This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Willo
With respect, I really don't think my posts warranted this tirade. I don't recognise the "Pretty strong language" to which you refer.I have formed a view which of course will in all probability turn out to be "Fact", time will tell. Aropos the composition of the panel, I was more than happy with the regulars who have been discarded for reasons which I suspect many believe. Now calm down dear - cold towels please. The fact that you won't answer which 'type' of person you don't want to see on the show as a result of the 'absolutely disgusting' changes says all it needs to. You're totally free to write in a patronising tone, which I hope is as a result of wanting to direct attention away from the prejudice your earlier replies appeared to demonstrate. End of the matter.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
The fact that you won't answer which 'type' of person you don't want to see on the show as a result of the 'absolutely disgusting' changes says all it needs to. You're totally free to write in a patronising tone, which I hope is as a result of wanting to direct attention away from the prejudice your earlier replies appeared to demonstrate. End of the matter. It is NOT a question of whom I do NOT wish to appear on the show, it is the fact that experienced and insightful pundits have been jettisoned for reasons which many believe to be true. Apropos your accusation about "Patronising" those who really know me would conclude that I am far from patronising, furthermore I really do not believe my style of writing enters this category. You have formed your conclusions and expressed your opinion and whilst I respect it, I am an disagreement with it on this matter.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
The fact that you won't answer which 'type' of person you don't want to see on the show as a result of the 'absolutely disgusting' changes says all it needs to. You're totally free to write in a patronising tone, which I hope is as a result of wanting to direct attention away from the prejudice your earlier replies appeared to demonstrate. End of the matter. Not quite. Q? What 'TYPE' of person do YOU want to see on the show? Ive turned your persuit of Willo around & have asked the very same Q? of you.
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise. |
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Not quite. Q? What 'TYPE' of person do YOU want to see on the show? Ive turned your persuit of Willo around & have asked the very same Q? of you. For the record I am not fazed by being interrogated.
|
|
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
Not quite. Q? What 'TYPE' of person do YOU want to see on the show? Ive turned your persuit of Willo around & have asked the very same Q? of you. If you're asking, whoever's got the best credentials for the job. Losing Keys and Gray was a blessing in disguise for Sky - it directly led to Gary Neville getting a chance who is an outstanding pundit and far more in tune with the modern game, as well as opportunities for Jamie Redknapp, Jamie Carragher and David Jones. I couldn't care less what race or gender those people are, or what the so-called PC brigade think of the visuals of the line up, or any of that. No-one here has any clue on Sky's reasoning for this. Even if they do want a more diverse line up, 35% of the PL is black, which wasn't the case when any of the 3 who have been sacked last had anything to do with the game. For reference: Charlie Nicholas (1995) A black panel member doesn't mean the PC brigade are being satisfied, it's probably more likely that person has a better idea of what is going on in the Premier League in 2020. The likes of Gareth Barry, David James, Kevin Phillips, Eddie Howe, Chris Hughton are far more relevant.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
This made me laugh
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
If you're asking, whoever's got the best credentials for the job. Losing Keys and Gray was a blessing in disguise for Sky - it directly led to Gary Neville getting a chance who is an outstanding pundit and far more in tune with the modern game, as well as opportunities for Jamie Redknapp, Jamie Carragher and David Jones. I couldn't care less what race or gender those people are, or what the so-called PC brigade think of the visuals of the line up, or any of that. No-one here has any clue on Sky's reasoning for this. Even if they do want a more diverse line up, 35% of the PL is black, which wasn't the case when any of the 3 who have been sacked last had anything to do with the game. For reference: Charlie Nicholas (1995) A black panel member doesn't mean the PC brigade are being satisfied, it's probably more likely that person has a better idea of what is going on in the Premier League in 2020. The likes of Gareth Barry, David James, Kevin Phillips, Eddie Howe, Chris Hughton are far more relevant. This isn't a question of whether anyone thinks that the above are great pundits or the colour of the panel but the real reasons for their replacement. There is a clear and undeniable directive on SSN to promote all things Black and female. This move is predictable in that sense. The other side of this is entertainment. Regardless of their abilities, the usual panel was amusing because of the humorous nature of their interplay. That has been slightly eroded by SKYs policy of having to include a token Black or Lesbian pundit, although Clinton is obviously a Palace hero and a funny guy, and it did point the way to this obvious eventuality.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
This isn't a question of whether anyone thinks that the above are great pundits or the colour of the panel but the real reasons for their replacement. There is a clear and undeniable directive on SSN to promote all things Black and female. This move is predictable in that sense. The other side of this is entertainment. Regardless of their abilities, the usual panel was amusing because of the humorous nature of their interplay. That has been slightly eroded by SKYs policy of having to include a token Black or Lesbian pundit, although Clinton is obviously a Palace hero and a funny guy, and it did point the way to this obvious eventuality. Which has been my over-riding message in my contributions to this debate. One can predict with a high degree of confidence the composition of the panel, now that 3 white,male, experienced and insightful pundits have been jettisoned. Good post, Mr Hrolf!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
This isn't a question of whether anyone thinks that the above are great pundits or the colour of the panel but the real reasons for their replacement. There is a clear and undeniable directive on SSN to promote all things Black and female. This move is predictable in that sense. The other side of this is entertainment. Regardless of their abilities, the usual panel was amusing because of the humorous nature of their interplay. That has been slightly eroded by SKYs policy of having to include a token Black or Lesbian pundit, although Clinton is obviously a Palace hero and a funny guy, and it did point the way to this obvious eventuality. That is obviously not the relevant stat for this conversation. I'd imagine at least 1/3rd, if not more premier league footballers are black. Whatever the reasoning for getting rid of them, they were all dreadful and in my view unwatchable. Hopefully they get some younger talent on there who have played the game more recently and realise that being a good football pundit doesn't just involve trying to be a lad.
