You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Olise, luck or skill?
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Olise, luck or skill?


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
Painter Flag Croydon 22 Mar 22 1.05pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

I believe it was intentional for this reason. A few minutes earlier Olise hit a similar shot from the same place, and with what looked like the same technique. That went wrong, so finding himself in that position in the penalty box a second time tried it again. This time the goal attempt nearly worked.

That's of course just an opinion, but it may explain why MO turned his back in annoyance/disappointment/whatever - it didn't go in. I suppose he should have been happy that it eventually did become a goal. That may show a little lack of team spirit, but hopefully that will grow as he matures.

Fat Frank has said it was a fluke and all our goals were lucky. He could of been our manager and wouldn’t of allowed that sort of play.

 

regpaddock Flag Suffolk 22 Mar 22 1.08pm

Slimey toad is on to something. If he's a leg spinner it must have hit him in the googlies. That explains it.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Mar 22 2.57pm

This is one of the most bizarre threads ever - how on earth can anyone think that was deliberate?

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Mar 22 3.00pm

Originally posted by regpaddock

Watch the Roehampton extended 9 minute highlights on youtube. That's the only replay that shows both identical Olise attempts. In each case his standing leg is in the same position and his left foot seems to collide with it. It wasn't a fluke and it wasn't an accident. The first attempt was a sighter and the second was spot on. It was brilliant.

So you can't mis-hit the ball twice in the same game?

His standing leg is in the same position because that's how you kick a football ffs - where else is it going to be?

 

regpaddock Flag Suffolk 22 Mar 22 3.32pm

Why is it bizarre? The kick fooled the entire Everton defense, everyone in the ground, the tv camera crew and everyone watching at home. The only person it didn't fool was Wilf who was aware of what might happen and was prepared. If Messi had done that there'd be bunting strewn all over Thornton Heath clock tower and all the way up the high street. We're not 4th division any more, we have class players and such players do incredible things.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Mar 22 4.22pm

Originally posted by regpaddock

Why is it bizarre? The kick fooled the entire Everton defense, everyone in the ground, the tv camera crew and everyone watching at home. The only person it didn't fool was Wilf who was aware of what might happen and was prepared. If Messi had done that there'd be bunting strewn all over Thornton Heath clock tower and all the way up the high street. We're not 4th division any more, we have class players and such players do incredible things.

I mean bizarre is the polite word.

It fooled the entire defence , everyone in the ground and the camera crews because it was an accident, obviously.

If Messi had done that, everyone would still be calling it a fluke, because it so clearly was.

 

regpaddock Flag Suffolk 22 Mar 22 4.53pm

Dear boy I think you're confusing 'intent' with 'outcome'. It might well have been a mis-cue, although many people on this site would disagree with you, but the original point centred around whether he meant to do it as part of a tactic, something that happens in training and is considered worthwhile. Of vourse it looked clumsy, eccentric things always do.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 22 Mar 22 4.56pm

Originally posted by regpaddock

Much has been said about our third goal against Everton. It's been described as lucky because Michael Olise mis-hit his shot and it rebounded off the post. This followed an earlier, similar, attempt and which to me looked somewhat like a top-spin lob in tennis which dips violently and stays in court. So was it luck or skill? I'm sure he knew exactly what he was doing. This boy looks incredible to me.

The two shots were in the same area, similar angle... I believe he has been practising that specific routine in training. The first flopped big time, the second was on target.

 


This was once a quality forum....

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 22 Mar 22 5.44pm

Originally posted by regpaddock

Dear boy I think you're confusing 'intent' with 'outcome'. It might well have been a mis-cue, although many people on this site would disagree with you, but the original point centred around whether he meant to do it as part of a tactic, something that happens in training and is considered worthwhile. Of vourse it looked clumsy, eccentric things always do.

The outcome is irrelevant in terms of whether he meant to slice the ball like that - intent is all that matters. In fact, if the outcome had been the ball spinning wide of the post, no one would dream of pretending he had meant to strike it that way. It's only because the outcome was a goal that such a silly point could be made.

If it was a mis-cue that ended up working out, it is by definition a fluke and you are disagreeing with yourself, dear boy.

The line about eccentric things always looking clumsy is like something David Brent would say.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 22 Mar 22 6.21pm

Pickford was on the 6-yard line. It could have been an attempted lob of it could have been an attempted curler. Olise clearly wasn't trying to hit the post but he was aiming to put the ball just inside the post, out of Pickford's reach.
Could say that all goals scored after the ball has hit a post are flukes, for me Olise tried something special that nearly came off.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 22 Mar 22 6.45pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This is one of the most bizarre threads ever - how on earth can anyone think that was deliberate?

I do. I think it was bizarre, but he tried the same thing a few minutes earlier, and I rolled my eyes both times because it looked far from the best option.

How often it will work is another question, but I bet we will see it again.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

regpaddock Flag Suffolk 22 Mar 22 7.11pm

So without wishing to make this exchange my life's work and within the parameters of banter and light-hearted fun, my point about eccentric things looking strange is entirely right. Half the balls Shane Warne bowled he invented, the slider, flipper etc., and no one thought the doosra was physically possible to deliver legitimately until Shaqlain Mushtaq did it.
Many, though nor all, seem unable to believe that topspin can be applied to a football in this way. Maybe it can't but why be so po-faced and certain when all any of us are doing is trying to control our excitememt at stuffing Everton 4 nil?

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 22 Mar 22 7.16pm

I think we would all like to think he meant it. I suspect in reality he didn't.

Only person who truly knows is him. I hope he gets asked in an interview sometime and he gives an honest answer.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 22 Mar 22 7.41pm

Originally posted by regpaddock

So without wishing to make this exchange my life's work and within the parameters of banter and light-hearted fun, my point about eccentric things looking strange is entirely right. Half the balls Shane Warne bowled he invented, the slider, flipper etc., and no one thought the doosra was physically possible to deliver legitimately until Shaqlain Mushtaq did it.
Many, though nor all, seem unable to believe that topspin can be applied to a football in this way. Maybe it can't but why be so po-faced and certain when all any of us are doing is trying to control our excitememt at stuffing Everton 4 nil?

If anyone is that interested there are YouTube tutorials on how to put topspin on the ball.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 22 Mar 22 8.37pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

This is one of the most bizarre threads ever - how on earth can anyone think that was deliberate?

I know, my flabber is truly ghasted!

 

regpaddock Flag Suffolk 22 Mar 22 9.01pm

Well Phil, if your flabber is that ghasted, what would it be if we were discussing something that actually mattered? Lighten up and smell the coffee.

 

Glazier#1 Flag 22 Mar 22 9.29pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I know, my flabber is truly ghasted!

Deliberate.Skill beyond measure.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 22 Mar 22 9.42pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

I know, my flabber is truly ghasted!

haha

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 23 Mar 22 5.58am

I agree with Reg Paddick. It's not a bizarre thread, it's mostly just light hearted banter (garnished with some questionable opinions) on a remarkable kick of the ball by a very remarkable player.

A bizarre thread would be the case for a flat earth or one which includes advocates of Putin's war.

Hang on, we have one of them. Head along to News and Politics.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 23 Mar 22 6.24am

I look forward to the day when Olise teases the ball between ground and boot in such a manner that the ball initially flies forward but then spins back, bamboozling the oncoming keeper. Imagine, for example, a Spitfire doing a loop the loop...

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Olise, luck or skill?