You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forest
November 16 2026 2.16am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Forest


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 19 Mar 24 4.23pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

Whilst there is a part of me that is happy about the point deductions, as we benefit, there is another part which does not like FFP.

Despite them dressing it up as protecting clubs and their communities the real reason behind it is the self interests of the large clubs and protecting the status quo. They have already had Manchester City and Chelsea gate crash their party and what would happen if a Palace or Ipswich could outspend them and do the same.

Businesses often have to invest to grow, sometimes making massive losses, it is a strategy that can have many pitfalls and result in failure, but if that's what the owners choose to do then so be it. Man Utd, Liverpool and Arsenal just want to preserve their 'right' at the top of the pecking order and maintain a closed shop for their own greed.

Do I want us to spend like mad and risk everything, then the answer is no. However, should we be punished for trying to compete, then the answer is no as well

You've more or less re-stated the point that John Textor made recently.

FFP benefits the ' big clubs ' because the smaller one's, even if they have investors/owners ready and willing to spend their own money, are constrained by the current rules.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 19 Mar 24 4.35pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

Whilst there is a part of me that is happy about the point deductions, as we benefit, there is another part which does not like FFP.

Despite them dressing it up as protecting clubs and their communities the real reason behind it is the self interests of the large clubs and protecting the status quo. They have already had Manchester City and Chelsea gate crash their party and what would happen if a Palace or Ipswich could outspend them and do the same.

Businesses often have to invest to grow, sometimes making massive losses, it is a strategy that can have many pitfalls and result in failure, but if that's what the owners choose to do then so be it. Man Utd, Liverpool and Arsenal just want to preserve their 'right' at the top of the pecking order and maintain a closed shop for their own greed.

Do I want us to spend like mad and risk everything, then the answer is no. However, should we be punished for trying to compete, then the answer is no as well

Very good post, for me anyway. I agree all round.

The whole thing does look a scapegoating exercise to kick lowly teams in the teeth, not that I'm complaining about that with our current position.

I also can't help but feel that football is after all a sport and it essentially says 'if you're commercial attraction strategy or results don't perform, we'll punish you further'.

The big boys won't complain, they've already cemented their status, but it essentially blocks anyone else from even mounting a challenge. The whole thing is the usual incompetent sh!t show from the FA et al in any instance and I'm not sure I buy into the narrative around it nor the supposed moral authority behind it's reasoning.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

silvertop Flag Portishead 19 Mar 24 7.50pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

At the moment, it isn't the biggest deal. However, when Man City get no punishment at all, how's it going to look? A fine for them and points deductions for everyone else is not going to wash either.

They have not been let off. The panel has yet to adjudicate.

Reckon about a year as there are 100s offences. However, I would be surprised if Man City stayed the dominant force after the decision is made. The new legislation could both give the FA teeth and ensure they don't bottle it/get turned by the vast £££.

BTW Man City are facing FFP charges. Everton and Forest are up against breach of accounting rules. Different regime.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 19 Mar 24 8.25pm

Originally posted by silvertop

They have not been let off. The panel has yet to adjudicate.

Reckon about a year as there are 100s offences. However, I would be surprised if Man City stayed the dominant force after the decision is made. The new legislation could both give the FA teeth and ensure they don't bottle it/get turned by the vast £££.

BTW Man City are facing FFP charges. Everton and Forest are up against breach of accounting rules. Different regime.

I really don't know the technicalities of the charges, not 100% sure anyone does but maybe it's out there. I just can imagine Man City getting something like having to put a load of money into grassroots football and enough said. I can't really predict what will happen - just guessing. I think a team relegated with a points deductions may feel a bit peeved. However, when considering what you say, I guess having titles stripped would be pretty nasty? Would people be happy with that? I'm guessing that would placate other teams.
Genuinely not sure how I feel about the deductions overall but I can say I'm not revelling in it. I don't particularly mind Forest but I don't particularly like Everton - but wish them no harm as it were.
The main thought in my mind about deductions is about thinking how we shouldn't anywhere near be relying on any of it - but here we are. There's still a nagging doubt in my mind about us, thinking I wish we had a bit more fight about us. We've been better with worse players, even including the bloody injuries. But those teams just seemed to have more guts. I don't find us that typical Palace gutsy/ scrapping for stuff this season. I'm not including particular players within this - more just an overall view of the current team.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Mar 24 7.22am

I think the Citeh one is going to be a challenge, I can almost imagine some sort of plea bargain to make it all go away & start with a clean slate (given the amount of charges & the time its going to take to go through them one by one) but to make that happen Citeh will have to admit that for at least some of the charges they broke the rules & they don't seem prepared to do that-

Ultimately the powers that be are going to want to punish Citeh in a way that reflects suitably with any financial breaches that they can prove but they are not going to want to publicly castigate one of their golden geese.

