This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by serial thriller
I find it particularly surprising that you, as Irish, see fit to assume that a religion holds all the responsibility for terrorist actions. I guess we should kick out all the Catholics and Protestants just in case that Irish border stuff flares up again hey? The Irish troubles are essentially the IRA wanting a unified Ireland and their opponents wanting to keep the union with Britain with an underlying, largely historical, religious element. Whereas the current Islamic fundamentalist terrorists openly and clearly state that their motivation is their religion and that they are carrying out their acts as a duty to their religion. The label Islamic Terrorism is entirely appropriate.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Certainly your suggestion that we repeat the same failed nonsense that has brought us to this point is nothing but a future of despair. I never said that banning halal meat and circumcision would 'stop terrorism'. It's one tool in the box that reduces the attractiveness of the country to that demographic. It also bans two barbaric and backward practices that should be banned regardless. I've gone over how this could be done in previous threads. Change UK's human rights law to enable the following: Stop the construction of new Mosques and ban Islamic religious schools. Ban halal meat and circumcision. Pay pakistan and Bangladesh to be willing to take 'citizens' that we want to deport from Islamic watch lists. That's a broad outline of the direction we need to move in if Islamic population increase and hence terrorism is going to be tackled. There isn't a chance in hell of it happening though because...essentially we aren't Poland or Hungary who actually monitor and care about demographics.
It's an interesting point of view but for me, falls down on one key thing. You are essentially trying to make the country less appealing to Muslims on the premise that they won't come here and therefore that will prevent terrorist attacks. The key issue here is that the terrorist attacks are all performed by people who are born here and are British. Therefore, your measures won't make the slightest difference. I'd argue that considering this is the case, making the existing people feel more unwelcome will create more of a divide and increase the likelihood of attacks. Equally, your entire premise relies on the assumption that terrorism is inevitable and no amount of education, engagement etc will prevent it. This is where we fundamentally disagree as I believe that with all individuals who have performed terrorist attacks, there would have been several stages where engagement and appropriate help would've prevented them from happening.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
It's an interesting point of view but for me, falls down on one key thing. You are essentially trying to make the country less appealing to Muslims on the premise that they won't come here and therefore that will prevent terrorist attacks. The key issue here is that the terrorist attacks are all performed by people who are born here and are British. Therefore, your measures won't make the slightest difference. I'd argue that considering this is the case, making the existing people feel more unwelcome will create more of a divide and increase the likelihood of attacks. Equally, your entire premise relies on the assumption that terrorism is inevitable and no amount of education, engagement etc will prevent it. This is where we fundamentally disagree as I believe that with all individuals who have performed terrorist attacks, there would have been several stages where engagement and appropriate help would've prevented them from happening. Seriously? Your belief that 'education, engagement' can work comes from a place of zero evidence and has been tried and proven a failure since mass migration started in WW2. The idea that we haven't tried very very hard to integrate is just at odds with what happened. Europe is probably the most welcoming area in the world to foreigners than any other continent.....much to its damage. Asking people to change identities doesn't work. The majority become more attached to them, not less......Anyone who's seen an Irish pub in England or the English in Spain knows that......You can't 'educate' people away from identity. It's common sense that second and third generations are going to be more identitarian not less as the cultural differences between their two cultural inputs are stark....Not relatively minor like say the English and Polish. It doesn't work.....It can only work with filtered success stories and so what you are in affect doing is giving over land and domains to different ethnicities and white flight will result at quicker and quicker rates. That's what actually happens....Your 'integration and education' is meaningless and misguided. Your politics has handed down a poisoned chalice to the next generations. You asked me for solutions.....they aren't perfect and they do result in division.....but that's the point. The future is going to be nothing but that anyway....and the do gooders paved the way to hell because they turned their head away from reality in preference to warm worded falsehoods. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Feb 2020 1.17pm)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
It's an interesting point of view but for me, falls down on one key thing. You are essentially trying to make the country less appealing to Muslims on the premise that they won't come here and therefore that will prevent terrorist attacks. The key issue here is that the terrorist attacks are all performed by people who are born here and are British. Therefore, your measures won't make the slightest difference. I'd argue that considering this is the case, making the existing people feel more unwelcome will create more of a divide and increase the likelihood of attacks. Equally, your entire premise relies on the assumption that terrorism is inevitable and no amount of education, engagement etc will prevent it. This is where we fundamentally disagree as I believe that with all individuals who have performed terrorist attacks, there would have been several stages where engagement and appropriate help would've prevented them from happening. This is a remarkably tolerant attitude but if people born and educated here have to be taught that stabbing or blowing others up is unacceptable behaviour then what form of engagement do you suggest?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
