You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Does religion have a place in modern society?
November 19 2026 5.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Does religion have a place in modern society?


Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >
Jonsey Flag wherever I lay my toolbox thats my... 17 Mar 05 11.28am

Quote OzzieBob at 17 Mar 2005 5:19am

Quote Jonsey at 17 Mar 2005 2:04am

Quote the despotic banana at 16 Mar 2005 7:21pm

Quote roffeyeagle at 16 Mar 2005 7:09pm

Quite simply, Britain is not a Muslim country, it is not a Sikh country, it is not a Hindu country. No disrespect to these religions at all, I respect people for choosing their beliefs and sticking to them but openly practising their religions will incite people, no question.


Surely then, the problem is not Muslims or Hindus but those small-minded bigots that are incited by other people having the audacity to be different to them?

edit: Muslims and Hindus have as much right as Christians to practice their religions.

Edited by the despotic banana (16 Mar 2005 7:22pm)


shame the muslims dont think the same, as if there is any sign of christianity or any religion other than the muslim faith being practised in there desert sorry countries you will more than likely be imprissoned or severly punished

That is simply not true, I have personally been to a Greek orthodox church in Jordan where they have a byzantine mosaic of a map of the holy land (it's a tourist attraction). I went on a Sunday and the Greek orthodox preist was giving his sermon in arabic to locals who looked like locals. There is also a Syrian Orthodox Church in Syria.


Try the home of Islam Saudi Arabia, i remember once going to the shops when i lived there and my mum was getting out the car and her cross that she always wheres fell out. A few of the locals went nutty and came over shouting the odds and the police even came over and went sick. We had to go to the police station and get a translator from the brittish embassy. They were so kind my mum got let off with a warning but told next time she would be in the s*** basically

 


MISSED MORE THAN YOU'LL EVER KNOW
RIP LUKE 26.5.1987-3.4.2004
[Link]

Pikester Flag Worthing 17 Mar 05 2.59pm

Quote cpfc-rjd at 17 Mar 2005 9:42am

We need religion because our ego demands that God himself must have made us because we are so special. We are as special as a fruit fly (which is magnificent in its own way.)

I think we simply cannot accept that things can just be, they do not need a beginning or end. Ultimately though, we do not have the capacity to understand where we came form or why we are here (though we don't like the idea that there may be no reason why we're here.)

Religion has no basis in fact and logicical thought must be suspended if one is to believe in it. In no other aspect of my life do I allow myself to believe in things that I cannot verify to a reasonable extent, so why should I believe in a God when there is no real evidence to suggest His existence?

I may as well believe ion the Easter Bunny.

As to Religion in society, I believe in people's right to believe anything they choose, so long as it does not harm anyone else. Thus, I want to see a fully secular society where Religion is banished form all aspects of the state. People would be welcome to practice religion in Private Churches etc but they would not be able to impose their religious beliefs or customs on anyone else.

I was going to post my own thoughts but that pretty much sums it up (apart from the fruitfly - nasty little buggers!)

If you go back to early times people worshipped the sun, they were frightened by eclipses, earthquakes and thought they had upset their gods.

As these phenonmena have been scientifically explained the various religions have grabbed hold of man's other insecurities and fears - the biggest being what happens when we die.

I remember these terrible cartoon leaflets being given out at school by the Charlie Churches basically saying that if I hadn't let Jesus into my heart before I croaked then I wouldn't be going to heaven - which seemed a bit spiteful to me.

I have a friend at work who is Muslim - he told me that if he didn't follow the beliefs he was told in hell they smash a rock over your head every minute of the day.

I think for far too long religion has traded on people's fears instead of embracing everyone - not just the devout.

I think the country would be better off if we all tried to live in what is often called a "Christian" way - but as Cucking has succingtly highlighted the Muslems family unit is putting to shame out terrible record of broken families and family values.

If people want to go to a church or mosque and it makes them happy and they aren't harming anyone else then good for them - but in return they should be respectful of everyone's rights to choose their own belief.


