You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are you Pardew in or Pardew out
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are you Pardew in or Pardew out


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Inapickle Flag South West 16 Dec 16 11.17pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

I think the writings on the wall, he has to prove himself soon, or he's gone. Its really as far as I'm concerned now down to the board and the chairman, how much grace he gets.

I think Man Utd probably bought him some grace. The Campbell decision was rubbish, but it didn't really cost us the game. That was the combination of one of the best midfielders in the game, and one of the best goal scorers in the game, and some very dodgy decisions (which both cost us, and kept us in the game)

Even if McArthur was on the pitch, that's still most likely in the back of the net (and is why Pogba is 90m and 290k a week, and Ibrahimovic is 200k a week).

I don't think, on reflection, that the Man Utd result was particularly bad, or lost because of the manager.

But Hull, unacceptable after Swansea and Burnley results. If we played against them with the discipline we played against United, Pardew would be safe in his job.

..is this the fault of the players or the fault of Pardew then?
..I don't really believe that both the handball and the disallowed goal can be classed as two individual opportunities because I feel the handball would have cancelled out the off-side seeing as it happened immediately after Ledleys moment and also the game would have gone onto a different path wouldn't it not, also we must not dismiss the point that in a penalty moment the kicker can miss or the keeper can save (no Speroni)...so I still personally feel that the refs did us right up the ....!

 

Inapickle Flag South West 17 Dec 16 12.02am

Originally posted by chateauferret

I don't think he should even be allowed to bounce on his way through the gates.

I make that a year since that Lee strike won it for us at Stoke and since then let's see. These I think are the decent league results since that day.

Palace 1 Norwich 0
Wet Spam 2 Palace 2
Arsenal 0 Palace 0
Palace 2 Stoke 1
Everton 1 Palace 1
Palace 4 Stoke 1
Sunderland 2 Palace 3
Palace 3 Southampton 0

Rest - s***e.

Eight out of 41. Two of those are wins by more than one goal and one of those two was flattering. Compare that with before that turning point and see we beat Chelsea and the bin dippers away, demolished the Toon and got results against teams around us. That was despite having a weaker strike force and mostly the same defenders.

I'm struggling to understand WTF he's still doing here.

0-0 away Bournemouth
0-0 home Swansea
1-1 away Swansea
2-2 away Sunderland
0-0 home Everton
1-1 home Bournemouth
2-1 away Middlesbrough
3-3 away Hull

..also in lots of lost games the end result often didn't reflect fairly on us and you must understand this, I include all the officials, all the cheating, all the silly individual mistakes from some of the players who apart from making these played well as did the rest of the squad, often the team was attacking and trying to get the equaliser because the majority of games was lost by only one goal.

No club in this league is easy to beat and we do not have any right to say we should be beating any of them, look at our squad and look at the oppositions squad, it really is not hard to work out...we are well placed and improving defensively for a real relegation fight that we will win, easily.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Dec 16 1.04am

Originally posted by Inapickle

0-0 away Bournemouth
0-0 home Swansea
1-1 away Swansea
2-2 away Sunderland
0-0 home Everton
1-1 home Bournemouth
2-1 away Middlesbrough
3-3 away Hull

..also in lots of lost games the end result often didn't reflect fairly on us and you must understand this, I include all the officials, all the cheating, all the silly individual mistakes from some of the players who apart from making these played well as did the rest of the squad, often the team was attacking and trying to get the equaliser because the majority of games was lost by only one goal.

No club in this league is easy to beat and we do not have any right to say we should be beating any of them, look at our squad and look at the oppositions squad, it really is not hard to work out...we are well placed and improving defensively for a real relegation fight that we will win, easily.

Your undying support is becoming creepy. Very feckin rarely does a manager turn form like this around. I sort of admire your loyalty but you're still a fool. There are several posters massively pro Pardew who've gone quiet because they know this is in severe sh-t.

You are with the remaining fools who think that loyalty to someone who'd drop us if it suits whilst producing appalling results is worth standing up for. What a strange environment with t1ts like this around.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Dec 16 1.08am

A soft touch this club has become now, like Cabaye falling down under Pogba. Pathetic leadership and management. The man is winging it and there are fools fooling for his transparent shyte.

