You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle vs Crystal Palace Carabao Match Thread
November 16 2026 3.18am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Newcastle vs Crystal Palace Carabao Match Thread


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Nov 22 10.50am

Originally posted by madcap_v2

I absolutely hate how this cup is treated/perceived.
We should be looking to win, always. It's a chance for silverware, to get to Wembley (Europe?).

If teams can't take it seriously, they might as well do away with it. Do we need two domestic cups?

I’m sure we had chances to score in the game but didn’t. Pens is a lottery.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 10 Nov 22 10.52am

Originally posted by YT

Yes, a win against Forest, who beat Spurs last night. Who better than us to bring them back down to Earth?

West Ham hadn’t lost since august and we played them off the park. Forest away will be 3 points all day long. I’m having a bet so will put it where it is

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 10 Nov 22 11.11am

This Cup has been largely a vehicle for Manchester City to add another cup in their cabinet.

Clubs tend to field weaker sides for this competition. In City's case they can field their reserve 11 who would probably get into the top six in the EPL.

 

TheFish Flag 10 Nov 22 11.41am

Geordie here,

I'd snap your arm off for a League Cup. We've not won a major domestic trophy since man landed on the moon.

Wasn't surprised to see us both field much changed sides and although we did try to win it in 90minutes with our substitutions I think a 0-0 was a fair result. Pens are a crapshoot and Botman taking one was surprising, Bruno looking to put one into space was even more of a shock. Either way, delighted to get past a tricky fixture and on into the next round. Just gotta hope we avoid Man City entirely, or catch them putting out a weaker side due to CL commitments.

Re: the noise levels, it always ends up being quieter in Cup games because so many there are kids, families or whatever, fewer of the usual League crowd. Also, the game wasn't exactly one to get you up out of yours eats, was it?

Hope everyone who made it up had a good time regardless of the match/result.

 

madcap_v2 Flag SE25 / Ibiza 10 Nov 22 11.49am

Originally posted by cryrst

I’m sure we had chances to score in the game but didn’t. Pens is a lottery.

I was referring to our starting XI. We should field our strongest team always in competitive matches

 


La la la your mum

Dubai Eagle Flag 10 Nov 22 11.58am

This is a competition that really needs looking at / maybe even a complete revamp - in line with modern circumstances -
PL funding & TV income for those broadcast is at record high -
European competition's dominate additional funding -
The PL top 6 have so many second string players that could walk into most other teams starting 11 -

In yesteryear there was always the chance that a club from the lower reaches could reach the final & win it, this possibility seems to have diminished to become virtually impossible.

Possible changes - Teams that qualify for Europe dont get to play in this domestic competion - OR make participation voluntary -
Or withdraw winning the competition as a way into Europe - or PL teams excluded.

All kind of radical suggestions (& there are probably plenty of other suggestions out there) can anyone say that the current format of this domestic cup competition fulfils its relevance to the modern day situation.

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

This Cup has been largely a vehicle for Manchester City to add another cup in their cabinet.

Clubs tend to field weaker sides for this competition. In City's case they can field their reserve 11 who would probably get into the top six in the EPL.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 10 Nov 22 12.01pm

Originally posted by madcap_v2

I was referring to our starting XI. We should field our strongest team always in competitive matches

And risked having a weakened side v Forest ? No thanks

Edited by babylonjohn (10 Nov 2022 12.01pm)

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 10 Nov 22 12.04pm

Also - according to google - Winners of the Caribou cup receive £100,000 + runners up £50,000 - hardly significant sums in relation to PL earnings, so surely its time to make the competition entry format fit the prize money -

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 10 Nov 22 12.04pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

This is a competition that really needs looking at / maybe even a complete revamp - in line with modern circumstances -
PL funding & TV income for those broadcast is at record high -
European competition's dominate additional funding -
The PL top 6 have so many second string players that could walk into most other teams starting 11 -

In yesteryear there was always the chance that a club from the lower reaches could reach the final & win it, this possibility seems to have diminished to become virtually impossible.

Possible changes - Teams that qualify for Europe dont get to play in this domestic competion - OR make participation voluntary -
Or withdraw winning the competition as a way into Europe - or PL teams excluded.

All kind of radical suggestions (& there are probably plenty of other suggestions out there) can anyone say that the current format of this domestic cup competition fulfils its relevance to the modern day situation.

The top six have been asking for this or variations on it, or maybe they would prefer a by to the semi finals.

The problem is that TV would not be interested if the big boys withdrew so I am not sure what the answer is.

I agree with your thrust that too many clubs fail to take it seriously until the later stages just don't know what the solution is without devaluing the competition.

If the money is in European competition I can see them withdrawing at some stage but the cup will suffer.

 


One more point

Dubai Eagle Flag 10 Nov 22 12.14pm

Here's another really challenging suggestion - Once a player participates in a European cup tournament in the same season (either starting 11 or comes on as a substitute) he is deemed to be Cup tied & illegible for domestic cup competitions - lol

 

taylors lovechild Flag 10 Nov 22 12.28pm

In the last decade Man City have won this cup six times, Liverpool twice, Man Utd once, and Swansea won it back in 2013.

Smaller clubs say it's their best chance of a trophy but in last five years only Saints have made the final. In fact, the FA Cup has seen more "smaller" teams make the final, with Leicester even winning it in 2020-2021.

