You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > US Supreme Court Ginsburg kicks the bucket
November 21 2026 10.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

US Supreme Court Ginsburg kicks the bucket


Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5
Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 28 Sep 20 2.28am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

You are the fool!

In any political grouping as large as the Democrats, or indeed the Republicans, there are going to be some who say stupid things and provide their opponents with the opportunity to sling mud. Not every Democrat believes in left-wing politics, or supports Antifa, just as not every Republican is a white supremacist or a proud boy.

Of course the Democratic Senators will probe a candidate's personal beliefs and elicit answers that they will need to stand by in the future. No jurist ought to allow their personal convictions to over-ride the law and making sure that won't happen is particularly important when dealing with anyone who holds a strong religious conviction. That's their job and you would not expect anything different, whether they be Democrat or Republican.

It's the same with adoption. They will probe the motivation and get statements on the record. There is nothing to see here at all.

The primary area of attack won't be on the candidate but on the process which puts her under consideration. Even that, I suspect, won't be centre stage. People have their minds made up about that already. The focus will be on what a Democratic POTUS, together with a Democratic majority in both houses, will do to repair this damage and restore the integrity, dignity and reputation of a country which has suffered such a huge fall in those areas in the last 4 years.

More waffle & subterfuge wrapped up as bulls*** from you, how unusual

 


Pro USA & Israel

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Sep 20 3.43pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

More waffle & subterfuge wrapped up as bulls*** from you, how unusual

What isn't unusual is a response which does nothing to counter the arguments but instead seeks to negatively categorise them with insults.

And I am accused of not engaging with the arguments!

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Sep 20 9.23pm

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It was very much more than a "grope" and she was a compelling and completely believable witness. I watched those hearings live and she either spoke the truth or was the greatest undiscovered actor the world has seen. Kavanaugh's face told a story too. It exposed him as a liar and a fraud. Nevermind it happened long ago, when standards differed. Truth and honesty are timeless and he failed.

There were others. They just didn't testify. Testifying in cases that impact Trump requires a lot of personal bravery, not only for yourself but your family and I can well understand why some are reluctant when careers have been ruined as a result.

When you wear blinkers, you only see what you want.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Sep 20 10.23pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

When you wear blinkers, you only see what you want.

Did you watch the hearing? If so what did you see that I didn't?

It wasn't just what she said that was compelling, or indeed on it's own, that important. He could easily have brushed it off by apologising, saying it was over stated and misremembered teenage antics and asking people to consider his record as a man, a father and a Judge. But no, he went full on Trump and took the blanket denial route, which given the authenticity of the witness made him look like a liar.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Sep 20 11.57pm

You know it's quite incredible that a grown adult would seriously put forward the idea that because person A seems believable to them, that we must then believe without any other actual evidence.

Blinkers isn't the half of it, trolling more like.

Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Sep 2020 11.58pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Sep 20 7.32am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Did you watch the hearing? If so what did you see that I didn't?

It wasn't just what she said that was compelling, or indeed on it's own, that important. He could easily have brushed it off by apologising, saying it was over stated and misremembered teenage antics and asking people to consider his record as a man, a father and a Judge. But no, he went full on Trump and took the blanket denial route, which given the authenticity of the witness made him look like a liar.

No I didn’t as I am not that interested and have a life. I made a general comment, One which my grandfather used a lot, especially when he was discussing politics, as always you have put your own slant on it.


Edited by Spiderman (29 Sep 2020 7.33am)

Edited by Spiderman (29 Sep 2020 7.35am)

Edited by Spiderman (29 Sep 2020 7.35am)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Sep 20 7.48am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Did you watch the hearing? If so what did you see that I didn't?

It wasn't just what she said that was compelling, or indeed on it's own, that important. He could easily have brushed it off by apologising, saying it was over stated and misremembered teenage antics and asking people to consider his record as a man, a father and a Judge. But no, he went full on Trump and took the blanket denial route, which given the authenticity of the witness made him look like a liar.

The witness only remembered the incident decades after it occurred and after she had undergone therapy. If the therapy was to recover her memories under hypnosis that is a discredited treatment due to the large number of cases of false memories. It may well be that she is convinced it happened when it never did.

It was a joke that the hearings were not allowed to question her on this therapy which after all was pivotal in her remembering.

As for the judge why should he apologize for something if it never happened. Just because you found her credible it doesn't mean it's a fact that she was assaulted. If you are going to destroy someone's career it might be nice to have some evidence as well.

 


One more point

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Sep 20 8.15am

Originally posted by Badger11

The witness only remembered the incident decades after it occurred and after she had undergone therapy. If the therapy was to recover her memories under hypnosis that is a discredited treatment due to the large number of cases of false memories. It may well be that she is convinced it happened when it never did.

It was a joke that the hearings were not allowed to question her on this therapy which after all was pivotal in her remembering.

