You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Spurs match thread
November 16 2026 2.45am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Palace v Spurs match thread


Page 5 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
cardiff eagle Flag 27 Oct 23 11.43pm

Wow. To say that is so unacceptable. Especially when he’s silent on the “starters” who have been terrible for ages. Really poor management.

Also, for those moaning about mateta standing off their keeper, edouard did the same and it is 100% coaching. That was the game plan and to not change it at 2-0 down was pathetic. Only time we stopped doing it was at 2-1 with 4 mins left which was bizarre. Result not unexpected but second half performance again is on Roy. He’ll keep us up as we know but we will have to endure poor performances every time to any top six team with zero fight shown and then rely on scraping some 1-0’s against the dross. Fine if objective only to stay up but pretty soul destroying to watch.

 

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 27 Oct 23 11.47pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

Perhaps it is all getting to him or he doesn’t give a flying anymore as he came out of retirement in the first place?

I struggle to believe we didn’t even press them when 0-2 down without his instruction so that seems odd. I also cannot see how him blaming and shaming the young players publicly is conducive towards anything positive for us nor a fair stance to take.

If he wants to complain he should point the finger toward lack of attacking options and no replacement for AWB who left some time ago now surely? Two players out and we offer very little going forward, telling.


Not sure. Seems like he's lost the plot this evening though.

Blaming the young players is unforgivable IMO. Rak-Sak has been one of our better players in recent weeks. Franca playing his first minutes in English football after an injury. Ahamada has barely had a chance.

The thing about Roy is that despite the negative, boring football he's always had a bit of credit in the bank for being regarded as a gent. Tonight perhaps the mask has slipped a bit.

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

The Dolphin Flag 27 Oct 23 11.52pm

Unacceptable comment on the subs who I thought did okay.
Getting bored with Roy ball again and to think we likely have Gareth ball to come.
I love Palace but am genuinely not sure how much more dross I can stomach.
I would rather lose giving it a go to be honest and his treatment of Richards is unfathomable.
A lot 20 something who is fitter,faster, stronger and so on than Ward cannot get on the pitch?
Piss poor management and maybe time to move on after tonight.
This is not a pant wetting rant - to those that will say it is.
I want to be entertained as well as support us and see us strive to get better.
We are going backwards

 

eaglesdare Flag 27 Oct 23 11.54pm

Really has got to the point where going to games is a chore again...

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 27 Oct 23 11.54pm

My recall was that when we pressed them at 1-0 down they played through us and scored. Game over.

If we don't get the first goal against and opponent like that we're done.

To be fielding a side so lacking in attacking guile after ten years in the Premier League isn't great.

Edited by Rachid Rachid Rachid (27 Oct 2023 11.56pm)

 

Romford-Eagle Flag Romford 27 Oct 23 11.55pm

Time for Roy to move aside, the difference in quality was embarrassing, the flicks and the movement from Spurs made us look like a pub team, we even made Ayew look good, as for Ward, words fail me.

Time to get a young progressive manager in, and no not Mr Woke Southgate...

 

Hannes Flag Vienna 28 Oct 23 12.02am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace


Not sure. Seems like he's lost the plot this evening though.

Blaming the young players is unforgivable IMO. Rak-Sak has been one of our better players in recent weeks. Franca playing his first minutes in English football after an injury. Ahamada has barely had a chance.

The thing about Roy is that despite the negative, boring football he's always had a bit of credit in the bank for being regarded as a gent. Tonight perhaps the mask has slipped a bit.

Maybe he was just as dissapointed as some of us after a good performance in the first half, threw away his composure for a few minutes and said some words he already regrets. Not unforgiveable IMO, just human.

 

Palacesince64 Flag Edinburgh 28 Oct 23 12.06am

Originally posted by The Dolphin

Unacceptable comment on the subs who I thought did okay.
Getting bored with Roy ball again and to think we likely have Gareth ball to come.
I love Palace but am genuinely not sure how much more dross I can stomach.
I would rather lose giving it a go to be honest and his treatment of Richards is unfathomable.
A lot 20 something who is fitter,faster, stronger and so on than Ward cannot get on the pitch?
Piss poor management and maybe time to move on after tonight.
This is not a pant wetting rant - to those that will say it is.
I want to be entertained as well as support us and see us strive to get better.
We are going backwards

He did well after PV made a balls of it but his master stroke was playing Eze and Olise together. At the time I thought it was brilliant but we’re suffering the consequences this season. There are no surprises with Roy’s team selection so the opposition know exactly what to expect. The only surprises tonight were that he actually brought on a few subs albeit too late and that he was such a grumpy old git in his post match interviews. Seems like someone rattled his cage this evening but his rants were self indulgent and unhelpful. Hopefully this is his last season.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 28 Oct 23 12.12am

He's probably got the hump about the lack of backing in the summer and given the constant clamour from fans to play young players who've clearly not been good enough it's hardly surprising he's getting a bit pissed off.

That was a sh1t line up tonight for a team that's been in the league as long as us (and I'm sorry to say it) but Rak-Sakyi and and Franca were rubbish when they came on.

