You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Murray & Gayle scoring 10 goals a season each
November 16 2026 7.23am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Murray & Gayle scoring 10 goals a season each


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 04 Mar 18 4.23pm

He still scored more goals in his 5 months at Bournemouth were he didn't start much than benteke has all of this season

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

mattteo Flag 04 Mar 18 4.25pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Problem was and is is that Gayle is anonymous in first halves. He cannot occupy defenders or find space whatsoever. All his success for us was in 2nd halves when its end to end stuff.

Gayle has scored more goals in first halves than Benteke in the same amount of playing time- statistical truth. I won't stay now and research every match he has scored in, but trust me, in the last 4-5 years, as long as they both played in the PL, Gayle has more goals scored in first halves. I looked it up myself.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 18 4.29pm

Originally posted by mattteo

Gayle has scored more goals in first halves than Benteke in the same amount of playing time- statistical truth. I won't stay now and research every match he has scored in, but trust me, in the last 4-5 years, as long as they both played in the PL, Gayle has more goals scored in first halves. I looked it up myself.

In the premier league? Rubbish.

 


COYP

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 04 Mar 18 4.32pm

It's true and he's scored more in the last two games then benteke has all season

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 04 Mar 18 4.34pm

Originally posted by baldeagle73

He still scored more goals in his 5 months at Bournemouth were he didn't start much than benteke has all of this season

Yeah probably, and I agree that Benteke has been a puddle of p1ss this season. Nobody foresaw that happening before we signed him and definitely not last season.

It's just not that simple that we should have Murray and Gayle now and we would've been alright all the way through. Nice thought but we either bought nobody and risked it or we signed a striker who did actually produce pretty quickly and we sold them when they agreed the offers received. If Benteke carried on from last season's healthy return as we expected we wouldn't be having this debate, but in his head he's got himself to this point.

 


COYP

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 04 Mar 18 4.36pm

3 goals in 19 prem games for Bournemouth only started under half those two one goal was a match winner against Chelsea at the bridge no match winning goals for benteke

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

The_Dumps Flag Croydon 04 Mar 18 4.36pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

Benteke- 15 league goals in the Premiership last season, 17 in all competitions. In a struggling side with a disastrous first half of the season.
Gayle- 23 goals in the Championship last season, 23 in all competitions. In a side that walked away with the Championship.
Murray- also 23 goals in the Championship last season, in a Brighton side that was runner up.

But on the basis of 1 bad season for Benteke and 1 above average one for Murray and Gayle, suddenly we've made a massive mistake?
We definitely made mistakes with back up strikers, but I think to deride Benteke as the worst thing to ever happen to the club after a poor season is a bit rich.

A bad season? A £30million striker - 2 x goals and one of the worst penalties taken all year across all divisions. That's not bad, that's f*&king appalling.

Edited by The_Dumps (04 Mar 2018 4.51pm)

 

The_Dumps Flag Croydon 04 Mar 18 4.39pm

Originally posted by The_Dumps

A bad season? A £30million striker - 2 x goals and one of the worst penalties taken all year across all divisions. That's not bad, that's f*&king appalling.

BTW Benteke scored 13 x goals in the previous season from open play (not pens) in the Premier league. Which I still don't think is good enough.

Edited by The_Dumps (04 Mar 2018 4.44pm)

 

mattteo Flag 04 Mar 18 5.00pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

In the premier league? Rubbish.


Do I get a beer if I prove it?

 

Boooo Flag 04 Mar 18 5.00pm

Originally posted by Gohammer

I think everybody blames Alan Pardew but what about the chairman and directors or the American’s who probably know very little about ‘soccer’! They cashed in theses players for a pittance and there have been no like for like or like for better. We had 2 proven goal scorers for the bench. Or starting together in a 2 up front.

Forgive me for nor reading this entire thread.
Glenn Murray's Mrs went on SM and said that Glenn wants to leave if he isn't guaranteed 1st team football. Pardew said he wasn't, the club sold him. He's moved on twice, a lot of our fans (including myself) haven't.

 


I refuse to believe there are that many people out there that can't spell. Too f**king lazy, that's what I think.

The Dolphin Flag 04 Mar 18 5.22pm

And I am one of them.
I think that what actually happened was that Murray was told that Wickham was now the no 1 striker and so he was going to be bench only most of the time.
Pardew did like to play his purchases.
Murray realised he wasn't going to get a look in and left and I don't blame him.
He should have been told that he was no 1 but that it was up to Wickham to displace him - good management and if he didn't perform he would have been expected to be dropped.
I don't mind that Gayle went - only Murray (oh and Jedi of course)!

 

Boooo Flag 04 Mar 18 6.38pm

Originally posted by The Dolphin

And I am one of them.
I think that what actually happened was that Murray was told that Wickham was now the no 1 striker and so he was going to be bench only most of the time.
Pardew did like to play his purchases.
Murray realised he wasn't going to get a look in and left and I don't blame him.
He should have been told that he was no 1 but that it was up to Wickham to displace him - good management and if he didn't perform he would have been expected to be dropped.
I don't mind that Gayle went - only Murray (oh and Jedi of course)!


I was torn about Jedinak. His pace had gone and the PL had worked out that if you round him you could take him out of the game. Also his passing was awful at the best of times.
The up side was that he showed courage all the time, made big decisions and never hid. I was there during one game he was benched and he looked sad, i could see it in eyes that he new it was time to move on. So glad that we probably had him at the peak of his career, most Palace fans will remember him fondly.

