You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > £43 million to try and replace Glenn Murray
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

£43 million to try and replace Glenn Murray


Page 5 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
IMMER PALACE Flag BIELEFELD 09 Sep 16 4.11pm

Have to say I always see the replacement of decent players like this - it takes time and money to replace the really good ones with an equivalent or better.

Quite often it demonstrates the futility of selling players as you spend several times the transfer fee working through a range of replacements.

That said, players age and there is always a right time to sell - the key is recognising it. I am reasonably confident Benteke will do a job for us and score goals. His performance at Bournemouth in taking and holding the ball through the air was the first time since Murray I have felt confident in a striker.

I think a lot of the ire at the OP is well over the top. If you take Palace out of it and think of the money Liverpool spent trying to replace Suarez or even Man Utd who still have a Roy Keane shaped hole in their midfield despite chucking squillions at it, it is an obvious conclusion.

Chill.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 09 Jan 18 9.54pm

I would like to hear if any opinions have changed with the passing of time regarding the subject matter of this thread after Glenn Murray knocked us out of the FA Cup last night with his 7th goal of the season.

Any glance of the responses will see I was absolutely slaughtered for what I suggested back in September, 2016.

Are opinions still as strong? Does anybody out there think the OP had a valid point at the time?

 

chateauferret Flag 09 Jan 18 10.08pm

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

I would like to hear if any opinions have changed with the passing of time regarding the subject matter of this thread after Glenn Murray knocked us out of the FA Cup last night with his 7th goal of the season.

Any glance of the responses will see I was absolutely slaughtered for what I suggested back in September, 2016.

Are opinions still as strong? Does anybody out there think the OP had a valid point at the time?

As I understand it Murray wanted to leave and that being the case the question of what would have happened if he had stayed is totally moot. When it's a player's time to move on he moves on. Otherwise you have a malcontent in your dressing room and that's really quite s***.

I couldn't give less of a f*** about the FA Cup this year.

Edited by chateauferret (09 Jan 2018 10.08pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Jan 18 10.43pm

Murray didn't touch the ball. He claimed it, but didn't touch it. Even if he did it was already going in, but he didn't.

Those smug cheeses probably think it's great he 'scored' a goal to beat our reserve defence in a game we're not bothered about, after cheering him breaking his leg for us before we beat them in the playoffs.

 


COYP

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 09 Jan 18 11.08pm

Nothing lasts forever and things have moved on considerably. At the time I was mystified as to why we sold Murray & Gayle, but kept Campbell. I still think that was a massive mistake.

Sure Trekkers cost a lot, but Sako was a freebie and he is getting the odd goal here and there. Let’s be positive and hope we get a half decent striker in this transfer window...

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 10 Jan 18 2.07am

In hindsight.....


Originally posted by spartakev2

Can't believe weve got benteke and remy and were still arguing aboit f*****g murray.

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 10 Jan 18 7.06am

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

I would like to hear if any opinions have changed with the passing of time regarding the subject matter of this thread after Glenn Murray knocked us out of the FA Cup last night with his 7th goal of the season.

Any glance of the responses will see I was absolutely slaughtered for what I suggested back in September, 2016.

Are opinions still as strong? Does anybody out there think the OP had a valid point at the time?

Murray has 7 goals this season ( two penaties ) Sako has 5 goals with no penalties and in a quarter of the game time , looks like he’s been replaced with a free transfer .....

 

The Dolphin Flag 10 Jan 18 7.33am

He should not have been sold by Pardew who bought Wicham for Murray to be the reserve and Murray didn't want that, nor do I blame Murray for that.
The right way to man manage that situation would have been to tell Murray that "you start as our No 1 striker and if you continue to play as well as you have then Connor won't get a game".
However - that is not Alan's style and he ideally wanted Murray to leave.
I can only hope that West Brom get relegated
1. Because that is one less place available to us
2. But more because I want to see Pardew fail and at last be found out for what the majority know that he really is - an arrogant self serving waste of space!

