You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game
November 16 2026 6.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Back from the game


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Mapletree Flag Croydon 01 Sep 18 5.54pm

In short, Meyer should have been on earlier and Kouyate probably from the start

Schlupp poor again and Ayew a cross between Schlupp and Frazier Campbell.

Townsend too good to take off. Hennessy and Wan Bassaka true class.

Biggest lesson is the same as last week. PVA allows crosses. Never stops them. Compare to AWB. The opposition can see that.

Bring back Souare anyone? Push PVA forward again?

 

YT Flag Oxford 01 Sep 18 5.58pm

I don’t wanna pour cold water on the two new boys; yes, they looked good but was it merely “fresh legs” in what must have been a tiring game? AWB is good, but he made a fair few mistakes today.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 01 Sep 18 6.04pm

Agree with all of that

Schlupp literally jogs/walks the whole game ..
Pitiful really ...
We had no Wilf today and today was the day that Townsend
would have to play the whole game . Yet he was subbed and Schlupp still jogs on
Two of the subs (Not Sorloth) made such a difference but brought on too late as per normal
The crowd was getting frustrated today even singing to Roy to make a substitution...
Southampton were and are an average side .. yet I thought they bullied Kelly and Sakho at times
Tomkins is a huge miss .. he calms the back four down ...
Meyer and Kouyate look like they will soon be regulars ... for what it’s worth I think Luca is looking jaded at the moment

 

trapperjohn Flag Horsham 01 Sep 18 6.06pm

Originally posted by Mapletree

In short, Meyer should have been on earlier and Kouyate probably from the start

Schlupp poor again and Ayew a cross between Schlupp and Frazier Campbell.

Townsend too good to take off. Hennessy and Wan Bassaka true class.

Biggest lesson is the same as last week. PVA allows crosses. Never stops them. Compare to AWB. The opposition can see that.

Bring back Souare anyone? Push PVA forward again?

Agree to an extent; Schlupp was poor but I didn’t see Andros do anything to warrant not being taken off .

Pretty much everyone else was meh but sorry the worst by far was Luka. Poor passing, poor positioning, poor free kicks and most of all where was the captain after the first goal? Everyone stood round looking shell-shocked and there was no geeing them up at all. I begin to wonder if his best games were alongside Cabaye? In which case bring in Kayoute and Meyer asap. Not knocked off the ball, driving forward whenever they could and wanting the ball.

Oh and I think you are very harsh about Ayew.

 


I got vision, and the rest of the world wears bifocals.

Casual Flag Orpington 01 Sep 18 6.26pm

MacArthur was decent. Meyer and Especially Kouyate looked good.
Wan BIssaka good first half. Hennessey made some good saves, but he was in no mans land for both goals. The rest were sh*t. Won’t play many teams worse than the saints this year. Very disappointing

 

george1212 Flag london 01 Sep 18 6.29pm

I thought Ayew looked liked a handful and a massive upgrade on Benteke.

It's quite shocking how reliant we are on Zaha however. We look so so poor without him.

Sorloth won't cut the mustard longer term. Max Meyer looks like he will be a good signing for us. Hard to tell at this stage but I think he looks good. An actual creative midfielder.

The best teams have 4-5 players that can turn a game like that and get back into it. We only 1 and he wasn't even on the pitch.

I'd say Wan-Bissaka is something to be positive about, so is Meyer and Kouyate. So our new signings look good, apart from Sorloth. He is another mediocre striker, it's just a question of how long Roy holds onto him.

Zaha and Ayew upfront is going to be quite dangerous.

So much for a great start to the season...!

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 01 Sep 18 6.37pm

Originally posted by Casual

MacArthur was decent. Meyer and Especially Kouyate looked good.
Wan BIssaka good first half. Hennessey made some good saves, but he was in no mans land for both goals. The rest were sh*t. Won’t play many teams worse than the saints this year. Very disappointing

It didn't take long for someone to blame Hennessey for both goals. Won't say more cos I don't want a yellow card.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

coulsdoneagle Flag London 01 Sep 18 6.47pm

Originally posted by Casual

MacArthur was decent. Meyer and Especially Kouyate looked good.
Wan BIssaka good first half. Hennessey made some good saves, but he was in no mans land for both goals. The rest were sh*t. Won’t play many teams worse than the saints this year. Very disappointing

Hennessey kept us in that game. He played superbly, without him we’d have been dead and buried much earlier.

First goal was a neat finish and piss poor defending by the CBs, second goal was 1 on 1 with everyone up the pitch and in no way his fault.

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 01 Sep 18 6.58pm

If I was Roy, I'd bounce them all back into training tomorrow for hard lessons debrief and intensive training around the international break. We CANNOT base club fortunes essentially around Zaha's team inclusion with ALL others needing to earnestly step up to the plate = ALL others in starting XI today did not do so against a team there for the taking.

