You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy, FFS pick Meyer!!!
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Roy, FFS pick Meyer!!!


Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 10 Feb 19 10.04am

superb when he came on. great movement. I think we can afford his weaknesses for what he brings. he makes Wilf a different proposition because he picks the ball up in dangerous positions, draws men to him, and can then release Wilf in more space than he otherwise gets.

I it's time he started a run of games. 100%.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Feb 19 10.10am

Originally posted by You What

Meyer looks pretty when making his passes and is very effective when we are in our flow, but when our backs are up against the wall give me McArthur all day long. He puts the hard graft in and gives us gritt in midfield that I think Meyer cannot offer. It’s difficult because there is different points in every game when both would excel.

When he comes on we don’t need to do as much defending, as he takes the game to the other team.

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Feb 19 10.19am

It is an interesting debate as to whether Meyer should start and I guess it depends on whether you prefer a safety first approach or would prefer to play on the front foot.
Roy is clearly in the first camp and will play strong and hard working midfield players all day long in preference to ball players.
The first priority for him is solidity and team shape.
He’s not alone in this among English coaches as players such as Hodfle, Bowles and Currie were left out over the years in preference to hard working physical players.
For me we tend to,look better when Meyer is involved as he knits the play together in advanced positions and have more variety to our play.
If we have our normal back four and two defensive midfield players as well as a hard working Townsend surely we can take a few more risks?

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 10 Feb 19 10.30am

Saha and Meyer are very in tune in and around the box, they are just given time to exploit the opposition. Then again our finishing was abysmal yesterday 26 attempts, yeah 26 attempts we should have absolutely buried WH...

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 10 Feb 19 10.44am

Originally posted by Casual

When he comes on we don’t need to do as much defending, as he takes the game to the other team.

Nope

It’s because the opposition are knackered by then

 

Curlyeagle 2 Flag Crowborogh 10 Feb 19 11.35am

Originally posted by matthau

Nope

It’s because the opposition are knackered by then

Spot on! And that’s why Meyer has the impact that he has as a substitute.

 

cpj Flag Kent 10 Feb 19 11.56am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Saha and Meyer are very in tune in and around the box, they are just given time to exploit the opposition. Then again our finishing was abysmal yesterday 26 attempts, yeah 26 attempts we should have absolutely buried WH...

What's Hennessey done to upset you???

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 10 Feb 19 12.19pm

Originally posted by You What

Meyer looks pretty when making his passes and is very effective when we are in our flow, but when our backs are up against the wall give me McArthur all day long. He puts the hard graft in and gives us gritt in midfield that I think Meyer cannot offer. It’s difficult because there is different points in every game when both would excel.

Agreed - Meyer wouldn’t have been suited for that first half yesterday. If McArthur hadn’t of been out there we might have been two or three down at half time. Perhaps there’s a place in the team for Meyer, Luka and McArthur?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 10 Feb 19 12.49pm

Originally posted by palace chick

Agreed - Meyer wouldn’t have been suited for that first half yesterday. If McArthur hadn’t of been out there we might have been two or three down at half time. Perhaps there’s a place in the team for Meyer, Luka and McArthur?

Unfortunately true.

 


COYP

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 10 Feb 19 12.59pm

Originally posted by Curlyeagle 2

Spot on! And that’s why Meyer has the impact that he has as a substitute.

If so, doubt Roy told him when he joined that he was going to fill this role. Suspect he will move on to pastures new if he remains a bench player.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Casual Flag Orpington 10 Feb 19 1.01pm

Originally posted by matthau

Nope

It’s because the opposition are knackered by then

So they are knackered and we aren’t? We were all over them second half yesterday, I thought it was because we’d gone up a gear and were the better team, I’m a bit disappointed it was just because they were knackered.

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Feb 19 2.17pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Seriously ? Couldn’t thread a pair of socks ? You must have had your head stuck up your arse for the last four years.

So MacArthur is a number 10 graced with the creativity necessary to play neat through balls?

