You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi
November 16 2026 10.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Jedi


Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >
Phil H Flag 08 Jan 17 12.46pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You don't make those decisions, luckily.

The price you're quoting is £8mil for someone who isn't going to be worth that.

It's not that Pardew sold Jedi, it's that he didn't replace him properly, although you could make a case for too many of that guard being sold, but then again the replacements come into question.

In fact all of Pardew's recruits should be questioned. Acquiescence top of the character requirements. Woodman and Salako, tick. Millen, you a yes man or afraid your job's in danger if you challenge super al? Check, you're safe as well. What a joke. Club run for Alan's job security. Utter farce. Glad it's all over. Start being professional again.

"Glad it's all over"? Someone could write a song a bit like that, maybe add "Baby I'm" to it?

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 08 Jan 17 1.01pm

Originally posted by Hudsoneagle

I totally disagree with you...I could not disagree with you more!

Murray - He is good enough to play for a prem team but he doesn't want to be a bench player. He is an honest bloke who wants to play a key role for a club and so he would rather play for Brighton regularly...but that doesnt mean he isn't good enough.

Jedinak - exactly the same thing...he wants first team football and Pardew said he couldn't ask him to sit on the bench for us week in week out (but Ledley and Mutch are ok for bench roles). It says a lot about his ability that he was more sought after than either Ledley or Mutch don't you think?

To say Gayle isn't good enough for the prem just shows what a plonka you are...top scorer for us 3 years running or something like that??? After barely starting a game? On fire in the Champ??? He is prem quality all day long but he didn't suit our system...in some respects we were not good enough for him because we couldn't play with a front two.

you've basically just said that all three are only good enough for the bench in the Prem, which means they're not Prem first team players which is pretty much what the OP was saying.

 

Mad4palace Flag 08 Jan 17 2.04pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

you've basically just said that all three are only good enough for the bench in the Prem, which means they're not Prem first team players which is pretty much what the OP was saying.

But if you get rid of those kinds of players then you end up with a premier league first xi with a lower championship level bench like we have now. Murray would have gotten plenty of game time last season, Jedinak under Allardyce or Pulis would probably still be an essential part of the team. Gayle was a bit of an enigma, so I could kind of see the logic in selling him for a good price.

 

mrfantasy Flag maidstone 08 Jan 17 2.22pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

As a club we have a bit of a history of bringing back players for second spells. (Andy Gray, David Hopkins,AJ, Wilf,Derry.) It rarely seems to work. Only Wilf and Derry spring to mind s a success and I would discount Wilf as he left when very young.

The old adage 'Never go back,' springs to mind. Old warriors are mostly just that, old. We need new champions now.

One of the best returnee's ever in my opinion was Steve Kember who was very instrumental in getting us promoted in 79 as he was back in 69.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 08 Jan 17 2.24pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

But if you get rid of those kinds of players then you end up with a premier league first xi with a lower championship level bench like we have now. Murray would have gotten plenty of game time last season, Jedinak under Allardyce or Pulis would probably still be an essential part of the team. Gayle was a bit of an enigma, so I could kind of see the logic in selling him for a good price.

Murray himself said, more than once, he wanted to move to guarantee more game time. He said the same at Bournemouth too. He would not have been happy unless he was guaranteed regular starts. That was not going to happen. It didn't happen at Bournemouth either.

Jedi had been poor for two seasons when he was sold. The mistake was not replacing him in midfield. We also were short of real leaders on the pitch, and that has been a problem for AP elsewhere.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Mad4palace Flag 08 Jan 17 3.30pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Murray himself said, more than once, he wanted to move to guarantee more game time. He said the same at Bournemouth too. He would not have been happy unless he was guaranteed regular starts. That was not going to happen. It didn't happen at Bournemouth either.

Jedi had been poor for two seasons when he was sold. The mistake was not replacing him in midfield. We also were short of real leaders on the pitch, and that has been a problem for AP elsewhere.


I get why we let Murray go in so far as he wanted more game time, he would have got that here at least for 15/16, obviously he didn't see that so he moved on. But Jedinak was happy to stay and we should have kept him, his performances only dropped under Pardew because Pards wanted him to play in a way that was not suited to him. Jedi was getting back to form at the tail end of last season, he was great in both appearances at Wembley and was decent against West Brom for the opening game this season.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 08 Jan 17 3.32pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

You don't make those decisions, luckily.

The price you're quoting is £8mil for someone who isn't going to be worth that.

It's not that Pardew sold Jedi, it's that he didn't replace him properly, although you could make a case for too many of that guard being sold, but then again the replacements come into question.

In fact all of Pardew's recruits should be questioned. Acquiescence top of the character requirements. Woodman and Salako, tick. Millen, you a yes man or afraid your job's in danger if you challenge super al? Check, you're safe as well. What a joke. Club run for Alan's job security. Utter farce. Glad it's all over. Start being professional again.