 


COYP

chateauferret Flag 17 Dec 16 1.18am

Originally posted by Inapickle

0-0 away Bournemouth
0-0 home Swansea
1-1 away Swansea
2-2 away Sunderland
0-0 home Everton
1-1 home Bournemouth
2-1 away Middlesbrough
3-3 away Hull

..also in lots of lost games the end result often didn't reflect fairly on us and you must understand this, I include all the officials, all the cheating, all the silly individual mistakes from some of the players who apart from making these played well as did the rest of the squad, often the team was attacking and trying to get the equaliser because the majority of games was lost by only one goal.

No club in this league is easy to beat and we do not have any right to say we should be beating any of them, look at our squad and look at the oppositions squad, it really is not hard to work out...we are well placed and improving defensively for a real relegation fight that we will win, easily.

Bill give you the Boro one. But this is a results business and we aren't getting the results. Once or twice, bad luck, maybe. But three-quarter of the time? Nah.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Midlands Eagle Flag 17 Dec 16 7.11am

Originally posted by Y Ddraig Goch

He didn't buy Kelly

Townsend is left footed, I don't remember any unhappy posters at the time

One knowledgeable forum poster even said that Townsend makes Bolasie look like a Sunday League player

 

Inapickle Flag South West 17 Dec 16 10.10am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Your undying support is becoming creepy. Very feckin rarely does a manager turn form like this around. I sort of admire your loyalty but you're still a fool. There are several posters massively pro Pardew who've gone quiet because they know this is in severe sh-t.

You are with the remaining fools who think that loyalty to someone who'd drop us if it suits whilst producing appalling results is worth standing up for. What a strange environment with t1ts like this around.

.. I just see this as purely a player fault, we need obvious strengthening in particular parts, Souare has been an awful miss and our backup squad is sadly very thin and miles away from being good enough to replace, we have failed with recruiting the correct players, it is a gamble but we are not able to buy a 'Benteke' all over the pitch to fix all the player problems, Newcastle have had for decades this very same problem that we have now, sometimes it is reasonably successful and sometimes it is not and quite often you will find that one particular player can arrive and be the capitalist for everything you need on and off the pitch, you just need luck to find them........and luck is definitely not shinning on us at the moment.

Today is the sort of day where luck could shine brightly in our direction and there is no need for you to get personal with me, I want the same as you, Mr Pardew wants the same as you, all the players want the same as you.

 

Inapickle Flag South West 17 Dec 16 10.13am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

A soft touch this club has become now, like Cabaye falling down under Pogba. Pathetic leadership and management. The man is winging it and there are fools fooling for his transparent shyte.

..is the fault of nobody else but the player himself.

 

Dancer Cat Flag Farnborough 17 Dec 16 10.34am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

A soft touch this club has become now"


What a accurate phrase to describe our current playing style.

We can't pass, we don't fight BUT we have individual talent (hence the entertainment), not even Pardew can take that away.

 

Shortbutts Flag Birmingham 17 Dec 16 11.08am

I'm with you, inapickle, on this and happy to be considered as a fool or t1t by Rudi and others.

I hate to see the team lose (it ruins my week), but I think on the whole we have not played that badly this year; certainly better than last season. We have suffered from lapses at the back - in particular Dann and Ward. We also miss Soaure.

I see a team that is still pulling together and fighting and are behind Pardew. At Hull they kept their heads up after a dreadful penalty decision and even fought back against Man U until succumbing near the end. Last season we were defensively strong, but couldn't score - this season we can score, but defensively there have been too many catastrophic lapses (player errors). It started with Dann being out and he has not recaptured his form since his return.

As much as Rudi may think I am a fool, I am shocked by the vitriol and what I see as unrealistic expectations. I have to lay some of the blame for this with Mr Parish - who has in my opinion over raised expectations with his comments that we are a mid-table club. We do not yet have a squad, funding or ground capacity to do this. I think we punch above our weight - this is not defeatist, but reflects experience of this and similar clubs. We are currently enjoying our most successful period ever - without last day relegation dramas. There are numerous big clubs in the Championship who would dream of being in our position.

I also do not see who this saviour manager will be that will come in Pardew's place. I think Pardew is an average manager at an average club. Why will a big name manager or bright star come to our club? Most likely we will get a cast off - perhaps Rowett is the best we could hope for. Many have turned us down over recent years.

I am happy for anyone to disagree with my opinion, hurl abuse my way, or question why I lack ambition for the club. I guess I have seen what happens too often when expectations become unrealistic; not just at this club, but others of similar scale. Leicester were a rarity for a reason.

