decent

They did look decent in the first half last week against Shrewsbury... but not in the 2nd... and lost 2-1. And that was with virtually a full strength team and to a Shrewsbury side without Sullay!

So no, I hardly think a soured Newcastle Fan has much credibility coming onto this board and telling Palace how to structure the club, right after they lost to Huddersfield.

No doubt Newcastle will be back soon, money talks... but right now Palace are the bigger club.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 16 Aug 16 5.08pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3040392]

Well that shows you don't need to spend millions to be a success. We got up running a tight ship and stayed up - its only since we've gone big time that we slip up.

Doesn't work for clubs like us. Never has

I am not sure what clubs like "US" are any more than "THEM" but I understand the point that you make.

Firstly of course you can spend huge amounts of money and screw it up.... you can spend money you don't have; and no one is advocating that. It is possible to spend wisely and cheaply though there are huge limitations to that strategy. Players are valued at what they are for a reason and it wont be often that you can judge a players value better than the club that have them.

Ultimately if you want quality then it costs. That is the case in most areas of life and certainly is the case in Football. Don't forget that the new TV deal has driven football inflation even higher. Under the new TV deal £30m is what you have to pay for a £20-25m striker.


 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 16 Aug 16 5.17pm

Originally posted by TheFish

Newcastle fans were roundly derided for saying Pardew was a limited manager and an awful person. The "difference it makes" is that, despite it transpiring that Newcastle fans were right, there's been no acknowledgement of that.

Pardew escaped Newcastle with little blame for the situation at St James'. Ashley is a bad owner, no doubt, but Pardew contributed to the malaise at the club and certainly shoulders the majority of the responsibility for poor selections, substitutions, tactics and performances. A responsibility that friends in the media helped him avoid.


What we have learned is that Newcastle are s*** regardless of who the manager is

 

Painter Flag Croydon 16 Aug 16 5.25pm

Newcastle are destined to follow Leeds, their fans are deluded in thinking they are big clubs, but badly managed from the top was their downfall.
A bit pathetic they are still going on about Pardew, probably their most successful manager in recent times.

 

Murray's the man Flag round ear 16 Aug 16 5.51pm

Originally posted by SussexShrew

They did look decent in the first half last week against Shrewsbury... but not in the 2nd... and lost 2-1. And that was with virtually a full strength team and to a Shrewsbury side without Sullay!

So no, I hardly think a soured Newcastle Fan has much credibility coming onto this board and telling Palace how to structure the club, right after they lost to Huddersfield.

No doubt Newcastle will be back soon, money talks... but right now Palace are the bigger club.

With no disrespect to Shrewsbury, maybe it's not such a big game for them. I only saw highlights of Huddersfield first game, but they looked a decent outfit to me. Yes Toon have lost both opening games but it's early days.

I'm not sure I'd say the Newcastle fan is soured, but just sharing the experience they had with Pardew. One thing is certain that a lot of fans are worried about where the club is heading this season

 


Johnny will return

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 16 Aug 16 6.10pm

I always thought it a bit weird and quasi racist how we thought the Geordies were -- collectively -- idiots. You've just got to worry when a healthy majority of people watching a team week in, week out don't like what they see.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

sprites Flag Auckland 16 Aug 16 7.18pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Our only attacking options were wide players, it's not hard to predict and it's not hard to defend against us. We had absolutely no creativity through the middle, having to squeeze Championship-quality Lee into the no. 10 position.

If we wanted a new manager we should have got one at the end of last season. Things will only be made worse by destabilising the club now.

Incorrect. He's prem standard.

 

OldFella Flag London 16 Aug 16 7.50pm

Originally posted by sprites

Incorrect. He's prem standard.

He really is not, Sprites. You need to watch more carefully/ the right way up.

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Deluded Flag 16 Aug 16 8.13pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

So, 18 months after your manager leaves you hunt down a palace website "in peace" to say I told you so, based on 1 game. Even the people in Geordie Shore had have the intellect to work out that's gloating.

We were 10 minutes away from winning the cup final and safe by Christmas last season. The dip in form was only attributed to a lack of a striker, injuries and the cup run.

In the past few years you've had the current England manager keep you up and Pardew but niether were good enough apparently.

Now you're in the Championship and have lost your first two games.

Pardew would have kept you up. Especially if he had the same amount of money as McLaren had.

It's people like you that have turned Newcastle toxic.

Edited by jeeagles (15 Aug 2016 12.53pm)

Big Sam was going to relegate us. We gave Derby 4 points that season whe their whole total was 11...

To be honest, before Pardew left we weren't actually flying.

And I don't know why are you talking about Newcastle here. This thread is about Pardew and it seems his excuses are running out. You have been s***e all 2016 and it has nothing to do with current Newcastle but all to do with Mr Pardew. I think you will sack him before Christmas.

Edited by Deluded (16 Aug 2016 8.16pm)

 

norwayeagle Flag Trondheim 16 Aug 16 8.19pm

I think Gallowgate Ender seems like a great bloke. Well written meanings, and don't try to gloat. We should wish supporters of his kind welcome..

 

bicycle repair man 16 Aug 16 8.34pm

I think Gallowgate Ender is a closet Super Al fan and secretly wants him back !

 

Podyonkers Flag Atlanta, Georgia 16 Aug 16 8.39pm

Originally posted by Gallowgate Ender

Not here to gloat or laugh or say we told you so.
But been reading palace fans on twitter and watching their games mainly via MOTD, nut really history is repeating.
The long winless runs, the baffling subs, the dreadful football, alienation of players (usually due to inability to man manage), the absolute spin "we play good attacking football" yet his teams are toothless.
At palace as at Newcastle, and his other clubs starts off well, gets his feet under the table then it all goes wrong.
It's down to his brilliance when the team win, but its bad luck, conspiracies, bad refs, the transfer window etc etc when it goes badly.

This man will ruin everything that's enjoyable about supporting your club. He'll divide the squad, divide the support and make it a pain in the arse to attend games because it's so dull.

I can see it has already started by skimming through this board. Don't fall into the trap of battered wife syndrome "well who else is better". Get out while you can

Well, we just lost the opening game of the season so the sky isn't exactly falling yet.

 


Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987.

essetwentyone Flag london 16 Aug 16 9.58pm

I think Galloway Ender should worry about his own lot and not waste his time on us !!! With 2 defeats so far in the Championship he should be wondering if Rafa will stay as a manager in Div 1 next season !!!!

 

Page 5 of 15 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle fan- I come in peace.