You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > De Boer: are you feeling optimistic or worried?
November 16 2026 9.10am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

De Boer: are you feeling optimistic or worried?


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 30 Jul 17 7.33pm

Just thought I'd garner people's vibes - it's all so unpredictable, but having made every team in the club change to 3-4-3 Frank won't half look a plonker if we lose our first four games, conversely he'll be hailed as a a genius if we win our first four. I like: the introduction of ball-playing defenders (only one so far I know but we seem to be targeting this type of player); insisting Luka play in a back three until we get a right back who can play as a 3rd defender (Van der Wiel? I hope he comes back on the radar, seems to have gone quiet here like it did for Riedewald - cud all be fake news re this one) and Loftus Cheek is an excellent addition. But the system might end up a heroic failure or a misconceived experiment exposed by Huddersfield & co. It could of course turn out somewhere in the middle, it probably will in the long term, but FDB's employing a high risk strategy changing the playing style root and branch in a matter of weeks - and it's fair to ask how you reckon it will pan out. I can see it going pear-shaped of course but I genuinely believe from the clues so far that it's more likely we'll be pleasantly surprised.
So thumbs UP from me.

 

Dan89 Flag Se25 30 Jul 17 7.44pm

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Just thought I'd garner people's vibes - it's all so unpredictable, but having made every team in the club change to 3-4-3 Frank won't half look a plonker if we lose our first four games, conversely he'll be hailed as a a genius if we win our first four. I like: the introduction of ball-playing defenders (only one so far I know but we seem to be targeting this type of player); insisting Luka play in a back three until we get a right back who can play as a 3rd defender (Van der Wiel? I hope he comes back on the radar, seems to have gone quiet here like it did for Riedewald - cud all be fake news re this one) and Loftus Cheek is an excellent addition. But the system might end up a heroic failure or a misconceived experiment exposed by Huddersfield & co. It could of course turn out somewhere in the middle, it probably will in the long term, but FDB's employing a high risk strategy changing the playing style root and branch in a matter of weeks - and it's fair to ask how you reckon it will pan out. I can see it going pear-shaped of course but I genuinely believe from the clues so far that it's more likely we'll be pleasantly surprised.
So thumbs UP from me.

It was seemingly obvious that when you have a football education that de Boer has , he was always gonna play a game where the play get lots of possession in high areas of the field. Parish must of known this, when he was appointed. If we go through a rough patch, we must back de Boer as this is a long term project. We looking for stability.

 


Another Damien Diagonal - Total Football

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Jul 17 7.52pm

I think developments on the playing field have surprised most of our supporters.It might take time for FDBs plans to really be effective so we might all need to be somewhat patient.The planned new signings will help of course.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 30 Jul 17 7.55pm

Optimistic - we've looked really assured in pre-season, not that that's always a reliable measure of anything. Deep down, I suppose I do feel that the squad would still be best-suited to a counter attacking 4-3-3, but we'll see how things go. Particularly reassured by De Boer saying that the defence is the most important part of winning.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 30 Jul 17 9.16pm

on balance, slightly worried.

maybe we can cobble together an effective 343 (I have doubts even about that from this squad ( but how can we get a squad together to cover injuries to that system?

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

redshift Flag Toronto 30 Jul 17 9.20pm

put me in the optimistic column.

 


Success will lie to you but failure always tells you the truth.

beak Flag croydon 30 Jul 17 9.21pm

New systems usually take a long time to perfect,I am worried that we will drop too many easy points early in the campaign.

 

.TUX. Flag 30 Jul 17 9.36pm

I've got no worries at all.
I believe we'll have a more than decent campaign and progress further as a club.
All good.

 


Buy Litecoin.

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 30 Jul 17 11.43pm

Optimistic - But i am a glass half filled person, on paper our team looks pretty solid and if we can avoid the multiple injuries in the same positions, we should do just fine.

Also our run in is nothing like the one we had towards the end of the 2016/2017 season, which makes me think we will finish mid table...

Edited by Gary St.Andrews (31 Jul 2017 12.06am)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 31 Jul 17 6.08am

Originally posted by Dan89

It was seemingly obvious that when you have a football education that de Boer has , he was always gonna play a game where the play get lots of possession in high areas of the field. Parish must of known this, when he was appointed. If we go through a rough patch, we must back de Boer as this is a long term project. We looking for stability.


There are fine margins in the PL and our "rough patches" have come close to relegating us in previous seasons. This "project" should indeed have been "long-term", with a measured change to a different style of play (if that's what was required) over an extended period, and not a complete change in a matter of weeks, particularly without the personnel to make it work. We were achieving "stability" under Sam and beating three of the top six in the process. Instead of building on that success, in our fifth season, we're back to the drawing board like a newly promoted club sailing into unknown waters. I hope that it all works out, but experience suggests we're taking a massive risk that has a high percentage chance of failure.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Face in Wetherspoons Flag 31 Jul 17 8.24am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

Just thought I'd garner people's vibes - it's all so unpredictable, but having made every team in the club change to 3-4-3 Frank won't half look a plonker if we lose our first four games, conversely he'll be hailed as a a genius if we win our first four. I like: the introduction of ball-playing defenders (only one so far I know but we seem to be targeting this type of player); insisting Luka play in a back three until we get a right back who can play as a 3rd defender (Van der Wiel? I hope he comes back on the radar, seems to have gone quiet here like it did for Riedewald - cud all be fake news re this one) and Loftus Cheek is an excellent addition. But the system might end up a heroic failure or a misconceived experiment exposed by Huddersfield & co. It could of course turn out somewhere in the middle, it probably will in the long term, but FDB's employing a high risk strategy changing the playing style root and branch in a matter of weeks - and it's fair to ask how you reckon it will pan out. I can see it going pear-shaped of course but I genuinely believe from the clues so far that it's more likely we'll be pleasantly surprised.
So thumbs UP from me.

