This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
He has been in the job 5 minutes -there is so much good news to see in what he has done / remains as trying to do - For me - he is doing well & like most of us going through life , every day is a school day. If you go to Man City, Liverpool, Chelsea supporters boards after every game you will see peoples opinions on who should have started, who should have come off the bench etc etc - & yet those 3 teams have just about the most experienced managers available. Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Before i start i am not advocating his dismissal, Pluses, He can attract players that other Managers cant, and he has instant respect from his players Minuses, He is very raw to the Job, and in my opinion has made a lot of selection and Substitution errors Discuss
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Before i start i am not advocating his dismissal, Pluses, He can attract players that other Managers cant, and he has instant respect from his players Minuses, He is very raw to the Job, and in my opinion has made a lot of selection and Substitution errors Discuss Why do you keep starting bellend threads ?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Before i start i am not advocating his dismissal, Pluses, He can attract players that other Managers cant, and he has instant respect from his players Minuses, He is very raw to the Job, and in my opinion has made a lot of selection and Substitution errors Discuss I can't believe I'm actually going to respond to this with hopefully a logical and well argued response given your tendencies to be selective in your responses but here goes anyway. I'll pick just one area that you raise : substitutions. Earlier in the season at Arsenal when leading 2-1 with less than 10 minutes to go Vieira brought on Tomkins for Edouard and we went to a back 5 to try to protect our lead. I think this was a mistake because we lost any attacking intent and ability to relieve pressure. Result - we draw 2-2. Last night when leading with less than 10 minutes to go Vieira takes off Olise and replaces him with Benteke, even though he had already replaced Edouard with Mateta essentially leaving us with two strikers and one of those playing out of position on the right (Mateta). I think he did this for 2 reasons: 1. Benteke is good at defending set pieces and corners and would hopefully help against the height of the Brighton centre backs if they push forward in attacking situations. 2. He remembered the Arsenal game and the fact he invited pressure by making too defensive a substitution and Benteke would hopefully help to hold the ball up and relieve pressure. (now we can argue how effective that would be but please don't just pick on this point and ignore the rest of this response - I know you love to do that). In hindsight (which is great but totally useless) he got both decisions wrong. IMHO at Arsenal he should have brought on another midfielder to help deny space in and around the box and last night he should have brought on Clyne and played 5 at the back with Clyne providing extra cover to Ward who had a really bad game. On another day and with a bit of luck both decisions would have worked and we'd be saying how inspired his substitutions were. But they didn't. At least last night he tried something different to simply throwing on another defender (like at Arsenal) and hoping for the best. Edited by Skinnii (15 Jan 2022 11.02am)
"The object of war is not to die for your country but to make some other b*stard die for theirs" - General Patton |
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
Why do you keep starting bellend threads ? T**t
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn |
|
|
Originally posted by Swindy
He is doing a good job. He has not had a full pre-season or full summer transfer window. Our play is far more entertaining & there are goals in this team. We have picked up points in games this season which would have been lost last season. There have been few games which we have not been in. Which ones, in your opinion? Man City is perhaps an obvious one, but which others?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
Why do you keep starting bellend threads ? I reckon starting threads is positive.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Swindy
He is doing a good job. He has not had a full pre-season or full summer transfer window. Our play is far more entertaining & there are goals in this team. We have picked up points in games this season which would have been lost last season. There have been few games which we have not been in. We must of lost points that we gained last season, as our points total after 20 games this season is exactly the same as last season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Lanzo-Ad
Before i start i am not advocating his dismissal, Pluses, He can attract players that other Managers cant, and he has instant respect from his players Minuses, He is very raw to the Job, and in my opinion has made a lot of selection and Substitution errors Discuss Whatever shortcomings result from the supposed minuses are more than compensated for by the pluses. He has my 100% confidence and support.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
Whatever shortcomings result from the supposed minuses are more than compensated for by the pluses. He has my 100% confidence and support. Agreed. New managers are bound to make mistakes as they learn about the players and what they can and can't do. A bad manager is one who doesn't understand that he made a mistake and keeps doing it. So far I have not seen that from PV so as long as he doesn't repeat those errors he has my support.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by babylonjohn
Why do you keep starting bellend threads ? Good question
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
I feel as though I expect more from Vieira and that we should be winning every game but perhaps that’s unrealistic. Taking on an ageing Hodgson team (not a dig btw) with comparatively limited funds in the premier league I feared it was a poisoned chalice. PV has managed to take that team, which has quite consistently threatened a relegation battle over the seasons, and managed to instil a relatively less anxious feeling in this fan whilst producing a more ambitious style of football (in my opinion). For me he’s far exceeded my initial expectations and looks set to guarantee PL football for next season and all whilst still managing a transition I’ve heard many a fan cry out for. The only negative of course is that he may well be poached by a ‘bigger’ team but if not, and he does stay, the future once again just for this fan, does seem a lot brighter than years past. COYP 🔴🔵🦅 Entirely agree. What’s the option? A rubbish manager who no one wants? This is the reality of football - if a “smaller” club have a 20 a season striker we can be in with a good shout of taking him away but by the same token “bigger” clubs can just take whoever they want from us. How do we resolve the problem? No idea. Leicester have had great success but they’ll have a problem in trying to sign a player who has the option of going to Liverpool, Man U, City, Chelsea etc.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.