You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So what are the problems?
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So what are the problems?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 05 Feb 17 9.01am

Let's just for a moment take away the emotions and look at why we just weren''t at the races against Sunderland.

For what it's worth here is my take.....
1. Sam is getting £4M allegedly to keep Palace up. Does this not cause a 'him and us' mentality?......he's getting all this money whilst we're getting f**k all.
2. We don't know what the relationship has been like between the Chairman and the players. For some reason do they feel hard done by (God knows why!) and it doesn't really matter what Manager is in the chair it would make no difference?
3. Sam must have known their collective state of mind because
before the match he made a number of statements about the game being high pressure and he didn't want a repeat of the Swansea match. This coming off the back of the Bournemouth match. Very odd thing to say as I believed this not only made the players doubt their own abilities but gave Sunderland a tremendous boost in confidence.
4. Right after Sam was appointed Millen made a veiled comment saying that perhaps this is what this group of players need or words to this effect. Is there a discenting faction within this group of players?
5. The fear of playing in front of your own fans over rules any game plan and the application and with it desire needed to get a result. This is perhaps the most worrying aspect and proves what a fickle group of players we have.
Clearly there is a core problem which needs sorting and quickly. Hopefully Luka and Sakho plus a fit Schlupp can help this but the players who were out there yesterday need to take a very close look at themselves both professionally and as role models.

 


Bring back Brolin

Mo Sizlak Flag 05 Feb 17 9.13am

There's only ever been one problem and that's Pardew.
This charlatan has gotten away with it since he took charge.
He had a good spell but he papered over so many cracks with the cup run.
And because he wasn't sacked early enough, we are now paying the price.
Its that simple.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

Salford eagle Flag 05 Feb 17 9.23am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Let's just for a moment take away the emotions and look at why we just weren''t at the races against Sunderland.

For what it's worth here is my take.....
1. Sam is getting £4M allegedly to keep Palace up. Does this not cause a 'him and us' mentality?......he's getting all this money whilst we're getting f**k all.
2. We don't know what the relationship has been like between the Chairman and the players. For some reason do they feel hard done by (God knows why!) and it doesn't really matter what Manager is in the chair it would make no difference?
3. Sam must have known their collective state of mind because
before the match he made a number of statements about the game being high pressure and he didn't want a repeat of the Swansea match. This coming off the back of the Bournemouth match. Very odd thing to say as I believed this not only made the players doubt their own abilities but gave Sunderland a tremendous boost in confidence.
4. Right after Sam was appointed Millen made a veiled comment saying that perhaps this is what this group of players need or words to this effect. Is there a discenting faction within this group of players?
5. The fear of playing in front of your own fans over rules any game plan and the application and with it desire needed to get a result. This is perhaps the most worrying aspect and proves what a fickle group of players we have.
Clearly there is a core problem which needs sorting and quickly. Hopefully Luka and Sakho plus a fit Schlupp can help this but the players who were out there yesterday need to take a very close look at themselves both professionally and as role models.

I think you're reading too much into it. We lost due to a combination of bad decisions tactically and the players bottled it.

Replacing the injured Cabaye with Ledley sealed the deal. The midfield was too one dimensional, Remy should have came on with macathur dropping in to Cabaye's position. Hopefully BS has learnt his lesson from yesterday, no more Ledley puncheon combination.

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

Mo Sizlak Flag 05 Feb 17 9.27am

That man has done untold damage to my club.
We should've learnt from Southampton, West Ham, Charlton and Newcastle.
He's always been a divisive character and anyone who can't see that is living in La La Land.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

timbob Flag 05 Feb 17 9.31am

I agree wholeheartedly

What happened to the palace faithful crowd that even cheered when we losing?

( palace 0 - 3 liverpool. Then fan power surge Palace 3 - 3 Liverpool )

Many other times when the loyal fans clapped a losing palace side off greeted by Jedi n Julian for doing so


There's been no warming of allardyce towards the fans that I have seen whatsoever .... WHY ?