Even if that was true 2 years ago, which is wasn’t, he is still having a poor, poor season by previous standards.

He is a combative defensively sound midfield player. As you saw quite clearly yesterday, he is fairly lost in and around the opponents box these days.

He is being asked to get forward a hell of a lot, and gets into areas where Max Meyer could deliver way more damage.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 10 Feb 19 4.04pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

So MacArthur is a number 10 graced with the creativity necessary to play neat through balls?

Even if that was true 2 years ago, which is wasn’t, he is still having a poor, poor season by previous standards.

He is a combative defensively sound midfield player. As you saw quite clearly yesterday, he is fairly lost in and around the opponents box these days.

He is being asked to get forward a hell of a lot, and gets into areas where Max Meyer could deliver way more damage.

No, stop putting words into others’ mouths. As you point out he’s no Pirlo but is far better than you’ve suggested.

Over the last four years he’s been up there as one of our best, most consistent performers and weighed in with his share of important goals. He’s played every position in midfield, never hides and nearly always a 7 out of 10 or better. This season he’s continued to be a threat in the final third but unfortunately his finishing (which was previously a strength) has deserted him.

Meyer has struggled to make a impact in a few of the games where he’s started but has impressed as a substitute and looks a good player.

The game at the top level has changed massively in the five years we’ve been in the Premier League and I’m not sure a team of our stature can enjoy the luxury of a playing a number 10.

With regard to yesterday JM was far from lost in West Ham’s penalty box and found some good positions but seems to have picked up the disease from a few of the others of losing his composure in front of goal.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 10 Feb 19 5.05pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

No, stop putting words into others’ mouths. As you point out he’s no Pirlo but is far better than you’ve suggested.

Over the last four years he’s been up there as one of our best, most consistent performers and weighed in with his share of important goals. He’s played every position in midfield, never hides and nearly always a 7 out of 10 or better. This season he’s continued to be a threat in the final third but unfortunately his finishing (which was previously a strength) has deserted him.

Meyer has struggled to make a impact in a few of the games where he’s started but has impressed as a substitute and looks a good player.

The game at the top level has changed massively in the five years we’ve been in the Premier League and I’m not sure a team of our stature can enjoy the luxury of a playing a number 10.

With regard to yesterday JM was far from lost in West Ham’s penalty box and found some good positions but seems to have picked up the disease from a few of the others of losing his composure in front of goal.

Not sure why in the first half he didn't put his head up to see where he was shooting ? Seemed to have his head down. Clearly by the 2nd half he was having the yips in front of goal like others in the team. This inability to convert in front of goal must be effecting everybody, as we seem to be snatching at every chance across the attack. Cannot fault his work rate though and your points stated.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Maine Eagle Flag USA 10 Feb 19 5.34pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

No, stop putting words into others’ mouths. As you point out he’s no Pirlo but is far better than you’ve suggested.

Over the last four years he’s been up there as one of our best, most consistent performers and weighed in with his share of important goals. He’s played every position in midfield, never hides and nearly always a 7 out of 10 or better. This season he’s continued to be a threat in the final third but unfortunately his finishing (which was previously a strength) has deserted him.

Meyer has struggled to make a impact in a few of the games where he’s started but has impressed as a substitute and looks a good player.

The game at the top level has changed massively in the five years we’ve been in the Premier League and I’m not sure a team of our stature can enjoy the luxury of a playing a number 10.

With regard to yesterday JM was far from lost in West Ham’s penalty box and found some good positions but seems to have picked up the disease from a few of the others of losing his composure in front of goal.

Didn’t put any words in your mouth, you said I had my head up my arse for suggesting MacArthur in not good at threading through balls - usually a skill we associate with gifted creative players with quick feet and good vision. Does that sound like anyone on our bench?

MacArthur is none of those things.

Not sure MacArthur been a “threat in the final 3rd” this season tbh.

