This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
Oooops sorry, yes I forgot Sahko got injured at the end. I realised after I hit the post button, darn. Regarding the bit, I have bolded. It must have been clear to FDB he was working with a very weak middle and back lineup that was compensated by a very strong forward line up, so yes it was touch and go last season. However, there is plenty to suggest that Frank was trying out players in different formations, knowing he won't have a lot to spend and went and got what he could for free plus 8 mils to top up the center, and openly stated he wanted a defender, a goalie and a forward. Actually given the size of the squad he had very little time to teach and get to know all the weaknesses. Ended up I guess in frustration looking at the development squad for answers, who ERONOUSLY he put faith in to perform with confidence. Again unlike many on this board, I am admitting that this is speculation. Although Gary Neville's summation after the Swans game in MOTD suggested that is exactly what he was doing. To disregard the injuries to Zaha Loftus-Cheek and Reidewald with such a thin squad, therefore should not have affected the strategy or re positioning of players is naive which I know you are not, but I guess that's your view. Since I have not seen you allude to those facts with any vigor. To not bear in mind that Townsend turned up late after the teams had already been submitted to the refs and therefore had to be benched, and the resulting re formation of players is apparently also FDB's fault, therefore, is something that doesn't warrant any defending is typical of the Frank Out sentiment. We all watched the same games, the truth of what really happend that contributed to the lost games, in my view lies closer to the summation of all the views expressed minus the bad journalists and the gun ho attitude of the 'Direct Football' brigade.
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
You talk about people being naive towards Frank. Just how would you describe his summer, definitely the Huddersfield game and the approach to the Swansea game? Frank needed half a team minimum to play 3-4-3 and that's on top striker, keeper etc etc etc. It was a ridiculous idea that was supposed to be a plan b, not plan a and forget all about the other plan. The mistakes happened because of the players and other players' positioning, therefore the formation that the players are not suited to and are out of position in. Ward all over the place, PVA too high up, confusion with marking and tracking over crosses from his or both wings. If/when he gets sacked, who would you like to replace him with?
|
|
|
Originally posted by matthau
If/when he gets sacked, who would you like to replace him with? Frank was behind my original list of Silva depending on his plans in interview. Didn't make enough or any effort there. Should've delayed 1 of 7 holidays and flown back rather than tell him to fly to Spain. He was in demand after all. Pellegrino was well worth an interview. Dyche. Now it's harder because they're all performing after starting new jobs and Dyche won't leave. We're probably left with Hodgson or maybe even Bilic. If we want an impact manager with lots of passion and inspiration then he might be the man. Apart from them and Allardyce there's no one else with prem experience out there. Parish ignored both of the 2 we could've got to try and wind the clock forward to Frank, only Frank wanted to put a turbo motor in the clock. Still time for Frank to succeed. Use the squad and Sammy properly and responsibly and he could. So far he hasn't.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
Interested to see whether he plays a back 3 or back 4 against Burnley. They would have conducted an in-depth tactical analysis of how Burnley play and at the end of the day FDB will decide which formation to play in the best interests of the team.Doubt if he will be swayed by those urging him to play differently. I get your point again. Picking a team that can switch would be the best idea if 3 at the back is his thinking, but to do that he'd have to pick Townsend at RWB which makes us even weaker up top. The other solution is Schlupp at LWB and Riedewald CB and after the switch, Schlupp goes left midfield. Or you mess about moving Ward from RWB to LB which is not for me. Edited by Rudi Hedman (08 Sep 2017 11.26am)
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I get your point again. Picking a team that can switch would be the best idea if 3 at the back is his thinking, but to do that he'd have to pick Townsend at RWB which makes us even weaker up too. The other solution is Schlupp at RWB and Riedewald CB and after the switch, Schlupp goes left midfield. Or you mess about moving Ward from RWB to LB which is not for me.
Bexley Dave Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing! "The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum) |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
I get your point again. Picking a team that can switch would be the best idea if 3 at the back is his thinking, but to do that he'd have to pick Townsend at RWB which makes us even weaker up too. The other solution is Schlupp at RWB and Riedewald CB and after the switch, Schlupp goes left midfield. Or you mess about moving Ward from RWB to LB which is not for me. I understand your arguments. What I was trying to say (Probably not very well !) is that FDB will make his decision based on what emerges from the tactical analysis and who is available to him and won't necessarily take heed of any siren voices telling him otherwise. That said if in his mind it is a close run thing between a 3 or a 4 he might go with a 4 so if it doesn't work he might not come in for further vituperation as he would have done what the vast majority have wanted.Continue with a 3 and we come unstuck and one can only imagine the furore ! Edited by Willo (08 Sep 2017 11.35am)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
You talk about people being naive towards Frank. Just how would you describe his summer, definitely the Huddersfield game and the approach to the Swansea game? Frank needed half a team minimum to play 3-4-3 and that's on top striker, keeper etc etc etc. It was a ridiculous idea that was supposed to be a plan b, not plan a and forget all about the other plan. The mistakes happened because of the players and other players' positioning, therefore the formation that the players are not suited to and are out of position in. Ward all over the place, PVA too high up, confusion with marking and tracking over crosses from his or both wings.
What you describe as bad position play, is strange if you are saying an experienced professional player like Ward was all over the place, cos he didn't know the difference between when we are transitioning from defense to attack and back to defence again, wow. I just call that unfit, and was undone time and again by faster players. The same goes for PVA to unfit/lazy to drop back when needed. These guys have been playing soccer for the best part of their lives, I argue that they do and for their wages ought to know better, and is preposterous to suggest they have no idea about those formations and how to deal with transitions. This is yet another example of scapegoating, If they were any good why didn't any team even in the championship or the leagues below put in so much as an enquiry for them that the papers so quickly jump at, in the transfer window, we needed the money. Gun Ho Direct football fanatics !!! have a view to suit their narrative.