 


You fed me, you bred me, I'll remember your name.

rach_cpfc Flag South Croydon 17 Mar 05 8.12pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 16 Mar 2005 9:26pm

I'd say that, given the increasing dis-satisfaction with the material and selfish world we live in, religion has perhaps never been more important. I'm not sure that this thread was intended to be a Christian v muslim debate but the truth is that religion, throughout history, has flourished most strongly amnongst the disadvantaged and disaffected. The more downtrodden people become (or feel they become), the more extreme they're prepared to be, as evidenced by the willingness of so many Palestinians to die for what they believe in.

Church of England attendances (the C of E was founded in the reign of Edward VI, not Henry VIII, by the way) are at an all time low because, as Rach has said, it will not publicly stand up for what it believes. Roman Catholicism, too, has seen an increasing number of adherents pay little more than lip service to its central doctrine and beliefs because it continually shies away from the very issues it should be publicly addressing . The countries where Catholicism is at its strongest is in poorer countries, such as in South America, where poverty and exploitation of the many by the few is the norm. In the more 'civilised', Western countries, Christianity in all its forms has had its balls cut off for the simple reason that people don't think they need it. Consumerism is the new religion.

There are many who argue that the decline in religion has co-incided with the break up of the traditional family unit. The increasing number of single parent families and the rise in petty crime committed by children from homes where there is no stable parental influence are social phenomena that simply can't be ignored. In the past, strict religious upbringing precluded such behaviour. Marriage was considered sacred and a commitment for life and not something to walk away from simply because one or other of them got p*ssed off with it. One of the main reasons why islam is taking such a hold in this country is because it places great emphasis on the security and stability of the family unit; the academic achievements of students from such backgrounds, I believe, far outstrip (pro rata) those of the indigenous population and the culture of the extended family is also far more deeply ingrained. It doesn't take a genius to work out that a strong, secure, family based society will prevail over one as disjointed, shallow and uncaring as ours has become.

Goodness me, Cucking, I agree with one of your posts ENTIRELY!

 


"....They will soar on wings like EAGLES; they will run and not grow
weary, they will walk and not be faint."

A_JsShorts 17 Mar 05 9.03pm

Religion will always have a place in modern society.

In this country due to Migration and immigration other religions are going to be a part of this society. I could spout on about embracing the diverse culture but I am not going to bother.

We are all moaning here about Muslims, but unless I have actually forgotton something major they haven't actually done anything to this country and I have never felt threatened by the muslim presence in this country, I appriciate that thmantalists like Hamza preech on the streets and make threats. (although I do not dispute the horific events of 9/11 and Madrid)

Be thankfull you are not in Northern Ireland where disputes over religion has caused so much hurt and pain.

Having been married, to a muslim, I am sick and tired of muslim people being tarred with the same brush.

People who live in this country IMO have to right to practice which ever religion they choose.

The Pope is another debate altogether, and is honestly a danger to society. Not physically obviously!!!

Edited by A_JsShorts (17 Mar 2005 9:04pm)

 

Legal Eagle Flag A town where fog lights shine, eve... 17 Mar 05 11.36pm

As an aside, something I was told by a headteacher way back in year 8 - religion in this country is not in any decline. The orthodox Church of England indeed is, if you take church attendance as a measure, but alternative Christian practices and other religions actually indicate that there is no overall decline in the practice of religion.

Well, apparently. He didn't give a source

 


It's just a matter of crossing the i's and dotting the t's

cpfc-rjd Flag Beckenham and the BBS 18 Mar 05 1.56pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 16 Mar 2005 9:26pm

I'd say that, given the increasing dis-satisfaction with the material and selfish world we live in, religion has perhaps never been more important. I'm not sure that this thread was intended to be a Christian v muslim debate but the truth is that religion, throughout history, has flourished most strongly amnongst the disadvantaged and disaffected. The more downtrodden people become (or feel they become), the more extreme they're prepared to be, as evidenced by the willingness of so many Palestinians to die for what they believe in.

