You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Keep Roy
November 16 2026 4.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Keep Roy


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 10 Apr 21 10.20pm

Originally posted by steven_t92

For the last 2 years Roy has continuously started games with players in the wrong position or with the mindset to not lose the game. After this long in the PL we shouldn't be doing that, we were past that long ago but are going backwards with that mentality. Facts don't lie...

last week on another thread i predicted we would lose £60m FY 2020 i was wrong we lost £58m.

if we hadnt have sold AWB FY 2019 we would have lost £40m.

I think if wilf goes (god i hope he doesnt), and massively reduce the wage bill this summer we could maybe only lose £10m FY 2021.

my point being, is that i judge my expectations based on what the squad looks like and what has been invested in it, when your favoured starters are ayew / mccarthy & kouyate (who i like) playing CB for a whole season you temper your expectations accordingly.

to demand more than what we have achieved shows a severe lack of understanding of the situation we find ourselves in, given the limited funds available to our manager.

that is why, i would be more than happy for him to sign a new contract, as if we make the wrong decision and go down, that £58m loss turns into double that.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


CPFCwetrust Flag Maidstone 10 Apr 21 10.39pm

Whats the point in getting players in if they aren't played braunston?

I mean Zaha is a winger playing as a forward when Bats and Mateta are on the bench, eze is an attacking midfielder playing cdm with Mccarthy bench warming, Kouyate is a cdm playing in defence with Dann and Kelly about, Schlupp is bench warming when he is creating chances more often than not.

My opinion is cpfc can buy players but the manager needs to play them and in the right positions or even play them...
Mateta won't be excited about joining now..I have no doubt.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 10 Apr 21 11.24pm

You can keep Roy and finish between 11-16 or you can go into the unknown. Trouble is Roy is getting too old to man manage. Tough call.

 

Eagle Black. Flag South Croydon 10 Apr 21 11.46pm

Sorry but it's time to ditch Roy for a younger more modern coach.

Roy is a gent,but end of the season time for a change.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 11 Apr 21 1.10am

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i get that...but he is still not very good even when played in his preferred position, IMO schluppy or andros should start in front of him.

we can look all the stats in the world to agree or disagree with roy being manager...all that matters at the end of the day is how many points after how many games and by that yardstick he is going a fantastic job.

You are 100% correct and one of the few one here that seem to understand being a Palace supporter.

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 11 Apr 21 1.23am

Originally posted by Brinscalleagle2

Sorry to disagree but Eze has shown no appetite for a fight since he has been here. Yes loads of talent and ability but absolutely no talent for working hard to make things happen. Nothing to do with Roy all to do with Eze and his lack of desire to work. Ayew does work and was doing what was always asked of him but just having an off day.

Agree, doesn't matter where Eze is played or where you think he he should be played, if he is selected to play he should do a darn site better than he did today.
Our whole game is based on teamwork, organisation and working hard and keeping mistakes to a minimum. We were under the cosh as we usually are against a top team playing at the top of their game, we didn't need Eze to gift them their first goal before we could adjust or settle down.
He is gifted and talented but still very much work in progress.

 

A89M Flag Streatham 11 Apr 21 6.55am

Did I miss something? Eze was LM and Ayew RM, where they've been playing all season. Chelsea pressed from the front resulting in the two receiving the ball in defensive positions but they were definitely not CDMs.

If Roy had played 3 CDMs at home and lost, he'd be blamed for not having a go at home. He can't win.

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Apr 21 7.07am

Originally posted by A89M

Did I miss something? Eze was LM and Ayew RM, where they've been playing all season. Chelsea pressed from the front resulting in the two receiving the ball in defensive positions but they were definitely not CDMs.

If Roy had played 3 CDMs at home and lost, he'd be blamed for not having a go at home. He can't win.

You are absolutely correct. We have fans saying that that was a defensive set up. Zaha Benteke Ayew Eze is far from defensive.

The problem with this game is that Roy should have actually played a defensive set up and played Schlupp and Townsend to protect our full backs.

Anytime we play Riedewald and Luka in midfield we may as well play 2 subbuteo men in there.

