You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Roy Hodgson thread


Page 52 of 65 < 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 >
ChrisGC Flag Wantage 27 Apr 19 10.48pm

Originally posted by Tickled pink

Majority wants him in, because the majority appreciate what he has and is doing at our club, we should be extremely grateful to have his leadership and experience, if the team fails to improve significantly with his influence over new signings in regards to his very little influence with this seasons squad we can then take your posts a little more seriously.

Just because you want him to stay that doesn't count as a majority.

I'd say he's on a seesaw, the balance was in his favour last week, less so this week. He'll be gone by Crimbo, we're not going to improve under him. This is the start of the slide.

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 27 Apr 19 10.54pm

Originally posted by Shifty97

Don’t see why people are so negative, at the start of the season, most would have taken the position we are in now. Roy isn’t perfect but really some people are expecting too much

Cmon really, what is too much exactly? I go to a football match to get entertained. I’ve now been to ten home matches this year I haven’t seen one win and I’ve seen some pretty piss poor performances if the truth be known. If that is expecting too much then you are truly not seeing the big picture.

Where I sit we have the benefit of Jim Cannon and Clinton Morrison’s pearls of wisdom after the match and believe me when I say they pulled no punches today, the words boring, were right at the top of the list and they are ex pros talking about the team they love.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Apr 19 10.55pm

Originally posted by ChrisGC

Just because you want him to stay that doesn't count as a majority.

I'd say he's on a seesaw, the balance was in his favour last week, less so this week. He'll be gone by Crimbo, we're not going to improve under him. This is the start of the slide.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Numbers Man Flag Tulse Hill 27 Apr 19 11.01pm

There is no doubt that RH’s away record is excellent. But this has been often due to Wilf and our penalty taking captain. If Wilf goes then where will we be? There has been very poor management decisions by SP/RH/other managers. For example signing Benteke, Wickham (reporting to be earning £60,000 per week) and Meyer ( reported earning £120,000 per week).

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 27 Apr 19 11.07pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Manager Vote' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by speediej

I have noticed quite a split between people wanting Roy in, or out.
I have made a poll to see where the majority lies. I would appreciate if you could answer it.


[Link]

Thanks

This should be pinned

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 27 Apr 19 11.22pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Manager Vote' by Midlands Eagle

What is the point of a poll, load of tosh. As for pinning it I can think of more important things in life, why rock the boat some people like RH others don't, voting on it proves s*d all.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Apr 19 11.24pm

Originally posted by Numbers Man

There is no doubt that RH’s away record is excellent. But this has been often due to Wilf and our penalty taking captain. If Wilf goes then where will we be? There has been very poor management decisions by SP/RH/other managers. For example signing Benteke, Wickham (reporting to be earning £60,000 per week) and Meyer ( reported earning £120,000 per week).

We have to gamble because we cannot afford the likes of Hazard, Aguero, Son, Van Dijk and Sterling, If we sell Zaha we will no doubt be able to buy some players to replace him, the money will reduce the gamble somewhat but it will still be a gamble sadly.

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 27 Apr 19 11.25pm

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Manager Vote' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by ChrisGC

This should be pinned

At lest 61% of people who have some sense thank goodness.

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Apr 19 11.29pm

Take one or two players out of the top six teams and watch them suffer on the pitch, I hate all this rubbish about Zaha, just look at how crap Chelsea are without Hazard!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Apr 19 11.31pm

Originally posted by syd snot

Sack the flabby chinned c*** and hire Steve McClaren immediately I say &#128521;

 

PatrickA Flag London 27 Apr 19 11.32pm

I’m fortunate to have seen the away wins at Manchester City, Newcastle and Arsenal this season , a feat I doubt we’ll see again for many years in one season.
However, I have also seen really poor performances at home this season epitomised by today.
Sloppy passing, lack of creativity going forward and essentially nine men behind the ball with only Wilf and Benteke forward.
There’s no point playing Benteke if we don’t play players close to him or hit crosses to take advantage of his aerial ability.
With Zaha off form as well we had zero threat and I can’t remember Pickford making a save.
I’m ok with Roy staying but I’d like to see it written into his contract that he can’t play 9 men behind the ball at home unless it’s against the top 4!

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 27 Apr 19 11.43pm

Benteke is a write off. s*** touch, no strength, poor movement, can’t stay on his feet or hold the ball up.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 27 Apr 19 11.49pm

Originally posted by A89M

All this talk about Roy and his negative tactics yet our shots on goal to date totals 447 for the season with 3 games to go, this puts us 7th out of the 20 clubs. The teams above us include 5 of the top 6 and Leicester.
Our highest recorded total is 476 which was last season under Roy.
We’ve also hit the woodwork 15 times which is the 4th highest this season, again the only teams above us are those that are in the top 6.