Church of England attendances (the C of E was founded in the reign of Edward VI, not Henry VIII, by the way) are at an all time low because, as Rach has said, it will not publicly stand up for what it believes. Roman Catholicism, too, has seen an increasing number of adherents pay little more than lip service to its central doctrine and beliefs because it continually shies away from the very issues it should be publicly addressing . The countries where Catholicism is at its strongest is in poorer countries, such as in South America, where poverty and exploitation of the many by the few is the norm. In the more 'civilised', Western countries, Christianity in all its forms has had its balls cut off for the simple reason that people don't think they need it. Consumerism is the new religion.

There are many who argue that the decline in religion has co-incided with the break up of the traditional family unit. The increasing number of single parent families and the rise in petty crime committed by children from homes where there is no stable parental influence are social phenomena that simply can't be ignored. In the past, strict religious upbringing precluded such behaviour. Marriage was considered sacred and a commitment for life and not something to walk away from simply because one or other of them got p*ssed off with it. One of the main reasons why islam is taking such a hold in this country is because it places great emphasis on the security and stability of the family unit; the academic achievements of students from such backgrounds, I believe, far outstrip (pro rata) those of the indigenous population and the culture of the extended family is also far more deeply ingrained. It doesn't take a genius to work out that a strong, secure, family based society will prevail over one as disjointed, shallow and uncaring as ours has become.

Yes but isn't it funny that many of the 'old fashioned values' brigade who go on about the decline of religion, the family and society are the same ones who voted for Thatcher as she destroyed communities and ruthlessly pursued policies which glamorized the consumer society and the money-mad world.

There is still the idea floating around that without Religion, one is morally bankrupt. Well, for me the idea that a good man will be in hell for eternity because he doesn’t believe in god, while a pedophile (for example) who believes (and repents) will go to paradise is not exactly morally sound.


 


"Her very Lowness with her head in a sling
I'm truly sorry but it sounds like a wonderful thing"

NEITHER LEFT OR RIGHT BUT OUT IN FRONT

[Link]

tetley Flag Wimbledon 18 Mar 05 3.19pm

today we must all unite in worshipping the great sun god!! let's get tanning!

 


It's not the fall that's important.....it's the landing

All Nature is but Art, unknown to thee;
All Chance, Direction, which thou canst not see;
All Discord, Harmony, not understood;
All partial Evil, universal Good

[Link]

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 18 Mar 05 6.14pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 17 Mar 2005 9:03pm

The Pope is another debate altogether, and is honestly a danger to society. Not physically obviously!!!

Edited by A_JsShorts (17 Mar 2005 9:04pm)

And how did you arrive at that conclusion?

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

A_JsShorts 18 Mar 05 6.55pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 18 Mar 2005 6:14pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 17 Mar 2005 9:03pm

The Pope is another debate altogether, and is honestly a danger to society. Not physically obviously!!!

Edited by A_JsShorts (17 Mar 2005 9:04pm)

And how did you arrive at that conclusion?

Welcome back Mr Funt

Well someone who tells people that condoms do not work and that the HIV virus can be passed through tthem is rather dangerous IMO. Many people look up to the Pope and will believe what he says, I just hope they are intelligent enough not to believe his rubbish. With 1 in 3 people infected in Africa with HIV/AIDS, who do not have but want access to contraception, I think what he is saying is absolutely disgraceful.


 

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 18 Mar 05 7.27pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 18 Mar 2005 6:55pm

Quote Cucking Funt at 18 Mar 2005 6:14pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 17 Mar 2005 9:03pm

The Pope is another debate altogether, and is honestly a danger to society. Not physically obviously!!!

Edited by A_JsShorts (17 Mar 2005 9:04pm)

And how did you arrive at that conclusion?

Welcome back Mr Funt

Well someone who tells people that condoms do not work and that the HIV virus can be passed through tthem is rather dangerous IMO. Many people look up to the Pope and will believe what he says, I just hope they are intelligent enough not to believe his rubbish. With 1 in 3 people infected in Africa with HIV/AIDS, who do not have but want access to contraception, I think what he is saying is absolutely disgraceful.

Thank you for your welcome.

