You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How Important Is Our New Academy to Our Future?
November 16 2026 4.12am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How Important Is Our New Academy to Our Future?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
Wilbraham413 Flag 04 Oct 21 12.02am

Can anyone educate me as to how our new academy works in terms of which young players do we have the advantage of signing? From what I understand, we should have an advantage signing young players in the South London area. Is this true? And now that we have a top level academy, it makes it more likely that we can retain local talent?

I'm hoping that our new academy gives us a pipeline of good young players that other mid-tier clubs won't have. Like I would imagine South London would have a constant stream of good young talent. That makes me think that even if we have a terrible year, and get relegated, we should be able to rebound quickly.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

deleted 25 Flag 04 Oct 21 7.38pm

The more established or successful a team is probably equates to less chance for young players to break through though injuries can throw an opportunity ; if we did get relegated then arguably the academy becomes more important, if the club is run sensibly

Chelsea seem to have the run of the best talent in South London so it’s good to offer competition. Being a level 1 - should make it easier to keep academy players

 

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 05 Oct 21 4.07pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Can anyone educate me as to how our new academy works in terms of which young players do we have the advantage of signing? From what I understand, we should have an advantage signing young players in the South London area. Is this true? And now that we have a top level academy, it makes it more likely that we can retain local talent?

I'm hoping that our new academy gives us a pipeline of good young players that other mid-tier clubs won't have. Like I would imagine South London would have a constant stream of good young talent. That makes me think that even if we have a terrible year, and get relegated, we should be able to rebound quickly.

Right on all counts Wilbraham.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 05 Oct 21 4.47pm

Academy 1 makes it easier to sign players and means that you can easily poach players from non Academy 1 clubs and makes it harder to have out own best academy players poached from other clubs. I don't agree with the EPPP but now it is there, we need to use it to our own advantage. It's vital for a London club as there are already 5 other Academy 1 clubs in London.

It's expensive so it's surprising so many non PL clubs are on the list; Arsenal, Aston Villa, Birmingham City, Blackburn, Burnley, Brighton, Chelsea, Crystal Palace, Derby County, Everton, Fulham, Leeds United, Leicester City, Liverpool, Newcastle United, Manchester City, Manchester United, Middlesbrough, Norwich City, Nottingham Forest, Reading, Southampton, Stoke City, Sunderland, Tottenham, West Brom, West Ham and Wolves.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

croydon proud Flag Any european country i fancy! 05 Oct 21 4.49pm

Originally posted by topcat

Academy 1 makes it easier to sign players and means that you can easily poach players from non Academy 1 clubs and makes it harder to have out own best academy players poached from other clubs. I don't agree with the EPPP but now it is there, we need to use it to our own advantage. It's vital for a London club as there are already 5 other Academy 1 clubs in London.

It's expensive so it's surprising so many non PL clubs are on the list; Arsenal, Aston Villa, Birmingham City, Blackburn, Burnley, Brighton, Chelsea, Crystal Palace, Derby County, Everton, Fulham, Leeds United, Leicester City, Liverpool, Newcastle United, Manchester City, Manchester United, Middlesbrough, Norwich City, Nottingham Forest, Reading, Southampton, Stoke City, Sunderland, Tottenham, West Brom, West Ham and Wolves.

Not long until the top 6 introduce the "super academy "then- to make the rest less lucrative- and attractive.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 05 Oct 21 4.58pm

In theory yes.

In practice, only time will tell.

So many players seam to move around the academies (Eze as an example) before finding a home.

Brentford have done away with their academy.... will be interesting to see if that's a better model in the long term

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 05 Oct 21 5.29pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Can anyone educate me as to how our new academy works in terms of which young players do we have the advantage of signing? From what I understand, we should have an advantage signing young players in the South London area. Is this true? And now that we have a top level academy, it makes it more likely that we can retain local talent?

I'm hoping that our new academy gives us a pipeline of good young players that other mid-tier clubs won't have. Like I would imagine South London would have a constant stream of good young talent. That makes me think that even if we have a terrible year, and get relegated, we should be able to rebound quickly.

Man U poached one of our Academy scouts - I hope they won't nick too many local players. [Link]

 


Red and Blue Army!

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 05 Oct 21 7.22pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Man U poached one of our Academy scouts - I hope they won't nick too many local players. [Link]

Indeed!

Jarrett seemed to be the main man in terms of our youth recruitment and it was well publicised that he was pivotal in the recruitment of so many of the current U18 squad, which has been phenomenally successful.

By poaching Jarrett, Man Utd clearly intend on cornering the South London market in terms of up and coming talent.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 05 Oct 21 7.33pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Indeed!

