You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
AERO Flag 11 Mar 18 3.52pm

Happenness stan Lets go for it , the Palace team have being carrying him for ages so China should be no problem . Or see what Uber charge Lol !!!

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 11 Mar 18 4.48pm

Originally posted by bifffabazz


Quite right. The lad did great creating something from nothing on the right in the lead up to the goal. Can anyone tell me that Benteke could have done that?

Agreed. He looks the goods.

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 11 Mar 18 5.18pm

I am no Benteke apologist, or some crazed optimist, but I really don't know about getting rid of Benteke.

I think that Sorloth has a lot of good about him, and I can see why Roy wanted him, but he does not seem to have the quality that Benteke has demonstrated over the years.

I can also understand why people have lost faith in Benteke, but he is proven to have kept poor sides in the Premiership. There is something horribly wrong with him at the moment, but I just get the feeling that he is still the best option that we have - although perhaps not at the moment.

I also feel that he has been terribly let down. I think that he is a confidence player that needs stability to perform. I also think he needs to be the main man, but not the only man. Our lack of stability this year and our transfer policy that resulted in him being the only striker seems to have weighed heavily on his shoulders.

I think that Roy has got what it takes to bring stability, and to get the best out of Benteke. I have a hunch that a bit of blind faith will pay dividends. He just needs to finish putting out the FdB fire first.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 11 Mar 18 5.24pm

Originally posted by dp

I am no Benteke apologist, or some crazed optimist, but I really don't know about getting rid of Benteke.

I think that Sorloth has a lot of good about him, and I can see why Roy wanted him, but he does not seem to have the quality that Benteke has demonstrated over the years.

I can also understand why people have lost faith in Benteke, but he is proven to have kept poor sides in the Premiership. There is something horribly wrong with him at the moment, but I just get the feeling that he is still the best option that we have - although perhaps not at the moment.

I also feel that he has been terribly let down. I think that he is a confidence player that needs stability to perform. I also think he needs to be the main man, but not the only man. Our lack of stability this year and our transfer policy that resulted in him being the only striker seems to have weighed heavily on his shoulders.

I think that Roy has got what it takes to bring stability, and to get the best out of Benteke. I have a hunch that a bit of blind faith will pay dividends. He just needs to finish putting out the FdB fire first.

You can offer many reasons, some I might agree with - my problem is that the man simply does not work hard enough.

 

Henry of Peckham Flag Eton Mess 11 Mar 18 5.24pm

It's a shame as I don't like to see someone like Benteke leave the club on a downer but if we can recoup a significant part of the £27m we spent on him then we should be able to get a decent replacement. He had a good game against Manure earlier in the week but didn't do much yesterday.

 


Denial is not just a river in Egypt

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 11 Mar 18 5.35pm

Originally posted by chris123

You can offer many reasons, some I might agree with - my problem is that the man simply does not work hard enough.

I don't have any reasons to offer. I don't know what is going on in Benteke's head, or why he is not firing. I just have a hunch that Roy is capable of getting the best out of him.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 11 Mar 18 5.48pm

Originally posted by A1969Eagle

Its rarely worked all season with Benteke as main man so we have to make changes, at least Sorloth as young player who needs time in Premier league to leanr outsmart defenders but when gets the ball, he wants to score.. what does Benteke want... his confidence is shot.
He (Benteke) is bossing Sorloth in the match rather than let Sorloth make his own decisions but him and Zaha worked much better. Yes keep the same 2nd half Zaha & Sorloth for the next match with benteke his replacement late in 2nd half with something to prove!!.

Sadly I dont think we shall see Wickham as premier leauge player again. Mr Sick Note always had a leg problem before the bad one, he took the penalty at Chelsea and wow did he wince, he came off soon after. His goals at WBA, he winced when he shot hard then next game out injured.

You patently don't know about Wickham, he has one knee injury before in 2011, when he missed only 3 games. He is currently recovering from an ACL injury, which everyone knows is a long term injury. Calling him Mr Sick Note is uncalled for.

 

tonymikejoe Flag UK 11 Mar 18 9.17pm

No wonder that genius Pardew described the signing of Benteke as a: "No brainer."

He even said at £50m securing the big Belgian's services would be a bargain.

What a joker, couldn't wait to bomb out Glenn Murray for the likes of Yaya Sanogo, Connor Wickham, Adebayor and now eventually big Ben.

Clueless.

 

merganser Flag 11 Mar 18 10.27pm

Something that intrigues me is that Sorloth is completely expressionless. Most players give a clue to their emotions, eg when they miss a sitter. But our new man seems totally unengaged. Must be something to do with the Nordic temperament, but a bit of passion wouldn't come amiss. Assuming the happy day comes (the sooner the better), I wonder if/how he'll celebrate scoring a goal.

 

jabber Flag pease pottage 11 Mar 18 10.56pm

Originally posted by chris123

You can offer many reasons, some I might agree with - my problem is that the man simply does not work hard enough.