Gayle had promise but his obvious clash of personalities (and probable s***e attitude) with Pardew did for him. Gave us memorable goals for which i'll always like him and the Scoucers will always hate him!

 


I refuse to believe there are that many people out there that can't spell. Too f**king lazy, that's what I think.

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 04 Mar 18 7.23pm

Originally posted by Boooo


I was torn about Jedinak. His pace had gone and the PL had worked out that if you round him you could take him out of the game. Also his passing was awful at the best of times.
The up side was that he showed courage all the time, made big decisions and never hid. I was there during one game he was benched and he looked sad, i could see it in eyes that he new it was time to move on. So glad that we probably had him at the peak of his career, most Palace fans will remember him fondly.

Gayle had promise but his obvious clash of personalities (and probable s***e attitude) with Pardew did for him. Gave us memorable goals for which i'll always like him and the Scoucers will always hate him!

So Jedi was slow and running out of gas at that time about 2 years ago ? It is sad that you were 'torn' about him.

So how do you account for his outstanding performance for Australia scoring a hat-trick only 2 months' ago ??????????

Before you say 'only Australia', their record compares favourably with ours at international level.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 04 Mar 18 7.30pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

So Jedi was slow and running out of gas at that time about 2 years ago ? It is sad that you were 'torn' about him.

So how do you account for his outstanding performance for Australia scoring a hat-trick only 2 months' ago ??????????

Before you say 'only Australia', their record compares favourably with ours at international level.

Two of those goals were penalties and the opponents were Honduras rated 65th in the World.

Edited by Willo (04 Mar 2018 7.32pm)

 

mattteo Flag 04 Mar 18 7.35pm

Originally posted by Willo

Two of those goals were penalties and the opponents were Honduras rated 65th in the World.

Edited by Willo (04 Mar 2018 7.32pm)

Wow, man, you didn't have to obliterate him ))))

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 04 Mar 18 7.55pm

I think people have forgotten Murray wanted first team football which is another reason he left.

Gayle has played this season in the league 26 and only scored 5 that is poor.

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

mattteo Flag 04 Mar 18 8.07pm

Originally posted by grumpymort

I think people have forgotten Murray wanted first team football which is another reason he left.

Gayle has played this season in the league 26 and only scored 5 that is poor.

Gayle has scored similar to Murray. 5 goals and 2 assists in 1300 minutes.

Murray has 7 goals and no assists in 1600 minutes (excluding penalties)

How is Gayle's season poor?

 

leifandersonshair Flag Newport 04 Mar 18 8.29pm

Originally posted by mattteo


Buddy, you need to get your facts straight.

1. Benteke scored 13 goals last year from open play, not 15. The fact that his teammates let him take 2 penalties doesn't mean he's better than if he had not taken them. But ok, let's go with the number 15 as he also accounted for 2 assists last season. His 13 goals from open play and 2 asists came in 3200 minutes, less than 1 every 200 minutes. If you count out the penalties he scored while at Villa and Liverpool, he pretty much has a similar ratio.

2. Gayle scored 23 and assisted 2 in 2300 minutes in all competitions last year, with no penalties taken. If his teammates had let Gayle take 2 penalties like Benteke, he could have had 2 more goals. But disregard the Championship goals. Gayle in the PL had scored for Palace 20 goals (18 from open play) and provided 1 assist in 2700 minutes. That's 1 every 140 minutes. This season he has 5 goals and 2 assists in 1300 minutes for Newcastle, somewhat keeping his tally (leading the line, not as second striker).

3. Glenn Murray had 19 goals from open play in the Championship, but 6 assists too in 3400 minutes. In the Premier League he had scored 8 from open play and assisted 3 in 1500 minutes for Crystal Palace and Bournemouth. This season (counting out the penalties) he has 6 goals and no assists in 1500 minutes.

Bottom line: if one striker takes penalties, his goals appear to be much more than what they truly are and perception makes him seem like a better player than he truly is.

So Championship goals equate to the same as Premiership goals then. Got it. And penalties don't count either. Right.

Bottom line- Benteke scored more goals in open play in the Premiership last season than either Murray or Gayle are likely to get this season for their respective clubs.

Don't get me wrong- Benteke IS having a bloody shocker of a season. Murray has scored a massive FOUR more goals this season and Gayle THREE (from open play, of course)- so you believe we would be massively better off with them instead. Yes, no doubt if we still had those 2 instead of Benteke then we'd be top 10. Or if we still had Allardyce in charge. Or if Wilf hadn't been injured.

No point bitching about what we SHOULD have done or what MIGHT have been. Benteke has not overnight become the worst player in the world, has he? He remains our main striker. Sorloth looks promising. We're still in a really bad situation. I think we'd be in a worse situation if we had never signed Benteke but had kept Murray and Gayle. You think differently. Fair enough.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 04 Mar 18 8.30pm

Wickham was a Parish signing.

Selling Murray was Parish's decision having received an offer that he couldn't refuse - don't blame him, at the time it was a good price.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, but if you look at the hard facts and how things have turned out, then we clearly have had the wrong end of those deals.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

mattteo Flag 04 Mar 18 8.36pm

Originally posted by leifandersonshair

So Championship goals equate to the same as Premiership goals then.


No, I specifically compared their Premier League goals in my post. I said "disregard the Championship goals". You're just being unfair here or bad intended or you can't read.

Those only "3 more goals", as you say, scored by Gayle came in 1300 minutes, not 1900, as Benteke has had (that's 50% more playing time).

Edited by mattteo (04 Mar 2018 8.44pm)

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Murray & Gayle scoring 10 goals a season each