You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have we really made progress ?
November 16 2026 6.51am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Have we really made progress ?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Del7 Flag 21 Oct 18 8.17pm

6 years as a Premiership club, whilst we have survived .... have we really made progress or are we just delusional.... after today’s result (Everton) it looks like it’s going to be another skin of the pants season ... I feel for Roy, a throughly decent bloke but he must be wondering what he has to do to get the team to play for 96 minutes plus ... individual mistakes litter our game and we get punished on many occasions.... I love my club but I hate every Monday having to go into work to discuss the recent result. ... What do we have to do to get a result, November for me has been written off so if we get as much as a point I’ll be delighted, if not shocked.
Please, please can we just win ugly ?

 

Bert's Boys Flag 21 Oct 18 8.26pm

No.
No improvement at the ground (Arthur Wait is still shocking)we have a new stand being built - when? delays already on that.
The team is no further forward.
Decent managers couldn't wait to go (Allardyce, Pulis)whilst mediocre and below average one's (Pardew)stayed well past their sell by date.
Sorry, but the blame falls squarely on Parish's shoulders.

 

becky Flag over the moon 21 Oct 18 8.28pm

Six years as a Premiership club IS progress... how soon we forget that we were once known as the yo-yo club.

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

Bert's Boys Flag 21 Oct 18 8.29pm

No improvement at the training ground either.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 21 Oct 18 8.35pm

Parish is not capable.

He is not capable to manage a squad properly, this is the biggest issue. We have a seriously poor set of attacking options, anyone can see that.

We were in for Tosun, we were in for Niasse, we let Murray walk, the list goes on.

We simply don’t have enough options up front and the buck stops with the chairman.

Sorloth was a very poor signing, we sat and watched Benteke last year and we signed Sorloth and Ayew on loan. Sorry but it’s not good enough.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 22 Oct 18 12.35pm

You could argue that we have progressed under our own terms. This is the longest spell we have spent in the top flight, and few would deny that we have a stronger squad than the one we set out with under Holloway back in August 2013.

The trouble is you have to compare yourself against the progress of other teams rather than your own, and there we have fallen short. In the Prem League if you stand still you quickly go backwards.

Lack of stability on the managerial front and some seemingly muddled thinking on building a balanced side has left us as vulnerable as we were 5 years ago. Add to that our still decrepit stadium, and it is hard to identify much progress on real terms rather than relative ones.

 

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Oct 18 12.57pm

Much better squad in every position but still dreadful in arguably the most important position of all - striker. Is there any team in this division, perhaps except Cardiff, with a worse strike force than us? Unacceptable and could cause a very, very expensive squad to get relegated and all of our progress to be undone.

If we get relegated we'll take massive losses on the likes of Benteke and Sakho just to get them off our wage bill. PVA, Wilf, Meyer, Tomkins, maybe Luka and Townsend will all go too, and when you consider we're paying 50+ grand per week for the likes of Schlupp and Riedewald, you wonder if we'd really have the money to renovate the squad. Our transfer business has been so appalling that relegation would be pretty ruinous.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 22 Oct 18 4.07pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Much better squad in every position but still dreadful in arguably the most important position of all - striker. Is there any team in this division, perhaps except Cardiff, with a worse strike force than us? Unacceptable and could cause a very, very expensive squad to get relegated and all of our progress to be undone.

If we get relegated we'll take massive losses on the likes of Benteke and Sakho just to get them off our wage bill. PVA, Wilf, Meyer, Tomkins, maybe Luka and Townsend will all go too, and when you consider we're paying 50+ grand per week for the likes of Schlupp and Riedewald, you wonder if we'd really have the money to renovate the squad. Our transfer business has been so appalling that relegation would be pretty ruinous.

Thats the reality of our situation and all for not targeting a striker in the summer .

 

MrSydney Flag 22 Oct 18 4.56pm

As a Yank who fell in love with Palace when they came up and NBC started carrying all the games...I'd have to say Yes & No. Yes, Palace staying up. No every year is skin of the teeth to survive dropping down. I get it that Palace doesn't have the deep pockets to sign cream of the crop players. Even the novice Palace fan knows we've been screaming STRIKER for at least 5 years now. What are the scouts telling Parish? Is he deaf? Does he have zero in the bank?