Let's chalk this match down as 'should've won but failed poorly and letting down the fans'.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 01 Sep 18 7.05pm

I would just like to say I haven’t enjoyed a game less in ages. We were poor apart from 15 mins towards the end. This is also compounded by the new season ticket holder sitting next to me who doesn’t stop moaning from start to finish. He will end end swallowing my fist before the season is out if he doesn’t shut the f*** up. Rant over.

 

muffinbrucie Flag london 01 Sep 18 7.08pm

We started slow and sluggish today. Saints were at us, in our faces from the start and we never seemed to recover. Most frustrating thing is when we finally win a corner and it doesn't beat the first man or Is so hard it goes fo a throw in on the other side. Ayew was ok, Wayne good again, Benteke poor again.Still were better off than last season

 


its a town full of losers, i,m pulling outta here to win

portlandeagle4 Flag Portland, Maine 01 Sep 18 7.09pm

With every miss, Benteke is digging himself a bigger and bigger hole of low confidence to get out of. Macca and AWB were solid, as was Hennessey, but Schlupp and Ayew didn't do enough. I think we should line up like this v Huddersfield

Hennessey
AWB Tomkins(if he's back) Sakho Souare
Meyer Kouyate Macca PVA
Zaha Townsend

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 01 Sep 18 7.20pm

im in shock after seeing a palace goal keeper save a penalty.

the arrival if guiata really has raised waynes game, bes on top, top form.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Loz83 Flag Crawley 01 Sep 18 7.20pm

Schlupp has been woeful for all 4 games. I’m not sure what he brings to the team. Left back cover for me.

 

chateauferret Flag 01 Sep 18 7.28pm

Originally posted by Bexley Eagle

I would just like to say I haven’t enjoyed a game less in ages. We were poor apart from 15 mins towards the end. This is also compounded by the new season ticket holder sitting next to me who doesn’t stop moaning from start to finish. He will end end swallowing my fist before the season is out if he doesn’t shut the f*** up. Rant over.

The only way the guy next to you isn't going to moan all the way through a match like that is if you're sitting in the away end. HTH.

 


============
The Ferret
============

PatrickA Flag London 01 Sep 18 7.51pm

First half was really poor today.
Can understand why you would sit deep and defend at home to Liverpool, but to do the same against Southampton?
It was obvious that it wasn’t working and the early part of the second half was more of the same.
I like Roy and he’s done a decent job, but on occasions he seems tactically inflexible.
I think this narrow midfield doesn’t suit Schlupp or Townsend, who after all aren’t midfield players.
There was a marked improvement when Kouyate and Meyer came on.
As a footnote I would add that I think Luka is missing Cabaye and doesn’t look the same player at the moment.

 

johnno42000 Flag 01 Sep 18 8.03pm

Originally posted by PatrickA

First half was really poor today.
Can understand why you would sit deep and defend at home to Liverpool, but to do the same against Southampton?
It was obvious that it wasn’t working and the early part of the second half was more of the same.
I like Roy and he’s done a decent job, but on occasions he seems tactically inflexible.
I think this narrow midfield doesn’t suit Schlupp or Townsend, who after all aren’t midfield players.
There was a marked improvement when Kouyate and Meyer came on.
As a footnote I would add that I think Luka is missing Cabaye and doesn’t look the same player at the moment.

I agree about Luca and Cabaye and it is a good point I hadn't really thought about. I wonder if Meyer could do a similar job as Cabaye with Luca?

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 Sep 18 8.15pm

Massively frustrating afternoon.

The starting 442 line up badly lacked guile and creativity and left our only decent carrier of the ball in Townsend playing too deep.

We should have been three goals down before Roy, at last, changed things and that should have been Ayew off, Meyer on and 433 / 451. However, Roy isn't responsible for Benteke and others missing so many chances.

Ayew slow and lacked Benteke's presence.

PVA and Schlupp's decision making in the final third and crossing was terrible.

The (normally decent) ref had a poor game not helped by his linesman.

Kelly looked lighweight against some rough and experienced forwards and defends better against the younger and quicker players.

Luka poor / jaded and, as others have inferred, needs Meyer in front of him.

Hennessey and Macarthur our best on the day.


 

Surrey Eagles Flag Sutton 01 Sep 18 8.26pm

Bexley Eagle, I really hope you sit in Holmesdale Upper block N about half way up?

 

PatrickA Flag London 01 Sep 18 8.29pm

I’m not sure Luka can play in central midfield 2 with Mcarthur ( who incidentally I think has started the season well).
I thought that against Watford, and today, we we were outfought, outpowered and seemed outnumbered in central midfield.
Last season’s good form coincided with Luka, Cabaye and Mcarthur in a fairly tight midfield controlling the game.
Hopefully we can revert to this with the new players once they have bedded in.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Back from the game