 

EddieMac Flag 11 Apr 21 7.11am

Originally posted by MKCPFC

Agree, doesn't matter where Eze is played or where you think he he should be played, if he is selected to play he should do a darn site better than he did today.
Our whole game is based on teamwork, organisation and working hard and keeping mistakes to a minimum. We were under the cosh as we usually are against a top team playing at the top of their game, we didn't need Eze to gift them their first goal before we could adjust or settle down.
He is gifted and talented but still very much work in progress.

Eze made a bad mistake but he will learn from it. He has done that exact same manoeuvre on the edge of his own box all season and got us out of many tricky situations with the ball. If he kicking it into row Z every time he would get slaughtered, he tries to keep the ball he gets slaughtered. The chap just can’t win.

Smashing football talent and we are blessed to have him.

 

Putitout Flag Oxford 11 Apr 21 9.49am


We can pick on individuals, and do. But the bottom line is our mid-field is just not good enough when pressed in the way it was. And that was going to apply no matter who we put out there. Even with changes in the second half we could have shipped several goals. It’s really not a matter of playing anyone out of position. You are either a top class mid-fielder or you are not, if the opposition set you a problem you solve it, The team yesterday was unchanged , and was set up to contain , but get at Chelsea, when the opportunity arose .
None of it mattered because the bottom line was no matter the line up we were not anywhere near good enough. And not for the first time in these circumstances.
I think if you listen to Hodgsons comments prior and after the game
he is only to well aware things have never been totally satisfactory regarding the ability of this squad, and that the situation is becoming worse. His comments seem to be those of a very nice man , trying to say ,they ain’t,t F—-ing good enough.

 

Elphers40 Flag Sunny South Coast 11 Apr 21 9.50am

Originally posted by CPFCwetrust

Whats the point in getting players in if they aren't played braunston?

I mean Zaha is a winger playing as a forward when Bats and Mateta are on the bench, eze is an attacking midfielder playing cdm with Mccarthy bench warming, Kouyate is a cdm playing in defence with Dann and Kelly about, Schlupp is bench warming when he is creating chances more often than not.

My opinion is cpfc can buy players but the manager needs to play them and in the right positions or even play them...
Mateta won't be excited about joining now..I have no doubt.

Really good post. Very difficult NOT to accept the validity of the points made.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 11 Apr 21 12.50pm

So starting a game with the intention of not losing is a mistake in your book?

You would prefer us to start with the mindset of losing is ok.

What facts don't lie? I don't see any facts in your post, opinions yes, facts nah.

Or, do you mean that your opinions are actually facts?

All a bit confusing

Originally posted by steven_t92

For the last 2 years Roy has continuously started games with players in the wrong position or with the mindset to not lose the game. After this long in the PL we shouldn't be doing that, we were past that long ago but are going backwards with that mentality. Facts don't lie...

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 11 Apr 21 12.55pm

Originally posted by HKOwen

So starting a game with the intention of not losing is a mistake in your book?

You would prefer us to start with the mindset of losing is ok.

What facts don't lie? I don't see any facts in your post, opinions yes, facts nah.

Or, do you mean that your opinions are actually facts?

All a bit confusing

If ever there was a post that highlighted the ridiculous notion of one extreme or the other.

 


COYP

CT GUY-BIGBALD EAGLE Flag bloomfield 11 Apr 21 11.14pm

Originally posted by MKCPFC

You are 100% correct and one of the few one here that seem to understand being a Palace supporter.

Guess to you doing a fantastic job is how he has managed to change the name of our Club to Crystal Pinata Football Club. Take away the luck component and your Roy being still in the job is just privilege. You guys talk of him not having spend options. B.S. When he was England Manager he could cherry pick from the league, only to be humbled by little Iceland. $hit this same Chelsea against newly promoted WBA last week turned tail.

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 11 Apr 21 11.41pm

[Link]

Ouch!!!! For me, this is why you keep Roy. We only invested around 16m when we made a 5m profit last year. To think we are going big in the summer is delusional,

I don’t think we will spend a lot in the summer. It will take 2-3 seasons to get out of this mess and unfortunately stying in the league, regardless of performances is 100% priority.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 12 Apr 21 10.22am

Originally posted by Ali_Campbell

[Link]

Ouch!!!! For me, this is why you keep Roy. We only invested around 16m when we made a 5m profit last year. To think we are going big in the summer is delusional,

I don’t think we will spend a lot in the summer. It will take 2-3 seasons to get out of this mess and unfortunately stying in the league, regardless of performances is 100% priority.


