This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Opinions are like arseholes, everyone's got one..
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
G Thomas 18 May 17 2.12pm |
|
|
Hello everyone, my name is Gareth Thomas and I'm a former rugby player, wrong shape ball joke there for you! Being gay myself (hope you don't think I'm going on about it there), I'm really interested in reading some of your opinions on the issue of chanting and what some people consider homophobic language; what do people think is the line between abuse and banter when it comes to football chants? I believe everyone is entitled to their opinion, but should also be brave enough to defend their opinions when challenged..
On that note, I'd really like to invite some of you to meet and exchange opinions on this subject. I'm making a documentary for the BBC and feel it's important to include a range of opinions and fan bases.
Let me know what you think on this subject, (not on me..I come in peace!)Gareth Thomas.
|
SwordFish Peasmarsh,East Sussex 18 May 17 2.15pm |
|
|
Personally I think if anyone is going to get offended by a chant or takes anything personally football matches are not the place for them! Too much of a nanny state nowadays watching what you say!! Fattest,sexist, racist, homophobic its all gone to far. Pathetic. I sing what I want and if anyone gets offended they should do one
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder
|
Bangell Oxford 18 May 17 2.17pm |
|
|
Promising start to this thread
|
Part Time James 18 May 17 2.18pm |
|
|
You're the second person to come on here and say this. Multiple user IDs?
I suspect to an outsider the comments on this forum may often appear to cross some kind of imaginary boundary and for that reason may have drawn your attention. Whilst a short trawl round the whole forum on a variety of subjects will demonstrate most people on here make tongue in cheek comments about everything.
Personally I find a lot of football chanting offensive. At the Burnley games they were singing about "staying up" but I've not had an erection since June 2004.
|
Part Time James 18 May 17 2.19pm |
|
Originally posted by SwordFish
Personally I think if anyone is going to get offended by a chant or takes anything personally football matches are not the place for them! Too much of a nanny state nowadays watching what you say!! Fattest,sexist, racist, homophobic its all gone to far. Pathetic. I sing what I want and if anyone gets offended they should do one
Yes, agreed, if you don't like comedians saying rude words you go to see Victoria Wood instead of Frankie Boyle. Although she's brown bread now so my argument falls apart a bit.
|
npn Crowborough 18 May 17 2.19pm |
|
Originally posted by Part Time James
You're the second person to come on here and say this. Multiple user IDs?
I suspect to an outsider the comments on this forum may often appear to cross some kind of imaginary boundary and for that reason may have drawn your attention. Whilst a short trawl round the whole forum on a variety of subjects will demonstrate most people on here make tongue in cheek comments about everything.
Personally I find a lot of football chanting offensive. At the Burnley games they were singing about "staying up" but I've not had an erection since June 2004.
That's uncanny - I HAVE had an erection since 2004!
|
Park Road 18 May 17 2.22pm |
|
|
Another gay thread that makes 3
|
SwordFish Peasmarsh,East Sussex 18 May 17 2.24pm |
|
|
Does anyone remember when some idiot came on here saying we should have a rainbow flag in the holmesdale??
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder
|
Part Time James 18 May 17 2.25pm |
|
Originally posted by npn
That's uncanny - I HAVE had an erection since 2004!
It was Neil Shipperley's fault I assume?
|
npn Crowborough 18 May 17 2.26pm |
|
|
Again, uncanny, since Shipperley hasn't been able to see his erection since 2004!
|
Part Time James 18 May 17 2.28pm |
|
Originally posted by npn
Again, uncanny, since Shipperley hasn't been able to see his erection since 2004!
I think that playoff final goal went in off his erection didn't it?
|
Alex1991 Ashford 18 May 17 2.32pm |
|
|
I don't think there's any room for it in this day and age. In 10/15 years time it will be viewed in the same way as racist chanting. There are undoubtedly many people watching the games who are struggling with their identities and to hear songs that make them suppress that is wrong. It's statistically likely that there is a member of our squad or backroom staff who is gay, as fans we shouldn't be insulting our own players and their lifestyle choices. When a player does come out then I think it will curb it even further.