As an outsider its easy to casually sit here & think - they broke the rules for a long period of time they should be relegated, titles & cups stripped, transfer embargo etc etc etc, but honestly I cant see it being that drastic -

when its all said & done it will probably end up with City starting a new season in the PL with a -20 points deduction & some public statements from both sides claiming that most of it was a misunderstanding of the ways that rules were applied at the time & how both parties still love each other & want to put the whole unfortunate saga to bed so that everyone can get on with enjoying the new season -


 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 20 Mar 24 8.27am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

I think the Citeh one is going to be a challenge, I can almost imagine some sort of plea bargain to make it all go away & start with a clean slate (given the amount of charges & the time its going to take to go through them one by one) but to make that happen Citeh will have to admit that for at least some of the charges they broke the rules & they don't seem prepared to do that-

Ultimately the powers that be are going to want to punish Citeh in a way that reflects suitably with any financial breaches that they can prove but they are not going to want to publicly castigate one of their golden geese.

As an outsider its easy to casually sit here & think - they broke the rules for a long period of time they should be relegated, titles & cups stripped, transfer embargo etc etc etc, but honestly I cant see it being that drastic -

when its all said & done it will probably end up with City starting a new season in the PL with a -20 points deduction & some public statements from both sides claiming that most of it was a misunderstanding of the ways that rules were applied at the time & how both parties still love each other & want to put the whole unfortunate saga to bed so that everyone can get on with enjoying the new season -


If City by some miracle were relegated it still would not be a fair outcome. They would be back in the PL the following season whilst keeping all their trophies.

A fair result would be that all their trophies should be cancelled and for every year they cheated they would incur a points deduction for each following season.

So to be clear if they cheated for 10 years then for the following 10 years they should be penalised each season.

Never going to happen of course, the most likely outcome is a one season penalty which their fans would take all day if they kept their trophies.

 


One more point

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 20 Mar 24 1.33pm

In my view, all judgements in these cases should be applied in the summer before the next season. So either they relegate a team, or deduct points this should be applied to the coming season before it starts. No mid-season points deductions.

This would be much fairer for everyone.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 20 Mar 24 2.25pm

Except the teams that got relegated in place of the ones that cheated.

Originally posted by Sansbup

In my view, all judgements in these cases should be applied in the summer before the next season. So either they relegate a team, or deduct points this should be applied to the coming season before it starts. No mid-season points deductions.

This would be much fairer for everyone.

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 20 Mar 24 10.47pm

It's not a level playing field ( Citeh ), spend on lawyers and potentially evade punishment.

The PL will protects it's product.

Fairly clear both Everton and Forest rolled the dice and lost.

Lots of talk about Chelsea being next

I will take anything that helps Palace maintain PL status

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Mar 24 6.12am

Apparently Chelsea referred themselves to the commission for transgressions during the Abramovic era, my guess is they did that because:

a) They knew there were rules that had been broken & wanted to get ahead of the game, especially seeing the charges being levied against City -
b) They wanted to get the credit for reporting themselves / co operating and anticipating leniency.
c) They wanted to get any punishment out of the way whilst they were having a crap season /consolidating problems.
d) They wanted to have begun to have an understanding of how the commission worked / real life experience before they found themselves being called up for transgressions in the Boehly era -

Originally posted by HKOwen

It's not a level playing field ( Citeh ), spend on lawyers and potentially evade punishment.

The PL will protects it's product.

Fairly clear both Everton and Forest rolled the dice and lost.

Lots of talk about Chelsea being next

I will take anything that helps Palace maintain PL status

 

Davepalace707 Flag Northumberland 21 Mar 24 7.45am

Originally posted by HKOwen

It's not a level playing field ( Citeh ), spend on lawyers and potentially evade punishment.

The PL will protects it's product.

Fairly clear both Everton and Forest rolled the dice and lost.

Lots of talk about Chelsea being next

I will take anything that helps Palace maintain PL status

They will only have lost if they get relegated this season. One of them won’t be and there’s a chance neither will be. They both overspent last season and stayed up by four or fewer points. You could argue they’ve already won as without spending they’d have been relegated. Four or six point deductions is not an adequate deterrent and other teams will gamble on spending to stay up.

 

Dubai Eagle Flag 21 Mar 24 8.24am

When you read the report on the Forest hearing it mentions several times that one of the things that the commission want to avoid is future situations where clubs can reliably forecast what penalty they will incur if they fall foul of the guidelines (by whatever amount) but its clear that even at these relatively early stages its already happening -

IDK what the answer is but maybe part of the answer could be harsher sentences for repeat offenders ?