 

Oysterman Flag Coulsdon 28 Oct 23 12.13am

Feel quite low tonight first half we looked in it second half we went to pieces after own goal and Roy to say we looked worse with subs on seemed pointless thing to say
Getting grumpy in his senior years

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 Oct 23 12.39am

Originally posted by Oysterman

Feel quite low tonight first half we looked in it second half we went to pieces after own goal and Roy to say we looked worse with subs on seemed pointless thing to say
Getting grumpy in his senior years

A bit of Dejavu from spurs at home last season, but not quite as bad in the end.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 28 Oct 23 12.44am

It’s just so frustrating how we stopped having a go second half, sitting there watching them passing it across the back. Although still frustrating, because they were there for the taking after our first half performance, I can sort of understand it at 0-0, but once we were 0-2 and have nothing to lose we should be getting stuck in and try to off load them, Romero to the keeper, Keeper back to Romero, and repeat FFS

 

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 28 Oct 23 12.44am

Disgraceful comments

I think played ok

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Oct 23 12.48am

Agree with most of what’s been said.

Just to vent a bit, I very rarely if ever leave early however tonight I really did feel quite dismal about everything, that with a general knackeredness and desire to get home in any instance, had an awful drive there and long week anyway.

The players out there did look like a shoestring side doing their best to pass as a PL team. Seemed like a ‘cup XI’ in many ways. I think SJ, MG,JA,JL and CD is a solid spine but we looked weak at full back (thought I thought Mitchell played well so only on Ward’s side) and offered hardly anything going forward, masked slightly by Ayew’s typically dogged and industrious performance which makes those who weren’t effective look even worse.

Having Roy then (apparently) show little regard if not disdain for the post match interview and throw the youngsters under the bus is even more concerning.

A real toys out the pram rant for me would include the OG, the lack of players we have/brought in, the general quality of those making up the numbers and the dragging of Roy out of retirement to equally drag us through another non-event of a season, hopefully scraping by without getting relegated. I’m not really in the mood nor do I think the context is too dramatic: losses to Moneybags, highflying Newcastle and a top of the league Spurs, but the general feeling is a concerning one. We always pride ourselves and take faith in being a scrappy unit, from our less glamorous corner of the capital, often conjuring shocks and getting by whatever the weather, with a real flair player or two thrown in. Roy has been a figurehead of this. Tonight however it’s not so much the result, it’s the feeling of a management team perhaps not wanting to be there, a lack of identity in the squad and a weak performance more reminiscent of a newly promoted team than an established PL side, which is what we are.

That’s just a bit off my chest but I’ve not felt this unenthusiastic about Palace for some time, and it is that, not some hysterical, over-emotional whine.

My word we could do with a result against Burnley, I’m dreading to think what the story will be if we don’t.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Living In Hope Flag Petersfield 28 Oct 23 12.50am

First visit to Selhurst Park this season, and sadly my worst fears about how we would look without Eze and Olise were realised.

I am quite surprised about some of the comments on here. I thought we were, as expected with no flair players, a very limited team who worked incredibly hard to stifle a far superior opposition for a chunk of the game. Maybe those describing it as a good performance for quite a while were allowing for just how unbalanced our team is currently - I don't know but for me we were relegation material all the way, and Spurs would have never forgiven themselves if they had failed to win.

Even a Royball team needs someone who is comfortable on the ball further up the pitch, and the ability to break with pace and a bit of skill. The starting line-up just doesn't have that, much as they put in a massive effort.

I didn't hear Roy's interview, but if he did criticise the subs, that was out of order. He unbalanced the team the other way around when we had Rak-Sakyi, Franca and Ahamada on for Schlupp, Lerma and Hughes, and if I am not mistaken, the starting eleven were 2-0 down and we won 1-0 with the subs.

As pretty much every game I have seen since the pandemic, Andersen and Guehi were our best players, and absolute quality, but we have a big problem when Andersen is the most likely to create a goal. As for the subs, I thought Ahamada did quite well. I hope it was nerves affecting Franca, who was truly awful, with his short performance including a terrible misplaced pass, a corner floated straight out of play, and the dreadfully fluffed chance at the end.

So not a lot to cheer about - with this line-up we will do well to get anything even against the worst teams in the league, though with Eze and Olise back, we will be a completely different proposition.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Oct 23 1.00am

Originally posted by Living In Hope

First visit to Selhurst Park this season, and sadly my worst fears about how we would look without Eze and Olise were realised.

I am quite surprised about some of the comments on here. I thought we were, as expected with no flair players, a very limited team who worked incredibly hard to stifle a far superior opposition for a chunk of the game. Maybe those describing it as a good performance for quite a while were allowing for just how unbalanced our team is currently - I don't know but for me we were relegation material all the way, and Spurs would have never forgiven themselves if they had failed to win.

Even a Royball team needs someone who is comfortable on the ball further up the pitch, and the ability to break with pace and a bit of skill. The starting line-up just doesn't have that, much as they put in a massive effort.