My feelings also as I've said on several threads. There won't be a big clear out this summer. I think it will be a case of
1) hard bargaining to significantly lower the wage bill with those the club wish to keep.
2) one (or possibly two) fairly cheap purchases
3) more loan players in, possibly with one having a buy option.
4) If Hodgson wants another year (at reduced salary) he might well be given it.

I'm NOT saying this is what I want - rather it's what I expect is most likely. I may well be wrong, of course. Time will tell.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 12 Apr 21 10.49am

Originally posted by Putitout


We can pick on individuals, and do. But the bottom line is our mid-field is just not good enough when pressed in the way it was. And that was going to apply no matter who we put out there. Even with changes in the second half we could have shipped several goals. It’s really not a matter of playing anyone out of position. You are either a top class mid-fielder or you are not, if the opposition set you a problem you solve it, The team yesterday was unchanged , and was set up to contain , but get at Chelsea, when the opportunity arose .
None of it mattered because the bottom line was no matter the line up we were not anywhere near good enough. And not for the first time in these circumstances.
I think if you listen to Hodgsons comments prior and after the game
he is only to well aware things have never been totally satisfactory regarding the ability of this squad, and that the situation is becoming worse. His comments seem to be those of a very nice man , trying to say ,they ain’t,t F—-ing good enough.

Agree with this only I think the problem when we're pressed is as much about the lack of craft and youth in our defence as well. Every time we play a side that is youthful and energetic the opposing manager has identified our deficiencies and killed the game early but Saturday was the hardest watch of the season IMO. At one point I honestly thought they might get ten.

Roy is quite old fashioned in that he doesn't change things much if we've had decent run as we had going into the Chelsea game. I think Luka and Riedewald are immobile and the latter particularly poor out of possession. We also don't have the benefit of Roy's most trusted in MacArthur who at 33 is still quicker around the pitch than both.

I think people are too hung up on formations although my preference would be 433 and I would use Townsend or Schlupp in a 442 rather than Ayew. Roy rightly received praise early in the season for getting more out of Zaha in a 442 after being shackled in a 433 last season.

Ongoing I think the club are putting themselves in a corner. Whatever peoples' opinion is of Freedman he hasn't been given much to spend and SP appears to control everything. I would doubt the likes of Dyche would be as gentlemanly in the media about the status quo.

The fact that the club are looking elsewhere wont have been lost on Roy and if he were offered another year I don't think it's certain he would accept it.


 

palace99 Flag New Mills 16 Apr 21 1.26pm

Originally posted by A89M

Did I miss something? Eze was LM and Ayew RM, where they've been playing all season. Chelsea pressed from the front resulting in the two receiving the ball in defensive positions but they were definitely not CDMs.

If Roy had played 3 CDMs at home and lost, he'd be blamed for not having a go at home. He can't win.

Do you think we 'had a go' last week?

In the 1st half we just sat back and let Chelski have the ball. Formation is irrelevant sometimes.
They played away in Europe only on Wednesday and would not have liked it if we started with a high intensity

 

Ali_Campbell Flag New Addington 16 Apr 21 2.52pm

I think when you concede two goals in 10 minutes against a top side, you strategy or game plan will be more conservative. We kept going against liverpool and conceded 7. If we had got through that first 25 minutes, the game would have been different.

I agree, the midfield is not good enough. The defence is too old and lacks pace which means we go into games very wary and defensive. We have a lost a 50m right back and replaced him with Joal Ward. Liverpool have lost a 80m cb and look at their problems.

I’ve said before, I think given the tools could play better football. I just think the pressure on staying in the league and finishing as high as possible given the clubs finances outways performances.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 16 Apr 21 3.08pm

Originally posted by palace99

Do you think we 'had a go' last week?

In the 1st half we just sat back and let Chelski have the ball. Formation is irrelevant sometimes.
They played away in Europe only on Wednesday and would not have liked it if we started with a high intensity

Difficult to '' have a go '' when you have just gifted the opposition 2 goals in the opening 10 minutes.

At least we regained some self respect with an improved second half.

The point about them playing in Europe in midweek becomes somewhat irrelevant when you look at the players they had on the bench.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Keep Roy