The Catholic Church is, I think, very close to altering its position re: birth control. When it was 'banned' (which it wasn't quite as it was frowned upon but left to individual conscience) in 1967, a commision appointed by the then Pope actually advised that barrier methods of contraception could sit comfortably within existing Church teaching. For reasons best known to himself, he chose to ignore that advice, and that position has been maintained by the current Pope. I'm not aware of him saying that condoms actually facilitate the transmission of HIV (I stand to be corrected on that point) but his condemnation (or should that be condomnation) of them is for spiritual reasons rather than anything else and that, of course, is the root of the problem.

I'm not sure that the spread of HIV in Africa is anything to do with the Pope; it's more a question of condoms just not being as freely available there as they are in the 'civilised' world. His comments, if they're true, are certainly irresponsible as they are not founded in fact but I don't think the Pope can be condemned out of hand for reminding the church's members what their obligations are - no blobs is part of the deal of being a catholic.

Anyway, as I said, with this Pope on his way out, I personally believe that in future the Church will permit artificial methods of contraception and will play a far bigger part in addressing matters such as the AIDS epidemic in Africa. It is, after all, exactly what Jesus would have done. The problem with the Catholic Church is that it does change, but it just takes blody ages to do it.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

A_JsShorts 18 Mar 05 7.40pm

Basically the Vatican argues that condoms are full of tiny holes, I have a link to an article in the Guardian.

[Link]

Also, I can't have been clear, I am not saying that the pope has anything to do with the AIDs epidemic in Africa - far from it. I just think that with it being such a huge problem out there he is being extremely irresponsible.

And your right he is on his way out the sooner the better as far as I am concerned!!

 

Petealiator Flag 1066 Country! 18 Mar 05 7.43pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 18 Mar 2005 7:40pm

in the Guardian.

Aaaah! Oh dear!

 


My Rocksteady band...
[Link]
[Link]
IT'S NOT SKA, IT'S ROCKSTEADY!

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 18 Mar 05 7.46pm

Sounds like the Cardinal they've quoted is making an early pitch for the Papacy.

Without wishing to get into a theological argument, there are grounds for permitting the use of condoms but it's going to take someone a little more enlightened than the present Pope to put it into practice. And before we knock John Paul II, he played a very big part in the fall of the Eastern Bloc and has publicy supported many, many worthwhile and humanitarian causes. Intransigent on some issues he may be, but he's not the satan you're making him out to be.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

A_JsShorts 18 Mar 05 8.00pm

Quote Petealiator at 18 Mar 2005 7:43pm

Quote A_JsShorts at 18 Mar 2005 7:40pm

in the Guardian.

Aaaah! Oh dear!

Sorry, should've known the Guardian wouldn't be the best source of evidence (but they seem to be the only paper to have ran the story!) for you so I have:

BBC [Link]

And I can't comment on the Popes good work, cos to be honest I don'y know much about it. Ignorant of me and I shall research!


Edited by A_JsShorts (18 Mar 2005 8:01pm)

 

thornton-heath eagle 07 May 05 2.08am

Quote roffeyeagle at 16 Mar 2005 6:58pm

Just looking at Britain, there is no way at all we can live in harmony if people (particularly Asians) openly practice their religions. The Christianity aspect of Britain is slowy dying by there is no way white Britains will accept Muslim extremists et al for much longer. It has to stop if this country wants to avoid serious conflict.


I find it quite ignorant that you think all Muslims are Asian. You really should get your facts correct before you give your opinion on such a delicate subject. Muslims come froma all over the world, as do Christians. Did you know that there are many Christians in Sri Lanka, ****stan and Indonesia and many other countries on the Asian continent?
Christianity isn't limited only to Europe, after all it did originate in the Middle East, where there are currently many Christians still.
Christianity ans Islam originated from the same bit of the globe....something to think about

 


.

thornton-heath eagle 07 May 05 2.22am

Jonsey Flag THE REAL JONSEY Time 17 Mar 2005 2:04am


shame the muslims dont think the same, as if there is any sign of christianity or any religion other than the muslim faith being practised in there desert sorry countries you will more than likely be imprissoned or severly punished


your theory is despicable!!! the middle still has many Christians living there who are of Arab race (not to mention the thousands of foregin workers there from European countries) As for Asian countries where Muslims are the majority, Christians are also there - Sri Lanka, India, Indonesia, Mayalsia, Thailand, Paakistan etc...
I haven't seen many of them being punished for their religion or imprisoned.