Jarrett seemed to be the main man in terms of our youth recruitment and it was well publicised that he was pivotal in the recruitment of so many of the current U18 squad, which has been phenomenally successful.

By poaching Jarrett, Man Utd clearly intend on cornering the South London market in terms of up and coming talent.

Players aged 13-16 have to live within 90 minutes travelling time of their club - bet they’re keen on HS2.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 05 Oct 21 8.53pm

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle

Players aged 13-16 have to live within 90 minutes travelling time of their club - bet they’re keen on HS2.

That is interesting to know Teddy, I wasn’t aware of that.

Clearly though United know exactly what they are doing by poaching Jarrett from us. The reports at the time of his appointment for United all commented on how influential and successful Jarrett had been with our recruitment of our current U18 squad.

Just reading some of the reports again it seems Jarrett had been with Palace for about ten years and was either Head of Academy recruitment or Assistant Head (dependent on which report you read) he was also the co-founder and director of football for Lambeth Tigers. Clearly hugely connected in London and the South and no doubt why United have appointed him as their lead scout for the ‘South of England’.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 06 Oct 21 2.16am

Very.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 06 Oct 21 8.55am

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

That is interesting to know Teddy, I wasn’t aware of that.

Clearly though United know exactly what they are doing by poaching Jarrett from us. The reports at the time of his appointment for United all commented on how influential and successful Jarrett had been with our recruitment of our current U18 squad.

Just reading some of the reports again it seems Jarrett had been with Palace for about ten years and was either Head of Academy recruitment or Assistant Head (dependent on which report you read) he was also the co-founder and director of football for Lambeth Tigers. Clearly hugely connected in London and the South and no doubt why United have appointed him as their lead scout for the ‘South of England’.


This is all highly irritating.

Hopefully effective plans in response are afoot.

London isn't the domain of fecking Man U......fecking Beckham should have been a Spurs player.

Edited by Stirlingsays (06 Oct 2021 8.56am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 06 Oct 21 10.21am

Academies purpose changes depending on where you are in The Footballing chain.

football League Clubs often rely on them to get in cheap talent for their first teams.

the higher echelon of premier league clubs; the ones that get the majority Of the TV/European coffers also seem to use them to get talent in their first team squads. They can afford to sign a higher number of these players, so they can skim off only the best players. They also have the benefit of Stronger Squads that can 'carry' the odd young developing player without too much reduction in quality, and are involved in so many competitions that they can play these prospects without too much risk, while giving them vital playing time.

For the rest of the Premier League clubs, the advantage is twofold;
1) the Main aim is to is to get in Talent, either by buying from other academies, or signing young, and developing them so they can be sold for profit, creating a decent revenue stream.
2)When their hand is forced(ie. injuries) they should have a greater standard of replacement available.

There is always the chance that a few of these prospects will be naturally good enough to get into the first team, but the Stakes Are higher.
Relegation is a massive danger, so playing these players is a Risk, often one that clubs are not prepared to take. Without that extenuating circumstance, many of the players will find it hard to get gametime.

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Oct 21 10.25am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Can anyone educate me as to how our new academy works in terms of which young players do we have the advantage of signing? From what I understand, we should have an advantage signing young players in the South London area. Is this true? And now that we have a top level academy, it makes it more likely that we can retain local talent?

I'm hoping that our new academy gives us a pipeline of good young players that other mid-tier clubs won't have. Like I would imagine South London would have a constant stream of good young talent. That makes me think that even if we have a terrible year, and get relegated, we should be able to rebound quickly.

The Academy is highly important to the clubs future.

To compete for the best talent both locally and from outside South London, the club needed to invest heavily to ensure we have facilities and an infrastructure that will make that talent consider Palace as somewhere they would want to be.

There are no guarantees that this will lead to a conveyor belt of youngsters feeding into the First Team, but it does give the club and the players the best possible platform to succeed.

Already we are seeing the U23's and U18's thriving, and I am sure the enhanced facilities we now have are having a positive effect on their performances.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Oct 21 10.47am

Coming back to Brentford, I do think it’s a fascinating experiment.

For anyone that doesn’t know, they folded their academy as the ROI wasn’t there for them. They still have reserve teams, but are not developing kids from a young age.

When you look at the U23s how many have we nurtured from kids, vs shipping in from other Academies?

But if you look at the guys that are ‘closest’ to the first team, there are a lot that were transferred straight in at U18s or U23 level, namely:

Rak-Saki – Came from Chelsea
Banks – Dundee
Nya Kirby – Spurs
Obrien – Cork
Hannam – West Ham

So could we do away with anything U17 and just get some more scouts in?


