You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 7 Labour MPs Quit
November 21 2026 10.42pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

7 Labour MPs Quit


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Stirlingsays Flag 20 Feb 19 4.06pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

I can see the Labour party becoming a party that relies almost entirely on the ever increasing minority vote while the White working class desert in droves to put their x elsewhere.


Yep, as usual, look to the states to see what's going to be happening.

It's all becoming increasingly about identity politics and it's all inevitable.

In happier news....I'm off for another biscuit.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2019 4.06pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Penge Eagle Flag Beckenham 20 Feb 19 4.24pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


Yep, as usual, look to the states to see what's going to be happening.

It's all becoming increasingly about identity politics and it's all inevitable.

In happier news....I'm off for another biscuit.

Edited by Stirlingsays (20 Feb 2019 4.06pm)

You are correct, it is all happening there. The likes of Kamala Harris and Corey Booker are ticking the inter-sectional boxes. But they are not going to win the swing industrial belt where the likes of a more moderate like Joe Biden would. So they are making a big mistake. All Trump needs to do is keep his mouth shut and the Dems will dig their own graves with their extreme policies. As for Labour, it makes sense to be anti-Semitic and target the Muslim vote because they vastly outnumber the Jews (it's all numbers game). While pretending to care about traditional white working class voters, many of the metropolitan bubble and northerners will put a X on Labour vote no matter what.

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 20 Feb 19 4.39pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

It's OK LAbourites.

Red Derek Hatton is back.

Should be a good indication of where Labour is heading under JC.

Odd that they now embrace communists and yet abandon their lifetime working class supporters in favour of the immigrant vote.
They are obviously planning for a future where immigrants and their offspring decide who runs the country.

I see your point about Hatton and the ground being safe for him to rise again from the dead like Dracula.

However, I would be interested to see how you think this abandonment of their working class support is manifest. I don't see that at all. In fact, the traditional left love them to bits. The problem with that party (OK just one problem) is near total disconnect between the executive and grass root support on one hand, and the PLP on the other.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 20 Feb 19 5.31pm

Originally posted by silvertop

I see your point about Hatton and the ground being safe for him to rise again from the dead like Dracula.

However, I would be interested to see how you think this abandonment of their working class support is manifest. I don't see that at all. In fact, the traditional left love them to bits. The problem with that party (OK just one problem) is near total disconnect between the executive and grass root support on one hand, and the PLP on the other.

Demographics will change that I suspect in the coming years.
There will always be those that choose a left-wing party but I think their White vote will diminish over time.
With such a feeble Tory government they should be streets ahead in the polls now but they are not. They only got so many seats last time because of the Minority vote in London, where the 'minority' is actually no longer a minority.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 20 Feb 19 6.04pm

What concerns me about this is that they actually believe there is a widespread desire for a centrist party demanding a second referendum. There isn't. In my opinion, people fall into the following broad boxes:
1) Militant Lefty Communist prats. Mostly agitators like Owen Jones, McDonnell etc and 'rebellious' students. Maturity usually sorts these out into the following:
2) Middle-class lefties. So long as you're saying the socially acceptable things, they'll vote for you.
3) Common sense, normal working people often mistakenly referred to as right wing
4) Other nutters. Ranging from tree shagging hippies to racist, dangerous far actual far right people.

Labour are no longer the party of the working class and are actively targeting the benefits brigade.

Who the f*** out of the above are going to buy what they're selling? Category 2 is clearly the target, but I'm not sure they have the numbers they'd need even if they could get the support of them all.

A new party targeting category 3 is where there's opportunity to my mind.

Edited by ChrisGC (20 Feb 2019 6.35pm)

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Feb 19 6.14pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

What concerns me about this is that they actually believe there is a widespread desire for a centrist party demanding a second referendum. There isn't. In my opinion, people fall into the following broad boxes:
1) Militant Lefty Communist prats. Mostly agitators like Owen Jones, McDonnell etc and 'rebellious' students. Maturity usually soughts these out into the following:
2) Middle-class lefties. So long as you're saying the socially acceptable things, they'll vote for you.
3) Common sense, normal working people often mistakenly referred to as right wing
4) Other nutters. Ranging from tree shagging hippies to racist, dangerous far actual far right people.

