You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread
November 16 2026 5.01am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread


Page 57 of 91 < 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 >
Painter Flag Croydon 29 Jan 20 11.26am

Originally posted by Den1923

Roy is not the problem, Parish/Freedman are the problems and until they are replaced, things will be just the same if Roy is there or not, clearly no proven PL Manager will want to be involved with a club that does not invest in the team, SP/DF have failed repeatedly to get signings over the line, there has to be something seriously wrong with these two as they seem to make the club toxic to new players, they only expertise they have is in last minute low key loan deals, they have no succession planning, we have an aging squad and frankly we are in serious trouble with no guarantee that we are safe even for this season. If we do get relegated it will be a seriously financial blow to the club and in the end only one person is responsible and that is Parish!

You don’t seem to think the Americans have any say in the running of the club and sanction any spending. Freeman has a good success rate in purchases, he has been involved in, it’s always a risk. If Parish isn’t given any funds by the Americans, who run their businesses prudently, he hasn’t a choice.
You allude to the club being toxic, which is only because they aren’t buying everything that moves, Goldberg tried that blew his money and nearly got the club closed down.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Jan 20 11.39am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

This post has been merged from a topic called 'Ambition of SP and Board always been survival...' by Midlands Eagle

If Zaha is staying until the end of the season that's a great development.

The time to worry about replacements is with Zaha, first....Zaha, second and Zaha third.

The ageing squad is responsible for a mid table position in our most successful era ever.

Value for money is rarely secured during mid season transfers.

I quote Gribbo.

‘Just keep going with the ageing squad of players until it catches up with us. Get relegated, new manager, start again with the kids we are buying and flush out the Americans when all the value has gone. The strategy is set, full ahead!’

Sustainable success has always been about a balanced squad, including the age of players, or you get a batch of players not up to it all at once, and for us they’ll be regulars. We haven’t recruited outfield players outside of the panini album successfully for quite a while.

The sale of AWB saved our &rses. As you say, what pans out with Zaha is also crucial. These are the only two players that have enabled us to do what bottom half teams have to do. Make profit on a few players rather than all out losses. Oh and Bolasie. Zaha hasn’t been sold yet.

AWB came about through necessity, and Zaha is depreciating without us knowing what we’ll do or who’s going to do it. Part of that we can’t control regarding future managers but it adds to the problems we’ve created with Benteke, Sakho, other established players at signature and nearing 20% off the pace, and we are still are creating because the strategy is to operate on a near term shoestring budget while hoping we’re bought out.

The accountancy decisions run the football now, and why I won’t get surprised or agitated each window. It is what it is. A bag of sh1t with major shareholders not doing what they came in to do. Build the club including the main stand. They did finance Sam’s survival campaign but they’ve now been repaid or in the process of full repayment and yet we’re borrowing money from banks charging interest to use some of instalment money from the sale of AWB. I suppose we’ll be biting our nails with Ward out again for months at some point and Kelly in at RB while that sh1t goes on. Paying interest on loans with billionaire owners.

Don’t count on much with this lot people. You’ll feel like a fool for doing so.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (29 Jan 2020 11.44am)

 


COYP

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 Jan 20 11.58am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I quote Gribbo.

‘Just keep going with the ageing squad of players until it catches up with us. Get relegated, new manager, start again with the kids we are buying and flush out the Americans when all the value has gone. The strategy is set, full ahead!’

Sustainable success has always been about a balanced squad, including the age of players, or you get a batch of players not up to it all at once, and for us they’ll be regulars. We haven’t recruited outfield players outside of the panini album successfully for quite a while.

The sale of AWB saved our &rses. As you say, what pans out with Zaha is also crucial. These are the only two players that have enabled us to do what bottom half teams have to do. Make profit on a few players rather than all out losses. Oh and Bolasie. Zaha hasn’t been sold yet.

AWB came about through necessity, and Zaha is depreciating without us knowing what we’ll do or who’s going to do it. Part of that we can’t control regarding future managers but it adds to the problems we’ve created with Benteke, Sakho, other established players at signature and nearing 20% off the pace, and we are still are creating because the strategy is to operate on a near term shoestring budget while hoping we’re bought out.

