This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.09pm
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 9.22pm
Quote Mongo Like Clunge at 25 Feb 2013 9.16pm
Quote Stuk at 25 Feb 2013 9.09pm
They could after all have beaten Sweden to the chase and applied to extradite him from us. Once they have him, I presume they could try him on all sorts of petty matters the like of which i've mentioned.
As it stands there is no case, he should stop using that as his defence against A) going to Sweden and B) breaking our laws. In all fairness the US could not extradite him until he's extradited to Sweeden, that would prevent the Sweedish extradition from the UK. I didn't say they could. I said they had plenty of time to do so before the Swedish case arose, if they'd wanted to.
Optimistic as ever |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 3.37pm
You know this 'illegal' tag is pretty silly. The world isn't a state, international law doesn't operate like a national court. Calling a war illegal in a way is just nonsense....All war is illegal in a sense. If it was officially proven to be 'illegal' which isn't going to happen then who is going to enforce this so called breaking of 'international law'? The UN is pretty clear on what is an isn't legal in terms of war, and has prosecuted a number of war criminals for statute crimes, most notably in result to the conflicts in the Balkans. War Crimes are on the UK statute of laws, and are enforcable, as are crimes against humanity, and even less offences regarding the abuse of public office and fraud offences relating to lying to parliment. Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 3.37pm
Are we going to somehow jail a former president and Prime Minister? How about the other twenty of so countries involved, how culpable are they in this 'illegal war'?.....Sounds very French revolution to me. Yes, we should, even if its only in relation to relatively minor offences, or complicity/conspiracy charges relating to the deaths of UK service men. And we should also pursue cases against others involved if they enter our jurisdiction. I don't care if the US would permit it, I'm not a US citizen, the alleged crimes relating to the UK government and agencys associated are our responsibility to resolve. Ethically, we have a responsibility, as a lawful democracy to present ourselves us such, rather than taking the easy route of sweeping the deaths of innocents and UK citizens under the carpet of convenience. We as a nation seem happy to intervene in the affairs of other nations (Libya) and yet when it comes to the home, we protect the guilty because of their station and status, not their innocence. Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 3.37pm
Even if the US would let it happen...Which it won't The US, who basically fund the UN as we know it would isolate themselves far more. It would be just the excuse that many Republicans would like....The country that attracts all that hate feeds more poor children than most of the rest put together. I don't care what the states does, just because everyone else acts in a manner of moral hypocracy to the deaths of foriegners and our own service men, doesn't mean we should. Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 3.37pm
Everything is a balancing act, we can't have the world just as we'd like it. Well you can, it seems, if you're wealthy enough or powerful enough. In fact it seems if you are the Tony Blair or George Bush and cronies, you can have the world the way you like it. Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 3.37pm
Really, if the reality that some push for actually happened then I think the world would be far more dangerous than it currently is......Probably be forced to be Chinese within a generation if the world were run by 'world government' idealists like yourself. You think the invasion of Iraq made the world safer. Afghanistan and Iraq removed the two major opponants of Iran from the world stage, weakened the security of pakistan, a nuclear power and essentially created a situation that has positively encouraged Iran and North Korea to pursue nuclear capability as a matter of necessity. If anything, the actions of the West in the pursuit of 'democracy in the middle east' has done far more harm than good, and led to massive improvements in the position of Islamist movements (many of whom ultimately will end up looking to the Russians and Chinese for support, and enriching their coffers for arms and technology). Rather than protect us from the tyranny of china, it has promoted Chinese interests world wide.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 26 Feb 2013 5.35pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.01pm
Quote Stuk at 26 Feb 2013 10.50am
Quote banksy at 26 Feb 2013 12.59am
I couldn't agree more with Jamiemartin721. He has made it very clear that Assange should not be in any way terrorised for simply disclosing the dirty secrets of the US and other governments. As such he is doing the world a huge public service. There is a difference between genuine issues of national security and nasty cover ups of wrong doings. What horrified me a few days ago was reading a number of comments on these boards that vilified Assange and made him out to be the villain of the piece. I hope those fans in due course realize how he is doing them and all of us a service by shining light on evil acts. A brave man indeed!
