You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha, our best.. ever?
November 16 2026 8.07am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Zaha, our best.. ever?


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
michaelpearce Flag grays 29 Oct 17 6.32pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

You beat me to it - the best 2 players ever to play for Palace - Kenny Sansom and Ian Wright, no if's, buts or why for's.

My Dad would argue Johnny Byrne - but I'm sure only because he was his captain in the academy/junior side. So way before my time - older HOL'ers may have a view.

Then you have IMO the likes of Jim Cannon, Billy Gilbert, Peter Nicholas, Nigel Martyn, Geoff Thomas, Vince Hilaire, Mark Bright, Nathaniel Clyne, Victor Moses etc..

One of personal favourites Jerry Murphy - such a sweet left peg....!!

Think Wilf is getting close - but as others have said needs consistency and longevity - if he achieves that it would be hard to argue he wouldn't be in the top 3 after King Ken and Sir Ian.

COYP

think that says most about different times could the old guard play today and could the new guard play back then. for me the old guard played like men, you didnt see them crying with the simplest of touches the old didnt wear shin pads most of the time

 

wilelliott88 Flag Manchester 29 Oct 17 6.48pm

In recent times I think the skill and flair side of his game is on par with Bolassie, however his defensive game and his end product have both significantly increased, he is undoubtedly our talisman and he is getting better each week, I just hope he stays!!

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 29 Oct 17 6.55pm

Johnny Byrne for me as was absolute class. Don't forget he played for England even though we were in Div 3 at the time. He commanded the then world record transfer fee and one of the few England players to score a hat trick in an England shirt.
Zaha? Yes a great player but his histrionics at times turn refs against him. That said though he should get more protection when it must be obvious to the ref he is being targeted a la Huddersfield.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 29 Oct 17 6.58pm

Originally posted by Casual

Jansen was better than freedman. IMO

of course you are correct, jansen was something special, beautiful 1st touch, he was made extra special by the fact he chose us over united.

f***ed off to swallow up jack walkers millions after only 25...shame

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Pikester Flag Worthing 29 Oct 17 7.37pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Think I would still choose the 1990-1992 John Salako and pre-injury plsyer over Wilf but only by the width of a pubic hair

When Johnny Salad broke into the England team he was absolutely on fire then cruelly injured and never reached that peak again. He was a great crosser of the ball though.

As has been said - if Wilf was to perform at this level for the rest of this season and maybe next then it would be very difficult not to have him in an All Time Palace XI.

He is carrying us at the moment and just needs to score more regularly and then the rest of the football world will be all over him.

These threads do make me laugh though - it's like reading Youtube comments when someone says Abba were better than the Beatles!

 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 30 Oct 17 7.31am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

You beat me to it - the best 2 players ever to play for Palace - Kenny Sansom and Ian Wright, no if's, buts or why for's.

My Dad would argue Johnny Byrne - but I'm sure only because he was his captain in the academy/junior side. So way before my time - older HOL'ers may have a view.

Then you have IMO the likes of Jim Cannon, Billy Gilbert, Peter Nicholas, Nigel Martyn, Geoff Thomas, Vince Hilaire, Mark Bright, Nathaniel Clyne, Victor Moses etc..

One of personal favourites Jerry Murphy - such a sweet left peg....!!

Think Wilf is getting close - but as others have said needs consistency and longevity - if he achieves that it would be hard to argue he wouldn't be in the top 3 after King Ken and Sir Ian.

COYP

Don't take anything away from Johnny Byrne , your Dad was right, he was great, playing for England (when they were a top team) when Palace were in the 4th Division,only an exceptional player could do that

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 30 Oct 17 8.37am

The best player ever to wear a Palace shirt in my time (since 77). I'm looking at it that he'll only be at Palace for a few more months so enjoy every performance he gives.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Oct 17 8.55am

I don't ever remember Salako saving our &rses like Zaha is doing or us having a minor minor chance without him. When did we ever sing 'He's just too good for you?'

 


COYP

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 30 Oct 17 10.20am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

You beat me to it - the best 2 players ever to play for Palace - Kenny Sansom and Ian Wright, no if's, buts or why for's.

My Dad would argue Johnny Byrne - but I'm sure only because he was his captain in the academy/junior side. So way before my time - older HOL'ers may have a view.

Then you have IMO the likes of Jim Cannon, Billy Gilbert, Peter Nicholas, Nigel Martyn, Geoff Thomas, Vince Hilaire, Mark Bright, Nathaniel Clyne, Victor Moses etc..

One of personal favourites Jerry Murphy - such a sweet left peg....!!

Think Wilf is getting close - but as others have said needs consistency and longevity - if he achieves that it would be hard to argue he wouldn't be in the top 3 after King Ken and Sir Ian.

COYP

Many of the players you mention above are also favs of mine, however you could not possibly suggest that players like Murphy or Nicholas are anywhere near as good as Wilf.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

michaelpearce Flag grays 30 Oct 17 11.22am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I don't ever remember Salako saving our &rses like Zaha is doing or us having a minor minor chance without him. When did we ever sing 'He's just too good for you?'

well you must be to young he covered lots of ground in attack and defence and in goal we had a stronger team all round, and he did try to carry us after wrighty had gone, sally played more attacking roll then thats how he done his knee i still wince seeing his leg go the wrong way, and we did sing his name not whats being sung for wilf but that is a new chant if you base it on chants then hilaires was better but not pc

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Oct 17 12.29pm

Originally posted by michaelpearce

well you must be to young he covered lots of ground in attack and defence and in goal we had a stronger team all round, and he did try to carry us after wrighty had gone, sally played more attacking roll then thats how he done his knee i still wince seeing his leg go the wrong way, and we did sing his name not whats being sung for wilf but that is a new chant if you base it on chants then hilaires was better but not pc

Agreed. John was just so solid in attack and defence as a wing back. Outstanding really. And when we came third he was certainly one of the best in a first XI packed with some genuinely very good players. Wilf is the stand out player in a first XI with only two or three very good players.