How did you replace properly why Jedi brought to the team though? In my mind there has been one player in my 30 plus years that could stand up to Jedi and that is Geoff Thomas. Players like these just don't come around often enough to be replaceable.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 08 Jan 17 3.50pm

Anyone remember all the posts on here saying he needed to be dropped, how slow he was and how his passing was too poor for the type of football we wanted to play. Blimey, suddenly he's our saviour. As many have said on here, wasn't wrong to sell him, was wrong not to replace him with a better defensive midfielder.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 08 Jan 17 3.54pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace


I get why we let Murray go in so far as he wanted more game time, he would have got that here at least for 15/16, obviously he didn't see that so he moved on. But Jedinak was happy to stay and we should have kept him, his performances only dropped under Pardew because Pards wanted him to play in a way that was not suited to him. Jedi was getting back to form at the tail end of last season, he was great in both appearances at Wembley and was decent against West Brom for the opening game this season.

Look up his record in the last two seasons he was with us. He was poor before AP showed up. Letting him go without replacing him properly was the big problem.

Just because he was a great leader for us, does not make him good enough to play. If that were true, then Bryan Robson would still be United's captain.

One of AP's problems was not bringing in players with genuine leadership qualities. I cannot imagine one of AP's signings as captain, even if they are good enough to play regularly.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 08 Jan 17 4.01pm

Tune in to BBC1 now and you can watch him.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

The Dolphin Flag 08 Jan 17 4.55pm

And he is doing a fine job as well!!!!!!

 

Mad4palace Flag 08 Jan 17 4.58pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

Look up his record in the last two seasons he was with us. He was poor before AP showed up.
Letting him go without replacing him properly was the big problem.

Just because he was a great leader for us, does not make him good enough to play. If that were true, then Bryan Robson would still be United's captain.

One of AP's problems was not bringing in players with genuine leadership qualities. I cannot imagine one of AP's signings as captain, even if they are good enough to play regularly.

Jedinak was playing the best football of his career before he went off to play in the Asia Cup. He came back when Pardew had been with the team for a few weeks and never got a good run in the team since. Before Pardew arrived he was statistically one of the top players in Europe.

 

chateauferret Flag 08 Jan 17 5.35pm

Anonymous for seventy minutes and then subbed off.

 


============
The Ferret
============

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 08 Jan 17 6.06pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Jedinak was playing the best football of his career before he went off to play in the Asia Cup. He came back when Pardew had been with the team for a few weeks and never got a good run in the team since. Before Pardew arrived he was statistically one of the top players in Europe.

No. Look it up. He was awesome in 2013-14. Not the next season. He was poor, in a poor start to the season. He then went away, came back and got sent off almost immediately for a deliberate elbow. It didn't get better after that.

2014-15, in the PL before he travelled: p. 18, W 3, D 7, L 8.
After he travelled: p. 6, W 3, D 0, L 3.

Without him in the team: p. 14, W 7, D 2, L 5.


 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Mad4palace Flag 08 Jan 17 6.22pm

Originally posted by NickinOX

No. Look it up. He was awesome in 2013-14. Not the next season. He was poor, in a poor start to the season. He then went away, came back and got sent off almost immediately for a deliberate elbow. It didn't get better after that.

2014-15, in the PL before he travelled: p. 18, W 3, D 7, L 8.
After he travelled: p. 6, W 3, D 0, L 3.

Without him in the team: p. 14, W 7, D 2, L 5.


You should mention that we were being managed by Warnock, so the losses can't be attributed straight to Jedinak or any other player for that matter. What I remember of that period was Jedinak being one of the few bright sparks, he had the free kick against Liverpool and was banging in the penalties.

 

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 08 Jan 17 6.34pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

You should mention that we were being managed by Warnock, so the losses can't be attributed straight to Jedinak or any other player for that matter. What I remember of that period was Jedinak being one of the few bright sparks, he had the free kick against Liverpool and was banging in the penalties.


In 2014-15, and 2015-16, we were worse when he played, even after we changed manager. Look up the results for 2015-16 too. It was the same pattern.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

Mad4palace Flag 08 Jan 17 6.40pm

Originally posted by NickinOX


In 2014-15, and 2015-16, we were worse when he played, even after we changed manager. Look up the results for 2015-16 too. It was the same pattern.

That goes back to my point that Pardew didn't know how to use him. Under Pulis he was great, under Warnock he was one of the few decent performers, I think Allardyce would know exactly how to use him.

 

bodge Flag 08 Jan 17 6.42pm

Jedi was great for us he is not a good sub and that would have been his role selling was best for both same with Murray and Gayle.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 08 Jan 17 6.47pm

Palace defy logic sometimes why sell the club captain for £3 million, didn't think of a replacement and how much that would cost so just didn't get anyone in.

So the lack of defensive cover sees Palace one point above the relegation places.

 

Mad4palace Flag 08 Jan 17 6.49pm

Ledley has made 12 starts this season. Who would you lot have preferred to have made 12 starts, Ledley or Jedinak?

 

Page 5 of 7 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Jedi