As for the judge why should he apologize for something if it never happened. Just because you found her credible it doesn't mean it's a fact that she was assaulted. If you are going to destroy someone's career it might be nice to have some evidence as well.

Careful Wisbech is never wrong

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 04 Oct 20 8.11am

Interesting article from NY Times about Ginsberg and her decision to stay on.

[Link]

It would appear that privately many people close to her thought she was selfish not to step down when Obama was in power.

Chickens may come home to roost.

 


One more point

Matov Flag 27 Oct 20 7.18am

Originally posted by Badger11

Chickens may come home to roost.

Indeed they have done...

[Link]

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 27 Oct 20 7.58am

Originally posted by Matov

Indeed they have done...

[Link]

Not to worry Sleep Joe has said he will stack the court if he wins even if it means increasing the number of judges. Of course that is NOT the same thing as Trump has done he is a very bad man.

 


One more point

Maine Eagle Flag USA 27 Oct 20 3.33pm

Originally posted by Badger11

Not to worry Sleep Joe has said he will stack the court if he wins even if it means increasing the number of judges. Of course that is NOT the same thing as Trump has done he is a very bad man.

Its called packing the court, or court packing.

It means increasing the number of judges, in terms of the supreme court.

It would be a fool's errand for Biden though, as the republicans would eventually be in power again, and they would add more again...

Except for 2 scenarios.

1 - Biden manages to amend the constitution to say, for arguments sake, 15 is the maximum, and he adds 6 liberals. I can imagine the right wing tears now.

2 - Biden has the senate and congress for a couple of years, then he can finally change voting laws here designed to suppress voting by democrats, and you may never see another republican president ever, so no republican could ever appoint another supreme court justice again. I can imagine more right wing tears on that one.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Matov Flag 27 Oct 20 8.29pm

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

Its called packing the court, or court packing.

It means increasing the number of judges, in terms of the supreme court.

It would be a fool's errand for Biden though, as the republicans would eventually be in power again, and they would add more again...

Except for 2 scenarios.

1 - Biden manages to amend the constitution to say, for arguments sake, 15 is the maximum, and he adds 6 liberals. I can imagine the right wing tears now.

2 - Biden has the senate and congress for a couple of years, then he can finally change voting laws here designed to suppress voting by democrats, and you may never see another republican president ever, so no republican could ever appoint another supreme court justice again. I can imagine more right wing tears on that one.

You forgot the third one. Full on civil war. Seriously. Or do you think these kinds of stunts would just be written off as political high jinx?

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

BlueJay Flag UK 27 Oct 20 9.33pm

Originally posted by Matov

You forgot the third one. Full on civil war. Seriously. Or do you think these kinds of stunts would just be written off as political high jinx?

Not allowing a vote on Merrick Garland could be described as a stunt. Confirming a justice 'during' a presidential election could also be described as a stunt. Republicans States have been expanding the number of seats on their states’ high courts [Link] and packing courts with lifetime appointed judges in numbers never seen before [Link] It's not for one party to reshape the rules, and the other to sit around.

If Democrats win the Presidency, Senate and House, once the opposites get over their 'it's rigged!' programming (or don't), there will essentially be a mandate from the American people and a rejection of what has come before. What they do with that is down to them just as it will be (and has been) if the GOP wins, but the rhetoric and actions of the last four years hardly signal a President trying to avoid a Civil War. He actively stokes divisions in a way that is off the charts by any acknowledged standard. My inclination though, is that Biden would be more moderate and 'reach across the isle', so we're more likely to have a boring 4 years they don't take real political advantage of. Contrast that with what Trump will turn the November - January transition period into, and you'll get a more accurate view of who is looking for the war.


Edited by BlueJay (27 Oct 2020 9.35pm)

 

Matov Flag 27 Oct 20 9.42pm

Originally posted by BlueJay


My inclination though, is that Biden would be more moderate and 'reach across the isle', so we're more likely to have a boring 4 years they don't take real political advantage of.


Edited by BlueJay (27 Oct 2020 9.35pm)

Biden will not even be allowed into his own office beyond PR photographs. Do you honestly think he will be running the show?

Ever since 2016 the Left have been constantly trying to undermine the results of democratic elections. Be it Brexit or Trump, the unrelenting effort has been to try and have both results declared null and void.

The Left have utterly undermined any confidence in the democratic process and if the Democrats try to rig the Federal system then all hell will, quite rightly, break loose.

Before 2016 the losing side just shrugged their shoulders and moved on but since then? No. The losers have done nothing other than try and re-write history. That comes at a price.

 


"The Party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command." - 1984 - George Orwell.

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Oct 20 12.10am

Originally posted by Badger11

Not to worry Sleep Joe has said he will stack the court if he wins even if it means increasing the number of judges. Of course that is NOT the same thing as Trump has done he is a very bad man.

