You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardews empty promises?
November 16 2026 11.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Pardews empty promises?


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Username Flag Horsham 06 Sep 16 9.56am

Originally posted by cpj

Yes - I'd drop Puncheon in an instant. Doesn't do enough and just slows the game down. Lee has hardly 'ripped up trees' either. Williams runs at defenders with the ball glued to his feet and will draw fouls all game long. Pardew asked him to show what he could do at the Euros, and he did that. If being an important member of a squad that reached the semi-finals doesn't qualify you to play for Palace then something is wrong.


Great, he wins free kicks occasionally.

He also struggles to stay on his feet, doesn't shoot, gets caught out of position and his passing isn't anywhere near as incisive as Punch or Lee.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

ambrose7 Flag Croydon 06 Sep 16 10.34am

I watched Boateng in a few Plymouth games when they were on TV last season and he didn't stand out in League 2. League 1 this season is a good move for him. If he tears it up, there might be something for him. Realistically though, he's 21 in January. It'd take one really big step to hit the heights of McArthur, Cabaye etc.

For all the clamour around Mile Jedinak, he is now what a good Championship club owns. That should put Boateng in perspective. The PL is always moving on.

For the 20 minute v Swansea argument, you could take a 20 minute segment from all of the players we own which demonstrate them as a Champions League player and another as a non-league player. To go against Pardew's judgement on the basis of that isn't enough.

For Kaikai, there's no chance he'd have been starting 20+ games this season. For every Alli who doesn't go out on loan, there's a Harry Kane who does, or John Stones who was at Barnsley, Danny Rose at Bristol City and so on.

KaiKai has done very well so far, but only played 27 games above League 2 level. A 40 game season in the championship for a good side won't do him any harm at all, if anything he needs to experience a long season at a good level. Dele Alli has at least done that. The only way to hurt him this season is to let him rot on our bench or given our strength now, probably in the reserves. That won't happen, he'll get game time against some very good sides and that will give him the best chance to succeed.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Sep 16 1.29pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3053759]

So that excuses you laying into people you don't agree with

Yes. Yes it does. Could you please punctuate properly, you wouldn't want anyone to think you're an idiot. Not that I'm at all insinuating it before you get trigger happy with the report button.

 

Littlebogreek Flag 06 Sep 16 1.38pm

Originally posted by ambrose7

I watched Boateng in a few Plymouth games when they were on TV last season and he didn't stand out in League 2. League 1 this season is a good move for him. If he tears it up, there might be something for him. Realistically though, he's 21 in January. It'd take one really big step to hit the heights of McArthur, Cabaye etc.

For all the clamour around Mile Jedinak, he is now what a good Championship club owns. That should put Boateng in perspective. The PL is always moving on.

For the 20 minute v Swansea argument, you could take a 20 minute segment from all of the players we own which demonstrate them as a Champions League player and another as a non-league player. To go against Pardew's judgement on the basis of that isn't enough.

For Kaikai, there's no chance he'd have been starting 20+ games this season. For every Alli who doesn't go out on loan, there's a Harry Kane who does, or John Stones who was at Barnsley, Danny Rose at Bristol City and so on.

KaiKai has done very well so far, but only played 27 games above League 2 level. A 40 game season in the championship for a good side won't do him any harm at all, if anything he needs to experience a long season at a good level. Dele Alli has at least done that. The only way to hurt him this season is to let him rot on our bench or given our strength now, probably in the reserves. That won't happen, he'll get game time against some very good sides and that will give him the best chance to succeed.

What a disgustingly well reasoned argument that makes total sense. Sensible posting has no place on the Hol!

 

citizensmudge Flag midlands 06 Sep 16 1.41pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Yes. Yes it does. Could you please punctuate properly, you wouldn't want anyone to think you're an idiot. Not that I'm at all insinuating it before you get trigger happy with the report button.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 06 Sep 16 2.26pm

Originally posted by cpj

Yes - I'd drop Puncheon in an instant. Doesn't do enough and just slows the game down. Lee has hardly 'ripped up trees' either. Williams runs at defenders with the ball glued to his feet and will draw fouls all game long. Pardew asked him to show what he could do at the Euros, and he did that. If being an important member of a squad that reached the semi-finals doesn't qualify you to play for Palace then something is wrong.

Behave. Williams wasn't an important member. Of the 6 games he was unused in 2, on for 25 mins if that in 3 and played 75 in the first game. Wales got where they got through hard work and taking each game as if it was their last, same way we got the final of the FA cup. Williams is nowhere near the level of Puncheon or Lee and to be honest he's not near the level of any of our midfielders hence he's in the Championship on loan. He's not progressed since his debut which was how long ago?

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Sep 16 2.44pm

Originally posted by cpj

Yes - I'd drop Puncheon in an instant. Doesn't do enough and just slows the game down. Lee has hardly 'ripped up trees' either. Williams runs at defenders with the ball glued to his feet and will draw fouls all game long. Pardew asked him to show what he could do at the Euros, and he did that. If being an important member of a squad that reached the semi-finals doesn't qualify you to play for Palace then something is wrong.

And then be out for three months.

 

Murray's the man Flag round ear 06 Sep 16 2.48pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

I got carded for telling the lad who started this thread to f*ck off. Apparently it's alright to spam the site with anti threads but if you vocally tell that person to f*ck off you get warned.