When you consider these stats and then cast your minds back to the opportunities the players have missed in games at home, Sakho’s missed header against Newcastle, MacArthur tap in against Watford, MacArthur again when he missed from 2 yards out. Take your pick of any player against Cardiff. A few of these go in and there would be a lot less disgruntled home fans wanting a change.
Key moments at home we have come up short and I don’t see what Roy can do, other than set the team up like he has done and hope his players have their shooting boots on.


Edited by A89M (24 Apr 2019 4.57pm)

Hodgson out brigade only read what they want to read, so sadly you're wasting your time.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Apr 19 12.02am

Originally posted by PatrickA

I’m fortunate to have seen the away wins at Manchester City, Newcastle and Arsenal this season , a feat I doubt we’ll see again for many years in one season.
However, I have also seen really poor performances at home this season epitomised by today.
Sloppy passing, lack of creativity going forward and essentially nine men behind the ball with only Wilf and Benteke forward.
There’s no point playing Benteke if we don’t play players close to him or hit crosses to take advantage of his aerial ability.
With Zaha off form as well we had zero threat and I can’t remember Pickford making a save.
I’m ok with Roy staying but I’d like to see it written into his contract that he can’t play 9 men behind the ball at home unless it’s against the top 4!

I'm sure if the Players felt they were able to hold onto the ball and pass to each other they would be able to upset Everton's play, but our players fell back because Everton made them due to extreme pressing and allowing us no room to move, Zaha had up to three players marking him every time he moved forward dangerously, we didn't stop ourselves ..Everton did because their squad was stronger and better then our squad, simple really.
We really do have an average squad of players, some are quite hopeless.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 28 Apr 19 12.21am

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Benteke is a write off. s*** touch, no strength, poor movement, can’t stay on his feet or hold the ball up.

His biggest problem is getting himself into the right place at the right time, he shouldn't be on any wing dribbling anywhere down it, the times today he was running around miles from where he should have been was ridiculous, the ball on his head with him running in the box (not offside) is where he should be every time we get into a crossing situation, then we need to have a look at the crossing because nine times out of ten it is absolutely disgusting, Benteke might as well not be there half the time anyway.

 

Teddy Eagle Flag 28 Apr 19 1.13am


We are 12th in the self styled Best League in the World. Where does everyone think we should be placed? It seems a lot of people would be pleased to see Benetiz take over - how’s he done this year?

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 28 Apr 19 1.50am

Originally posted by Teddy Eagle


We are 12th in the self styled Best League in the World. Where does everyone think we should be placed? It seems a lot of people would be pleased to see Benetiz take over - how’s he done this year?

Don't go all factual mate.
You need to understand that many posters on here think that they are on BOL not HOL due to the similarities of the kit.

 

ChrisGC Flag Wantage 28 Apr 19 7.03am

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Manager Vote' by Midlands Eagle

Originally posted by PZ Eagle

At lest 61% of people who have some sense thank goodness.

I'm encouraged to see that 20% are starting to think bigger and demand better. This number will only increase as the poll rises from a handful of people to a total where it can be taken seriously.

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 28 Apr 19 7.31am

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Cmon really, what is too much exactly? I go to a football match to get entertained. I’ve now been to ten home matches this year I haven’t seen one win and I’ve seen some pretty piss poor performances if the truth be known. If that is expecting too much then you are truly not seeing the big picture.

Where I sit we have the benefit of Jim Cannon and Clinton Morrison’s pearls of wisdom after the match and believe me when I say they pulled no punches today, the words boring, were right at the top of the list and they are ex pros talking about the team they love.

I’m afraid this is the problem with many new ‘fans’. Supporting a team is an emotional attachment, often stressful, not entertainment. Entertainment is a rare bonus when we play well.

Presumably you’ve only be going to Palace since we got promoted, because I can assure you the many years we spent in the Championship certainly were not entertainment.

Re the Everton match, I didn’t see if but sounds like it was a crap match. Although given that Everton have won 4 of their last 5, including wins against Man Utd, Arsenal and Chelsea, I’d take a 0-0 draw all day.

 

The Dolphin Flag 28 Apr 19 8.08am

None of us know what goes on behind closed doors and whilst RH has done an amazing job really we could have done more this season in my opinion.
If he is staying then find but I hope that we don't lose players because of him - Wilf, AWB and Luka.

 

Page 52 of 65 < 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The Roy Hodgson thread