This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Pensioner Kills Burglar In Hither Green
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Lyons550 Shirley 04 Apr 18 11.54am |
|
|
[Link]
...and he's now been arrested on suspicion of Murder....
What are peoples thoughts on defending your own property and self defence in the home leading to the death of the perp?
Edited by Lyons550 (04 Apr 2018 12.00pm)
The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 04 Apr 18 12.02pm |
|
|
It's sensible to arrest him until the full facts are known. The BBC article is thin on facts so it is difficult to comment further on this case.
However, generally, I think anyone should be able to defend themselves and their property but it shouldn't give them the right to murder someone.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
Buckspalace Thornborough 04 Apr 18 12.07pm |
|
|
Yes need to get the facts but if the intruder was not there in the first place up to no good then this would never have happened so to a certain extent brought it on themselves.
|
Midlands Eagle 04 Apr 18 12.15pm |
|
|
Murder will never stick but manslaughter may depending on the facts but in view of the fact that the homeowner was 78 I can see him getting off whatever he is charged with.
I am a hardliner on the subject of burglary and believe that stabbing a burglar should be allowed
|
IMpalace London 04 Apr 18 12.37pm |
|
|
Thought of someone being charged for defending their home doesn't sit well with me.
Unless you can prove that killing/injuring the burglar was completely unnecessary i.e. you already had him tied up or locked in a room with all your family safely outside then I struggle to see why you should convict someone.
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 04 Apr 18 12.44pm |
|
|
IMP I agree 100%.
|
npn Crowborough 04 Apr 18 12.45pm |
|
|
self defence doesn't give you carte blanche to kill someone (the farmer who shot a burglar running a way from his property, for instance, while I sympathise, was stretching the definition). However, in this case, from the little the BBC have said so far, he's surely unlikely to be charged (2 burglars, armed with a screwdriver, force him into the kitchen where the knives are = "oh dear, how sad, never mind"
|
IMpalace London 04 Apr 18 1.00pm |
|
Originally posted by npn
self defence doesn't give you carte blanche to kill someone (the farmer who shot a burglar running a way from his property, for instance, while I sympathise, was stretching the definition). However, in this case, from the little the BBC have said so far, he's surely unlikely to be charged (2 burglars, armed with a screwdriver, force him into the kitchen where the knives are = "oh dear, how sad, never mind"
Agreed, although it's hard to know where that line stands. It seems completely unreasonable to me to judge these cases in the cold light of day when people are likely to act extremely irrationally when someone has invaded their home and they feel they or their family are threatened. Difficult one. With the very limited facts presented so far, feel strongly that the guy in this case should walk free.
|
Forest Hillbilly in a hidey-hole 04 Apr 18 1.35pm |
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
Thought of someone being charged for defending their home doesn't sit well with me.
Unless you can prove that killing/injuring the burglar was completely unnecessary i.e. you already had him tied up or locked in a room with all your family safely outside then I struggle to see why you should convict someone.
You sum up my thoughts, based on the information released by the police so far One of the intruders was armed with a screwdriver, and this would reasonably constitute a threat, based on the fact he was on someone elses property and had confronted the owner.
The media wording is kind of inflammatory. For example, when Islamic State murdered unarmed hostages, it was described as 'executions'. Now this pensioner is potentially being charged with murder. I trust truth and justice will eventually prevail, and this wasn't a case of two gas engineers on an emergency call-out. 
I disengage, I turn the page.
|
Stuk Top half 04 Apr 18 1.51pm |
|
|
Comes home to find two blokes half his age in the middle of a burglary and then gets threatened by at least one of them.
Shouldn't be charged with anything. The second intruder should go to jail and think himself lucky.
Optimistic as ever
|
jimruss Sidcup 04 Apr 18 2.14pm |
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Murder will never stick but manslaughter may depending on the facts but in view of the fact that the homeowner was 78 I can see him getting off whatever he is charged with.
I am a hardliner on the subject of burglary and believe that stabbing a burglar should be allowed
Absolutely.
If someone breaks into your property as far as I'm concerned they are fair game, if they get hurt or worse then so be it.
|
monkey Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 04 Apr 18 2.21pm |
|
|
My wife’s grand parents used to live in a ground floor flat on a council estate in Tulse Hill, everyone used to worry about them, but her grandad was a proper ‘harry brown’ he used to say ‘if anyone gets in here I’ll kill the b******, what they gonna do, put me away for life?? At my age I could be in me box anyway time they get round to it’
Good luck to this old boy
|
Charlie Croker Hampshire 04 Apr 18 2.27pm |
|
|
Slightly different outcome, but I remember my dad telling me about his mate cementing broken glass on top of his wall to keep out the scrotes and being told off by the local PC. His mate's reasoning was the same though, if you don't try and break in, you won't get hurt. If you get hurt, that's your fault.