The accountancy decisions run the football now, and why I won’t get surprised or agitated each window. It is what it is. A bag of sh1t with major shareholders not doing what they came in to do. Build the club including the main stand. They did finance Sam’s survival campaign but they’ve now been repaid or in the process of full repayment and yet we’re borrowing money from banks charging interest to use some of instalment money from the sale of AWB. I suppose we’ll be biting our nails with Ward out again for months at some point and Kelly in at RB while that sh1t goes on. Paying interest on loans with billionaire owners.

Don’t count on much with this lot people. You’ll feel like a fool for doing so.


Edited by Rudi Hedman (29 Jan 2020 11.44am)

Nice post Rudi. In reality they have invested very little in our club. The easy short term answer of course is get shot of Sakho, Benteke, Wickham, Zaha and the wage bill will plummet. The only one we will really miss is Wilf and despite what people think, he can be replaced. We just need to stop relying on one player to make things happen. Use his money to buy two wingers IMO.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 29 Jan 20 12.08pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Nice post Rudi. In reality they have invested very little in our club. The easy short term answer of course is get shot of Sakho, Benteke, Wickham, Zaha and the wage bill will plummet. The only one we will really miss is Wilf and despite what people think, he can be replaced. We just need to stop relying on one player to make things happen. Use his money to buy two wingers IMO.

Agree, we are so predictable when Wilf plays, especially when Townsend isn't available to provide a second option. Our team is built around Wilf and it's all about defend for our lives and hope that when we can get the ball to him, Wilf will skin a defender or three and either score or put a killer cross in for a tap in a la Citeh game.

 

pieceofcake Flag Cell 36,HMP Albany 29 Jan 20 12.31pm

Originally posted by Den1923

Roy is not the problem, Parish/Freedman are the problems and until they are replaced, things will be just the same if Roy is there or not, clearly no proven PL Manager will want to be involved with a club that does not invest in the team, SP/DF have failed repeatedly to get signings over the line, there has to be something seriously wrong with these two as they seem to make the club toxic to new players, they only expertise they have is in last minute low key loan deals, they have no succession planning, we have an aging squad and frankly we are in serious trouble with no guarantee that we are safe even for this season. If we do get relegated it will be a seriously financial blow to the club and in the end only one person is responsible and that is Parish!

And then Parish gets to buy the club at a greatly reduced price.Is that what's going on?

 

Den1923 Flag 29 Jan 20 1.53pm

Originally posted by Painter

You don’t seem to think the Americans have any say in the running of the club and sanction any spending. Freeman has a good success rate in purchases, he has been involved in, it’s always a risk. If Parish isn’t given any funds by the Americans, who run their businesses prudently, he hasn’t a choice.
You allude to the club being toxic, which is only because they aren’t buying everything that moves, Goldberg tried that blew his money and nearly got the club closed down.

I'm sorry but I disagree, it was Parish who got the Americans involved and brokered the deal with them. The Americans, must understand the difference between the value of their investment in the PL will be entirely different as a championship club or dare I say a league one outfit. Parish is supposed to be the CEO but he cannot walk the talk. We have in recent seasons see many supposed transfers fall down at the last minute and instead seen the candidates go to our rivals as whatever is on offer at CP seems to be toxic, even managers have walked before Roy arrived because I suspect of lack of meaningful investment in the first team squad, although some other spin has been put on that to protect parish et-al. Parish has a total control culture and really does not allow any incomings unless they on his terms, which often sound unrealistic and unreasonable. As for Freedman, I do not recall any signings that have been down to him that stand out or indeed any idea of what succession planning he has in place to replace ageing players. He has been unable to for at least two transfer windows, if not longer, to find a decent striker even though everyone (except maybe Parish) knew that we needed one and the same can be said about our LB position after AWB left. In fact give him credit by all means when its due, in that respect Freeman was a good player forus, but also do not forget as a Manager he left the club for Bolton as he thought his options were better there!

The clubs transfer policy and handling is a shambles and embarrassment to all!

