You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > having your cake and eating it
November 22 2026 12.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

having your cake and eating it


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
carlonoil Flag Naples 26 Oct 16 7.35pm

So Ashers Bakery lose their appeal over the 'gay cake'. Even Peter Tatchell accepts that this an appaling ruling.

This verdict is a defeat for freedom of expression. As well as meaning that Ashers can be legally forced to aid the promotion of same-sex marriage against their wishes, it also implies that gay bakers could be forced by law to decorate cakes with homophobic slogans. It seems the judges have decided that businesses cannot lawfully refuse a customer’s request to propagate a message, even if it is sexist, xenophobic or anti-gay and even if the business owners have a conscientious objection to it. Although I strongly disagree with Ashers’ opposition to marriage equality, in a free society neither they nor anyone else should be compelled to facilitate a political idea they oppose.

 

OhthisbloodyPC Flag 27 Oct 16 1.12am

There's always a few hooligans that give the majority a bad name.

This seems to be true of the gay community.

I bet these cake activists have got fake business cards made up, which they give out to victims, saying something like "Congratulations, you have met the Intercity Offence Taking Firm"

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 27 Oct 16 10.39am

Bunch of Masterbakers

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 27 Oct 16 11.19am

Originally posted by carlonoil

So Ashers Bakery lose their appeal over the 'gay cake'. Even Peter Tatchell accepts that this an appaling ruling.

This verdict is a defeat for freedom of expression. As well as meaning that Ashers can be legally forced to aid the promotion of same-sex marriage against their wishes, it also implies that gay bakers could be forced by law to decorate cakes with homophobic slogans. It seems the judges have decided that businesses cannot lawfully refuse a customer’s request to propagate a message, even if it is sexist, xenophobic or anti-gay and even if the business owners have a conscientious objection to it. Although I strongly disagree with Ashers’ opposition to marriage equality, in a free society neither they nor anyone else should be compelled to facilitate a political idea they oppose.

Actually its irrelevant, they broke the laws of contract, that specifically prohibit businesses from discrimination against customers on grounds of gender, sexuality, race or religion.

A business, that caters to the public, is bound by legal requirements that prohibit it from discrimination in its provision of service. Irrespective of their beliefs of employees and owners. Whilst a business can refuse to accept 'political messages etc' it must be across the board (it cannot discriminate on personally held views).

In specifically refusing service on the basis of the message being about gay marriage, to a person who was gay, the case was on a hiding to nothing. Especially given it had accepted payment for the order and then decided to reject it.

Has the business specifically touted itself as a Religious outlet, catering to a specific religious group (such a Plymouth Brethren), then it might have had a case (as its revenue is specifically tied to that faith and its beliefs). However it isn't, its a common garden community bakery that caters to the community in general, and as such is bound by the discrimination act.

Freedom of Expression and Speech only refer to the capacity for protection from the state, it doesn't exclude you from the application of laws that apply to everyone (hence Freedom of Speech doesn't protect from incitement crimes or shouting fire in a crowded cinema).

In no way does this decision mean you can't refuse to print homophobic or anti-religious messages (they would fall under the Equality acts). What you can't do is selectively discriminate.

They were never going to win their case, or their appeal. Its not even about gay rights, its the same rights everyone has. Unless specifically licensed no business can refuse you service without good and lawful reason.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Donnyeagle Flag doncaster 27 Oct 16 11.25am

Thats not quite right, A business can refuse service at their discretion they don't have to actually give you a reason.
They cant refuse service on the basis of your gender or beliefs

 

carlonoil Flag Naples 27 Oct 16 12.22pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

A business, that caters to the public, is bound by legal requirements that prohibit it from discrimination in its provision of service. Irrespective of their beliefs of employees and owners. Whilst a business can refuse to accept 'political messages etc' it must be across the board (it cannot discriminate on personally held views).

What does this mean?

Edited by carlonoil (27 Oct 2016 12.22pm)

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Oct 16 12.50pm

Originally posted by carlonoil

What does this mean?

Edited by carlonoil (27 Oct 2016 12.22pm)

Let me help. If you open a shop then you sell to everyone or no one. And you obey the law.

 

carlonoil Flag Naples 27 Oct 16 12.58pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Let me help. If you open a shop then you sell to everyone or no one. And you obey the law.

So you can go into a Jewish owned bakery and say you want a cake with "the Holocaust was a lie" on it?
Or you can go into any bakery and ask for a cake that says "support lowering the age of consent to 10"?
Or you can go into a Islamic owned bakery and ask for a cake that says "I hate muhammad and his beard"?

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Oct 16 1.04pm

Originally posted by carlonoil

So you can go into a Jewish owned bakery and say you want a cake with "the Holocaust was a lie" on it?
Or you can go into any bakery and ask for a cake that says "support lowering the age of consent to 10"?
Or you can go into a Islamic owned bakery and ask for a cake that says "I hate muhammad and his beard"?

You have to obey the law including though not restricted to anti discriminatory law? You can set up any number of scenarios which you can decide for yourself whether they breach existing legislation. For example I don't understand how the age of consent one applies? What laws does it breach other than good taste.

 

carlonoil Flag Naples 27 Oct 16 1.11pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

You have to obey the law including though not restricted to anti discriminatory law? You can set up any number of scenarios which you can decide for yourself whether they breach existing legislation. For example I don't understand how the age of consent one applies? What laws does it breach other than good taste.

