You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year
November 16 2026 5.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Player of the year


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
BM Flag 22 Jul 20 5.21pm

1. Jordan Ayew
2. Wilfried Zaha
3. Vicente Guiata
4. James McArthur
5. James Tomkins
6. Cheikhou Kouyate
7. Scott Dann
8. Gary Cahill
9. Christian Benteke
10. Patrick van Aanholt

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jul 20 5.24pm

Originally posted by BM

1. Jordan Ayew
2. Wilfried Zaha
3. Vicente Guiata
4. James McArthur
5. James Tomkins
6. Cheikhou Kouyate
7. Scott Dann
8. Gary Cahill
9. Christian Benteke
10. Patrick van Aanholt

Is that a list to choose from or a list of preference in numeric order?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 22 Jul 20 5.32pm

Sorloth

 


Red and Blue Army!

BM Flag 22 Jul 20 5.40pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Is that a list to choose from or a list of preference in numeric order?

My top ten

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jul 20 5.56pm

Originally posted by BM

My top ten

Jeez what a bad season

 

*jack* Flag Eastbourne 22 Jul 20 6.04pm

None of them

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 22 Jul 20 7.13pm

Originally posted by BM

1. Jordan Ayew
2. Wilfried Zaha
3. Vicente Guiata
4. James McArthur
5. James Tomkins
6. Cheikhou Kouyate
7. Scott Dann
8. Gary Cahill
9. Christian Benteke
10. Patrick van Aanholt

Cahill by a country mile, then Guaita- without them 2 we would have gone down this year..!!

Then possibly Ayew 3rd.

The rest of them have had an entirely forgettable, underwhelming and underperforming season IMO.

For me much as I love him - Wilf has had he’s worst season for us - shown glimpses e.g. goal against Chelsea but just no consistency and that’s what will always hold him back.

But at least we are still in the Prem - let’s see what the window and next season brings..!!

COYP

 

BM Flag 22 Jul 20 7.38pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Cahill by a country mile, then Guaita- without them 2 we would have gone down this year..!!

Then possibly Ayew 3rd.

The rest of them have had an entirely forgettable, underwhelming and underperforming season IMO.

For me much as I love him - Wilf has had he’s worst season for us - shown glimpses e.g. goal against Chelsea but just no consistency and that’s what will always hold him back.

But at least we are still in the Prem - let’s see what the window and next season brings..!!

COYP

Cahill has done okay but the love he gets is mystifying.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 22 Jul 20 7.54pm

Guaita for the points he saved and Ayew for the points he scored, all the rest have been distinctly mediocre.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jul 20 7.55pm

Originally posted by BM

Cahill has done okay but the love he gets is mystifying.

Really?!

 

BM Flag 22 Jul 20 8.12pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Really?!

Absolutely. He’s no better than Tomkins, Sakho or Dann and his passing is bang average. He’s been a good freebie but the idea that he’s been outstanding is just a myth that loads of people have fallen for.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 22 Jul 20 9.14pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Cahill by a country mile, then Guaita- without them 2 we would have gone down this year..!!

Then possibly Ayew 3rd.

The rest of them have had an entirely forgettable, underwhelming and underperforming season IMO.

For me much as I love him - Wilf has had he’s worst season for us - shown glimpses e.g. goal against Chelsea but just no consistency and that’s what will always hold him back.

But at least we are still in the Prem - let’s see what the window and next season brings..!!

COYP


This pretty much gets it spot on

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 22 Jul 20 9.15pm

Originally posted by BM

Absolutely. He’s no better than Tomkins, Sakho or Dann and his passing is bang average. He’s been a good freebie but the idea that he’s been outstanding is just a myth that loads of people have fallen for.

This is a joke right?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jul 20 9.40pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

This is a joke right?

Unfortunately I do not think it is, bizarre

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Jul 20 9.42pm

Originally posted by BM

Absolutely. He’s no better than Tomkins, Sakho or Dann and his passing is bang average. He’s been a good freebie but the idea that he’s been outstanding is just a myth that loads of people have fallen for.

Not my POTY but he has been excellent. To say he is no better than the other 3 is in my opinion, staggering but you are entitled to your opinion

 

rawpalace05 Flag Saltdean 22 Jul 20 10.06pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Cahill by a country mile, then Guaita- without them 2 we would have gone down this year..!!

Then possibly Ayew 3rd.

The rest of them have had an entirely forgettable, underwhelming and underperforming season IMO.

For me much as I love him - Wilf has had he’s worst season for us - shown glimpses e.g. goal against Chelsea but just no consistency and that’s what will always hold him back.

But at least we are still in the Prem - let’s see what the window and next season brings..!!

COYP

Jimmy Mac and PVA have also been excellent. I'd say its a dead heat between VG, GC and JA for the top 3. Scott Dann has also shown that he was very unlucky to have made it out of sorts back when he was injured and JT came in. Always been class IMO and a comfortable stand in for GC - he's been great

Edited by rawpalace05 (22 Jul 2020 10.07pm)

 


1/6/2010.a new era.we made it everyone!!!lets get the ball rolling for another 105 years of proud history.thank you cpfc2010.

palace forever.eeaaaaaaaaaaaaaggglless!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 22 Jul 20 10.17pm

Being asked to vote for the POTY after SEVEN straight defeats is somewhat galling but I shall put the post lockdown blues aside and remember that prior to it we reached safety and the three players mainly responsible for that imo were Guaita, Cahill and Ayew. Trying to choose between them is difficult but I'll plump for Guaita.

 

BM Flag 22 Jul 20 10.19pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

This is a joke right?

It’s not his fault but Cahill is grossly overrated by most fans. We have an excellent pool of 4-5 CBs and he is one of them but he’s not the best by any means. I’d put him behind Tonks, Sakho and Dann.

 

jeeagles Flag 23 Jul 20 8.13am

Originally posted by BM

Cahill has done okay but the love he gets is mystifying.

He's certainly a player we didn't need to sign.

With Sakho, Tompkins, Dann, Kelly, and Kayoute all able to play centre back, I think investment would have been much better spent elsewhere.

Guiata for me. Might have made a couple of mistakes but also won games for us.

 

kev64 Flag Cambs 23 Jul 20 8.39am

Originally posted by jeeagles

He's certainly a player we didn't need to sign.

With Sakho, Tompkins, Dann, Kelly, and Kayoute all able to play centre back, I think investment would have been much better spent elsewhere.

Guiata for me. Might have made a couple of mistakes but also won games for us.

Seriously, Sakho sick note 3/10 Tompkins 8/10 injured, Dann 7/10 slowing down, Kelly ok back up guy 6/10.

Cahill is a class act, he may be on a big wage a got a nice sign on fee but he was ever present from day one until a week or so ago and he has not cost us the 40 odd mill we’ve poured down the drain on Sakho, who now he’s out again we have no chance of off loading .

Along with Tekkers, SP waved goodbye to 80 mill on these frauds over the last few years. With zero re sale values.

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Player of the year