I think it's wrong to judge sorloth after 3 games, lets judge him at the end of the season when he's played his first full game with zaha. I can remember people criticizing jedinak after 10 games. It's my opinion that when sorloth has played as many games as benteke for us his stats will be better.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 11 Mar 18 11.04pm

I think there is a growing acceptance that we will be in the Championship next season and to my mind Sorloth could prove very effective in that division.

It is very hard for a young lad to make the step up from the Danish League to the PL in a struggling team but he could really blossom in the lower division which might serve him well if he goes on to play in the PL.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 11 Mar 18 11.31pm

Originally posted by Willo

I think there is a growing acceptance that we will be in the Championship next season and to my mind Sorloth could prove very effective in that division.

It is very hard for a young lad to make the step up from the Danish League to the PL in a struggling team but he could really blossom in the lower division which might serve him well if he goes on to play in the PL.

I think you will be pilloried for that first sentence you wind up.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 12 Mar 18 4.23am

Originally posted by Willo

I think there is a growing acceptance that we will be in the Championship next season and to my mind Sorloth could prove very effective in that division.

It is very hard for a young lad to make the step up from the Danish League to the PL in a struggling team but he could really blossom in the lower division which might serve him well if he goes on to play in the PL.

Are you a West Brom fan Willo?

 

FinchleyEagle Flag 12 Mar 18 7.52am

For our sake and for Benteke's own sake, he has to be dropped.

Form and confidence are hard to get right sometimes, effort and application are not. He simply isn't grafting to make it happen.

He needs a wake-up call and we don't have room for anyone who isn't 100% commmitted.

 


You'll be forever in my family's memories and it was an honor and privilege to play and lead in the red and blue
Yours sincerely
Mile Jedinak

MikeCrete Flag Crete 12 Mar 18 8.01am

Originally posted by Willo

I think there is a growing acceptance that we will be in the Championship next season and to my mind Sorloth could prove very effective in that division.

It is very hard for a young lad to make the step up from the Danish League to the PL in a struggling team but he could really blossom in the lower division which might serve him well if he goes on to play in the PL.

No there is not, We will stay up. Please give it a rest.
Sorloth will score more goals than Benteke has, in the remainder of this season; hopefully Benteke wont be seen in the Red 'n'Blue again; unless we have no option through injury & he gets sent to China.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Mar 18 8.59am

Benteke never came out for the second half.
Since then Hodgson has criticised the team's effort in the first half.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 12 Mar 18 9.04am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

I think you will be pilloried for that first sentence you wind up.

Certainly NOT trying to trigger any reaction on HOL at all.

I have witnessed more posters on here sharing my viewpoint and several others I have spoken to or been in communication with outside of HOL also believe that we will be relegated, hence my comment.

In any event, let's not get drawn into that debate - let's concentrate on the subject matter.

Edited by Willo (12 Mar 2018 9.05am)

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 12 Mar 18 9.07am

Originally posted by tonymikejoe

No wonder that genius Pardew described the signing of Benteke as a: "No brainer."

He even said at £50m securing the big Belgian's services would be a bargain.

What a joker, couldn't wait to bomb out Glenn Murray for the likes of Yaya Sanogo, Connor Wickham, Adebayor and now eventually big Ben.

Clueless.

We only stayed in the Premier League last season because of Benteke 16 goals.

 

JtCpfc Flag 12 Mar 18 9.25am

Originally posted by SeagullHunter

Sorloth was w*** today. Surprised so many here singing his praises. Should have had two, lost every aerial battle, jogged about, poor first touch. I feel as though it should have been him off at HT, rather than Benteke, and that sentiment was definitely echoed by others that were there. Quite surprised posters here think it was the other way round!

Edited by SeagullHunter (10 Mar 2018 8.36pm)

Completely agree. I do not understand why people are raving about him. He was woeful at Chelsea. How he missed from 8 yards out where he hit the post i'll never know, not to mention the fact he took the ball of zaha for it.

Benteke all day long for me, hes had a hand in 7 of our 10 goals in 2018, 6 assists and a goal so clearly he is creating chances.

Sorloth looks slow and clueless, I hope for the good of the club that he comes good.

 

colinandsued Flag Haywards Heath 12 Mar 18 9.44am

Based on what I've seen over the past few games I would have to say Sorloth on Sat against Huddersfield. He's raw and inexperienced and it's a huge step-up from the Danish League to the Premier League. However, he's full of running and hit the post and had a goal disallowed on Sat. Benteke is so palpably lacking in form and confidence and just 2 goals all season tells its own story.

However, it's Roy Hodgson that sees them in training and has to judge their current attitude, aptitude and ability. What I'm really hoping is that competition between Sorloth and Benteke, and with Wickham back in training, produces goals and improved performances for the critical last 8 games.

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Poll: Sørloth or Benteke?