This is a remarkably tolerant attitude but if people born and educated here have to be taught that stabbing or blowing others up is unacceptable behaviour then what form of engagement do you suggest? It’s not about teaching them that. It’s about ensuring that they are educated and not disillusioned with society so they don’t believe the extremists beliefs and ideologies.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stirlingsays
Seriously? Your belief that 'education, engagement' can work comes from a place of zero evidence and has been tried and proven a failure since mass migration started in WW2. The idea that we haven't tried very very hard to integrate is just at odds with what happened. Europe is probably the most welcoming area in the world to foreigners than any other continent.....much to its damage. Asking people to change identities doesn't work. The majority become more attached to them, not less......Anyone who's seen an Irish pub in England or the English in Spain knows that......You can't 'educate' people away from identity. It's common sense that second and third generations are going to be more identitarian not less as the cultural differences between their two cultural inputs are stark....Not relatively minor like say the English and Polish. It doesn't work.....It can only work with filtered success stories and so what you are in affect doing is giving over land and domains to different ethnicities and white flight will result at quicker and quicker rates. That's what actually happens....Your 'integration and education' is meaningless and misguided. Your politics has handed down a poisoned chalice to the next generations. You asked me for solutions.....they aren't perfect and they do result in division.....but that's the point. The future is going to be nothing but that anyway....and the do gooders paved the way to hell because they turned their head away from reality in preference to warm worded falsehoods. Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Feb 2020 1.17pm) Making the country unappealing isn’t going to work as the crimes are committed by those born here. Your solutions don’t work and have less evidence base than mine.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
Making the country unappealing isn’t going to work as the crimes are committed by those born here. Your solutions don’t work and have less evidence base than mine. Have a look into the backgrounds of people higher up in Islamic terrorist circles and you may be quite surprised what you find. The 9/11 bombers all attended Western Universities for example - was that not giving them ample evidence of a society trying to educate and help them achieve more?
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
Making the country unappealing isn’t going to work as the crimes are committed by those born here. Your solutions don’t work and have less evidence base than mine. Your solutions have been tried for over fifty years. Mine haven't. But you're still repeating points I've already answered in my post. So I'll give up....no point. You believe in your little pipe dreams.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
| W12 06 Feb 20 8.09pm | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
Making the country unappealing isn’t going to work as the crimes are committed by those born here. Your solutions don’t work and have less evidence base than mine. They are not all born here e.g. all the Borough Market savages were all born abroad. Also somewhat irrelevant if they are basically living completely apart from British indigenous people. Do you think an of these people consider themselves British over and above their cultural homeland or indeed their identify as a Muslim. Obviously none of them do.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
It’s not about teaching them that. It’s about ensuring that they are educated and not disillusioned with society so they don’t believe the extremists beliefs and ideologies. How does being disillusioned cause knife/machete/bombing attacks? There have been millions of people in this country with good reason to be disillusioned, through poverty, unemployment, and lack of opportunity who didn’t resort to targeted slaughter.
|
|
[Tweet Link]
|
|
| W12 07 Feb 20 7.10am | |
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE
[Tweet Link]The key words here are “are not to be” No explanation required
|
|
|
Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE
[Tweet Link]While it's the working classes taking the hits nothing is going to change. These people are neo liberals and all while it isn't their children and they have enough money to get out.....they couldn't give a monkey's. As is always the way, until there is a major tragedy and huge pressure on them these berks wouldn't do anything different. I cross my fingers that I'm wrong. Edited by Stirlingsays (07 Feb 2020 8.05am)
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
How does being disillusioned cause knife/machete/bombing attacks? There have been millions of people in this country with good reason to be disillusioned, through poverty, unemployment, and lack of opportunity who didn’t resort to targeted slaughter. It makes you more susceptible to extremist ideology which then leads to attacks. It’s basically that and mental health that are the two key drivers. So all I’m saying is focus on the cause.
|
|
|
Originally posted by cardiff eagle
It makes you more susceptible to extremist ideology which then leads to attacks. It’s basically that and mental health that are the two key drivers. So all I’m saying is focus on the cause. Many of these extreme views may well be held by British born people but generally their parents weren't born here. My 11 year old grandaughter drew a picture of Nigel Farage emerging from a turd. Where does an 11 year old get ideas like that from if not from her parents
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Many of these extreme views may well be held by British born people but generally their parents weren't born here. My 11 year old grandaughter drew a picture of Nigel Farage emerging from a turd. Where does an 11 year old get ideas like that from if not from her parents 11 year olds love going on a wind up.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
|
Originally posted by ASCPFC
Her mother (my daughter) shares her views
|
|
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
Her mother (my daughter) shares her views Well, I trust it was well drawn. Take a photo of it and send it to Wisbech. He can use it as his profile picture.
Red and Blue Army! |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.