 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Jan 18 7.59am

I don't really understand the criticism of Wickham, other than that he's had injury problems. If you look at his record he actually has 9 goals and 3 assists in 23 starts. Some his goals were worldies and before he was injured he was starting to look like a player with real potential. He did suffer the same as Bentenke for his perceived lack of interest at times, but I think that may just be the expression he carries and his style of play. I really hope he makes it back.

Remy never got a chance because of injuries and last season Bentenke had a very good goal scoring record.

I think the reaction to the OP was perhaps a bit OTT, but they did write post that was likely to stir some emotions. Personally, I was thankful for what Murray did for us but I've never wished we had him back. Despite being at Brighton I'm glad he's finally playing regularly in the PL, but I don't think he's the player he was and I wouldn't be surprised to see him benched once Brighton bring in another striker (they've scored even less goals than us).

Edit: I just checked and of Murray's 6 league goals this season two were penalties (he also missed one). So that's actually only four goals in open play. Not exactly prolific (albeit better than Bentenke's one goal!)

Edited by taylors lovechild (10 Jan 2018 8.07am)

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Jan 18 8.59am

Shouldn't have sold Murray at the time that we did, but if we were still relying on him as first-choice striker at this point, it would be an even greater failing.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 10 Jan 18 9.03am

Probably not the right forum, but any news on Wickham??
Im very concerned at the length of time out especially with a knee injury.

 

Aolcpfc Flag Finchley, London 10 Jan 18 9.05am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

He should not have been sold by Pardew who bought Wicham for Murray to be the reserve and Murray didn't want that, nor do I blame Murray for that.
The right way to man manage that situation would have been to tell Murray that "you start as our No 1 striker and if you continue to play as well as you have then Connor won't get a game".
However - that is not Alan's style and he ideally wanted Murray to leave.
I can only hope that West Brom get relegated
1. Because that is one less place available to us
2. But more because I want to see Pardew fail and at last be found out for what the majority know that he really is - an arrogant self serving waste of space!

Exactly.

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 10 Jan 18 9.20am

Benteke's goals kept us up last season, so opinion strong about calling him a flop.
And further it's history, a lot of dwelling in the past does no-one any good.

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

I would like to hear if any opinions have changed with the passing of time regarding the subject matter of this thread after Glenn Murray knocked us out of the FA Cup last night with his 7th goal of the season.

Any glance of the responses will see I was absolutely slaughtered for what I suggested back in September, 2016.

Are opinions still as strong? Does anybody out there think the OP had a valid point at the time?


 

Jacey Flag 10 Jan 18 9.23am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

He should not have been sold by Pardew who bought Wicham for Murray to be the reserve and Murray didn't want that, nor do I blame Murray for that.
The right way to man manage that situation would have been to tell Murray that "you start as our No 1 striker and if you continue to play as well as you have then Connor won't get a game".
However - that is not Alan's style and he ideally wanted Murray to leave.
I can only hope that West Brom get relegated
1. Because that is one less place available to us
2. But more because I want to see Pardew fail and at last be found out for what the majority know that he really is - an arrogant self serving waste of space!

E+ a prancing peacock,hopeless dancer!!

 

Palace in the Blood Flag 10 Jan 18 10.25am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

He should not have been sold by Pardew who bought Wicham for Murray to be the reserve and Murray didn't want that, nor do I blame Murray for that.
The right way to man manage that situation would have been to tell Murray that "you start as our No 1 striker and if you continue to play as well as you have then Connor won't get a game".
However - that is not Alan's style and he ideally wanted Murray to leave.
I can only hope that West Brom get relegated
1. Because that is one less place available to us
2. But more because I want to see Pardew fail and at last be found out for what the majority know that he really is - an arrogant self serving waste of space!


My remembrance of the facts are quite different from yours.
He was injured in playoff final and returned just after xmas. Pulis was our manager . Murray played 15 times and scored 1 penalty, Jerome was generally preferred.

Pulis brought in Fraizer Campbell and was looking at other strikers before he left.

Warnock came in and virtually first thing he did was send GM out on loan.