Every week I wait for the shining Palace that I've seen over the years, but those performances seem to be coming less and less frequently.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Oct 18 5.24pm

Originally posted by Pete53

You could argue that we have progressed under our own terms. This is the longest spell we have spent in the top flight, and few would deny that we have a stronger squad than the one we set out with under Holloway back in August 2013.

The trouble is you have to compare yourself against the progress of other teams rather than your own, and there we have fallen short. In the Prem League if you stand still you quickly go backwards.

Lack of stability on the managerial front and some seemingly muddled thinking on building a balanced side has left us as vulnerable as we were 5 years ago. Add to that our still decrepit stadium, and it is hard to identify much progress on real terms rather than relative ones.

This. Our team has got better, but the premiership is different now, with promoted teams spending 100, teams like everton fielding a team worth 300m. Teams I would have said we were similar too, burnley, Bournemouth even brighton progressing more than us.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Oct 18 5.41pm

Originally posted by spartakev2

This. Our team has got better, but the premiership is different now, with promoted teams spending 100, teams like everton fielding a team worth 300m. Teams I would have said we were similar too, burnley, Bournemouth even brighton progressing more than us.

Our net spend in the summer was £10 Mill.
Compare this to Burnley £30 Mill, Bournemouth £28 Mill and Brighton £52 Mill.

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Oct 18 6.12pm

Originally posted by Willo

Our net spend in the summer was £10 Mill.
Compare this to Burnley £30 Mill, Bournemouth £28 Mill and Brighton £52 Mill.

Which is the point I'm making...

 

jeeagles Flag 22 Oct 18 6.57pm

I think a lot of fans underestime how touch it is to stay in the Premier league. As teams stay up for longer, the expectations of fans grow to want to achieve something that's beyond their means. After they start to want someone that unachievable they clubs start to turn on themselves and become toxic.

There's been 49 premiership clubs. Loads have been in for a season or two, then completely disappeared. Lots have had a boom or bust business model which has distroyed them.

Only 6 teams have never been religated. It's pretty much inevitable that we will at some point. I couldn't find a stat on how many have lasted 6 consecutive seasons but I'm sure it will be lower than people expect.

Going up and staying up was a fluke. Expecting to stay up shows progress.
Building the new stand will make us more competitive.

We just have to be patient and hope we don't mess it up.

 

*jack* Flag Eastbourne 22 Oct 18 7.47pm

How does building a new stand make us more competitive? Revenue from a few thousand extra seats won't add enough extra revenue to make any difference and the work involved in making it happen will take the club managements eye off the ball even more than it is already.

 

PatrickA Flag London 22 Oct 18 8.34pm

It’s not that long ago we were playing with ten men behind the ball, David Wright in midfield and Jermaine Easter up front..
Clearly there has been considerable progress.
However, as the standard of the players have improved it’s no surprise that expectations are raised.
Parish is a realist and is doing his best.
In my view our scouting department has been found wanting in recent years.
Watford, Southampton and even Brighton seem able to pick up reasonably priced players who make an immediate contribution and have scope,for improvement.
Difficult to think when we have done this in recent times.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Oct 18 8.52pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Moaning Minnies' by Midlands Eagle

too many on this forum atm, we HAVE progressed, when we came up we had Parr and Moxey at left back, now PVA, in the middle Meyer, Luka and Jimmymac over Jedi, KG and O'Keefe, striker-wise it's gone wrong but Parrish has really splashed the cash at times, but of necessity he has become too short-termist, not his intention but that's the way things have panned out, though he has clearly rubbed a few managers up the wrong way, we've been poor and thrown away points this season but this "Parrish has screwed us up" line is so wide of the mark, delays to the new stand? Aren't there always and do we really know how much control he has over the process. As a team we keep possession far better than we could in our first few seasons, for the first 30 min v Wolves we looked like the accomplished premier side and them like an underdog away side trying to snatch something, can some of you not put up with a poor run without throwing your toys? If we get relegated we could fall into the Charlton trap with a load of over paid uninterested players, that's where Parrish may be cuplable, I'd like to see us grooming talent and adding value like Bournemouth do, not expensive fire fighting which is bumping the wage bill up so high, but get one thing clear, Parrish is mainly responsible for the most successful period on our history, some on here are 'so whatting'at the prospect of the new stand, unbelievable, point out SP's failings by all means, but casting him as a failure or a liability is f*cking ridiculous.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 22 Oct 18 8.56pm