I didn't hear Roy's interview, but if he did criticise the subs, that was out of order. He unbalanced the team the other way around when we had Rak-Sakyi, Franca and Ahamada on for Schlupp, Lerma and Hughes, and if I am not mistaken, the starting eleven were 2-0 down and we won 1-0 with the subs.

As pretty much every game I have seen since the pandemic, Andersen and Guehi were our best players, and absolute quality, but we have a big problem when Andersen is the most likely to create a goal. As for the subs, I thought Ahamada did quite well. I hope it was nerves affecting Franca, who was truly awful, with his short performance including a terrible misplaced pass, a corner floated straight out of play, and the dreadfully fluffed chance at the end.

So not a lot to cheer about - with this line-up we will do well to get anything even against the worst teams in the league, though with Eze and Olise back, we will be a completely different proposition.

Agree with most of that there. I didn’t stay long enough to watch much of Franca but it doesn’t sound great. Glad Ahamada played well, I’m quietly a big fan of his and want to see more of him.

It can actually be hard to identify whether we just don’t have the personnel (without Ebz and Olise) or whether it’s the often referenced ‘Royball’ or both.

I’m convinced Roy plays for the 0-0 against clubs expected to be in the top half, and that always opens the possibility for a win if we nab a goal. Tonight we actually had the better chances and completely suffocated them first half, we executed a good game plan IMHO. When that first goal was hammered home by Ward though it felt like an immediate ‘Game Over’, or maybe that’s just me.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

Living In Hope Flag Petersfield 28 Oct 23 1.17am

Pretty much agree with all you say Nicholas - we had a couple of chances in the first half and they didn't, but somehow the chances felt like luck rather than skill (though stopping them was a combination of tactical masterclass and fantastic effort). I also believe Roy's tactic against better teams (maybe not surprising without Eze and Olise) is to stay in the game at 0-0, and maybe, just maybe, we nick a goal.

Originally posted by Nicholas91 I had the same feeling when they went 1-0 up that we had no chance of scoring, but eventually score we did, and had a decent chance for 2-2. I will be delighted if we get a result against Burnley, but my head is telling me that we will get beaten. But if we do get Eze and Olise back soonish, I think we will avoid a relegation scrap.

Agree with most of that there. I didn’t stay long enough to watch much of Franca but it doesn’t sound great. Glad Ahamada played well, I’m quietly a big fan of his and want to see more of him.

It can actually be hard to identify whether we just don’t have the personnel (without Ebz and Olise) or whether it’s the often referenced ‘Royball’ or both.

I’m convinced Roy plays for the 0-0 against clubs expected to be in the top half, and that always opens the possibility for a win if we nab a goal. Tonight we actually had the better chances and completely suffocated them first half, we executed a good game plan IMHO. When that first goal was hammered home by Ward though it felt like an immediate ‘Game Over’, or maybe that’s just me.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 28 Oct 23 4.58am

A lot of emotional comments, understandable I guess. But let's face it, it's Groundhog Day again isn't it? With a couple of key creative players injured, the lack of quality and nous in the art of controlling the game in those areas necessary to score a goal becomes blatantly apparent.
It's been mentioned that Ward needs to be replaced, but the plate spinning circus act of player acquisition has somehow meant that he's still here, perhaps he has some super power we don't know a about - a bit of a mystery because he's become a bit of a liability.
Alas Mateta and Edouard would have fallen at the first hurdle if assessed by Brighton's scouting algorithm, I concede that finding a decent striker on the cheap is a very difficult thing.
Regarding Roy Hodgson, he is what he is, and at the beginning of the season I thought it likely that we would finish between 12th and 14th again. I did ask myself who comes in after him? Does Parish have a plan?
Groundhog Day.

Edited by southnorwoodhill (28 Oct 2023 5.49am)

 

CT Charlie Flag 28 Oct 23 5.25am

I feel like quite the contrarian.

1) Without Ebz and Olise, we earned 11 corners to 2 for Spurs.
2) We allowed the team at the top of the table, only 1 shot on target, while outshooting them 13 to 10.
3) We gave a handful of young, unproven attackers plenty of valuable, high-pressure minutes.
4) If you see Roy's comments about the young players IN CONTEXT, it doesn't sound hyper-critical. Overall, he sounded supportive and sympathetic to their situation.

If Roy is feeling peeved, it's because (like us fans) he wishes the club had shored up its defensive ranks this summer, and perhaps found some experienced depth in attack. Mostly, though, he's been dealt a harsh hand, missing our two most skilled players for a substantial part of the season to date.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 28 Oct 23 6.44am

At 0-0 we made Spurs look bang average and it took another Wardy mishap to put them in front. I thought Wardy looked like a Championship player last year and he’s getting worse.

Richard’s would have banged that in to touch on the left knowing there was no one around him. After that we made them look like Bayern Munich and even then we could have got it back to 2-2 and no one could have said we didn’t deserve it.

I’m already f***ed off with this season and we are only 10 games in!

 

Page 5 of 10 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Palace v Spurs match thread