This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
He'll be back soon with a very very long post, quoting many stats explaining why he's not drowning and you have no idea what you're talking about. It takes all sorts. I don't mind all the stats and long posts to be fair - and Matteo is no different to many of us who can readily assert how right we are in our own minds when posting. On topic, no thanks to Bats. Edited by Mr_Gristle (26 Jan 2018 6.37pm)
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Crystal_Clear
An observation :- Negative : Neither seem to be able to buy a goal at the moment Plus side : Benteke can have a physical presence to bring other players into the game, whilst Batsuayi work rate are and movement is better. Take your pick.
Ok, statistics are not always relevant, but Batshuayi has absolutely no problem regarding scoring. As opposed to Benteke, who has started countless matches this season. Yes, different teams, but how many goals should Batshuayi have for him to be considered able to buy a goal at the moment?
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
Ok, statistics are not always relevant, but Batshuayi has absolutely no problem regarding scoring. As opposed to Benteke, who has started countless matches this season. Yes, different teams, but how many goals should Batshuayi have for him to be considered able to buy a goal at the moment? To debate the topic properly; I think the issue with this comparison is that Batshuyai is nearly exclusively used when Chelsea are chasing a game and need a goal - invariably, leading the line for a very good team who are going gun-ho for a goal is going to lead to quite a few chances. Impact players will always tend to have a good minutes-goals ratio, because they're being deployed for a short time to do one specific thing. I don't agree with the view that Batshuyai "can't buy a goal", but simply comparing his goal/assist ratios to Benteke is hugely flawed. Iheanacho is the best example of this - phenomenal goal to minutes at City (amongst the best in PL history at one point), and has been thoroughly ineffective in a weaker side.
|
|
|
As opposed to Iheanacho, Batshuayi has been a starter for Marseille a long time and he was amazing. Hence why Chelsea bought him for 30+million
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
As opposed to Iheanacho, Batshuayi has been a starter for Marseille a long time and he was amazing. Hence why Chelsea bought him for 30+million Sure, agreed - that doesn't disprove my point however; comparing Benteke and Batshuyai's stats for this season is flawed.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Ali_Campbell
There’s a reason their football has been so limited. I go to lots of Leicester games and they are both shocking players. Iheanacho has no real pace (I whitnessed live him being out paced by Jonathan Walters which is no mean feet) and despite the goals at city which were tap-ins, his all round play ain’t great. Apart from score for city, he never did anything else. Now he has to work harder and move...it’s no surprise he hardly makes the bench Slimiani is better and god loves a tryer. He gives his all every week, but he is the Algerian Frazier Campbell. We need goals and Benteke has proved he can get them. We just need patience through the next thousand minutes (Big eyes emoji) That's the decider for me - Benteke, whilst admittedly having a poor season, is a proven goal scorer for our club and in this league. Batshuyai, who I rate as a good young player, is not. Maybe if we were in a better position we could afford to take such a risk, but as it is, I'd stick with Benteke.
|
|
|
We need another striker, not swapping one.
|
|
|
We need two strikers before Tuesday
|
|
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Ultimately you can read any of the fans forums or pundits opinions to see what people think of Batshuayi, or alternatively you can watch him and see that he spends all game making pointless flicks and tricks, doesn’t pressurise defenders and doesn’t make anywhere near enough dangerous runs. His ability isn’t in question as a finisher, he obviously can finish chances, but the reason Conte wants him gone is because he doesn’t work for the team. Conte is like Roy in that he likes players sticking to their task and the sum of the team getting the result. That’s how he has got the best out of players like Moses and Christenson. If you have watched a single game this season under Roy you would know that everyone has a role in the team that they rigidly stick to apart from Zaha who has a somewhat freer role. And while Benteke has not managed to hit any kind of form, hasn’t managed to score or create much, (an assist here and there and one goal against Leicester is all), he has stuck to his task pretty well in terms of positioning and helping the teams shape. He is part of a resurgent palace while personally out of form and looking shot of confidence with missed chances when he is in the right area. He isn’t playing well enough that’s obvious to anyone with half a brain even mattteo, but swapping him for a showboater with a far worse work ethic would be madness. At last a voice of reason. The abuse CB gets from those around me when he stays on halfway line and doesn't chase down defenders when they have the ball near their own area, do people not think that he is playing to instructions rather than just being out and out lazy? Dont get me wrong he is having a poor season and I do believe patience with him is wearing thin but those that call him crap (Matteo) are, in my opinion, talking out their a****
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
So let me get this straight: Batshuayi, who is young and everyone says has a lot of energy and runs a lot, is not doing his job, but Benteke, who sits back and has fans frustrated with his lack of commitment and pressing is just following orders from Roy to close spaces and not tire himself up? And I'm the one with half a brain? I guess Ben is keeping himself fresh to bag in all those goals He has turned us down once and is not performing for Chelsea - move on.
|
|
|
Originally posted by mattteo
So let me get this straight: Batshuayi, who is young and everyone says has a lot of energy and runs a lot, is not doing his job, but Benteke, who sits back and has fans frustrated with his lack of commitment and pressing is just following orders from Roy to close spaces and not tire himself up? And I'm the one with half a brain? I guess Ben is keeping himself fresh to bag in all those goals So did Bamford (another Chelsea forward) & I don’t think there’s a Palace or Chelsea fan alive that thinks he’s any good in the EPL. We are a better side with Benteke in it despite the lack of goals as we need an outlet in the way we currently play. Perhaps you should actually go and watch a few games to get your head round how being an effective part of a team is more important than individual performance? In fact, a mate has a spare ticket for the CFC v NUFC match tomorrow- you could watch the game & get the fans perspective on Batshuayi.
Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nobbybm
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.