Having watched the first half of Leicester vs Arsenal I have come to the conclusion we have clearly regressed this season. Leicester, a team we thrashed not long ago, have played Arsenal off the park with their slick passing, pace and precision. Pretty much everything we fail to demonstrate week in week out. Arsenal have been lucky as they should have conceded a pen and should be playing with 9 men.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Oct 18 9.00pm

Originally posted by *jack*

How does building a new stand make us more competitive? Revenue from a few thousand extra seats won't add enough extra revenue to make any difference and the work involved in making it happen will take the club managements eye off the ball even more than it is already.

brilliant, let's keep Selhurst just the way it is, that's sure to attract ambitious players,
if you fall behind you become less competitive, if you have ambition to stay in the prem you need a prem stadium, there's too much chippy stone throwing on these pages theses days, Parrish is in the arena and he got there by himself, and that's something too many on these pages fail to understand or respect because they could get nowhere near to that themselves, nor could I btw, but I don't need to knock high achievers just bcos I'm not one.

 

tillysosser Flag far far away 22 Oct 18 9.02pm

it means that after 6 years of being in the premiergreed we would have something to show for it.


remember players and managers come and go.... the stadium stays forever

Originally posted by *jack*

How does building a new stand make us more competitive? Revenue from a few thousand extra seats won't add enough extra revenue to make any difference and the work involved in making it happen will take the club managements eye off the ball even more than it is already.

Edited by tillysosser (22 Oct 2018 9.02pm)

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 22 Oct 18 9.35pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Moaning Minnies' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

too many on this forum atm, we HAVE progressed, when we came up we had Parr and Moxey at left back, now PVA, in the middle Meyer, Luka and Jimmymac over Jedi, KG and O'Keefe, striker-wise it's gone wrong but Parrish has really splashed the cash at times, but of necessity he has become too short-termist, not his intention but that's the way things have panned out, though he has clearly rubbed a few managers up the wrong way, we've been poor and thrown away points this season but this "Parrish has screwed us up" line is so wide of the mark, delays to the new stand? Aren't there always and do we really know how much control he has over the process. As a team we keep possession far better than we could in our first few seasons, for the first 30 min v Wolves we looked like the accomplished premier side and them like an underdog away side trying to snatch something, can some of you not put up with a poor run without throwing your toys? If we get relegated we could fall into the Charlton trap with a load of over paid uninterested players, that's where Parrish may be cuplable, I'd like to see us grooming talent and adding value like Bournemouth do, not expensive fire fighting which is bumping the wage bill up so high, but get one thing clear, Parrish is mainly responsible for the most successful period on our history, some on here are 'so whatting'at the prospect of the new stand, unbelievable, point out SP's failings by all means, but casting him as a failure or a liability is f*cking ridiculous.

We have had hundreds of millions of pounds thrown at us. I would hope we would have replaced Dean Moxey.

Good you talk about left backs, when Pap Souare had a car accident we didnt have a single other senior left back at the club - how many years was that into SP's reign? That is p&ss poor squad management.

Again after several years if we had not assembled some players who can play a bit more football than Mile Jedinak then Parish would want shooting.

SP has done some things well, and made some good signings hear and there. Vastly outweighing that he has made error after error, recklessly ill equipping the club to compete in the Premier League. Lets review some of those howlers:

1 - When Mandanda left we just forgot to replace him, maybe the post it note fell of SP's desk. Through some lucky miracle Hennessey has actually come good, after we finally get a player in to challenge him....hmmm....coincidence?
2 - We left the Niasse deal (like oh so many) so so late that when it collapsed we had no plan B - remember not having a single fit senior striker at the club?
3 - After a manager search lasting 2 weeks too long Parish hires a manager famous for possession based football with a questionable man management style...oops
3a - Then tweets about unity and then fires the guy after the Burnley game where we should have won 4-0 if our players could actually hit the target
4 - Sorloth, Alex
5 - Inability to hold on to any managers for any length of time
6 - Look at our current attacking options and tell me SP knows who to manage a squad?
7 - Handling of the HF tantrum - secretive, protracted, takes a stand then does a total 180 and no real explanation/discussion with all the affect parties, and a seemingly ballsed up approach to the singing section already
8 - Murray, Glenn

Yes SP has presided over our longest stay in the top flight, but its more through luck than judgement.

Edited by Maine Eagle (22 Oct 2018 9.36pm)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Have we really made progress ?