This has obviously all come about because of Brighton going up, but from a Palace point of view why would that need to be an insult. We've had far more success than them. I'll be singing about that.
"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.
|
SwordFish Peasmarsh,East Sussex 18 May 17 2.34pm |
|
Originally posted by Alex1991
I don't think there's any room for it in this day and age. In 10/15 years time it will be viewed in the same way as racist chanting. There are undoubtedly many people watching the games who are struggling with their identities and to hear songs that make them suppress that is wrong. It's statistically likely that there is a member of our squad or backroom staff who is gay, as fans we shouldn't be insulting our own players and their lifestyle choices. When a player does come out then I think it will curb it even further.
This has obviously all come about because of Brighton going up, but from a Palace point of view why would that need to be an insult. We've had far more success than them. I'll be singing about that.
Oh dear..... here we go
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 18 May 17 2.36pm |
|
|
I'm confused now. Are you Gareth Thomas, the former rugby player or Sion Thomas posing as Gareth Thomas?
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
Alex1991 Ashford 18 May 17 2.36pm |
|
|
Just my opinion, I'm not stating it as fact. I am acutely aware that lots of people will disagree !
"Brighton are talking about how they're coming for us. And it's like, we've been waiting in the Premier League for you for ages." Wilfried Zaha, 2017.
|
Bangell Oxford 18 May 17 2.38pm |
|
|
If I can offer an overly intellectual opinion, I did make an interesting note from Randall Collins' book on the micro-sociology of violence recently:
'Despite the use of sexist epithets to insult men they do not like, the hooligans of the 1980s were ardent admirers of Margaret Thatcher and the queen—presumably because these could be used to assert English solidarity and superiority, and to put down respectable educated liberals and leftists; although in Italy they chant ‘f*** the Pope!’, at home they defend the Catholic church, out of hostility to the Anglican establishment (Buford 1993: 95). The pattern is much like that analyzed by Katz (1999) in his study of freeway road rage: curses are brought to one's lips because they fit the particular target one is confronting at the moment; they need not be based on deeply held beliefs, and the repertoire can be inconsistent and contradictory from occasion to occasion.'
I'd suggest that homophobic taunts are a similar phenomenon: those chanting mostly aren't deep-seated homophobes, but instrumentalise a background convention of homophobia, as Anthony King has argued in the case of most racist chanting.
So I don't think that most people joining in with these chants are particularly hateful; but intent is somewhat irrelevant when the effect is chanting that equates homosexuality with all sorts of negative traits. There's no room for subtlety in a crowd.
|
Michaelawt85 Bexley 18 May 17 2.42pm |
|
|
The second person to post on here about this bbc documentry. Notice 'gareths' email address on his profile . Used the name sion. Similar to r he address being used by another poster who has been emailing people wanting them to talk on this subject.
A good piece of advice someone gave me. Don't let your ego blind you. Approach this with caution. I wonder if similar things are being posted in any other fans forums for other clubs or is it just palace. Easy to get carried away at games when in a crowd with a mob mentality under the influence of alcohol. Don't say you haven't been warned about the attention which is coming out way .
I have attached the email I and other members received. Make of it what you will..
And as James has said lots of members on this site know each other in real life and banter with each other. I would take much of what is written here with a big pinch of salt
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC
|
Michaelawt85 Bexley 18 May 17 2.43pm |
|
|
This email
Attachment: Screenshot_2017-05-18-14-38-46.png (180.99Kb)
When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC
|
mezzer Main Stand, Block F, Row 20 seat 1... 18 May 17 2.47pm |
|
|
Interesting they're both Welsh.
Same village? Must be unusual
Living down here does have some advantages. At least you can see them cry.
|
Part Time James 18 May 17 2.51pm |
|
Originally posted by mezzer
Interesting they're both Welsh.
Same village? Must be unusual
BOOM! I knew I'd voted for the right guy!
|