You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle v Crystal Palace match thread
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle v Crystal Palace match thread


Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >
samprior Flag Hamburg 20 Apr 22 10.05pm

Originally posted by gerry theagle

Hughes is injured.

He was on the bench though.

Games like this evening makes me come round to the idea of 5 substitutions. Would have been great to bring on Hughes and Eze to further push to get back in the game. I guess we'll see it next season.

 

cardiff eagle Flag 20 Apr 22 10.07pm

Originally posted by Petts Wood Eagle

Well that's another 90 minutes of my life I can't get back.

Keeper.

Distribution is woeful.

Defence.

Back, side, side, back, hoof, back, side side back, hoof. rinse and repeat.

Midfield.

Slow, Slow, Slower than slow.

Forwards.

Stealing a living.


Sadly accurate.

Add in vieira making bizarre defensive subs too week in week out even when losing

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Apr 22 10.12pm

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

So frustrating to go from 9th place ahead of an FA Cup semi-final, to being knocked out, and now we're down to 14th. We could easily finish 16th this year, which would be an utter sh-t result to end the season.

We never show up in the first half of matches, it's like we have to wait to get yelled at at half-time. We pass back relentlessly, even under little pressure. McArthur did more work in 30 minutes than everyone else combined for 90.

We "controlled" the last 20 minutes today, but even then we couldn't get one shot on target. I have no idea what the problem is with the mentality of our players, but something needs to change next year. Bring in someone who puts in a shift.

Newcastle are allowed to defend and do it very well, but they were also allowed by the officials to take the piss by constantly stopping us with niggly fouls and much too much rolling around faking injury and the amount of non fouls awarded against us became an issue as the game came to an end. Zaha had our best attempt that could've very easily gone in with their keeper wrong footed.

 

joe_cpfc Flag Basingstoke 20 Apr 22 10.13pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Deserved a draw with an excellent second half, the ball just didn't fall for us but having said that Newcastle did defend very very well, nothing wrong with losing to a team that hustled us to death during the first half with a very well taken goal, our second half performance just highlights to me that we have a very promising future, do not understand all the crap being written on here tonight.

Disagree. I don't think they defended well at all. They sat back and just let us do absolutely nothing upfront, it looked clueless.
Their keeper had 2 powder puff shots to save all game.
I wouldn't say they hustled us in the 1st half either, they totally outplayed us mainly due to a dire midfield pairing which to be fair hasn't done that badly up until this game but for whatever reason looked non existent tonight.
Im not saying it's our God given right to win these games and a draw would have been a good result and a win would have been great but it was absolutely 5hit.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 20 Apr 22 10.19pm

Zaha should have scored. Ayew made the wrong decision 99% of the time. Our midfield has no creativity. A good goal scored against us. The usual Palace story really.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 20 Apr 22 10.19pm

I've not watched either the Leicester or tonight's game as I can't be arsed poncing about with streams.

But I don't see the poor performances as a surprise under the circumstances either side of a cup semi-final.

Newcastle are on a roll at home, have spent a few quid and our away form hasn't been great.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 20 Apr 22 10.21pm

Originally posted by cardiff eagle

Sadly accurate.

Add in vieira making bizarre defensive subs too week in week out even when losing

He took off a midfielder and put on a striker, how is that defensive. We went 4-4-2 having had no influence on the game with our standard 4-3-3. That required the replacement of Gallagher (who was having a quiet game), with Mateta and McArthur to add a bit more thrust in midfield. It worked very well and were we not so toothless in front of goal we would have got something out of the game.

I haven’t always liked his decisions but today they were good substitutions.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 20 Apr 22 10.22pm

Havent seen the game tonight so havn't a clue what happened . The predictable were s***e comments after a defeat dont tell me a lot so I had a look at the Newcastle forum

'Targett MotM by a mile ' (left back )
'Vieria made some clever tactical changes '
'If Palace had started like they finnished we wouldn't have won that '
'Brilliant defending , we look so organised '
'Thank your god Zaha missed that '
' Fair play to Palace ,I thought we were going to run out easy winners at HT '
ect ect

Sounds as if we did all right without doing enough . Take a deep breath its been a tough week .