Meyer is not a number 10. He played def mid for schalke. He could be asked to do the exact role that MacArthur did yesterday and we would probably score more goals.

Everything you say about MacArthur and his historical importance is basically correct, apart from him being a “threat” this year where he has 2 goals, one of which was a cross.

You cannot judge Meyer on 1 or 2 games here or there, he needs a run of games otherwise it’s apples to oranges however the evidence was clear for everyone to see yesterday. MacArthur had a mare, committed the worst miss I have seen all year and in 10 mins on the pitch Meyer added more to our attacking game than MacArthur had all game long.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 10 Feb 19 6.33pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Didn’t put any words in your mouth, you said I had my head up my arse for suggesting MacArthur in not good at threading through balls - usually a skill we associate with gifted creative players with quick feet and good vision. Does that sound like anyone on our bench?

MacArthur is none of those things.

Not sure MacArthur been a “threat in the final 3rd” this season tbh.

Meyer is not a number 10. He played def mid for schalke. He could be asked to do the exact role that MacArthur did yesterday and we would probably score more goals.

Everything you say about MacArthur and his historical importance is basically correct, apart from him being a “threat” this year where he has 2 goals, one of which was a cross.

You cannot judge Meyer on 1 or 2 games here or there, he needs a run of games otherwise it’s apples to oranges however the evidence was clear for everyone to see yesterday. MacArthur had a mare, committed the worst miss I have seen all year and in 10 mins on the pitch Meyer added more to our attacking game than MacArthur had all game long.

Meyer had a run of six starts Burnley, Brighton, West Ham, Leicester, Man City, Cardiff. Roy hooked him in the Cardiff game when he was poor. Went to all of these except Brighton.

As I’ve suggested before, Roy could do with mixing things up a bit but Meyer has looked panicked at times when he’s received the ball deep in his own half with no immediate option.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 10 Feb 19 6.40pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Didn’t put any words in your mouth, you said I had my head up my arse for suggesting MacArthur in not good at threading through balls - usually a skill we associate with gifted creative players with quick feet and good vision. Does that sound like anyone on our bench?

MacArthur is none of those things.

Not sure MacArthur been a “threat in the final 3rd” this season tbh.

Meyer is not a number 10. He played def mid for schalke. He could be asked to do the exact role that MacArthur did yesterday and we would probably score more goals.

Everything you say about MacArthur and his historical importance is basically correct, apart from him being a “threat” this year where he has 2 goals, one of which was a cross.

You cannot judge Meyer on 1 or 2 games here or there, he needs a run of games otherwise it’s apples to oranges however the evidence was clear for everyone to see yesterday. MacArthur had a mare, committed the worst miss I have seen all year and in 10 mins on the pitch Meyer added more to our attacking game than MacArthur had all game long.

Agree.

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 28 Feb 19 10.45am

I think last night was a huge example of the difference Max makes when he plays.
He links with Wilf so well, he drives forward, tricky feet, shoots on sight.
I dont understand why hes not getting a chance. When he comes on, hes our best player, but its never more than 15 mins or so.
I have no doubt that he will be on his bike in the summer.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 28 Feb 19 10.49am

For the sake of his career he will be looking to get out of Palace, that's obvious. Personally I dont think the 3 in midfield works, we just get overun so to go to a 4 Max should get a chance. Arguably Kouyate should aguably be playing too so when we play a 3 its just doesnt work. Roys just not going to drop both Jimmy and Jeff. Other issue for me regarding Max is, to me hes made his best performances when coming off the bench. When he has started games has been quite the same.

Edited by MonsterMunch (28 Feb 2019 10.50am)

Edited by MonsterMunch (28 Feb 2019 10.52am)

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 Feb 19 10.52am

I think it’s becoming clear that Max must’ve slippped Roy’s wife some German sausage or something, because we do look a better team with him in the side, but Roy does seem reluctant for some reason.

Edited by monkey (28 Feb 2019 11.29am)

 

Page 5 of 9 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Roy, FFS pick Meyer!!!