Originally posted by Davepalace707

They will only have lost if they get relegated this season. One of them won’t be and there’s a chance neither will be. They both overspent last season and stayed up by four or fewer points. You could argue they’ve already won as without spending they’d have been relegated. Four or six point deductions is not an adequate deterrent and other teams will gamble on spending to stay up.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 21 Mar 24 8.29am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

When you read the report on the Forest hearing it mentions several times that one of the things that the commission want to avoid is future situations where clubs can reliably forecast what penalty they will incur if they fall foul of the guidelines (by whatever amount) but its clear that even at these relatively early stages its already happening -

IDK what the answer is but maybe part of the answer could be harsher sentences for repeat offenders ?

I get the point but it means that the fans wont understand why one club gets treated differently to another and then we suspect the process.

I would prefer a simple tariff system after all fans should be able to understand the rules.

You then need to ensure that the tariff system doesn't reward rule breaking.

 


One more point

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Mar 24 9.11am

Originally posted by Badger11

If City by some miracle were relegated it still would not be a fair outcome. They would be back in the PL the following season whilst keeping all their trophies.

A fair result would be that all their trophies should be cancelled and for every year they cheated they would incur a points deduction for each following season.

So to be clear if they cheated for 10 years then for the following 10 years they should be penalised each season.

Never going to happen of course, the most likely outcome is a one season penalty which their fans would take all day if they kept their trophies.

People may scoff, but the fact that the regulator is now backed by statutory force, I suspect the Sheikh will not be able to buy his way out of this. Too many eyes on this.

I would not be surprised if the FA "did a Rangers" and turfed them out of the professional league. EUFA may also ban them from European competition, but that would be a largely symbolic gesture given they are not going to qualify from the Conference.

It would throw up a whole raft of issues - now academic - what their current owner does, a fire sale of the worlds most expensive talent (we would target their U21s), what happens to the power vacuum, what the prem will look like when they return in successive promotions, will they reclaim their top status...

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Mar 24 9.17am

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

Apparently Chelsea referred themselves to the commission for transgressions during the Abramovic era, my guess is they did that because:

a) They knew there were rules that had been broken & wanted to get ahead of the game, especially seeing the charges being levied against City -
b) They wanted to get the credit for reporting themselves / co operating and anticipating leniency.
c) They wanted to get any punishment out of the way whilst they were having a crap season /consolidating problems.
d) They wanted to have begun to have an understanding of how the commission worked / real life experience before they found themselves being called up for transgressions in the Boehly era -

This would be the most significant factor.

And it also suggests their legal advice is: you did it and any defence has no prospect of success. Mea culpa and acts of mitigation and they are likely to be treated much better than Man City who appear to have sought to cock-a-snoop, resist and ride their luck.

But they should still be penalised in a way that genuinely hurts. You can't help but feel that Boehly has bought himself a pig in a poke.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 21 Mar 24 1.53pm

Originally posted by Dubai Eagle

IDK what the answer is but maybe part of the answer could be harsher sentences for repeat offenders ?

I'd do a sliding scale from 6 - 12 points for the first offence and a 1 window transfer ban.

2nd offence double, 3rd triple etc.

Maybe some teams would risk it once to stay up, but I don't think they'd repeat if it meant losing their PL status.

 

est1905 Flag 22 Mar 24 5.39pm

Originally posted by Sansbup

In my view, all judgements in these cases should be applied in the summer before the next season. So either they relegate a team, or deduct points this should be applied to the coming season before it starts. No mid-season points deductions.

This would be much fairer for everyone.


How would it be fairer on Luton who may go dow THIS season and have abided by the rules. The Premier league clubs unanimously voted for punishment in the same season a club is found guilty so its a done deal. Everton, Forest and Everton again to be punished before the end of the season.
Leicester are currently out of the Prem's juristiction (them being in the Championship) but they will be handed a points deduction the minute they are promoted too. And rightly so. Maybe if clubs now know a sanction will 100% be coming their way they might stop spending money they are not allowed to spend.
I'm actually in agreement that owners should be allowed to spend over the threshold if they front and guarantee all costs themselves but until the rules are changed they need to abide by them

 

pssguy Flag 22 Mar 24 5.55pm

Make it a criminal offence with the Chairman taking the rap. Apply Texas border sanctions viz. 6 months in the clink for first offence , 10 years for second. That should sort it

 

HKOwen Flag Hong Kong 25 Mar 24 10.44pm

Originally posted by Davepalace707

They will only have lost if they get relegated this season. One of them won’t be and there’s a chance neither will be. They both overspent last season and stayed up by four or fewer points. You could argue they’ve already won as without spending they’d have been relegated. Four or six point deductions is not an adequate deterrent and other teams will gamble on spending to stay up.

Fair point, but what do you do? Make the penalty relegation?
It's never going to be solved in a way that pleases everyone

 


Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance.

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 26 Mar 24 6.49am

Forest have appealed their points deduction. Bearing in mind that they were let off 2 points for co-operating I hope the appeal takes back those 2 points for not accepting the verdict.

 


One more point

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Forest