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 29 Jan 20 2.47pm

Quite simply I cannot see how majority shareholders don't pull the strings. Not sure how you can think differently Den. If there is a lack of investment in this club it is only coming from one area. Don't be surprised to find money being siphoned off to the US in the accounts when they come out.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 Jan 20 3.09pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Quite simply I cannot see how majority shareholders don't pull the strings. Not sure how you can think differently Den. If there is a lack of investment in this club it is only coming from one area. Don't be surprised to find money being siphoned off to the US in the accounts when they come out.

Quite honestly none of us know who pulls the strings and don't forget that if the Americans put in £10m for transfers then Parish also has to stump up £5m

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Jan 20 3.53pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Quite honestly none of us know who pulls the strings and don't forget that if the Americans put in £10m for transfers then Parish also has to stump up £5m

Really, a director can make a loan without a change to equity surely?

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 29 Jan 20 3.56pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Quite honestly none of us know who pulls the strings and don't forget that if the Americans put in £10m for transfers then Parish also has to stump up £5m

Investments are given as loans secured against the club - hence administration. Nobody stumping up personal fortunes here.

 


Red and Blue Army!

Den1923 Flag 29 Jan 20 4.25pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Quite simply I cannot see how majority shareholders don't pull the strings. Not sure how you can think differently Den. If there is a lack of investment in this club it is only coming from one area. Don't be surprised to find money being siphoned off to the US in the accounts when they come out.

The Americans would have to be really stupid, if they cannot see the difference in the value of a football club in PL versus one in the lower divisions. Surely, like all investors they want to protect their investment which is currently not happening, our team has little or no injury cover, no firing striker, no RB to replace AWB, although that may be about to change if Ferguson passes his
medical which is taking place as we speak. Taking Directors drawings and leaving the team to flounder does not sound good business practice to me!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Jan 20 4.27pm

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Investments are given as loans secured against the club - hence administration. Nobody stumping up personal fortunes here.

Taking out a loan before MAN UTD make a compulsory instalment payment on AWB is very bad imo. Why these Americans can’t make a short term loan is a question that should be put to CPFC.

And there’s a case for spending some, even if a small amount, of future sales of Zaha or Sakho. I guess that’ll have to wait until the summer and these shareholders should be grateful for var and Guaita’s form this season it isn’t a very immediate need to spend fairly heavily after virtually fvck all in August.

At least we’re signing Nathan Ferguson, which is what clubs of our size need to add into the mix instead of everyone being 29 and on max Prem wages for their calibre. Doesn’t last.

 


COYP

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 29 Jan 20 4.37pm

I just cannot understand why football supporters expect business people to put money into a club with little or no chance of getting a return on that money and when they do see a return why the hell do people complain about that. When you 'invest' in a savings account you expect interest on your money and you expect to get all your investment back, that's just normal.

The problem at Palace is that it is proving very difficult to make the business case for infrastructure work and given premier league wages, very difficult to invest in the squad. Hence the budget buys and loans. Parish is trying to move things forward year on year in small ways. I think now that the new stand was just a publicity stunt to try to attract interest and I don't think it has worked and has just left supporters disappointed.

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 29 Jan 20 4.46pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

I just cannot understand why football supporters expect business people to put money into a club with little or no chance of getting a return on that money and when they do see a return why the hell do people complain about that. When you 'invest' in a savings account you expect interest on your money and you expect to get all your investment back, that's just normal.

The problem at Palace is that it is proving very difficult to make the business case for infrastructure work and given premier league wages, very difficult to invest in the squad. Hence the budget buys and loans. Parish is trying to move things forward year on year in small ways. I think now that the new stand was just a publicity stunt to try to attract interest and I don't think it has worked and has just left supporters disappointed.


Well plus a share of £2.5 billion in Premier League telly money each year?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Jan 20 7.29pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

I just cannot understand why football supporters expect business people to put money into a club with little or no chance of getting a return on that money and when they do see a return why the hell do people complain about that. When you 'invest' in a savings account you expect interest on your money and you expect to get all your investment back, that's just normal.

The problem at Palace is that it is proving very difficult to make the business case for infrastructure work and given premier league wages, very difficult to invest in the squad. Hence the budget buys and loans. Parish is trying to move things forward year on year in small ways. I think now that the new stand was just a publicity stunt to try to attract interest and I don't think it has worked and has just left supporters disappointed.

