You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Proper goodby for Roy on Sat
November 16 2026 3.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Proper goodby for Roy on Sat


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
deleted 25 Flag 01 May 22 1.03pm

Think we didnt get a chance to say bye to Roy with lockdown so will be able to do so Sat unless he gets sacked next week!

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 01 May 22 1.06pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Think we didnt get a chance to say bye to Roy with lockdown so will be able to do so Sat unless he gets sacked next week!

Good point. We can give him a decent send off and also say “goodbye” to Watford.

 

Palace Old Geezer Flag Midhurst 01 May 22 1.32pm

I think he'll secretly enjoy a thumping Palace win and will feel suitably humbled by a lively Selhurst 'adios and good luck'.

 


Dad and I watched games standing on the muddy slope of the Holmesdale Road end. He cheered and I rattled.

southnorwoodhill Flag 01 May 22 2.30pm

Every Palace player to get on the scoresheet, that should do the trick.

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 01 May 22 5.06pm

Originally posted by Palace Old Geezer

I think he'll secretly enjoy a thumping Palace win and will feel suitably humbled by a lively Selhurst 'adios and good luck'.

Probably be a lot of our fans hoping that happens if it means Hodgson goes - seems to still be uncertain either way but surely he won't stick around.

Never really won the support of our fans compared to Ranieri - don't if that is down to his personality or just because Roy managed you guys.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 01 May 22 5.28pm

Originally posted by Superhorns3

Probably be a lot of our fans hoping that happens if it means Hodgson goes - seems to still be uncertain either way but surely he won't stick around.

Never really won the support of our fans compared to Ranieri - don't if that is down to his personality or just because Roy managed you guys.

Didn’t know we were rivals Why get rid of Ranieri then? No disrespect to you Superhorns but your club needs a complete overhaul from top to bottom.
A loud rendering of “ his one of our own” should get the atmosphere going

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 May 22 5.40pm

Think you’ll find a few in the Palace squad will be bang up for this and see Roy off with a royal hammering - Wilf for one - get the impression there’s not much love lost in that relationship..!!

IMHO - Roy has an undeserved reputation of being a decent Manager - he is in fact a Manager with very limited in formations and style of play..!!

He proved that with both England and Palace..!!

Noticed yesterday when Watford’s fete of relegation confirmed - Ray Lew did the MOTD interview - Roy nowhere to be seen..!!

If memory serves me correct didn’t he do exactly the same thing after the Iceland debacle - resigned and tried to avoid doing any press interview on the basis he had resigned..!!

He also did the same for us in a game where we got hammered - can’t recall which one specifically.

Roy’s record at Watford is even worse than his predecessor Ranieri and Watford have gone down without a whimper.

There’s an argument that says that we under performed under Roy given the resources he had it his disposal due to his unwavering commitment to “Roy ball”..!,

Look I’m not saying don’t give him a great send off - he obviously deserves that - but I just think there a lot of “rose colored Roy glasses” about just how good he actually was..!!

I for one am so happy we now have Vieira and give Watford a royal hammering on Saturday.

COYP

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 01 May 22 6.02pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Think you’ll find a few in the Palace squad will be bang up for this and see Roy off with a royal hammering - Wilf for one - get the impression there’s not much love lost in that relationship..!!

IMHO - Roy has an undeserved reputation of being a decent Manager - he is in fact a Manager with very limited in formations and style of play..!!

He proved that with both England and Palace..!!

Noticed yesterday when Watford’s fete of relegation confirmed - Ray Lew did the MOTD interview - Roy nowhere to be seen..!!

If memory serves me correct didn’t he do exactly the same thing after the Iceland debacle - resigned and tried to avoid doing any press interview on the basis he had resigned..!!

He also did the same for us in a game where we got hammered - can’t recall which one specifically.

Roy’s record at Watford is even worse than his predecessor Ranieri and Watford have gone down without a whimper.

There’s an argument that says that we under performed under Roy given the resources he had it his disposal due to his unwavering commitment to “Roy ball”..!,

Look I’m not saying don’t give him a great send off - he obviously deserves that - but I just think there a lot of “rose colored Roy glasses” about just how good he actually was..!!

I for one am so happy we now have Vieira and give Watford a royal hammering on Saturday.

COYP

Don't you just hate people who sit on the fence . . .

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 01 May 22 6.13pm

Originally posted by Spiderman

Didn’t know we were rivals Why get rid of Ranieri then? No disrespect to you Superhorns but your club needs a complete overhaul from top to bottom.
A loud rendering of “ his one of our own” should get the atmosphere going

Well only in the week leading up to the games I think - bit like when we play Bournemouth.

Pretend to really dislike each other for a bit.

I think any of our fans would agree with you there on the needing an overhaul comment.

A couple of seasons too many of changing managers and bringing in random players hoping they'd be a success but turn out not to be.

It's all got a bit complacent really and we haven't improved the team from when we went down last time but given out lots of contracts to older players.


"!Noticed yesterday when Watford’s fete of relegation confirmed - Ray Lew did the MOTD interview - Roy nowhere to be seen.."

TBF Roy was ill in the week and hadn't spoken to the media Pre match either.

Not that it would make much difference as our fans don't take kindly to what he says most of the time.

In fairness to Hodgson the away form bar one or two games hasn't been bad but there aren't 20k fans at those games whereas we've lost every home game since he came in and in many different ways!


As I said elsewhere most of the fingers are pointed at the board really - maybe the reason we've had 2 guy in their 70s as manager is because no-one with any great long term ambition wants the job for example as they'd get no time or spied on like hawks all the time?

I do think most of the players have tried generally but just not been good enough or the ones with more quality like Sarr been injured or out of form.

