You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this
November 16 2026 5.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 13 Jan 20 11.05pm

Originally posted by fishbone

southnorwoodhill
I presume Camarasa is now free to talk to the Spanish media about his experience here; should be interesting.
I cannot understand loaning a player who never gets used, that's a waste of a loan. Completely inept recruitment.

I couldn't agree more and very insulting to the player!!

Perhaps there's more to it. Deductions without data - very unwise.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 13 Jan 20 11.55pm

Originally posted by Cucking Funt

Perhaps there's more to it. Deductions without data - very unwise.

The reason is attitude. Came in with a billy big bollocks attitude, arrogant, sometimes late for training, sometimes not even turning up.

Clearly didn’t fit the culture and with a poor work ethic. No amount of creativity outweighs retaining a strong team culture.

All that said, surely should have been researched better to avoid wasting everyone’s time. Or Roy took a gamble and felt he could get him working. Who knows.

What is also clear is that he would be playing if he was good enough, for enough and committed enough. At least two of those he was not. Not that hard to understand, really.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Jan 2020 11.55pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Jan 20 12.08am

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

The reason is attitude. Came in with a billy big bollocks attitude, arrogant, sometimes late for training, sometimes not even turning up.

Clearly didn’t fit the culture and with a poor work ethic. No amount of creativity outweighs retaining a strong team culture.

All that said, surely should have been researched better to avoid wasting everyone’s time. Or Roy took a gamble and felt he could get him working. Who knows.

What is also clear is that he would be playing if he was good enough, for enough and committed enough. At least two of those he was not. Not that hard to understand, really.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (13 Jan 2020 11.55pm)

If this was /is the case, why did he even get taken on loan? Wasn't due diligence done? Totally inept.
I'm not defending Camerasa btw, just curious about the procedure that brought him here.

 

jeeagles Flag 14 Jan 20 8.35am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I find it galling that he never got an opportunity.
He played 5 mins in the Premier League for us and the club is supposed to form an opinion as to whether to exercise an option to purchase him?
Yes I know we don’t know how he has been in training and the rumour mill has been in overdrive since he hasn’t featured.
What I do know is that he can deliver a good set piece, has a very good shot and is a decent passer of the ball.
All qualities that the squad palpably lack.
In a similar vein Hodgson has been trying to
push Jairo out of the club from the outset.
Firstly to Swansea and then to European clubs.
I acknowledge that Hodgson gets results and , to use the cliche, it’s a results business.
But I despair of Hodgson’s mistrust of skill and it may explain why he has never really achieved the heights in a long career.


I totally agree with this.

Reidewald has shown that we have talented players in the squad he just refused to use.

The manager has surely got to have some say on players we sign?!

Some might blame this on Camarasa's bad attitude, this is all just hear say, but if you know you aren't going to get a look in, then why should you bother.

Roy's been around long enough to know how to keep a job. If he doesn't get involved in transfers, then it's one less thing to be accountable for.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 14 Jan 20 9.25am

Originally posted by Willo

Hodgson has said that in midfield we are "Blessed in that department" and have "Strength of numbers" so what may one ask was the rationale for signing Camarasa who clearly never fitted into our system ?

After signing Camarasa,Rakip,Jach,Sako,Sorloth etc is it any wonder that supporters are quizzical about our recruitment?

Edited by Willo (13 Jan 2020 6.55pm)

After watching football for many years, you must know that not all signings work out. Often what you get is not what you expected to end up with. We aren’t the only club to make mistakes, an example recently which is quite high profile, Drinkwater went to Chelsea for £40m didn’t work out, now taken on loan to Burnley and still not getting a game. He was a key player in Leicester’s title year, now in a different environment can’t perform.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Jan 20 9.44am

I trust Roy.

I have no idea what went wrong but from the outside I think we have a solid happy hard working squad and my impression is that Roy expects new players to fit into that ethos. The only one who probably has any latitude is Wilf.

If I was a player I would like to work with a manager that has that ethos, work hard, fit in and play for the team. You know where you stand. If Camarasa wasn't prepared to do that then I think Roy was entitled to bench him.

The question really should be why did we recruit him I would have hoped that someone would have done their homework. There are stories that Ferguson had people following around target players to check on their social life etc. before he signed them, makes sense to me.

Every club signs a dud I don't know if Roy wanted him or he was foisted on him time to move on.

 


One more point

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 14 Jan 20 9.45am

Originally posted by Painter

After watching football for many years, you must know that not all signings work out. Often what you get is not what you expected to end up with. We aren’t the only club to make mistakes, an example recently which is quite high profile, Drinkwater went to Chelsea for £40m didn’t work out, now taken on loan to Burnley and still not getting a game. He was a key player in Leicester’s title year, now in a different environment can’t perform.

And Burnley have ditched him as well he is now at the Villa.

 


One more point

taylors lovechild Flag 14 Jan 20 10.39am

Originally posted by Badger11

And Burnley have ditched him as well he is now at the Villa.

...and he was responsible for two of Man City's goals on his debut!!

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 14 Jan 20 10.42am

Originally posted by jeeagles

I totally agree with this.

Reidewald has shown that we have talented players in the squad he just refused to use.

The manager has surely got to have some say on players we sign?!

Some might blame this on Camarasa's bad attitude, this is all just hear say, but if you know you aren't going to get a look in, then why should you bother.

Roy's been around long enough to know how to keep a job. If he doesn't get involved in transfers, then it's one less thing to be accountable for.

Managers don't get involved in transfers though do they ?

They identify positions that they want players for and then it's over to the Director of Football ( in our case Freedman ) to recruit the players.