|
|
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
That is obviously not the relevant stat for this conversation. I'd imagine at least 1/3rd, if not more premier league footballers are black. Whatever the reasoning for getting rid of them, they were all dreadful and in my view unwatchable. Hopefully they get some younger talent on there who have played the game more recently and realise that being a good football pundit doesn't just involve trying to be a lad. I don't share these sentiments at all but HOL would be rather tedious if we all agreed with one another as part of a gargantuan 'Love-In' !
|
|
|
Originally posted by IMpalace
That is obviously not the relevant stat for this conversation. I'd imagine at least 1/3rd, if not more premier league footballers are black. Whatever the reasoning for getting rid of them, they were all dreadful and in my view unwatchable. Hopefully they get some younger talent on there who have played the game more recently and realise that being a good football pundit doesn't just involve trying to be a lad. I’d wager the viewing demographic on Saturday afternoon is the age demographic of the sacked panel. Many reasons why. Home owners, paying mortgages so don’t just go out spending disposable income they probably don’t have, retired, tired after a week at work as happens more with age. Younger people are out and about whereas older blokes are at home. We’ll see what happens but advertising revenue will come into consideration if a bad decision is made. What hasn’t been mentioned yet is young people apparently don’t watch tv these days. But now they do and suddenly their wishes and desperation to make everything diverse when merit suffices, they want tv changed and personalities like Matt Le Tissier effectively cancelled because he dared to use his freedom of speech to say something about Covid and a marxist or black power political group. This is not a good way to be going. Merit should be rewarded.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Bexley Eagle
As with everything in this world the programme has to evolve and reinvent itself every so often. These guys have had a good run. Why should they be immune to what happens all the time in the real world. They should run two separate programmes, advertisers get 2 shows for the price of 1. See what the viewing figures say. It’ll be what the majority of the audience identifies with. I am of course joking due to the uproar and vandalism when one gets taken off air.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger
This isn't a question of whether anyone thinks that the above are great pundits or the colour of the panel but the real reasons for their replacement. There is a clear and undeniable directive on SSN to promote all things Black and female. This move is predictable in that sense. The other side of this is entertainment. Regardless of their abilities, the usual panel was amusing because of the humorous nature of their interplay. That has been slightly eroded by SKYs policy of having to include a token Black or Lesbian pundit, although Clinton is obviously a Palace hero and a funny guy, and it did point the way to this obvious eventuality. Yes it’s a good post. Common sense has gone out of the window as usual. I would understand Ian Wright being hired. Micah Richards I can’t remember seeing. Jermaine Jenas is too clever and analytical for Sky Sports Saturday and Alex Scott or anyone of any sex or trans sex lol who hasn’t played top division football is just bizarre but of course more box ticking. Anyway, Daily Mail reports or thinks Jeff Stelling is thinking that he may as well go the way it’s gone or going.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Badger11
Just picking up on the demographics comment and not specific to any TV company. We are told that young people have no money and don't watch traditional TV. We are told that the baby boomers are the lucky generation who have it all including house, pension and disposal income. And yet TV companies are obsessed with chasing the yoof culture and alienating the pale and the stale who actually watch telly and have money to spend. And to prove the point a little niche TV channels called Talking Pictures (old B&W) run by a father and daughter from their bedroom gets higher ratings than MTV and many BBC programs.
Yep, someone at Sky aiming to be like the liberal, woke box ticking BBC could be making the worst decision Sky Sports has made.
COYP |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.