There's no captain going to the corner of singing n loud fans thanking them for their contribution win or lose WHY ?


There appears to be a 'distance'. between this group and the loyal fan base and the staff n players which I have rarely witnessed in 40 years of support WHY ?

It's been five weeks under the 'New order'

Sam needs to get 'in touch' with the fan base for sure, n geeee them up

The players also need to do this, as Julian tried to do a short while ago to the singing section

We need that encouragement .... that energy...right now.....!

Also guys n gals can we look past blame and just get behind our team please and stand up and be proud and be PALACE !!!

We need to get back our rep for being loud and being great supporters do we want Brighton to swap with us ?

I'm going to stoke next sat now as a result of yesterday to contribute let's turn this around peeps n play our part as loyal fans

R.I.P Dear Staffie

COYP

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Feb 17 9.36am

Squad like a J cloth I'm afraid. A large number of players who have stepped up to the plate in the past have lost form, the replacements haven't stepped in to fill these voids, compounded with areas where we have needed huge improvements over all of our stay in the PL such as attacking centre midfield remaining. If you are playing a lone striker you have to have at least one player willing to get 10 yards from him and give him some support, instead of delivering poor balls up to him.

Edited by Booted Eagle (05 Feb 2017 9.36am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Painter Flag Croydon 05 Feb 17 9.37am

There are a multitude of problems, that appear obvious.

1. There appears to be no pattern to how we play, it seems to change every game. So the players don't know what they are supposed to be doing. Every player should know, what is expected of them, they don't, they seem strangers that just met in the changing room.
2. Lack of organisation in defence still. In yesterdays game, everytime we were attacking Sunderland, they were perfectly lined up in 2 banks of When they attacked us, we were shambolic.
3. No leader on the pitch, along with no desire from about 5 players.
4. Fitness was an issue, getting better.
5. No point blaming Pardew anymore, that is easy cop out.
6. Puncheon and Ledley need a long rest, not needed in the team as contribute nothing anymore.

 

Salford eagle Flag 05 Feb 17 9.41am

Originally posted by timbob

I agree wholeheartedly

What happened to the palace faithful crowd that even cheered when we losing?

( palace 0 - 3 liverpool. Then fan power surge Palace 3 - 3 Liverpool )

Many other times when the loyal fans clapped a losing palace side off greeted by Jedi n Julian for doing so


There's been no warming of allardyce towards the fans that I have seen whatsoever .... WHY ?

There's no captain going to the corner of singing n loud fans thanking them for their contribution win or lose WHY ?


There appears to be a 'distance'. between this group and the loyal fan base and the staff n players which I have rarely witnessed in 40 years of support WHY ?

It's been five weeks under the 'New order'

Sam needs to get 'in touch' with the fan base for sure, n geeee them up

The players also need to do this, as Julian tried to do a short while ago to the singing section

We need that encouragement .... that energy...right now.....!

Also guys n gals can we look past blame and just get behind our team please and stand up and be proud and be PALACE !!!

We need to get back our rep for being loud and being great supporters do we want Brighton to swap with us ?

I'm going to stoke next sat now as a result of yesterday to contribute let's turn this around peeps n play our part as loyal fans

R.I.P Dear Staffie

COYP


The Liverpool game we got played off the park in that first half and there certainly wasn't any cheering from the palace end. Goals change games though and it sparks the crowd!

I'm sure if we had scored a goal early in the second half the crowd would have picked up yesterday.

 


California sunlight - sweet Calcutta rain - Honolulu starbright - the song remains the same

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 05 Feb 17 9.42am

Originally posted by timbob

I agree wholeheartedly

What happened to the palace faithful crowd that even cheered when we losing?

( palace 0 - 3 liverpool. Then fan power surge Palace 3 - 3 Liverpool )

Many other times when the loyal fans clapped a losing palace side off greeted by Jedi n Julian for doing so

There's been no warming of allardyce towards the fans that I have seen whatsoever .... WHY ?