And John's time was when the rules of football favoured the defences before they were changed to favour the attackers.

Wilf is fantastic and so was John. But if either of them were chosen to play for today's very top teams Bayern or Juve or PSG then I would have to say John is the one who would fit in more.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 30 Oct 17 1.49pm

Salako was a good player but not in the same league as Wilf. Salako had the benefit of a good side around him but Zaha is practically carrying the club on his own. If we stay up it'll be the greatest achievement in the clubs history by their greatest ever player. 39 years of going to Palace and I don't believe I will ever see a player better than Wilf in another 39.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 30 Oct 17 3.11pm

It's so hard to compare players across eras, isn't it? Wilf is just a joy to watch and I think he loves playing for the club (no doubt the ~£110-120k a week probably doesn't hurt).

In my lifetime of watching, Wrightie and Wilf would be the ones. Genuinely special talents who just had something in their DNA that others don't -- a fire to make a difference. Salako really didn't do it over a sustained period. He'd just got there and then got injured and never scaled those same heights ever again. Very sad, really.

I've heard it said that Johnny Byrne was something.

Btw, the idea that we don't have really classy players is daft. We have many.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Oct 17 6.21pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

It's so hard to compare players across eras, isn't it? Wilf is just a joy to watch and I think he loves playing for the club (no doubt the ~£110-120k a week probably doesn't hurt).

In my lifetime of watching, Wrightie and Wilf would be the ones. Genuinely special talents who just had something in their DNA that others don't -- a fire to make a difference. Salako really didn't do it over a sustained period. He'd just got there and then got injured and never scaled those same heights ever again. Very sad, really.

I've heard it said that Johnny Byrne was something.

Btw, the idea that we don't have really classy players is daft. We have many.

Wilf, Andros, Mamadou and....?

The rest are trailing that trio surely?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


palacenomatterwhat Flag Kings Lynn 30 Oct 17 6.52pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

Wilf, Andros, Mamadou and....?

The rest are trailing that trio surely?

I still rate Ian Wright up there for us, he was excitingly classy you didn't know what he would do and although that is similar to Wilf, Wrighty did it over a period of time for us, I was gutted when he left for Arsenal. I think Wilf has the potential to be better, I'd just like to see his goal ratio go up

 


and it's goodnight from me.......

Joe Bloggs Flag Nr Norwich 30 Oct 17 6.55pm

Byrne...Wright and Sansom played High level international football,Byrne played on dreadful pitches and was the clever player who had the ability to improve other players...notably Geoff Hurst.

Wilf is an exciting player perhaps not quite at that level yet and he certainly plays in a much tougher league ....he is very close but needs to create more chances and score more goals.Perhaps in another couple of seasons.

 

Forest Hillbilly Flag in a hidey-hole 30 Oct 17 7.34pm

Originally posted by murphyn13

It's a resounding yes from me. I can't remember anyone who performs as he does under pressure. What. A. Legend.

YEP
worth the entrance fee on his own.

 


I disengage, I turn the page.

michaelpearce Flag grays 31 Oct 17 6.46am

Right a little bit of prospective last season Wilf had good games but the team pulled us out of the sh*t not just one player,
seems like his greatness is based on 2 games chelsea & west spam in both games Townsend worked well with Wilf to give defenders a hard time, if by the end of the season Wilf has hit 15 goals no reason why he cant do that,we can then look at him being up there he is still work in progress
For those who remember Vince Hilaire when he was good he was brilliant the crowd the manger all shouted at the team to give him the ball but when he was bad he was awful
Wilf is not so hit and miss as vince but still think he is behind taylor rogers budgie and sally who all played in the same position

 

Ian-VI Flag Vicenza 02 Nov 17 3.50pm

I think Zaha is slowly getting our best ever.
I haven't seen some of the old ones, so I cannot give a sentence, but I think he's getting there already.
Allow me to say this, I might become not popular, but this is what I think. I have seen Attilio Lombardo was voted in our best 11 ever. Now, I have seen him play for years here in Italy, with Samp, Juve etc... I'm not saying he was bad, he was in the National Team too, but honestly, he was a solid player, but Zaha is hands, feet, head, and whatever you want over him... It's a world apart.
That's what makes me think he must be very close to our best ever.

 


The best footie management game: [Link]

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 02 Nov 17 3.55pm

Originally posted by Ian-VI

I think Zaha is slowly getting our best ever.
I haven't seen some of the old ones, so I cannot give a sentence, but I think he's getting there already.
Allow me to say this, I might become not popular, but this is what I think. I have seen Attilio Lombardo was voted in our best 11 ever. Now, I have seen him play for years here in Italy, with Samp, Juve etc... I'm not saying he was bad, he was in the National Team too, but honestly, he was a solid player, but Zaha is hands, feet, head, and whatever you want over him... It's a world apart.
That's what makes me think he must be very close to our best ever.

Not sure how much you watched of Lombardo whilst at Palace however nobody would of described him as just a 'solid player'. The guy was mustard my friend.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Zaha, our best.. ever?