Parroting Trump's silly epithet? Biden hasn't said he will pack the court! In fact he has spoken against the idea in the past as he knows very well it could easily rebound in the future.

What he has reserved his position and will consider what to do when he knows what is actually needed AND possible.

That something will be needed is obvious. Removing any suspicion of political influence from the highest court is essential. Changing the voting rules within the Senate back to requiring cross party support of candidates and setting term limits for justices may do it.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Oct 20 7.33am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

Parroting Trump's silly epithet? Biden hasn't said he will pack the court! In fact he has spoken against the idea in the past as he knows very well it could easily rebound in the future.

What he has reserved his position and will consider what to do when he knows what is actually needed AND possible.

That something will be needed is obvious. Removing any suspicion of political influence from the highest court is essential. Changing the voting rules within the Senate back to requiring cross party support of candidates and setting term limits for justices may do it.

The Supreme Court has always been political it is nothing new. Obama wanted Ginsburg to step down so he could put his pick in her place in case the republicans got back in. Up until the 1950's the court was always socially conservative then it swung liberal and now maybe it's going back the other way.


Just because Trump gets his judge it doesn't mean they will vote the way he wants them to. Lots of judges once appointed for life and free from political pressure have surprised the public with their verdicts.

Earl Warren was a conservative republican politicain appointed to the Supreme Court by Eisenhower as he was thought to be "sound". Instead be became one of the most liberal judges and led the charge in championing civil rights.

The sensible thing for sleepy Joe to do is just appoint his judge next time there is a vacancy which is what all the other Presidents have done. Trump has been lucky that 3 of them have died during his presidency normally it's less than that.

As for structural reforms to the court I suspect that once it quietens down the democrats will leave well along.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Oct 20 8.57am

Originally posted by Badger11

The Supreme Court has always been political it is nothing new. Obama wanted Ginsburg to step down so he could put his pick in her place in case the republicans got back in. Up until the 1950's the court was always socially conservative then it swung liberal and now maybe it's going back the other way.


Just because Trump gets his judge it doesn't mean they will vote the way he wants them to. Lots of judges once appointed for life and free from political pressure have surprised the public with their verdicts.

Earl Warren was a conservative republican politicain appointed to the Supreme Court by Eisenhower as he was thought to be "sound". Instead be became one of the most liberal judges and led the charge in championing civil rights.

The sensible thing for sleepy Joe to do is just appoint his judge next time there is a vacancy which is what all the other Presidents have done. Trump has been lucky that 3 of them have died during his presidency normally it's less than that.

As for structural reforms to the court I suspect that once it quietens down the democrats will leave well along.

It is simply untrue that the US Supreme Court has always been political. Until a relatively short time ago Presidents nominated outstanding candidates irrespective of their perceived political leanings. It is only in recent years it has drifted this way. The big change was though when McConnell changed the rules which allowed a simple majority of Senators to move the process forward. In the past this had always been two-thirds and then three-fifths. It's this which has cemented the politicisment as McConnell openly says this is so they can throw out things like Obamacare and Roe v Wade.

So whilst the Judges may still be able to surprise when it's a bunch of motivated politicians selecting them for their own purposes the system isn't healthy.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Oct 20 9.19am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

It is simply untrue that the US Supreme Court has always been political. Until a relatively short time ago Presidents nominated outstanding candidates irrespective of their perceived political leanings. It is only in recent years it has drifted this way. The big change was though when McConnell changed the rules which allowed a simple majority of Senators to move the process forward. In the past this had always been two-thirds and then three-fifths. It's this which has cemented the politicisment as McConnell openly says this is so they can throw out things like Obamacare and Roe v Wade.

So whilst the Judges may still be able to surprise when it's a bunch of motivated politicians selecting them for their own purposes the system isn't healthy.

Up until the 1950s there was a consensus in Congress because the pro segregation Democrats didn't want a liberal judge that would rock the boat in the south. So they were fine with most Republican socially conservative nominations.

However the Supreme Court today simply reflects the divisions in the country as both parties move further apart from each other.

As for politicians electing judges I agree it is a lousy system but this is what the founding fathers wanted.

 


One more point

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 28 Oct 20 10.23am

Originally posted by Badger11

Up until the 1950s there was a consensus in Congress because the pro segregation Democrats didn't want a liberal judge that would rock the boat in the south. So they were fine with most Republican socially conservative nominations.

However the Supreme Court today simply reflects the divisions in the country as both parties move further apart from each other.

As for politicians electing judges I agree it is a lousy system but this is what the founding fathers wanted.

This idea that "what the founding fathers wanted" is the only thing that matters seems what is throttling common sense in the USA and holding them back. Those founding fathers were wise men who would not have claimed the ability to foresee the future or restrict the country from responding to it.

So I see it as an excuse and not a reason not to bring in changes which are needed.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

Page 5 of 5 << First< 1 2 3 4 5

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > US Supreme Court Ginsburg kicks the bucket