But go ahead and have another ill informed pop at Hodgson

 


Old, Ungifted and White

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 14 Jan 20 11.06am

Think Roy, great as he has been for us has a default play to not lose,and when you do try to equalize philosophy. thus he prefers to work in the realm of what he knows first.it had to take a ward injury and awb hitting it right out of the park. meyer is another example. jairo yet another. wont dare to use them creatively from the outset

 

cpj Flag Kent 14 Jan 20 11.09am

Typical Hodgson. Will never play a creative attacking midfielder. If I was Meyer I'd be thinking hard about my future. Absolute disgrace. Nor do I beleive this 'bad attitude' business - Warnock seemed to think he was OK.

 

HolmesdaleUpper Flag Sanderstead 14 Jan 20 11.20am

To be fair to Roy, I saw AWB alot in the U23 before he got his chance and never thought for a minute he would make such an impact in the first team. He was OK but never more. With Jairo wasn't it only a few games ago against Watford that people on here were still slatting him?
Hindsight is a wonderful thing.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards SW19 CPFC Flag Addiscombe West 14 Jan 20 12.52pm

Originally posted by cpj

Typical Hodgson. Will never play a creative attacking midfielder. If I was Meyer I'd be thinking hard about my future. Absolute disgrace. Nor do I beleive this 'bad attitude' business - Warnock seemed to think he was OK.

Simply not the case. Historically, he's had issues at pretty much every club he's been at. Including Cardiff under Warnock. Great quote from him here sums him up for me...

"I think it's down to the player really. If you saw Sol Bamba's scan on his thigh then he wouldn't have played the last six weeks and he's probably been our best player, and he told me 'I'm alright gaffer.' And I think that that's the makeup of players, (some are) stronger than others."

Essentially, talented guy, knows it, doesn't work hard enough and head easily turned. I do agree that this should have been looked at more before signing but maybe they just took a gamble on him.

Mercenary. Doesn't fit well into a hard working, dedicated tight knit squad.

Simple as.


PS. On Meyer – he's a creative player but he is tiny, not physical enough and will only ever make a difference in certain games where he has space and isn't going to be bullied on the pitch. That's why he is so effective as a second half sub – can come on when players are more tired and less likely to track and hassle him. I can therefore understand why he doesn't play enough, although he has also been injured for a while and was just getting a run in the team before Auba nailed him.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2020 12.54pm)

 


Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.

susmik Flag PLYMOUTH -But Made in Old Coulsdon... 14 Jan 20 2.51pm

Originally posted by cpj

Typical Hodgson. Will never play a creative attacking midfielder. If I was Meyer I'd be thinking hard about my future. Absolute disgrace. Nor do I beleive this 'bad attitude' business - Warnock seemed to think he was OK.

Roy has ALWAYS had his own ideas and will never ever change I am afraid.... He DOES have his favourites!!

 


Supported Palace for over 69 years since the age of 7 and have seen all the ups and downs and will probably see many more ups and downs before I go up to the big football club in the sky.

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 14 Jan 20 4.07pm

Originally posted by susmik

Roy has ALWAYS had his own ideas and will never ever change I am afraid.... He DOES have his favourites!!

You're absolutely right !

 


Old, Ungifted and White

eagle@ tn34 Flag hastings 14 Jan 20 5.30pm

Originally posted by SW19 CPFC

Simply not the case. Historically, he's had issues at pretty much every club he's been at. Including Cardiff under Warnock. Great quote from him here sums him up for me...

"I think it's down to the player really. If you saw Sol Bamba's scan on his thigh then he wouldn't have played the last six weeks and he's probably been our best player, and he told me 'I'm alright gaffer.' And I think that that's the makeup of players, (some are) stronger than others."

Essentially, talented guy, knows it, doesn't work hard enough and head easily turned. I do agree that this should have been looked at more before signing but maybe they just took a gamble on him.

Mercenary. Doesn't fit well into a hard working, dedicated tight knit squad.

Simple as.


PS. On Meyer – he's a creative player but he is tiny, not physical enough and will only ever make a difference in certain games where he has space and isn't going to be bullied on the pitch. That's why he is so effective as a second half sub – can come on when players are more tired and less likely to track and hassle him. I can therefore understand why he doesn't play enough, although he has also been injured for a while and was just getting a run in the team before Auba nailed him.

Edited by SW19 CPFC (14 Jan 2020 12.54pm)

Zola or dennis wise werent any bigger if not a bit smaller and they tore teams apart.
But all of this doesnt matter if Meyer is going to be injured for a while

COYP

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 14 Jan 20 6.52pm

if any other business if 1.5 million was wasted heads would roll.Surely Roy would have been asked prior to Camarasa signing if not why because he certainly didnt want him

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 14 Jan 20 7.07pm

Originally posted by eagle@ tn34

Zola or dennis wise werent any bigger if not a bit smaller and they tore teams apart.
But all of this doesnt matter if Meyer is going to be injured for a while

COYP

They, had bags of upper body strength, as did Gaza, it gives them the ability to not be taken off the ball to easily.
Meyer, doesn’t appear to have it in the quantity needed just yet. Very talented, but not quiet strong enough to make a big impression in the Premier yet.

 

jeeagles Flag 14 Jan 20 7.24pm

Originally posted by n wales eagles

if any other business if 1.5 million was wasted heads would roll.Surely Roy would have been asked prior to Camarasa signing if not why because he certainly didnt want him

It would probably cost more than that to get rid of Roy.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 14 Jan 20 7.42pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

It would probably cost more than that to get rid of Roy.

Or FdB. Oh.

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Why does Roy treat Camarasa like this