There's no captain going to the corner of singing n loud fans thanking them for their contribution win or lose WHY ?

There appears to be a 'distance'. between this group and the loyal fan base and the staff n players which I have rarely witnessed in 40 years of support WHY ?

It's been five weeks under the 'New order'

Sam needs to get 'in touch' with the fan base for sure, n geeee them up

The players also need to do this, as Julian tried to do a short while ago to the singing section

We need that encouragement .... that energy...right now.....!

Also guys n gals can we look past blame and just get behind our team please and stand up and be proud and be PALACE !!!

We need to get back our rep for being loud and being great supporters do we want Brighton to swap with us ?

I'm going to stoke next sat now as a result of yesterday to contribute let's turn this around peeps n play our part as loyal fans


I do think that the problems on the pitch are perhaps a little more fundamental than can be addressed by upping the noise level.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 05 Feb 17 10.00am

Originally posted by Painter

There are a multitude of problems, that appear obvious.

1. There appears to be no pattern to how we play, it seems to change every game. So the players don't know what they are supposed to be doing. Every player should know, what is expected of them, they don't, they seem strangers that just met in the changing room.
2. Lack of organisation in defence still. In yesterdays game, everytime we were attacking Sunderland, they were perfectly lined up in 2 banks of When they attacked us, we were shambolic.
3. No leader on the pitch, along with no desire from about 5 players.
4. Fitness was an issue, getting better.
5. No point blaming Pardew anymore, that is easy cop out.
6. Puncheon and Ledley need a long rest, not needed in the team as contribute nothing anymore.

Good points. This is a fair point and I understand what you are getting at but yesterday surely changing the formation might of been justified ? We were playing at home against another struggling club. Why were we seemingly looking to snick a win from the off under this scenario ?

Edited by Booted Eagle (05 Feb 2017 10.01am)

Edited by Booted Eagle (05 Feb 2017 10.02am)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Feb 17 10.10am

Maybe we need to take an idea from the 'w**k breaks at work' thread. As soon as they go a goal down, someone playing the worst is nominated to fake a broken leg. They all go off for a break and come back less stressed.

The play like w**kers at times. May as well.

 


COYP

Mo Sizlak Flag 05 Feb 17 10.16am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Maybe we need to take an idea from the 'w**k breaks at work' thread. As soon as they go a goal down, someone playing the worst is nominated to fake a broken leg. They all go off for a break and come back less stressed.

The play like w**kers at times. May as well.

 


Babs and Clean Willie were in love they said....

chateauferret Flag 05 Feb 17 10.20am

Originally posted by Mo Sizlak

That man has done untold damage to my club.
We should've learnt from Southampton, West Ham, Charlton and Newcastle.
He's always been a divisive character and anyone who can't see that is living in La La Land.

This. It now looks as if some of the players have been so badly damaged they'll never be competitive in the Premier League again. Delaney probably more due to age. But Puncheon, Kelly, Hennessey, Ledley - completely f***ed. They can only be repaired in a full and well-designed close-season boot camp, if at all.

Dann and Ward also severley damaged.

 


============
The Ferret
============

chateauferret Flag 05 Feb 17 10.23am

Originally posted by Salford eagle

I think you're reading too much into it. We lost due to a combination of bad decisions tactically and the players bottled it.

Replacing the injured Cabaye with Ledley sealed the deal. The midfield was too one dimensional, Remy should have came on with macathur dropping in to Cabaye's position. Hopefully BS has learnt his lesson from yesterday, no more Ledley puncheon combination.

No more Ledley or Puncheon full stop. Schlupp and Milevojevic.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 05 Feb 17 10.28am

Originally posted by chateauferret

This. It now looks as if some of the players have been so badly damaged they'll never be competitive in the Premier League again. Delaney probably more due to age. But Puncheon, Kelly, Hennessey, Ledley - completely f***ed. They can only be repaired in a full and well-designed close-season boot camp, if at all.