Labour are no longer the party of the working class and are actively targeting the benefits brigade.

Who the f*** out of the above are going to buy what they're selling? Category 2 is clearly the target, but I'm not sure they have the numbers they'd need even if they could get the support of them all.

A new party targeting category 3 is where there's opportunity to my mind.

This is the absolute pits of political debate - ‘mine is the common sense view for normal people’.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 20 Feb 19 6.17pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This is the absolute pits of political debate - ‘mine is the common sense view for normal people’.

You're a category one, aren't you?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 20 Feb 19 6.23pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

You're a category one, aren't you?

I’m just a normal guy who uses common sense.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (20 Feb 2019 6.24pm)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 20 Feb 19 6.26pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I’m just a normal guy who uses common sense.

Edited by EverybodyDannsNow (20 Feb 2019 6.24pm)

Cat 3 then, Good lad.

Edited by ChrisGC (20 Feb 2019 6.34pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Feb 19 7.36am

Originally posted by ChrisGC

What concerns me about this is that they actually believe there is a widespread desire for a centrist party demanding a second referendum. There isn't. In my opinion, people fall into the following broad boxes:
1) Militant Lefty Communist prats. Mostly agitators like Owen Jones, McDonnell etc and 'rebellious' students. Maturity usually sorts these out into the following:
2) Middle-class lefties. So long as you're saying the socially acceptable things, they'll vote for you.
3) Common sense, normal working people often mistakenly referred to as right wing
4) Other nutters. Ranging from tree shagging hippies to racist, dangerous far actual far right people.

Labour are no longer the party of the working class and are actively targeting the benefits brigade.

Who the f*** out of the above are going to buy what they're selling? Category 2 is clearly the target, but I'm not sure they have the numbers they'd need even if they could get the support of them all.

A new party targeting category 3 is where there's opportunity to my mind.

Edited by ChrisGC (20 Feb 2019 6.35pm)

One of the Tory MPs claims the party has been hijacked by UKIP and that MPS are afraid of the extremists in the local party. What she meant of course was leavers, well she is forgetting the vast majority of Tory voters are leavers. She is the one out of step with the electoral support for the Tory party.

The independent group is pro Remain and there is a place in politics for that view. However what else does this group have in common? Asking for a 2nd referendum whilst denying your own voters a by election smacks of self serving and I suspect that many will see it as that.

My guess is that at the next GE these people will go the same way as the SDP and will lose their seats or migrate into the Lib Dems.


This will only be an issue if the independent group grows substantially. Right now it is a group of disgruntled politicians who have no clear policies or aims beyond Remain. I think if there was a public appetite for a new third way the Lib Dems would be mopping up.

As for what happens now in parliament well I think this helps Mrs May and Corbyn they no longer have to pander to these people who were always going to vote against any Brexit deal.

 


One more point

dannyboy1978 Flag 21 Feb 19 7.55am

Why didn't this bunch just join the lib dems?

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Feb 19 8.16am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Why didn't this bunch just join the lib dems?

Exactly.

Most politicians love to kid themselves that "they" are the reason why they are elected when actually most voters would struggle to name their MP. Shave a monkey put the right colour rosette on and you have an MP.

60% of the voters in Anna Soubry's constituency voted to leave. At the next GE where does she think her votes are coming from? In the Tory party betrayal is the ultimate sin so she will automatically lose loads of votes for that.

It's not impossible to succeed but I do think that today's MPs over play their own importance, they are party drones so take the party away and you have an empty suit.

As for the future it's easy to be a rebel and be against but what are you for and why is that any different from the Lib Dems? And if you are aligned to the Lib Dems why are the public not voting for that?