Leeds on Monday will tell us how the tail end of the season is going to go ......COYP !

 

taylors lovechild Flag 20 Apr 22 10.36pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Havent seen the game tonight so havn't a clue what happened . The predictable were s***e comments after a defeat dont tell me a lot so I had a look at the Newcastle forum

'Targett MotM by a mile ' (left back )
'Vieria made some clever tactical changes '
'If Palace had started like they finnished we wouldn't have won that '
'Brilliant defending , we look so organised '
'Thank your god Zaha missed that '
' Fair play to Palace ,I thought we were going to run out easy winners at HT '
ect ect

Sounds as if we did all right without doing enough . Take a deep breath its been a tough week .

Leeds on Monday will tell us how the tail end of the season is going to go ......COYP !

They were being kind. We struggled to live with their aggression and were lucky to only be a goal down after an hour. Once again we spent so much time passing around at the back even when losing. Vieira made the right call on the hour and we probably should have equalised.

Their idol Bruno did a dive at one point that made Havertz look honest. They also kicked Zaha all game and really should have had at least a couple more bookings. I thought Wilf kept a cool head given the ref was doing sod all.

The team who wanted it more won on the day. My memory of the game will be the silly little Saudi owner waving his giant Newcastle flag and then getting trapped under it.

 

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 20 Apr 22 10.38pm

Bad performance after a bad week, probably heart of hearts expected it ,
Pessimist in me is very worried we in trouble next season (even this season) however head tries to tell me don’t be stupid ? My head is right? …… right?

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Apr 22 10.41pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

He took off a midfielder and put on a striker, how is that defensive. We went 4-4-2 having had no influence on the game with our standard 4-3-3. That required the replacement of Gallagher (who was having a quiet game), with Mateta and McArthur to add a bit more thrust in midfield. It worked very well and were we not so toothless in front of goal we would have got something out of the game.

I haven’t always liked his decisions but today they were good substitutions.

Yes, he corrected the situation that Newcastle had put onto us very well tonight.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 20 Apr 22 10.46pm

Originally posted by SwordFish

Bad performance after a bad week, probably heart of hearts expected it ,
Pessimist in me is very worried we in trouble next season (even this season) however head tries to tell me don’t be stupid ? My head is right? …… right?

Actually we had an excellent first half against Chelsea and an excellent second half tonight, so yes you're being extremely stupid.

 

SwordFish Flag Peasmarsh,East Sussex 20 Apr 22 10.52pm

Erm calm down tickling pink! We were not excellent I first half against Chelsea we was a team on back foot trying to create something which never happened and tonight was shocking ,


Edited by SwordFish (20 Apr 2022 10.56pm)

 


“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Apr 22 10.52pm

Very predictable result, I predicted a narrow defeat and I am often well wide of the mark.
Still,deeply disappointing, indeed my dear wife mentioned that my face was shouting "Misery Misery". I told her in no uncertain terms to pipe down.

 

palace chick Flag South Croydon 20 Apr 22 10.53pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Havent seen the game tonight so havn't a clue what happened . The predictable were s***e comments after a defeat dont tell me a lot so I had a look at the Newcastle forum

'Targett MotM by a mile ' (left back )
'Vieria made some clever tactical changes '
'If Palace had started like they finnished we wouldn't have won that '
'Brilliant defending , we look so organised '
'Thank your god Zaha missed that '
' Fair play to Palace ,I thought we were going to run out easy winners at HT '
ect ect

Sounds as if we did all right without doing enough . Take a deep breath its been a tough week .

Leeds on Monday will tell us how the tail end of the season is going to go ......COYP !