Dann and Ward also severley damaged.

This is sadly true. What Pardew did to Kelly is criminal. No left back cover at all and then plays Kelly there for 2 months and Ward at right back instead of the other way round.

And people say he's probably laughing at this and us now.

 


COYP

Maddie Flag Crawley 05 Feb 17 10.49am

Originally posted by Painter

There are a multitude of problems, that appear obvious.

1. There appears to be no pattern to how we play, it seems to change every game. So the players don't know what they are supposed to be doing. Every player should know, what is expected of them, they don't, they seem strangers that just met in the changing room.
2. Lack of organisation in defence still. In yesterdays game, everytime we were attacking Sunderland, they were perfectly lined up in 2 banks of When they attacked us, we were shambolic.
3. No leader on the pitch, along with no desire from about 5 players.
4. Fitness was an issue, getting better.
5. No point blaming Pardew anymore, that is easy cop out.
6. Puncheon and Ledley need a long rest, not needed in the team as contribute nothing anymore.

Absolutely agree with your points. Why on our are we playing our best player, MacArthur, as a winger. As far as I can remember he has never played there. At the if the day the players are coached in where to play and it failed miserably. Why oh why are we not playing two strikers at home against the team with the worst defensive record in the league. Our play has not improved under bfs in fact we are letting in goals by the shed load since he came in. Wrong choice of manager he is greedy and o my in it for the money. Since the Americans started getting involved on the playing side it has been a disaster.

 

Rainforest Flag London England 05 Feb 17 11.05am

Originally posted by Maddie

Absolutely agree with your points. Why on our are we playing our best player, MacArthur, as a winger. As far as I can remember he has never played there. At the if the day the players are coached in where to play and it failed miserably. Why oh why are we not playing two strikers at home against the team with the worst defensive record in the league. Our play has not improved under bfs in fact we are letting in goals by the shed load since he came in. Wrong choice of manager he is greedy and o my in it for the money. Since the Americans started getting involved on the playing side it has been a disaster.

I wonder whether they interfere in the day to day running of the club or whether they call the shots in the selling and buying of players.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 05 Feb 17 11.15am

Originally posted by Mo Sizlak

There's only ever been one problem and that's Pardew.
This charlatan has gotten away with it since he took charge.
He had a good spell but he papered over so many cracks with the cup run.
And because he wasn't sacked early enough, we are now paying the price.
Its that simple.

I think it's time to give it a rest otherwise you will be in danger of being thought of as a one trick pony.

Blaming Pardew for absolutely everything is neither constructive nor the answer to our current plight so it's not that simple

 

Aray Flag South London 05 Feb 17 11.32am

Goalkeeper makes a mistake and the trouble starts. Cabeye replaced with Ledley (surely Flamini was the better option) Punch remains in midfield

I cannot understand why Jim Mac didn't swap positions with punch

Delaney's poor distribution putting Ledley in trouble- and let's face it he can do that all by himself.

Tomkins turned inside out by Defoe and unable to hit the back end of a cow with a banjo. To think He took the ball off Dann's head...

Sat on a train with a Sunderland fan. Reckons SA will get us going in the end. He still thinks they're going down. Let's face it - they can't face us every week.

More generally- I'm concerned with our shape as Ward is no wing-back. Hope we go back to 4 at the back coz we can then drop DD and PVA will need someone good in front of him but that only works if he's at leftback - not left wingback.


 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 05 Feb 17 11.39am

Originally posted by Mo Sizlak

There's only ever been one problem and that's Pardew.
This charlatan has gotten away with it since he took charge.
He had a good spell but he papered over so many cracks with the cup run.
And because he wasn't sacked early enough, we are now paying the price.
Its that simple.


well said. Pardew has left a toxic cloud and it may be too late to save us.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So what are the problems?