You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref vs Liverpool
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ref vs Liverpool


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Apr 18 2.34pm

Originally posted by the silurian

OK thank you...so if at his assessment Swarbrick is adjudged to have made a big error, what is his likely punishment? A fine? Demotion for a game? Of course, he is being judged by other referees who will obviously see things from his perspective! We have witnessed 1 referee being demoted, 1 out of all the referees over the years! Not very stringent then is it! Other than your good self, Souness is the only other pundit who believes he was correct in not booking and sending off mane, hopefully next weeks referee will see any handball by a Palace player as a simple error and let it go with no punishment, but I wont be holding my breath!

Former senior referees are best qualified to assess the referee's technical performance.
And it is just not referees who are involved in the assessment - 'Match Delegates' consist of former managers and players who assess the consistency of decisions and management of the match.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 01 Apr 18 2.51pm

Here we go again. Another thread hijacked and ruined. Time to close it down again.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 01 Apr 18 2.54pm

Originally posted by Willo

I of course have never attended such a post-match analysis for obvious reasons but I do know how they are conducted.

Each PL game is assessed 'Forensically' by a former senior referee who scrutinises every decision using the match footage and 'ProZone' to measure the officials’ technical performance. Match delegates assess the accuracy and consistency of decision making and their management of the match.I understand it is a vigorous evaluation with no stone left unturned.

We have witnessed a referee being demoted and clearly if a referee was consistently not performing to standard he would be removed from the Elite list.

An organisation not without controversy.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 01 Apr 18 3.00pm

So the ref gives us a free kick which wasn’t accidental handball, he just didn’t follow it through with a sending off...

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 01 Apr 18 3.08pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

Here we go again. Another thread hijacked and ruined. Time to close it down again.

Is this your first post?

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 Apr 18 6.50pm

Originally posted by Willo

I totally refute the allegation that Swarbrick cheated in not awarding a second yellow card.I will certainly defend Swarbrick against this charge.One can only speculate as to his thinking but it was certainly not influenced by any so called "Big club bias" or external influences and all that hogwash.

He will have to explain his decision as part of his post-match analysis.

And you can prove this how? or are you just speculating?

Edited by Willo (01 Apr 2018 12.43pm)

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Apr 18 7.42pm

Originally posted by Willo

I have consistently said that referees DO err from time to time - they are not always right.

On average they make approx 245 decisions in a game and make on average 5 mistakes which means they are right 98% of the time.

I refer to previous analysis and evidence which I posted demonstrating that around 25% of matches are affected by major decisions being called wrongly by referees. I am not going to repeat it all here but suffice it to say that you're using statistics to massively distort the truth.

And I long ago stopped reading anything you post which contains the word "forensically" or "scrutinise".

As for Mane, he handled the ball to stop Cabaye's attack and tried to pass it off as mistakenly thinking he'd been given a free kick. He's a professional footballer so he knows damn well that you play to the whistle.

Hands up anyone who thinks Cabaye would have been afforded the same latitude if the roles were reversed.

Edited by chateauferret (01 Apr 2018 7.46pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

IMilburn Flag Chiang Rai / Rayong 01 Apr 18 11.53pm

I have seen those statistics too; indeed the latest claim is that they are right 99.2% of the time. However, they are not independent statistics but are produced by Professional Game Match Officials Limited, the organisation headed by Mike Riley which provides the referees to the FA and Football League.


Originally posted by Willo

I have consistently said that referees DO err from time to time - they are not always right.

On average they make approx 245 decisions in a game and make on average 5 mistakes which means they are right 98% of the time.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 02 Apr 18 7.10am

Look a ref makes a mistake and we lose its the refs fault,
not the 2 glaring chances our striker had or poor defending, yes he got it wrong,
i drink with 2 ex refs and 1 whos son will next season will be a referee in the 4th tier,all said he got that wrong,this will be highlighted in the match report for failing to give a card for deliberate handball as per the guide lines.
at the end of the day we lost because we made more mistakes than the ref that is the bottom line,also our record against 10 men is not good
And remember there not on 50,000+ a week

 

becky Flag over the moon 02 Apr 18 7.58am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

Look a ref makes a mistake and we lose its the refs fault,
not the 2 glaring chances our striker had or poor defending, yes he got it wrong,
i drink with 2 ex refs and 1 whos son will next season will be a referee in the 4th tier,all said he got that wrong,this will be highlighted in the match report for failing to give a card for deliberate handball as per the guide lines.
at the end of the day we lost because we made more mistakes than the ref that is the bottom line,also our record against 10 men is not good
And remember there not on 50,000+ a week

But they are on up to £70,000 a year, which is not bad for a couple of days 'work' a week

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

michaelpearce Flag grays 02 Apr 18 8.16am

Originally posted by becky

But they are on up to £70,000 a year, which is not bad for a couple of days 'work' a week

Would you do it knowing that you get the blame for one mistake all for 70,000 a year while most on the pitch earn that in a week and have thousand calling you all the names under the sun,im old school if i ref one game they wouldn't get half the fouls and there would be alot of cards for being well was going to say girls but have watch ladys football and they dont roll around like the men

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 02 Apr 18 8.33am

It is best to ignore Willo, he is an obvious troll who hijacks every thread.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 02 Apr 18 8.44am

Another ref who got two decisions wrong at Chelsea yesterday.