There is scope at Palace for an owner to develop the club and sell it on. It’s at this point I’d question why someone business savvy would want to buy Palace and concern me seeing as its very steep at the top of the summit and potentially fast on the way down. A lot of this rests on staying in the Prem, which of course is the case with the current us shareholders money tied in now, and probably why they eventually agree they either keep updating the squad or see their shares worth a fraction of the current value.

 


COYP

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 Jan 20 7.36pm

Originally posted by chris123

Really, a director can make a loan without a change to equity surely?

I believe that the agreement when the Americans came in was that whatever monies they loaned to the club would be matched by parish so if they put in a combined £20m Parish would have to put in £10m to match them

Originally posted by ASCPFC

Investments are given as loans secured against the club - hence administration. Nobody stumping up personal fortunes here.

Their loans may well be secured although they aren't at the moment but Parish may well not have the liquid funds to match the Americans investment

Edited by Midlands Eagle (30 Jan 2020 6.06am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 29 Jan 20 9.36pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

I believe that the agreement when the Americans came in was that whatever monies they loaned to the club would be matched by parish so if they put in a combined £20m Parish would have to put in £5m to match them

Their loans may well be secured although they aren't at the moment but Parish may well not have the liquid funds to match the Americans investment

You should’ve said this ages ago. May well have answered why they haven’t spent any money more than is within the contract of share agreements, although maybe that partly happened when they covered Sam’s January survival fund and they’re not doing it again after they found we’re always a possible to get relegated like 12 other clubs.

But we shouldn’t be borrowing from banks when Man Utd are due to pay us compulsory instalments months or a year later. That’s bad.

 


COYP

Wilbraham413 Flag 30 Jan 20 3.09am

Originally posted by rollercoaster

I just cannot understand why football supporters expect business people to put money into a club with little or no chance of getting a return on that money and when they do see a return why the hell do people complain about that. When you 'invest' in a savings account you expect interest on your money and you expect to get all your investment back, that's just normal.

I agree, and the point being that the current Premier League model is a huge disincentive for investment.

Would you personally invest your money in any club outside the top 6? I wouldn't. Watford and Bournemouth seemed safe for years, and this year they are in the relegation hunt. Stoke was a model for years, and they are gone.

The possibilities are (1) you stay up this year and make a slight profit, or (2) you get relegated and lose everything. It's an all-risk and little-reward proposition.

In my opinion the PL needs to change its business model to make it more attractive to invest money in clubs outside the big 6.

My personal opinion is that relegating 3 out 14 teams each year is way too much. Until that changes, no one is going to be willing to invest in lower clubs.

 


2017 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Middlesboro
2018 Jan. (Sako) Palace 1 - 0 Burnley
2019 May (Batshuayi, Batshuayi, OG, Van Aanholt, Townsend) Palace 5 - 3 Bournemouth
2020 Feb. (Van Aanholt) Palace 1 - 0 Newcastle

Midlands Eagle Flag 30 Jan 20 6.09am

Originally posted by Wilbraham413

I agree, and the point being that the current Premier League model is a huge disincentive for investment.

Would you personally invest your money in any club outside the top 6? I wouldn't. Watford and Bournemouth seemed safe for years, and this year they are in the relegation hunt. Stoke was a model for years, and they are gone.

The possibilities are (1) you stay up this year and make a slight profit, or (2) you get relegated and lose everything. It's an all-risk and little-reward proposition.

In my opinion the PL needs to change its business model to make it more attractive to invest money in clubs outside the big 6.

My personal opinion is that relegating 3 out 14 teams each year is way too much. Until that changes, no one is going to be willing to invest in lower clubs.

Then why did the Americans buy in in the first place and why doesn't Parish sell out as there must be many willing billionaires willing to buy the club

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 30 Jan 20 6.56am

In my opinion, the Americans miscalculated two big things: stadium redevelopment & Brexit.

That aside, I suspect they feel a mid table finish is realistic without significant spend. They are risk takers & perhaps willing to take that risk.

A better question is why they aren't investing far more to know the market? We clearly aren't fabulous in that regard.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Page 57 of 91 < 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > The moaning about Parish/Hodgson/Freedman thread