 


One more point

Red Al Flag Reading 21 Feb 19 8.28am

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


"Labour is championing their interests at the expense of the traditional voter.
It is not surprising that a party wishes to get elected but everyone should understand that if you are White and working class you no longer matter."

Do you have any evidence to support that claim? Which Labour policies are designed to help immigrants but not the "white working class"? Are the interests of the "white working class" different from the "black working class" or even just the "working class"?

Edited by Red Al (21 Feb 2019 8.29am)

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 21 Feb 19 8.29am

Originally posted by Badger11

One of the Tory MPs claims the party has been hijacked by UKIP and that MPS are afraid of the extremists in the local party. What she meant of course was leavers, well she is forgetting the vast majority of Tory voters are leavers. She is the one out of step with the electoral support for the Tory party.

The independent group is pro Remain and there is a place in politics for that view. However what else does this group have in common? Asking for a 2nd referendum whilst denying your own voters a by election smacks of self serving and I suspect that many will see it as that.

My guess is that at the next GE these people will go the same way as the SDP and will lose their seats or migrate into the Lib Dems.


This will only be an issue if the independent group grows substantially. Right now it is a group of disgruntled politicians who have no clear policies or aims beyond Remain. I think if there was a public appetite for a new third way the Lib Dems would be mopping up.

As for what happens now in parliament well I think this helps Mrs May and Corbyn they no longer have to pander to these people who were always going to vote against any Brexit deal.

I looked at their constituency figures and 4 of the 8 have slim majorities in Leave constituencies.

Soubry has committed career suicide. A leave borough and only 800 majority.

Chuka thinks he's safe with a 19k majority in an 80% remain borough, but he's not. You could run a donkey in a red cap and it will always win there. I expect Labour to put forward a black/Asian candidate and take that back, nobody likes a turncoat.

The good thing is, they've probably ensured no deal. They surely have to abstain from the vote on the deal making it nigh impossible for May to get the numbers.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 21 Feb 19 8.31am

Originally posted by Badger11

Exactly.

Most politicians love to kid themselves that "they" are the reason why they are elected when actually most voters would struggle to name their MP. Shave a monkey put the right colour rosette on and you have an MP.

60% of the voters in Anna Soubry's constituency voted to leave. At the next GE where does she think her votes are coming from? In the Tory party betrayal is the ultimate sin so she will automatically lose loads of votes for that.

It's not impossible to succeed but I do think that today's MPs over play their own importance, they are party drones so take the party away and you have an empty suit.

As for the future it's easy to be a rebel and be against but what are you for and why is that any different from the Lib Dems? And if you are aligned to the Lib Dems why are the public not voting for that?

Great post.

All of these MPs are active on twitter. I think they've taken their echo chamber as a true reflection on public feeling. Very silly

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 21 Feb 19 10.24am

I really wouldn't be surprised if the 'Band of 11' were joined by some more second referendum remainers in the coming days and weeks.

Going back a few years the 'Gang of four' caused a split, thus far the defectors have merely caused a splinter.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2019 10.32am)

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 21 Feb 19 10.46am

Originally posted by Willo

I really wouldn't be surprised if the 'Band of 11' were joined by some more second referendum remainers in the coming days and weeks.

Going back a few years the 'Gang of four' caused a split, thus far the defectors have merely caused a splinter.

Edited by Willo (21 Feb 2019 10.32am)

The 'Gang of Four' faded away, it is essential in a democracy that you are whipped and the withdrawal was too much.

It is very difficult to adjust to not being whipped after so many years and counselling should be made available.

If Anna Sourbry was made Chief Whip there would be a rush to join (wow)....



 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 21 Feb 19 10.49am

Originally posted by dannyboy1978

Why didn't this bunch just join the lib dems?

Indeed. What makes the Lib Dems so toxic that those on the right of the Labour party and the left of the Tories can't join them. The Libs are the only (UK wide) pro remain party, they would seem to be an obvious choice to defect to.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > 7 Labour MPs Quit