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by crystalball
Right on all counts mate I don't understand the commitment to 3-4-3 when our squad clearly doesn't suit it and are used to 4-3-3. What's more De Boer played 4-3-3 throughout his time at Ajax, and had a fair amount of success with it. I watched Arsenal play 3 at the back to Liverpool's 4.Liverpool gave their defenders problems in that Firmino dropped deep and in effect they has 2 'No 10s' and the Arsenal central defenders had nobody to mark causing confusion not least because they had to cope with runners from deep.Salah and Mane also went inside, allowing Liverpool's full-backs space to get into wide positions. Tactical masterpiece by Klopp but some of the Arsenal players weren't committed to the cause and let their team down. Edited by Willo (08 Sep 2017 12.40pm)
|
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
I watched Arsenal play 3 at the back to Liverpool's 4.Liverpool gave their defenders problems in that Firmino dropped deep and in effect they has 2 'No 10s' and the Arsenal central defenders had nobody to mark causing confusion not least beacuse they had to cope with runners from deep.Salah and Mane also went inside, allowing Liverpool's full-backs space to get into wide positions. Tactical masterpiece by Klopp but some of the Arsenal players weren't committed to the cause and let their team down. Edited by Willo (08 Sep 2017 12.39pm) Kind of what my replies are to your prediction Frank may play 3 v Burnley's possible 2 strikers.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Willo
It was actually 5 teams, apart from us it was Man Utd, Man C,Swansea and Watford.Burnley abstained. you're right, it said two on the radio this morning but other places are reporting 5. Surprised Man Utd voted against given how early they did their business. Maybe it's more about selling than buying.
|
|
|
Scheduled for 1.30 in 5 mins. No stream I'm aware of. Someone on the BBS will probably type out almost word for word.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
Kind of what my replies are to your prediction Frank may play 3 v Burnley's possible 2 strikers. Wasn't my prediction but he might deem that a 3 at the back against Burnley might be more advantageous for us if they play 2 up front.Burnley have had a tendency to play a 2-man strikeforce but not seen them or heard how they have setup this season.Our club with their analysis will know !
|
|
|
Originally posted by Rudi Hedman
What absolute garbage. Frank played all pre season 3-4-3 and 3 matches with 3 at the back, completely ignoring the limitations of ward, which you seem stubborn with too. It's not just fitness. You tell me how good ward is with nobody to pass to on the outside? OK Rudi no probs
As the ball advances up the field the idea is to narrow the opposition thus giving an opportunity for the wings to then stretch the defense, by fast short one touch play taking the ball up the field.
3 maybe 4 out of the defenders on our books before Sackho are just not up to the job anymore, which just creates problems. Sorry to say, love them, but it's time to start giving way to the youth.
They (the mids) need to get closer to each other and to give each other more support thereby creating the short fluid passing game and narrowing the opposition.
He is used to being the target man, and needs to run about a bit more to create the passing spaces. That AM or wings can find easily. It's no longer a straight dash goalwards game every time sometimes yes, of course, anything to get a goal.
And the most laughable of all, you tell me why you think ward is going to be able to play as a wing back when his best football has been in a 4 when safety before attack is the main message? And ward is nearing the latter years of his career. Young legs, Spring chicken he isn't. Old dog and new tricks for a usual back 4 RB is what he is. It is laughable indeed at your conclusion since [I believe] he was only there mainly because of injuries, lateness etc. The first game was an experiment true, but then the injuries set in. Didn't Frank say only 3-4-3? Well he bl33ding well did, did he not? No thats a total misquote, or bad TV edit, he never stated only 3-4-3. Its always 3-4-3, 4-3-3, and 3-5-1 as primary settings of Total football. In fact a recent interview I recall, maybe after the swans game He re-iterated that very misquote. Still time but it'll be to save his neck first. This pipe dream is months and possibly more Windows away.
I've been following Ajax as my only foreign team, If you don't count Hearts (for personal reasons) since the days when the Crystal Palace Kit was like the Ajax style sash, ours Red and blue. Waiting for that big Academy in the sky to come down to the Palace before any other South London Team does and realises the massive potential in the demography. Hopefully, before the big sky comes down on me and eventually takes me away. It's a business model that has worked for many, Southampton the most consistently, I don't want local kids to be slaves to breeder academies like Chelski with their 57 and counting loanees. I hope Parish has the courage to finish what he started and keeps Frank on for a few windows, at least we both agree it's gonna take that to get there. Have a good day
School, SN.Juniors, SN High, Selhurst. 1st match 1972 CP 2 N. Utd 1. Thank you, John Jackson and Vince Hilair for brightening our darkest days. I moved to the west country in 1983. Always Proud and 'Glad All Over' to be a Palace Fan. |
|
|
Originally posted by bexleydave
So far, on Twitter from the press conference: Loftus Cheek returns to squad for Sunday Hoping Tomkins and Cabaye available, decision after Saturday training FDB has positive feeling after seeing training this week - knows it takes time - have a long-term project here Wants to start seeing the performances he's expecting - once we get results it will give all the confidence we need Edited by bexleydave (08 Sep 2017 1.50pm) So there - He is going to be around for a while yet !
Edited by Willo (08 Sep 2017 1.56pm)
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.