As for the desert, Christianity began in that same desert!!!
Jesus wasn't born in Europe!!
Was he??

Edited by thornton-heath eagle (07 May 2005 2:24am)

 


.

thornton-heath eagle 07 May 05 2.33am

Quote roffeyeagle at 16 Mar 2005 8:24pm

Quote the despotic banana at 16 Mar 2005 8:15pm

roffeyeagle first brought up Hindus when he said - "Britain is not a Muslim country, it is not a Sikh country, it is not a Hindu country."

Basically, if you're not a WASP, F*CK OFF!

Did I ever say that if you're not a WASP then f*** off?

No, I said why should non-WASPs be allowed to openly practice a religion that does not belong in Britain? Why should non-WASPs be allowed to aggravate British people with their religous antics, if it is not even the home of the religion? It's not only that, but this inept Government are letting them do it, and anything we say that is protecting us is wrong. This is totally f***ed up.

I accept that the world is evolving, people want to make better lives for themselves in wealthier areas. Fair play to you, trying to make the most of what you are. But why should they be allowed to do it at the expense and aggravation of WASPs or any other Christian? They shouldn't, that's my point.

It wouldn't be alright if millions of WASPs went over to ****stan and starting building churches, having anti-Islamic marches, burning the ****stani Flag and started openly practicing Christianity in ****stan would it? No.

Edited by roffeyeagle (16 Mar 2005 8:31pm)


There are already churches in ****stan you idiot! They have been there since the British Empire decided to take over a thriving nation (of mixed religions) and turn it to sh*te before they left.
those churches haven't been torn down or burnt, in fact they are still used as a place of worship by the Christians there.

I feel you have a slight hatred for other races/religions??? correct me if i'm wrong, obviously

 


.

Jonsey Flag wherever I lay my toolbox thats my... 09 May 05 4.36pm

Quote thornton-heath eagle at 07 May 2005 2:22am

Jonsey Flag THE REAL JONSEY Time 17 Mar 2005 2:04am


shame the muslims dont think the same, as if there is any sign of christianity or any religion other than the muslim faith being practised in there desert sorry countries you will more than likely be imprissoned or severly punished


your theory is despicable!!! the middle still has many Christians living there who are of Arab race (not to mention the thousands of foregin workers there from European countries) As for Asian countries where Muslims are the majority, Christians are also there - Sri Lanka, India, Indonesia, Mayalsia, Thailand, Paakistan etc...
I haven't seen many of them being punished for their religion or imprisoned.

As for the desert, Christianity began in that same desert!!!
Jesus wasn't born in Europe!!
Was he??

Edited by thornton-heath eagle (07 May 2005 2:24am)


I lived in Saudi for 10 years so im sure i have a better idea than yourself of how the Christians are treated in those countries. you can read as many newspapers or articles on the internet as you like but you wont know what its like unless you lived there

 


MISSED MORE THAN YOU'LL EVER KNOW
RIP LUKE 26.5.1987-3.4.2004
[Link]

thornton-heath eagle 10 May 05 12.32am

maybe i do know whats its like!!!

you talk too much crap, thats all.

there are Arab Christians in the Mid. East, who arent treated any worse than the other Arabs.

maybe because you talked a lot of crap they treated you like it too?

 


.

Jonsey Flag wherever I lay my toolbox thats my... 10 May 05 1.20am

Quote thornton-heath eagle at 10 May 2005 12:32am

maybe i do know whats its like!!!

you talk too much crap, thats all.

there are Arab Christians in the Mid. East, who arent treated any worse than the other Arabs.

maybe because you talked a lot of crap they treated you like it too?


sshhh do not speak of what you do not understand

 


MISSED MORE THAN YOU'LL EVER KNOW
RIP LUKE 26.5.1987-3.4.2004
[Link]

Page 5 of 6 < 1 2 3 4 5 6 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Gold Talk > Does religion have a place in modern society?