Edited by MrRobbo (06 Oct 2021 10.50am)

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Oct 21 11.09am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Coming back to Brentford, I do think it’s a fascinating experiment.

For anyone that doesn’t know, they folded their academy as the ROI wasn’t there for them. They still have reserve teams, but are not developing kids from a young age.

When you look at the U23s how many have we nurtured from kids, vs shipping in from other Academies?

But if you look at the guys that are ‘closest’ to the first team, there are a lot that were transferred straight in at U18s or U23 level, namely:

Rak-Saki – Came from Chelsea
Banks – Dundee
Nya Kirby – Spurs
Obrien – Cork
Hannam – West Ham

So could we do away with anything U17 and just get some more scouts in?


Edited by MrRobbo (06 Oct 2021 10.50am)

First off, it's interesting what Brentford have done but is it sustainable ? It may not suit their current business model but at some point that may need to change.

Their reserve ( B ) team don't appear to be playing against quality opposition on a regular basis so I'm unclear as to how that helps with player development.

As for our own Academy, the investment made is starting to pay dividends in as much as we can attract players from other clubs academies as well as giving us a better chance with local talent.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 06 Oct 21 11.33am

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Coming back to Brentford, I do think it’s a fascinating experiment.

For anyone that doesn’t know, they folded their academy as the ROI wasn’t there for them. They still have reserve teams, but are not developing kids from a young age.

When you look at the U23s how many have we nurtured from kids, vs shipping in from other Academies?

But if you look at the guys that are ‘closest’ to the first team, there are a lot that were transferred straight in at U18s or U23 level, namely:

Rak-Saki – Came from Chelsea
Banks – Dundee
Nya Kirby – Spurs
Obrien – Cork
Hannam – West Ham

So could we do away with anything U17 and just get some more scouts in?


Edited by MrRobbo (06 Oct 2021 10.50am)

No doubt youth recruitment is important, but all of our most successful graduates are from within:

Moses, Zaha, Clyne, AWB - behind that you've got your Routledge and Watson types.

 

MrRobbo Flag Chaldon 06 Oct 21 11.36am

Only time will tell if its sustainable, but there are a lot of positive things happening at Brentford. As well as on pitch, they seem to excel in other areas e.g. scouting.

I guess my point was about the usefulness about anything below the U18s when it seems that you can just ship in a load of talent at 18 to fill the reserve teams. So, is that money spent on the 8-17 year olds better off spent on youth scouts?!

Not sure I believe it is, but an interesting debate, especially considering how many of our up and coming players were ‘poached’.

But that all being said. Wan-Bisakka came though and made us a tonne of profit, and Mitchell came to us after Brentford folded their academy.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 06 Oct 21 11.58am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

Can anyone educate me as to how our new academy works in terms of which young players do we have the advantage of signing? From what I understand, we should have an advantage signing young players in the South London area. Is this true? And now that we have a top level academy, it makes it more likely that we can retain local talent?

I'm hoping that our new academy gives us a pipeline of good young players that other mid-tier clubs won't have. Like I would imagine South London would have a constant stream of good young talent. That makes me think that even if we have a terrible year, and get relegated, we should be able to rebound quickly.


Thanks for starting this thread Wilbraham. Some varied and interesting views which show just how complex the question is.

 

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 06 Oct 21 12.05pm

Originally posted by MrRobbo

Only time will tell if its sustainable, but there are a lot of positive things happening at Brentford. As well as on pitch, they seem to excel in other areas e.g. scouting.

I guess my point was about the usefulness about anything below the U18s when it seems that you can just ship in a load of talent at 18 to fill the reserve teams. So, is that money spent on the 8-17 year olds better off spent on youth scouts?!

Not sure I believe it is, but an interesting debate, especially considering how many of our up and coming players were ‘poached’.

But that all being said. Wan-Bisakka came though and made us a tonne of profit, and Mitchell came to us after Brentford folded their academy.

Just my view, but the ' real money ' is spent at a higher level than the 8-17 age groups. But the improved Academy gives those age groups something tangible to aim for as opposed to the rough and ready facilities the club has had in the past.

As for spending more money on youth scouts, well I can only speak from experience but I was only paid expenses when I was one ( not for Palace, I might add ). At the lower age groups I've seen kids go to several clubs without making it for one reason or another, it's a real ' churn ' at those levels, and indeed further up the age scales...where you have the Rak-Sakyis and Hannans of this world.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How Important Is Our New Academy to Our Future?