Pardew arrived brought him back from Reading and gave him a new contract. He played 20 times and scored 7 goals. He also brought in Shola Ameobi as cover

Following season as you say Connor Wickham arrived. GM played 2 games in league and scored no goals, he was unhappy at being a bench player and when Bournemouth showed an interest he asked to go. Should we have kept a player who wanted to leave?

At Bournemouth he played 22 games and scored 4 goals. Initially he was a starting player but over season he dropped to bench and was 3rd choice by end of season.

He joined BHA on loan which became permanent in 40 games in championship he scored 23 goals. This year he was only in first team due to injuries and as you say he has scored 6 goals, more than Benteke.

In retrospect should he have stayed? Probably yes, he would have been a bench player but he was at Bournemouth and probably still is at BHA

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 10 Jan 18 11.15am

Originally posted by Palace in the Blood


My remembrance of the facts are quite different from yours.
He was injured in playoff final and returned just after xmas. Pulis was our manager . Murray played 15 times and scored 1 penalty, Jerome was generally preferred.

Pulis brought in Fraizer Campbell and was looking at other strikers before he left.

Warnock came in and virtually first thing he did was send GM out on loan.

Pardew arrived brought him back from Reading and gave him a new contract. He played 20 times and scored 7 goals. He also brought in Shola Ameobi as cover

Following season as you say Connor Wickham arrived. GM played 2 games in league and scored no goals, he was unhappy at being a bench player and when Bournemouth showed an interest he asked to go. Should we have kept a player who wanted to leave?

At Bournemouth he played 22 games and scored 4 goals. Initially he was a starting player but over season he dropped to bench and was 3rd choice by end of season.

He joined BHA on loan which became permanent in 40 games in championship he scored 23 goals. This year he was only in first team due to injuries and as you say he has scored 6 goals, more than Benteke.

In retrospect should he have stayed? Probably yes, he would have been a bench player but he was at Bournemouth and probably still is at BHA

This is how I see it also. GM would have been, both for the last couple of seasons and now, a great 2nd/3rd striker but nothing more.

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 10 Jan 18 1.28pm

Originally posted by comeonyoueagles20

Murray has 7 goals this season ( two penaties ) Sako has 5 goals with no penalties and in a quarter of the game time , looks like he’s been replaced with a free transfer .....

Sorry - surely you know that there is no such thing as a free transfer. Sako is reportedly on £55k a week. So over a 3 year contract he will cost the club over £8m.
Yes, he's doing ok now but take the first few months and last few months out of the last 2.5 years and he's been a complete waste of money. Furthermore, as his wages are so high championship clubs who have expressed an interest in signing him have quickly cooled their interest, probably when they become clear of his wages.

At the most he's a £20k a week player. The rest is the 'free' element.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Jan 18 5.37pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

Probably not the right forum, but any news on Wickham??
Im very concerned at the length of time out especially with a knee injury.

Was back in training mid December but heard nothing since . Hope he hasn't taken a step backward but in his case it sounds like no news is bad news .

 

comeonyoueagles20 Flag caterham 10 Jan 18 6.11pm

Originally posted by palace99

Sorry - surely you know that there is no such thing as a free transfer. Sako is reportedly on £55k a week. So over a 3 year contract he will cost the club over £8m.
Yes, he's doing ok now but take the first few months and last few months out of the last 2.5 years and he's been a complete waste of money. Furthermore, as his wages are so high championship clubs who have expressed an interest in signing him have quickly cooled their interest, probably when they become clear of his wages.

At the most he's a £20k a week player. The rest is the 'free' element.

Yeh thanks for all that..... I am fully aware that “free transfers “ aren’t free and a key point you’ve missed out is the player is normally given a large signing on fee too , but it was in reference to the poster referring to Glenn Murray as a free transfer, and a piss take post.

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 10 Jan 18 8.27pm

Hindsight is of no use to a manager and chairman who make the big calls. Really and truly a striker would gain millions on his price because he scored 10 goals in his last 20 or if C Wickham was to get back to fitness for a season and score say 15 goals he would still be worth more than we have paid out. A few ifs there but our current strikers also have age on their side to find some better form.

 

Page 5 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > £43 million to try and replace Glenn Murray