Originally posted by Inapickle

.. I just see this as purely a player fault, we need obvious strengthening in particular parts, Souare has been an awful miss and our backup squad is sadly very thin and miles away from being good enough to replace, we have failed with recruiting the correct players, it is a gamble but we are not able to buy a 'Benteke' all over the pitch to fix all the player problems, Newcastle have had for decades this very same problem that we have now, sometimes it is reasonably successful and sometimes it is not and quite often you will find that one particular player can arrive and be the capitalist for everything you need on and off the pitch, you just need luck to find them........and luck is definitely not shinning on us at the moment.

Today is the sort of day where luck could shine brightly in our direction and there is no need for you to get personal with me, I want the same as you, Mr Pardew wants the same as you, all the players want the same as you.


Edited by Shortbutts (17 Dec 2016 11.10am)

 

lancseagle Flag burnley 17 Dec 16 11.23am

You could say Bournemouth & west brom & watford & burnley are punching above there weight or maybe better managers I don't think we are. Been unlucky with injuries but that's when the squad kicks in & the signings (most) have been iffy. It was obvious you wouldn't get a sustained run from CW in the side that 1 was always waiting to happen.

Edited by lancseagle (17 Dec 2016 12.14pm)

 

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 17 Dec 16 12.05pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

so your a reluctant out then? surely that means deep down you know hes a bettter manager, and were a better tram than results.

i hear the same parish soundbites about us becoming a proper top half team and getting into europe but we know really hes like us, a fan and i recon he just happy as long as we keep sucking on the titties of this PL cash cow.

we have no right to be beating any team in this league or finishing top half.

maybe i have low expectations or maybe im just a realist.

i would much rather have somebody who cares about the club like pardew who i could actually imagine, and would like to be here for 10 years than some crooked sheister like fat sam or pulis who just only be here for the short term and dont give 2 s***s.

Ok except Pardew doesn't care about the club,ALL he cares about is the money, same as ALL footballers today. If it was caring about the club, why does Oscar walk away from a probable league winning club like Chelsea?? FOR THE MONEY, THATS ALL!

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 17 Dec 16 12.08pm

Another loss today and he should be gone

 

cpfc1976 Flag Reading 17 Dec 16 2.46pm

For Parish and everyone else that in defending Pardew like to remind us that results in calendar years mean nothing.

I would like to know, if Pardew stays, at what point will you start recognising stats as relevant? Surely its finally time to take notice of our abysmal run this year and act upon them now, before they really do become irrelevant and we are down.

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 17 Dec 16 2.56pm

With the players fighting amonst themselfs ie Zaha not happy about being in the wall, i think pardew is losing the dressing room

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 17 Dec 16 3.34pm

Football is a results business.he's not getting the results so should go. If he was at any other club in any division he would have gone long ago.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 17 Dec 16 3.38pm

I will be absolutely shocked if Parish keeps Pardew if we get nothing at Watford

 

kennybrowns leftfoot Flag Reigate 17 Dec 16 3.43pm

Originally posted by Bangell

I will be absolutely shocked if Parish keeps Pardew if we get nothing at Watford

And I genuinely don't think we will get anything at Watford. Sadly I can see us going the entire Xmas period and not picking up a single point.

 


Don't waste your time with jealousy. Sometimes your ahead, sometimes your behind, the race is long. But in the end it's only with yourself!!

fed up eagle Flag Between Horley, Surrey and Preston... 17 Dec 16 3.44pm

Out, now. FFS just go Pardew.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 17 Dec 16 4.14pm

Pardew to stay IN. Watford away is crucial given games coming up - a draw at least. Realistic target results?

vs Arsenal AWAY - loss
vs Swansea HOME - win (+ 3pts)
vs West Ham AWAY - draw (1 pt)
vs Everton HOME -win (3pts)
vs Bournemouth AWAY- win (3pts)
vs Sunderland HOME -win (3pts)
vs Stoke City AWAY -draw (1pt)
vs Middlesbrough HOME -win (3pts)
vs West Brom AWAY - draw (1pt)
vs Spurs HOME - loss
vs Watford HOME - win (3pts)
vs Chelsea AWAY - loss
vs Southampton AWAY -draw (1pt)
vs Arsenal HOME -loss
vs Leicester City HOME - win (3pts)
vs Liverpool AWAY - loss
vs Burnley HOME - win (3pts)
vs Man City AWAY - loss
vs Hull City HOME - win (3pts)
vs Man Utd AWAY -loss

What do you think?

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are you Pardew in or Pardew out