The big issue is that Man City's second XI is better than most team's first XI, so they can just throw it on the pile with their other trophies. Meanwhile the likes of Liverpool often stumble through the early rounds with youth and then bring out the big guns when it matters. The whole thing is a bit of a joke when a club our size leaves out some of its best players for a competitive game. Let's face it, if we really serious about winning then we wouldn't have left Zaha and Eze at home.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 10 Nov 22 12.39pm

Originally posted by madcap_v2

I absolutely hate how this cup is treated/perceived.
We should be looking to win, always. It's a chance for silverware, to get to Wembley (Europe?).

If teams can't take it seriously, they might as well do away with it. Do we need two domestic cups?


It's a competition that IMO is well past its sell-by date. We only really need one major cup. Yes, teams played more games years ago BUT at nowhere near the intensity at which football is played today in the PL.

I'd rather have 3 points from Forest on Saturday than a place in the next round of the Carabao Cup. Each to their own, I suppose.


 

Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Nov 22 12.59pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Also - according to google - Winners of the Caribou cup receive £100,000 + runners up £50,000 - hardly significant sums in relation to PL earnings, so surely its time to make the competition entry format fit the prize money -

Thats the problem with it when you consider each place higher in the PL is worth £ 2.2 Million its a wonder any first team players are involved

Its a nothing cup thats only comes to life if you stumble into the semi finals and is not worth wasting time or resources on

Its generally cheating the fans the way clubs play weakened sides ,even lower league teams rest players for this shambles of a competition .
The format to fit the prize money would be for carabao to go sponser the girls , they need it more than we do

 

Uphill Flag Bedford 10 Nov 22 1.09pm

No greater indication of the downfall of Luka.

Another missed penalty, another yellow card. Pens and free kicks used to be his speciality but his appetite for cards is undiminished. His creativity and passing were always his weakest points.

Isn't it time he is dropped and Will Hughes (tidy against Newcastle) gets a run ?

 


Man and boy Palace since my first game in 1948 sitting on my dad's shoulders

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 10 Nov 22 2.05pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

This is a competition that really needs looking at / maybe even a complete revamp - in line with modern circumstances -
PL funding & TV income for those broadcast is at record high -
European competition's dominate additional funding -
The PL top 6 have so many second string players that could walk into most other teams starting 11 -

In yesteryear there was always the chance that a club from the lower reaches could reach the final & win it, this possibility seems to have diminished to become virtually impossible.

Possible changes - Teams that qualify for Europe dont get to play in this domestic competion - OR make participation voluntary -
Or withdraw winning the competition as a way into Europe - or PL teams excluded.

All kind of radical suggestions (& there are probably plenty of other suggestions out there) can anyone say that the current format of this domestic cup competition fulfils its relevance to the modern day situation.

I like it as it's a chance for silverware, but I agree it needs a revamp of sorts.

I would suggest a north/south split until the semi finals and I would remove the two legged semi final format - have always disagreed with this as it reduces the chance of a shock result.

Lastly, I'd award the winner a space in the Europa League ahead of the Conference League - which to be fair, is more of a punishment than it is a prize.

 

YT Flag Oxford 10 Nov 22 2.28pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

This is a competition that really needs looking at / maybe even a complete revamp - in line with modern circumstances -
PL funding & TV income for those broadcast is at record high -
European competition's dominate additional funding -
The PL top 6 have so many second string players that could walk into most other teams starting 11 -

In yesteryear there was always the chance that a club from the lower reaches could reach the final & win it, this possibility seems to have diminished to become virtually impossible.

Possible changes - Teams that qualify for Europe dont get to play in this domestic competion - OR make participation voluntary -
Or withdraw winning the competition as a way into Europe - or PL teams excluded.

All kind of radical suggestions (& there are probably plenty of other suggestions out there) can anyone say that the current format of this domestic cup competition fulfils its relevance to the modern day situation.

Participation IS voluntary.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Nov 22 4.12pm

Bah, from memory we exited fairly swiftly when Roy was in charge, and I see no difference in the list of priorities facing the club under Vieira. A totally debased competition, teams don't even bother to put out their strongest side, which says everything.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 10 Nov 22 4.35pm

If it is voluntary then that point doesn't show up on the Carabao cup competition website where it talks about clubs from the PL & EFL participating -

Perhaps you have seen it mentioned somewhere ?
Or know of clubs that have declined to participate ?


Originally posted by YT

Participation IS voluntary.

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Nov 22 8.59pm

Originally posted by Uphill

No greater indication of the downfall of Luka.

Another missed penalty, another yellow card. Pens and free kicks used to be his speciality but his appetite for cards is undiminished. His creativity and passing were always his weakest points.

Isn't it time he is dropped and Will Hughes (tidy against Newcastle) gets a run ?

Luka didnt miss the penalty ,the keeper made a decent save . He plays in a position ,protecting the defence ,where yellow cards are an unfortunate bi-product of doing the job . Look at any DM in the country and they will have yellow cards against their name . Its notable that he is cute enough never to get another one .

He is not the player he was but Id still take him over Hughes who is rightly another notch down the pecking order .

 

sprites Flag Auckland 10 Nov 22 9.25pm

Originally posted by Elpis

Luka didnt miss the penalty ,the keeper made a decent save . He plays in a position ,protecting the defence ,where yellow cards are an unfortunate bi-product of doing the job . Look at any DM in the country and they will have yellow cards against their name . Its notable that he is cute enough never to get another one .

He is not the player he was but Id still take him over Hughes who is rightly another notch down the pecking order .

What a sensible post from someone who clearly knows their football.

 

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Newcastle vs Crystal Palace Carabao Match Thread