Very worried I am afraid. Alan Pardew went for the expansive football approach last Season and we looked like relegation fodder by Christmas. It was only when we went back to the style that we know best under Big Sam that we picked up the points to survive. It seems that Steve P and the Board are committed to open play and at least he has signed a Manager who appears to be better placed to implement the system and both of our new signings are already able to play to it. It is, of course, imperative that we start the Season well to pick up points for a 'comfort zone' but I fear that we are not ready for instant success (still learning) but will be picking up draws rather than wins until the new system is 'bedded' in. I hope for the best but we clearly need two good strikers to join the Squad as an early injury to Benteke would be hard to cope with. Still not sure why some people have turned on Joel Ward and Jimmy Mac as both are more than good enough for the Squad and will be needed if things do not turn out well and we have to revert to our traditional style and scrap to dig out points.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 31 Jul 17 8.40am

Neither optimistic or worried yet as it all depends on two things. Firstly the other new players that we are reputedly bringing in and FdB's ability to switch to a plan B if plan A isn't working

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 31 Jul 17 8.53am

I'm optimistic.with all due respect to Pardew playing a more possession based game is a part of De Boers DNA.what i've seen in the friendlies so far is us playing some good football but at the same time being solid at the back.two of those games against premier league opposition we will get better also with new signings coming in.

 

budapest cpfc Flag Wien 31 Jul 17 8.59am

YES until I come on here with all the BS this wrong that's wrong get behind FDB and the boys

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 31 Jul 17 9.03am

good point - last season Conte changed the system to suit the Chelsea players, we seem to be doing the reverse: suiting the players to a system - which concerns me. But the formation might just be a template for possession or a starting point, and if it's clear we revert to more familiar formations when we need to then we can be a lot less concerned. It does make sense that there is consistency throughout the club, and with all this high-pressing and most teams having two defensive midfielders, where only one used to do, defences get much better protection than before and if you can free up another defender it's definitely the way to go these days - teams who can't play three at the back, even if it's not their regular formation, may find things getting harder - I think Spurs are the only team in the top six who don't ever play with a back three, it's harder to organise but makes sense in terms of numbers and space on the pitch. I argued this two or three years back and was met for the first time with the rudeness of Bexleydave - to be fair he seems to have improved.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 31 Jul 17 9.08am

Originally posted by budapest cpfc

YES until I come on here with all the BS this wrong that's wrong get behind FDB and the boys

This is a forum for discussion, where all are entitled to express their views and, because they may differ from your own, doesn't make them "BS". Expressing a reasonable concern does not equate to a lack of support. As a matter of interest, exactly how do you plan to "get behind FdB and the boys" from Hungary?

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 31 Jul 17 9.10am

I think he's doing a great job.

Don't really understand why people aren't impressed.

The youth he's giving game time don't look lost, which means it's the right call. So their stock is rising. #check

No one ever thought they'd be this ready. #check

Playing more of a passing game. #check

EVERYONE was at pains that we only had one system. #check

FdB spends pre session learning a new system. #check

We look more comfortable on the ball then we ever have. #check

Talk from the dressing room is that everyone is embracing his ideas. #check

First loan signing looks quality #check

First actual signing (for only £8m) looks quality first team starter #check

Sounds like we're very much looking to sign other ball playing players #check

Hold our own in our pre season games. #check

Don't look lost in the new system the coach has coached #check

HOLs lining up with blame should manager fail. #check

Edited by Goldfiinger (31 Jul 2017 9.18am)

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 31 Jul 17 9.14am

Originally posted by bexleydave

This is a forum for discussion, where all are entitled to express their views and, because they may differ from your own, doesn't make them "BS". Expressing a reasonable concern does not equate to a lack of support. As a matter of interest, exactly how do you plan to "get behind FdB and the boys" from Hungary?

Budapest cpfc like all of us is Hungary for success

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 31 Jul 17 9.16am

Are you feeling optimistic or worried?

This will reveal little about the future of Palace and more about the individual posters' outlook on life. I'm feeling optimistic, more than that actually, quite positive, about our future!

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 31 Jul 17 9.19am

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

I think he's doing a great job.

Don't really understand why people aren't impressed.

The youth he's giving game time don't look lost, which means it's the right call. So their stock is rising. #check

No one ever thought they'd be this ready. #check

Playing more of a passing game. #check

EVERYONE was at pains that we only had one system. #check

FdB spends pre session learning a new system. #check

We look more comfortable on the ball then we ever have. #check

Talk from the dressing room is that everyone is embracing his ideas. #check

First loan signing looks quality #check

First actual signing (for only £8m) looks quality first team starter #check

Sounds like we're very much looking to sign other ball playing players #check

HOLs lining up with blame should manager fail. #check

Edited by Goldfiinger (31 Jul 2017 9.13am)

Great post Goldfiinger.agree with all you say.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > De Boer: are you feeling optimistic or worried?