This board used to be alright, now it's full of w*nkers and snidey c*nts. [

You mean the mods?

 


Johnny will return

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 06 Sep 16 2.53pm

However much he is 'one of our own Joniesta is neither a regular for Wales nor an integral part of the way they play.

He is not the world beater we all hoped he was and you can only be the next big thing for so long (especially now his hairline is in fast retreat&#128515

His time won't come and he will once his contract is up plough a relatively successful furrow in the lower leagues

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Sep 16 2.54pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3053915]

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

I got carded for telling the lad who started this thread to f*ck off. Apparently it's alright to spam the site with anti threads but if you vocally tell that person to f*ck off you get warned.

This board used to be alright, now it's full of w*nkers and snidey c*nts. [

You mean the mods?

Check you out trying to make me bite. Have a biscuit & give yourself a pat on the back.

Edited by Southampton_Eagle (06 Sep 2016 2.54pm)

 

citizensmudge Flag midlands 06 Sep 16 3.03pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3053915]

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

I got carded for telling the lad who started this thread to f*ck off. Apparently it's alright to spam the site with anti threads but if you vocally tell that person to f*ck off you get warned.

This board used to be alright, now it's full of w*nkers and snidey c*nts. [

You mean the mods?

Big Chief Mullery's second in command baiting the trap with his finger on the trigger.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Sep 16 3.42pm

Originally posted by citizensmudge


Big Chief Mullery's second in command baiting the trap with his finger on the trigger.

If I may respond in language that you would understand. Baaaa baaaaa

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 06 Sep 16 3.52pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

However much he is 'one of our own Joniesta is neither a regular for Wales nor an integral part of the way they play.

He is not the world beater we all hoped he was and you can only be the next big thing for so long (especially now his hairline is in fast retreat&#55357;&#56835

His time won't come and he will once his contract is up plough a relatively successful furrow in the lower leagues

Career wise, I think for a couple of seasons now he's been in a position where he needs to be regularly getting games at a lower level.

Kids got talent and potential, but the injuries have just kept setting him back. I think if he leaves and goes to an average championship, or newly promoted league 1 side, he could seriously ignite a career and possibly end up making it to the top league, or become a significant championship level player.

But whilst he's still here, that's not going to happen. He needs to be part of someones 'plans', not a loan star.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Sep 16 4.07pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

If I may respond in language that you would understand. Baaaa baaaaa

A wise man once said "Nothing like an erudite post to make your point if you are not articulate enough to make a cultured response to something that you disagree with"

 

Murray's the man Flag round ear 06 Sep 16 4.17pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Check you out trying to make me bite. Have a biscuit & give yourself a pat on the back.

Edited by Southampton_Eagle (06 Sep 2016 2.54pm)

I think you owe the mods an opology. There only trying to let people have reasoned debate which you have failed to do.

Trying to bully people who have a different opinion from you

 


Johnny will return

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 06 Sep 16 4.28pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3053960]

I think you owe the mods an opology. There only trying to let people have reasoned debate which you have failed to do.

Trying to bully people who have a different opinion from you

In all fairness, it's very tedious seeing threads that have a different title but all with the same underlying ajenda. That's not reasoned debate, that's putting a negative spin on anything you can, to try and justify your stance. Being called out is always going to happen when you only have 1 real point to try and make and then do so over and over under different titles so if you don't like it, don't do it.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Sep 16 4.39pm

[quote=Murray's the man;3053960]

I think you owe the mods an opology. There only trying to let people have reasoned debate which you have failed to do.

Trying to bully people who have a different opinion from you

I owe no-one an apology, and I certainly won't give an apology I don't mean because you're goading me.

Have a word with yourself.

 

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 06 Sep 16 4.42pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

In all fairness, it's very tedious seeing threads that have a different title but all with the same underlying ajenda. That's not reasoned debate, that's putting a negative spin on anything you can, to try and justify your stance. Being called out is always going to happen when you only have 1 real point to try and make and then do so over and over under different titles so if you don't like it, don't do it.

Quite.

 

Murray's the man Flag round ear 06 Sep 16 4.56pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

In all fairness, it's very tedious seeing threads that have a different title but all with the same underlying ajenda. That's not reasoned debate, that's putting a negative spin on anything you can, to try and justify your stance. Being called out is always going to happen when you only have 1 real point to try and make and then do so over and over under different titles so if you don't like it, don't do it.

I've never said Pardew should be sacked, just that he doesn't follow through on what he says.

Our nett expenditure virtually doubled last season but it hasn't lead to better league position. If you did a graph its a worrying trend.

I do think some of the backroom staff changes are slightly worrying. anyway I'm done with this thread, leave this site to the people who know best. The keyboard warriors

 


Johnny will return

johnmcormick8 Flag Brundish 06 Sep 16 5.08pm

Alan, Steve the whole -fing kitnkaboodle at Palace are doing their level best to make the club the best it has ever been.
Now Alan is experienced player/coach who knows the game and the players. He may not in top 5 of managers in the EPL but he isn't the worst either so CAN WE ALL CALM DOWN PLEASE! and get back to supporting and not endlessly moaning, snipping whinging. If want success go support one of the top 5/6 otherwise strap yourself in the rollercoaster.

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Pardews empty promises?