"Former referees' chief Keith Hackett says referee Craig Pawson did not deal with tackles from Tottenham's Erik Lamela and Jan Vertonghen "correctly" in their side's win at Chelsea and that "if VAR had been in use, Tottenham would have finished the game with nine men"

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

the silurian Flag The garden of England.(not really) 02 Apr 18 8.53am

Originally posted by michaelpearce

Look a ref makes a mistake and we lose its the refs fault,
not the 2 glaring chances our striker had or poor defending, yes he got it wrong,
i drink with 2 ex refs and 1 whos son will next season will be a referee in the 4th tier,all said he got that wrong,this will be highlighted in the match report for failing to give a card for deliberate handball as per the guide lines.
at the end of the day we lost because we made more mistakes than the ref that is the bottom line,also our record against 10 men is not good
And remember there not on 50,000+ a week

As far as I am aware, no one has said we lost because of the referee's decision, what people are saying is that things MAY have been different had he sent off Mane, which he should have done. Maybe it was a genuine error BUT its strange that it usually is an error in favour of the big club which helps them win. Ok they may have won anyway 10 men r not but it would be good if occasionally
we got those sort of decisions FOR us instead of against us, as someone else said, if that had been Cabaye or Luka handling that ball, Im 99% sure they woud have had a red card brandished at them, being that they were on a yellow!!
Asian betting is massive and its not beyond the realms of possibilty that things like that decision happen for a reason! I for one hope not but one day I suspect things may come to light that prove otherwise.

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 02 Apr 18 8.57am

VAR is not the answer just image if all decisions was reviewed would be playing till 10 at nite,also managers would have to blame the players for results god help us it would be anarchy, lets just except refs have only 2 eyes and give what they see

 

michaelpearce Flag grays 02 Apr 18 9.08am

Originally posted by the silurian

As far as I am aware, no one has said we lost because of the referee's decision, what people are saying is that things MAY have been different had he sent off Mane, which he should have done. Maybe it was a genuine error BUT its strange that it usually is an error in favour of the big club which helps them win. Ok they may have won anyway 10 men r not but it would be good if occasionally
we got those sort of decisions FOR us instead of against us, as someone else said, if that had been Cabaye or Luka handling that ball, Im 99% sure they woud have had a red card brandished at them, being that they were on a yellow!!
Asian betting is massive and its not beyond the realms of possibilty that things like that decision happen for a reason! I for one hope not but one day I suspect things may come to light that prove otherwise.


Yes there could be something in what you said and big club syndrome I dont know if anyone has done any stats on it,there was abit of finger pointing at the ref, as i said we havent got a good record against 10 men so result may have been the same

 

kevlee Flag born Wandsworth emigrated to Lanc... 02 Apr 18 9.20am

Having read a lot of this thread the major opinions are:
1. he made an awful decision, and most people agree it should have been a red card; and
2. as per one, but the reason he did it is because he wanted Liverpool to win and also because he is corrupt and was paid backhanders by unknown third parties, possibly in Asia.
I think its number 1 and he should be sent for retraining or even demoted from the panel for the rest of the season.
If someone seriously reckons its number two then its a case for the police surely?

 


Following Palace since 25 Feb 1978

chateauferret Flag 02 Apr 18 9.27am

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

Another ref who got two decisions wrong at Chelsea yesterday.

"Former referees' chief Keith Hackett says referee Craig Pawson did not deal with tackles from Tottenham's Erik Lamela and Jan Vertonghen "correctly" in their side's win at Chelsea and that "if VAR had been in use, Tottenham would have finished the game with nine men"

The only reason I've ever seen Spurs play without committing at least one unpunished sending-off offence is because they sold Kyle Walker.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 02 Apr 18 9.54am

Heavens above !

Big club bias, cheating, Asian betting markets - mass hysteria has taken the place of reasoned debate. I totally reject such risible accusations. Cheap shots as far as I am concerned.

Trust me, referees don't want to be involved in any controversies. They take a pride in their performances and want to come off the field having performed with great aplomb. They might make mistakes but they don't knowingly make mistakes to favour a team. They are human they are not cheats.

With regard to the Mane incident clearly if a second yellow had been issued there wouldn't be the controversy but this is not what lost us the game. Referees err from time to time but they are honest errors and ones which are highlighted in their vigorous post-match evaluation.

Anyway out now so HOL will be a WILLO free zone for a while!


Edited by Willo (02 Apr 2018 9.56am)

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 02 Apr 18 10.04am

Originally posted by Willo

Heavens above !

Big club bias, cheating, Asian betting markets - mass hysteria has taken the place of reasoned debate. I totally reject such risible accusations. Cheap shots as far as I am concerned.

Trust me, referees don't want to be involved in any controversies. They take a pride in their performances and want to come off the field having performed with great aplomb. They might make mistakes but they don't knowingly make mistakes to favour a team. They are human they are not cheats.

With regard to the Mane incident clearly if a second yellow had been issued there wouldn't be the controversy but this is not what lost us the game. Referees err from time to time but they are honest errors and ones which are highlighted in their vigorous post-match evaluation.

Anyway out now so HOL will be a WILLO free zone for a while!


Edited by Willo (02 Apr 2018 9.56am)

Not issuing a second yellow card to Mane was a turning point and it did determine the outcome of the game. Klopp would have settled for a point as his substitutions after that incident were thrown up in the air with the Lallana injury. The refs make a lot of poor decisions every weekend, not from time to time ....

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ref vs Liverpool