This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by pax3908
If that head butt had occured in the local night club or pub,there would have been all sorts of reaction along the lines of the culprit being arrested and charged etc etc,why is it then acceptable to deal with this offence by internal discipline when it is clearly an offence that should be dealt with by the police,what kind of example does it give to population if there is one rule for footballers and everyone else is treated differently,it is about time this was dealt with by criminal prosecution route!! If plod think it merits outside intervention then it will happen I’m sure. Duncan Ferguson went down for an on field offence I think. Now with the abuse on insta etc it could roll into a criminal investigation. He’s out today giving all the apologies so that tells me a brief has been involved at some point.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
The last thing we need is outside intervention in sporting arena . Football is an adrenalin fueled sport that controls itself and should stay that way .
Agree. There have been numerous punches thrown in Rubgy etc. and I am wondering if they have ever been investigated by law enforcement? Not to my knowledge? Equally, very easy for me to say this, but if a player nutted me like that on the pitch I'd reserve all right to try and break is jaw and argue my case that it was 'self defence' and merits if not the same punishment as said player then less.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
The last thing we need is outside intervention in sporting arena . Football is an adrenalin fueled sport that controls itself and should stay that way .
IMO It's views like this that keep us in the dark ages. Nutting someone is never an in-house problem. It is assault and should be treated as such or will never be eradicated. Edited by gloryhunter (17 Aug 2022 8.44am)
gloryhunter (eagle in exile) |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Agree. There have been numerous punches thrown in Rubgy etc. and I am wondering if they have ever been investigated by law enforcement? Not to my knowledge? Equally, very easy for me to say this, but if a player nutted me like that on the pitch I'd reserve all right to try and break is jaw and argue my case that it was 'self defence' and merits if not the same punishment as said player then less. There would be much case law in your favour, whereby someone who has been assaulted has justifiably thumped the assailant on the grounds that they expected the assault to continue. It's even been established that you can thump someone if you believe they are about to assault you. Edited by YT (17 Aug 2022 8.52am)
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
|
Originally posted by Elpis
The last thing we need is outside intervention in sporting arena . Football is an adrenalin fueled sport that controls itself and should stay that way .
My dear chap if you can't see the correlation between the two acts of violence,that is precisely why we have that type of violence in society today !!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Frickin Saweet
we have headbutts in society because occasionally a footballer does it? I think we have headbutts in society because it's often the shortest route to physical attack when people are in close proximity in a heated exchange. Up the ban/punishment yes, but getting the police involved is ridiculous. Might as well make the sport non-contact or kill it off altogether and be done with it. We nearly did that under Roy
|
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Agree. There have been numerous punches thrown in Rubgy etc. and I am wondering if they have ever been investigated by law enforcement? Not to my knowledge? Equally, very easy for me to say this, but if a player nutted me like that on the pitch I'd reserve all right to try and break is jaw and argue my case that it was 'self defence' and merits if not the same punishment as said player then less. I know of a case where the son of someone I knew in Hong Kong was jailed for an attack on the rugby field in the UK. Many cases in UK of rugby players jailed for attacks on opponents
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I know of a case where the son of someone I knew in Hong Kong was jailed for an attack on the rugby field in the UK. Many cases in UK of rugby players jailed for attacks on opponents Interesting! Honestly never heard of any! Was that professional HKO or Amateur?
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle
Did anyone else notice what provoked Anderson into pushing him? I thought Nunez had tried to headbutt him in the previous tussle, but missed, and this angered Anderson. If I am right, then I suspect his suspension may be quite a long one as it wasn't simply a reaction to a push, but part of a pattern. Yep, think that has been well documented WE. I suspect Andersen was doing nothing out of the ordinary by giving Nunez a tough time and using a bit of physicality and that Nunez's first attempts of sticking his head in Andersen's face was the initial reaction which provoked Andersen to (rightly) remonstrate somewhat and shove Nunez's outstretched arm which in turn led to 'the' headbutt. Again, as has been mentioned by many, I am sure this has not gone unnoted by many a PL defender as an expose of Nunez's fragility and inability to handle a bit of 'rough-housing' and his 'red card' mishandling of the situation.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
Agree. There have been numerous punches thrown in Rubgy etc. and I am wondering if they have ever been investigated by law enforcement? Not to my knowledge? Equally, very easy for me to say this, but if a player nutted me like that on the pitch I'd reserve all right to try and break is jaw and argue my case that it was 'self defence' and merits if not the same punishment as said player then less. It's a tricky area. If a fast bowler hits a batsman, sorry batter, with a bouncer is he then entitled to go and clout the bowler with his bat in retaliation?
|
|
|
Originally posted by Teddy Eagle
It's a tricky area. If a fast bowler hits a batsman, sorry batter, with a bouncer is he then entitled to go and clout the bowler with his bat in retaliation? No would be my answer. That is part of that particular sport. There is a difference between 'a bit of rough treatment' and an assault. Tackles in football can actually be a lot worse, there's been many a broken ankle, leg etc. I'd argue a very strong 'ball and man' tackle is part of the sport and therefore not punishable however a Roy Keane-esque attempt to purely just hurt someone could very well be framed as an assault. Although the law may not work that way I think most sensible thinking people could differentiate the difference between foul play and assault. A bowler may well throw an aggressive bouncer but equally off a more easily played ball a batsperson ( -.-' ) may well be able to smash a ball straight back at a bowler's cannister. Downing tools to throw hands would arguably be less dangerous for either but crosses a boundary. Agree on tricky area but I think common sense would prevail although I acknowledge we are living in a post-common sense society.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!! |
|
|
Originally posted by Nicholas91
No would be my answer. That is part of that particular sport. There is a difference between 'a bit of rough treatment' and an assault. Tackles in football can actually be a lot worse, there's been many a broken ankle, leg etc. I'd argue a very strong 'ball and man' tackle is part of the sport and therefore not punishable however a Roy Keane-esque attempt to purely just hurt someone could very well be framed as an assault. Although the law may not work that way I think most sensible thinking people could differentiate the difference between foul play and assault. A bowler may well throw an aggressive bouncer but equally off a more easily played ball a batsperson ( -.-' ) may well be able to smash a ball straight back at a bowler's cannister. Downing tools to throw hands would arguably be less dangerous for either but crosses a boundary. Agree on tricky area but I think common sense would prevail although I acknowledge we are living in a post-common sense society. Yes, you're right.
|
|
|
Originally posted by pax3908
If that head butt had occured in the local night club or pub,there would have been all sorts of reaction along the lines of the culprit being arrested and charged etc etc,why is it then acceptable to deal with this offence by internal discipline when it is clearly an offence that should be dealt with by the police,what kind of example does it give to population if there is one rule for footballers and everyone else is treated differently,it is about time this was dealt with by criminal prosecution route!! Not sure if you have seen the video on twitter, but Anderson was all over him the whole time, pushing, pulling, using the dark arts, almost Latin in his approach to defending, Nuñez could say he was provoked. Imagine if someone pushed and barged you for 50 minutes. brilliant defending from Anderson though
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.