As Tachell said: "in a free society neither they nor anyone else should be compelled to facilitate a political idea they oppose." I would go further, and say that a business should have the right to refuse a customer for any reason whatsoever.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Oct 16 1.17pm

Originally posted by carlonoil

As Tachell said: "in a free society neither they nor anyone else should be compelled to facilitate a political idea they oppose." I would go further, and say that a business should have the right to refuse a customer for any reason whatsoever.

Tatchell is entitled to the his point of view but it is not the law and I hope it never becomes the law

As for any business having the right to turn away anyone it likes. A Britain where signs can go up like "No Blacks, No Irish, No dogs" which we used to have in the UK is not a place I want to live.

 

carlonoil Flag Naples 27 Oct 16 1.23pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Tatchell is entitled to the his point of view but it is not the law and I hope it never becomes the law

As for any business having the right to turn away anyone it likes. A Britain where signs can go up like "No Blacks, No Irish, No dogs" which we used to have in the UK is not a place I want to live.

You think it doesn't happen - with or without signs?

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Oct 16 1.26pm

Originally posted by carlonoil

You think it doesn't happen - with or without signs?

That is an entirely different point

The fact that some people steal things doesn't mean the Theft Act should be repealed

 

paperhat Flag croydon 27 Oct 16 1.30pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

Tatchell is entitled to the his point of view but it is not the law and I hope it never becomes the law

As for any business having the right to turn away anyone it likes. A Britain where signs can go up like "No Blacks, No Irish, No dogs" which we used to have in the UK is not a place I want to live.

are you a Black, Irish dog owner by chance>?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


npn Flag Crowborough 27 Oct 16 1.31pm

Originally posted by Sedlescombe

You have to obey the law including though not restricted to anti discriminatory law? You can set up any number of scenarios which you can decide for yourself whether they breach existing legislation. For example I don't understand how the age of consent one applies? What laws does it breach other than good taste.

I guess the obvious example would be to go into a gay bakery in England and request a cake with "make gay marriage illegal". They both request a change to existing laws in their respective countries, and both would be unpalatable to the proprietors regardless of the sexuality of the person making the order.

My point has always been that the sexuality of the people requesting the cake was completely irrelevant - if I'd asked for the same cake (as a straight bloke) they wouldn't have liked it either, so nobody was discriminated against.

Jamie's point on contract law may have had some bearing, if the bakery was sued for breach of contract, but they weren't. They were done under discrimination legislation, which just seems plain wrong.

Incidentally, I have no problem with gay marriage - you could marry a horse for all the difference it makes to me!

 

paperhat Flag croydon 27 Oct 16 1.33pm

Originally posted by npn

I guess the obvious example would be to go into a gay bakery in England and request a cake with "make gay marriage illegal". They both request a change to existing laws in their respective countries, and both would be unpalatable to the proprietors regardless of the sexuality of the person making the order.

My point has always been that the sexuality of the people requesting the cake was completely irrelevant - if I'd asked for the same cake (as a straight bloke) they wouldn't have liked it either, so nobody was discriminated against.

Jamie's point on contract law may have had some bearing, if the bakery was sued for breach of contract, but they weren't. They were done under discrimination legislation, which just seems plain wrong.

Incidentally, I have no problem with gay marriage - you could marry a horse for all the difference it makes to me!

i'm not a big fan of cakes tho

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Oct 16 1.36pm

Originally posted by paperhat

are you a Black, Irish dog owner by chance>?


Irish Setters that had black fur had a miserable time finding a kennel for the nighgt

 

npn Flag Crowborough 27 Oct 16 1.37pm

Originally posted by paperhat

i'm not a big fan of cakes tho

cakeophobe!

 

carlonoil Flag Naples 27 Oct 16 1.39pm

Originally posted by npn

I guess the obvious example would be to go into a gay bakery in England and request a cake with "make gay marriage illegal". They both request a change to existing laws in their respective countries, and both would be unpalatable to the proprietors regardless of the sexuality of the person making the order.

My point has always been that the sexuality of the people requesting the cake was completely irrelevant - if I'd asked for the same cake (as a straight bloke) they wouldn't have liked it either, so nobody was discriminated against.

Jamie's point on contract law may have had some bearing, if the bakery was sued for breach of contract, but they weren't. They were done under discrimination legislation, which just seems plain wrong.

Incidentally, I have no problem with gay marriage - you could marry a horse for all the difference it makes to me!

Very well put, couldn't agree more. Of course the other irony is that the "make gay marriage illegal" slogan would be superfluous in Northern Ireland as it is illegal there! The Ashers are being persecuted for declining something that is not even legal in their region.

 

Sedlescombe Flag Sedlescombe 27 Oct 16 1.41pm

Originally posted by npn

I guess the obvious example would be to go into a gay bakery in England and request a cake with "make gay marriage illegal". They both request a change to existing laws in their respective countries, and both would be unpalatable to the proprietors regardless of the sexuality of the person making the order.

My point has always been that the sexuality of the people requesting the cake was completely irrelevant - if I'd asked for the same cake (as a straight bloke) they wouldn't have liked it either, so nobody was discriminated against.

Jamie's point on contract law may have had some bearing, if the bakery was sued for breach of contract, but they weren't. They were done under discrimination legislation, which just seems plain wrong.

Incidentally, I have no problem with gay marriage - you could marry a horse for all the difference it makes to me!

They were done under discrimination legislation because that was the legislation they were in breach of, which seems appropriate. It is an interesting point if a straight couple going into the same shop would have been prosecuted in the same way - and I don't know the law well enough to answer that.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > having your cake and eating it