Edited by Superhorns3 (01 May 2022 6.28pm)

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 01 May 22 6.31pm

Originally posted by eagleman13

Don't you just hate people who sit on the fence . . .

LOL- deserved that..!!

COYP

 

mtp1958 Flag Oswestry 01 May 22 6.48pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

Think you’ll find a few in the Palace squad will be bang up for this and see Roy off with a royal hammering - Wilf for one - get the impression there’s not much love lost in that relationship..!!

IMHO - Roy has an undeserved reputation of being a decent Manager - he is in fact a Manager with very limited in formations and style of play..!!

He proved that with both England and Palace..!!

Noticed yesterday when Watford’s fete of relegation confirmed - Ray Lew did the MOTD interview - Roy nowhere to be seen..!!

If memory serves me correct didn’t he do exactly the same thing after the Iceland debacle - resigned and tried to avoid doing any press interview on the basis he had resigned..!!

He also did the same for us in a game where we got hammered - can’t recall which one specifically.

Roy’s record at Watford is even worse than his predecessor Ranieri and Watford have gone down without a whimper.

There’s an argument that says that we under performed under Roy given the resources he had it his disposal due to his unwavering commitment to “Roy ball”..!,

Look I’m not saying don’t give him a great send off - he obviously deserves that - but I just think there a lot of “rose colored Roy glasses” about just how good he actually was..!!

I for one am so happy we now have Vieira and give Watford a royal hammering on Saturday.

COYP

Think your being a little harsh his record not bad check wiki have seen alot worse . he kept us safe it was to late to turn watford round

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 01 May 22 7.03pm

My impression was that Roy managed the relationship between Zaha and the club really well despite the former's clear desire to leave.

 

deleted 25 Flag 01 May 22 8.04pm

It's a bit like Jason Donovan and Kylie going back to Neighbours for the last episode where it all started

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 01 May 22 8.42pm

Roy did well for us and put us on a stable footing but he was to set in his ways to take us to another level, but I wish him well

 

CT Charlie Flag 01 May 22 11.25pm

I really like Roy and I really like Vieira. Their approaches are different, but so are the players in their squad. PV's approach wouldn't have worked with the players Roy managed, and Roy's approach, well, it's hard to say how it would work with the current group.

Gallagher, Olise, an experienced Mitchell, Mateta, Guehi, Andersen, and... Clyne & Eze in the mix... Apples and oranges.

Roy deserves our respect on Saturday.

 

davidmyboy Flag 01 May 22 11.59pm

Roy deserves Respect we were never a Man City or Real Madrid , he kept us in the Prem for years, not pretty but with an older squad we survived, now have a great chance to move forward. Just be thankful and appreciate what he did as at the time we were in the SH1*. Many thanks Roy. Hope he learns and and enjoys how to retire. I did and have, never want to work again there are better ways to waste your life. But if you need to enjoy.

 

YT Flag Oxford 02 May 22 7.43am

Don't volunteer to write the banner!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

Nubes Flag London 02 May 22 7.46am

There’ are a lot of palace who fail to recognise the plan and bigger picture of our stay in the prem.

This has been done to death especially at the end of last season.

Roy, enabled and allowed us to be where we are today. He is absolutely key to the fact that this season we could build on our successes of maintaining prem status with players who know the league, know the little nuances of how to survive and innately are at the level as a team who would finish mid-table.

He kept us in the prem, safe pair of hands, didn’t need to spend a whole lot of money whilst Parish the club management could develop our infrastructure.

The club had a clear plan, to run down contracts and bring in a younger manager to deliver upon the clubs ‘Vision’ for the future of lowering the average age of the squad.

Roy’s ball wasn’t pretty but it was necessary for our development. (It’s like saving for a deposit for a house - for a period of years - you can’t go out and spend or splash the cash as you did previously, in essence for a period of time you become boring as it is a needs must if you want that deposit for your future)

Roy should get our respect he fulfilled his brief of keeping us afloat and is a significant part of our recent history, appreciate what he did for us and try not to compare to Viera as they have different briefs.

I will salute Roy and clap him and enjoy the game. He laid the foundations after a period of instability with chop and change and on-going firefighting with management.

Viera essentially is a better attempt at what we tried to achieve with FDB!

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 02 May 22 8.04am

Originally posted by YT

Don't volunteer to write the banner!

He deserves a good send off, not only did he keep us afloat, he also did a great job in taking Watford down

 

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 02 May 22 8.30am

Originally posted by Nubes

There’ are a lot of palace who fail to recognise the plan and bigger picture of our stay in the prem.

This has been done to death especially at the end of last season.

Roy, enabled and allowed us to be where we are today. He is absolutely key to the fact that this season we could build on our successes of maintaining prem status with players who know the league, know the little nuances of how to survive and innately are at the level as a team who would finish mid-table.

He kept us in the prem, safe pair of hands, didn’t need to spend a whole lot of money whilst Parish the club management could develop our infrastructure.

The club had a clear plan, to run down contracts and bring in a younger manager to deliver upon the clubs ‘Vision’ for the future of lowering the average age of the squad.

Roy’s ball wasn’t pretty but it was necessary for our development. (It’s like saving for a deposit for a house - for a period of years - you can’t go out and spend or splash the cash as you did previously, in essence for a period of time you become boring as it is a needs must if you want that deposit for your future)

Roy should get our respect he fulfilled his brief of keeping us afloat and is a significant part of our recent history, appreciate what he did for us and try not to compare to Viera as they have different briefs.

I will salute Roy and clap him and enjoy the game. He laid the foundations after a period of instability with chop and change and on-going firefighting with management.

Viera essentially is a better attempt at what we tried to achieve with FDB!

Good post, that's exactly how I see it (and I suspect most Palace fans will feel the same).

 

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Proper goodby for Roy on Sat