You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > GOAT or GPPOAT
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

GOAT or GPPOAT


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 06 Mar 21 7.23am

This snippet from a clickbait article got me thinking:

'The Ivory Coast international might go down in history as the best player to appear for the South London side, and his attacking influence is really needed as the club are lacking a threat upfront without him.'

This, obvz, is about Zaha and his return to fitness.

So what truth does it hold?

Who is our greatest player in history?

Lombardo?
Byrne?
Salad?

You thoughts.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Mar 21 8.57am

You can't include Lombardo as great player that he was he was only with Palace for five minutes.

Don Rogers had a greater goal scoring record with us with 28 goals in 70 appearances and almost all of them were a wonder to behold.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 06 Mar 21 9.09am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You can't include Lombardo as great player that he was he was only with Palace for five minutes.

Don Rogers had a greater goal scoring record with us with 28 goals in 70 appearances and almost all of them were a wonder to behold.

Lombardo made 47 appearances and stuck with us following relegation.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 06 Mar 21 9.54am

Kenny, Don and Wilf.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 06 Mar 21 10.46am

It's an interesting question, but it's a bit like asking who is the greatest racing driver of all time?

The era when they raced or, in this case, when they played, has an influence I think. Lewis Hamilton looks good in the record books, but the car he drives is far better than the others and a darn sight safer than cars in the 50s and 60s. So, although the record books don't show it I would vote for Fangio as the GOAT simply because of his skill in a fragile car with absolutely no safety features whatsoever. Stirling Moss a close second.

As for Palace's GOAT I'm thinking of how the game was played on a pitch of mud on a rainy day with a leather ball weighing gawd knows how much more than today's beach balls. Johnny 'Budgie' Byrne would get my vote, although I don't remember much about him. Don Rogers, as suggested by Midland is a good candidate.

But my favourite player of all time, although not necessarily the greatest, was Vince Hilaire. Local lad, great on the ball and a real entertainer. Magic.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Mar 21 10.46am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You can't include Lombardo as great player that he was he was only with Palace for five minutes.

Don Rogers had a greater goal scoring record with us with 28 goals in 70 appearances and almost all of them were a wonder to behold.

Greatest player has to include some length of service which is why I have to give it to Zaha.

 


One more point

TheBigToePunt Flag 06 Mar 21 11.33am

If you base it on what they achieved for Palace then it's difficult to look past Wilf, even if he's less exciting than he used to be.

Wilf
Wright
Bright
Thomas
Martyn

I only started going in the late 80s.

Edited by TheBigToePunt (06 Mar 2021 11.38am)

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Mar 21 12.17pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

You can't include Lombardo as great player that he was he was only with Palace for five minutes.

Don Rogers had a greater goal scoring record with us with 28 goals in 70 appearances and almost all of them were a wonder to behold.

Always will be Rogers for me. Vince was great to watch but Peter Taylor had a much better scoring record - to get into the England team as a third division player took some doing.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 06 Mar 21 1.17pm

Originally posted by Mapletree


Lombardo made 47 appearances and stuck with us following relegation.

True but statistics don't tell you everything as if I recall most of his appearances and goals were in the second tier as he broke his leg and missed half of his single season in the top league

 

kingdowieonthewall Flag Sussex, ex-Cronx. 06 Mar 21 1.45pm

'killer' patterson , just for smacking Roy Keane in the boat.
(Don Rogers most likely, but Ian Wright used to get that same buzz going round the ground, when he attacked)

Although only with us a too short while, Lombardo was utter class, exuded it.
Saw him at Gatwick airport once, took a bit of self restraint not to do the Ayatollah !

 


Kids,tired of being bothered by your pesky parents?
Then leave home, get a job & pay your own bills, while you still know everything.

slubglurge Flag welling 06 Mar 21 1.50pm

Sansom for me, Rogers for the sheer excitement to watch but Sansom went on to have a stellar career for club and country

 

crystal-purley Flag Purley 06 Mar 21 3.01pm

Most of those mentioned but Rachid just for the sheer entertainment value.

 


Enjoying getting up later and not having someone who knows better than me (apart from the missus of course).

Dubai Eagle Flag 06 Mar 21 3.15pm

Some great names already mentioned - I would have to add John Jackson, AJ & Jim Cannon to the list, Not necessarily the absolute greatest of all time but for sure (at least for me) the list wouldn't feel right without them included.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 06 Mar 21 3.27pm


Going further back Peter Simpson must be in with a shout.
In later years he had a tobacconists in Croydon which some on here could well have visited in the 60s.

[Link]


 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 06 Mar 21 4.13pm

aj

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 06 Mar 21 4.28pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


Going further back Peter Simpson must be in with a shout.
In later years he had a tobacconists in Croydon which some on here could well have visited in the 60s.

[Link]


Blimey, just goes to show how tricky this is. Hadn't been aware of Simpson I'm ashamed to say, but quite a CV.

Everybody has a very valid shout for their star man - all of them made terrific contributions to the club in their time.

I went for Vince, but since I did I've regretted not naming Wright and Sansom who others have identified and who I remember watching with great pleasure. Especially Wright at Wembley.

Anyway, I'll stick with Vince as my favourite.

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 06 Mar 21 4.46pm

Only oldies like me (been supporter since 194
would unequivocally plump for the late, great Johnny Byrne.

It was a privilege to watch him weave his magic from the open spaces of Selhurst (just the one stand then)

And those of my era will always say that John Jackson
was our best keeper in living memory. Those were the days of leather balls, quagmire pitches and an anything goes attitude to keepers by opposing No.9s - it was brutal and none but the bravest would prevail.

Even when he moved on to Orient he was the bravest of the brave.

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 06 Mar 21 5.24pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

Blimey, just goes to show how tricky this is. Hadn't been aware of Simpson I'm ashamed to say, but quite a CV.

Everybody has a very valid shout for their star man - all of them made terrific contributions to the club in their time.

I went for Vince, but since I did I've regretted not naming Wright and Sansom who others have identified and who I remember watching with great pleasure. Especially Wright at Wembley.

Anyway, I'll stick with Vince as my favourite.



He would be my second choice after Wilf.

 


One more point

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 06 Mar 21 5.30pm

Originally posted by Uphill

Only oldies like me (been supporter since 194
would unequivocally plump for the late, great Johnny Byrne.

It was a privilege to watch him weave his magic from the open spaces of Selhurst (just the one stand then)

And those of my era will always say that John Jackson
was our best keeper in living memory. Those were the days of leather balls, quagmire pitches and an anything goes attitude to keepers by opposing No.9s - it was brutal and none but the bravest would prevail.

Even when he moved on to Orient he was the bravest of the brave.

Nice one. I don't clearly recall seeing Byrne in his pomp, but I watched him play when he came back for a while. Past his best really. My Dad used to wax lyrical though, always his favourite player.

Now John (Stonewall) Jackson I do remember seeing and he certainly was a cracking keeper. He came to a youth club event to answer questions from us kids. I got his autograph by handing him a programme but was too nervous to speak.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 06 Mar 21 5.45pm

loved Don Rogers, kenny Samson, Ian Wright and Wilf too but for me Johnny Byrne is the greatest I've ever seen in a Palace shirt. consider that he played for England while in the3rd Div, unheard of toady and rare even then, ,when sold it was a British record transfer fee equivalent to Bale's record of 83 million now.

Edited by PZ Eagle (06 Mar 2021 5.46pm)

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > GOAT or GPPOAT