If someone broke into my house, cornered me with a weapon - especially one that could be used to stab - I would like to think I'd grab, and use, a knife - or similar. Using your own weapon should surely fall into the category of 'reasonable force though.
Edited by Charlie Croker (04 Apr 2018 2.28pm)
“My experience of life is that it is not divided up into genres; it’s a horrifying, romantic, tragic, comical, science-fiction cowboy detective novel. You know, with a bit of pornography if you’re lucky."
|
npn Crowborough 04 Apr 18 2.32pm |
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
Agreed, although it's hard to know where that line stands. It seems completely unreasonable to me to judge these cases in the cold light of day when people are likely to act extremely irrationally when someone has invaded their home and they feel they or their family are threatened. Difficult one. With the very limited facts presented so far, feel strongly that the guy in this case should walk free.
Precisely. In the movies, you punch someone, they are out cold. Reality is not like that, and if I, my home, or my family are threatened by more than one assailant, I'm not going to let up on person #1 until I'm bloody sure he's not getting up (ideally because he's incapacitated, but I'm afraid I can't guarantee that incapacitation wouldn't be permanent). The last thing you want to do is to not go far enough, and end up still facing 2 assailants, one who now has a bloody nose, and a sense of indignation!
|
coulsdoneagle London 04 Apr 18 2.41pm |
|
|
Right that he is arrested and the due process is followed while the events are established, and it will also be right that if he was indeed defending himself within reasonable force against assailants that he isn’t charged with anything. It’s too soon to say for sure but from the sounds of it he did nothing wrong and was defending himself against intruders threatening him with a screwdriver in his own home.
|
Badger11 Beckenham 04 Apr 18 3.41pm |
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle Right that he is arrested and the due process is followed while the events are established, and it will also be right that if he was indeed defending himself within reasonable force against assailants that he isn’t charged with anything. It’s too soon to say for sure but from the sounds of it he did nothing wrong and was defending himself against intruders threatening him with a screwdriver in his own home.
Not sure I agree with this. How about the police do their due process and if any evidence points to his guilt then arrest him? He is 78yo man unless the police have knowledge that he is a flight risk he is not going anywhere. This wasn't a street fight. I would have taken him to the station got a statement and then released him pending enquiries. So unless he told the coppers at the scene that he was guilty I am surprised.
One more point
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 04 Apr 18 3.42pm |
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Right that he is arrested and the due process is followed while the events are established, and it will also be right that if he was indeed defending himself within reasonable force against assailants that he isn’t charged with anything. It’s too soon to say for sure but from the sounds of it he did nothing wrong and was defending himself against intruders threatening him with a screwdriver in his own home.
Yep.
Fair game. Next case please, clerk.
COYP
|
jeeagles 04 Apr 18 4.11pm |
|
|
Great work by the old guy. The arrest could be routine, questioning him would be reasonable given the circumstances but hopefully they will let him go soon and the process won't be traumatic for him.
The "victim" would not show anyone he burgled any sympathy and deserves none of the protection society offers its law abiding citizens.
As someone mentioned earlier, there doesnt appear to be any comparison with the Tony Martin case. He shot his burglar in the back from distance whilst he was running away. He had a history of firearms offences. He'd have had to have unlocked a gun kept in one room, then a ammunition cabinet in another room, chased the guy, then shot him. Again, no sympathy for the victim, but he was a mad old reclusive farmer who was probably a danger to himself and society.
|
Dave58 Ipswich 04 Apr 18 4.51pm |
|
|
Violent burglaries are common in all parts of the country. You see horrifying reports of pensioners getting beaten up so bad , it basically ends their life. The scum that broke in probably thought it was another easy target. If they charge this hero, there will be an outcry as people have had enough. Hopefully his heroic actions may deter other scum, but sadly I doubt it.
|
Direwolf Lincoln 04 Apr 18 5.01pm |
|
|
This feels wrong to me in the sense of the guy defending himself and his property. I suspect the burglar with the screwdriver was not there to fix a loose shelf but I guess we have to wait for the full facts to emerge in order to understand why he has been charged.
|