That’s a fair enough summary from Newcastle fans from that second half. It really was that final ball and perhaps to slow in the build up allowing Newcastle to get players behind the ball. Don’t like our combinations in midfield. I always feel we don’t play the best midfield players alongside each other and then take of one or two of them bringing on someone like Macca who would benefit still having them on the pitch. The substitutions never seem to make us a better team at present. On Sunday we brought on more forward players leaving one midfield type player on the pitch. And then when I thought Luka was coming on for one of those forwards he took of Kouyate. For me having Gallagher, Kouyate and Macca together or even Hughes or Schlupp gives more balance and these players can get into the box as well as making crucial passes to create chances. All we end up with when we bring to many forwards on is our back four hitting long balls which are easily dealt with. Both Chelsea and Newcastle were there for the taking in the last two matches and we blew it with strange formations and substitutions in my opinion :-( Let’s hope we get back to winning ways next Monday?

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Apr 22 11.02pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Zaha should have scored. Ayew made the wrong decision 99% of the time. Our midfield has no creativity. A good goal scored against us. The usual Palace story really.

I would not be unhappy to see Ayew shown the door.He offers nothing at all.
McArthur has been a great servant but he is 34 and in the twilight of his career.
Most certainly, we need more creativity from our midfield next season and attacking full-backs would introduce a different dimension to our play.

Edited by Willo (20 Apr 2022 11.03pm)

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 20 Apr 22 11.24pm

If the midfield unable to provide then forwards (whoever they are) will not score.

It has been like this ever since we got in the Premier League.

To mention a few of a very poor bunch:
Kouyate - big and strong but can't pass other than sideways
Schlupp - adds nothing to our attack, passes to marked colleague unfailingly
Ayew - no end product
Edoard/Mateta - no skill for either
Mitchell - weaknesses exposed

Until we get a midfield general we won't go forward

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 20 Apr 22 11.56pm

As someone mentioned to me tonight, in Hodgson's last 3 seasons, after 32 games, we had amassed 10 wins twice and 11 wins once, currently after 32 games we have only won 8 games.

Edited by Willo (20 Apr 2022 11.57pm)

 

CT Charlie Flag 21 Apr 22 1.13am

A lot of alarmist thinking here. We had a letdown game, where we lost 45 minutes because PV wanted to see more of Edouard and Schlupp when it might have been better to see more of Mateta and take a longer look at Hughes. But Newcastle were aggressive today, and we were subconsciously hoping they'd feel easy after Chelsea.

We're no better or worse than we were during our no-loss streak. We're just a bit tired because we lack mental & physical stamina due to inexperience (the youngsters) and age (the veterans). We can still easily finish in the top half of the table if we make it a priority and believe in ourselves.

 

radicalsteve Flag ottawa 21 Apr 22 3.08am

In all honesty, this was never going to be an easy game, based on their home form recently, and if we came away with a point, that would have been acceptable. However.... we were completely disjointed. I lost count of the times we passed in reverse instead of going forward, unable to creat space, can't release the ball quickly, because the forwards are not running into space fast enough. Anyways, no point in being an armchair coach. From what I see, not enough quality in midfield, neither of our wingbacks confident enough on the break .... but our centre backs showed that they can be reliable, dependable and the core of the defense next year. One of our biggest issues is that Wilf gets fouled in rotation, referees dont give the cards (3 strikes and then you are out), Wilf get pissed and then it all goes downhill from there as it infects the whole team. And yes, Ayew is so much not up to standard - I understand that Olise was hooked because he refused to close down Saint-Maximin as per PV's instructions, so he deserved to be subbed, but Ayew is no Olise .... by a long shot.

Will be interesting to se if PV starts to plan ahead now and bring in some younger talent - surely Scott Banks can be more impactful than Jeff Schlupp, he is a waaay more skillful player, notwithstanding he does not have the experience in the big leagues ... but maybe now is the time to give these guys some experience before next season.

Edited by radicalsteve (21 Apr 2022 3.15am)

Edited by radicalsteve (21 Apr 2022 3.16am)

Edited by radicalsteve (21 Apr 2022 3.21am)

 

Page 5 of 8 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle v Crystal Palace match thread