All he really is, is a serial law breaker hiding being a fake political stance. Isn't that what governments have done in their pursuit of him and the consequent media coverage? I'd never really paid much attention to wikileaks or Assange prior to the 'gulf war' revelations, and increasing persicution by assorted embrassed governments. I'd suggest that since its inception in 2006, Wikileaks has served the public interest.
I'd suggest they're no more a public service than the other hackers. They're not hackers, they commit no crime in the obtaining of information, its hosted by them online. They don't actually steal the information, they rely on others to provide it for them. Much in the way news media operates with leaks and informants.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 4.06pm
Rendition and imprisonment without trial are both wrong. That's my position on that....What to do about it, well that's another question. Isn't this why we have a secret service, to do the dirty things, and not get caught (or at least make them deniable). How hard is it to actually get a conviction for conspiracy to commit terrorist offences - We didn't need special rules against the Irish Republicans, or torture or rendition - You only have to show three or more people in cahoots to break the law, and its then down to them to prove their innocence (Conspiracy charges are unusual as the onis is on the accused to prove their innocence). Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 4.06pm
On the wider point I don't believe in letting possible threats knowingly walk the streets and I don't agree it's valid to spend large amounts of money keeping tabs on thousands of people. Problem is, most of the people picked up aren't really that much of a threat. Mostly they were people who were pro-Islamist in their home nation and involved in terrorist funding overseas, and we'd turned a blind eye to them between the 1980s and 2001. After 9/11 they served much more as people who provoked the media, rather than actually carried a real threat or risk to citizens of the UK (those held in Belmarsh for example, were advocates of Jyhad). All of them had pretty much committed offences for which they could have been jailed, just not very serious ones. Although after the new labour anti-terrorist laws, it became very easy to become a terrorist, even by association. The degree to which someone is a threat, when the evidence is suppressed, and the hearings held in closed court, with no jury, is entirely down to the statement of those making the accusation.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| Pinky |
|
|---|---|
|
New Statesman has a lot of stuff about Assange by a variety of writers (not all supportive, by any means), covering the legal arguments in some depth and even indulging in a little character assassination along the way.
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stirlingsays at 26 Feb 2013 7.38pm
I've seen statistics on Saddam's rule that put the annual death toll from him at levels near post-war 'civil war' levels anyway. Well, the realistic ones.....The difference between Saddam and the war was eventually those numbers were going to vastly reduce.....Under Saddam he was horribly constant and effective with his secret service. Now Iraq has no sanctions, selling oil and increasing its yield. Deaths are way down, economic activity far higher. Iraq now has the opportunity of actually becoming far richer still due to its oil....That oil that everyone said the West were stealing. By no means is it ideal but the future is far brighter for Iraq than it was before. Edited by Stirlingsays (26 Feb 2013 8.10pm) Apart from the militas, the bombings and the death squads, a corrupt police force, sectarian politics, increasing fundermentist movements, privitised resources, persicution of women and gay men, its looking really bright. Iraq will not become a stable modern democracy. The country might not even avoid a full scale civil war. The government is barely functioning. As for the other arabic nations, those uprisings will deliver increasingly fundermentalist and anti-secular, anti western governments.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
|
Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.52pm
Quote Kermit8 at 22 Feb 2013 3.45pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.38pm
Quote Kermit8 at 22 Feb 2013 3.31pm
Quote Stuk at 22 Feb 2013 3.20pm
Quote Kermit8 at 22 Feb 2013 3.04pm
Or he could be given safe passage to a Quito bound plane from Heathrow if evidence from Sweden is suspect rather than hand him over to the Americans via Stockholm and a 50 year prison sentence for speaking freely. We'll just ignore international law then will we? If we're gonna do that I'd rather storm the embassy and accidentally kill him. Come on you bleeding heart lefties. That's 2000 baby incubators he's cost, or 28,000 weeks of state pension.
Should never have come to the UK to start with and his own nation doesn't want to get involved. It also will not happen. Enjoy:
But he is not in the UK, is he? Also, he has been accused of rape. Not been found guilty of but accused of. If he has a case to answer then fair enough but until then isn't it obvious and wise to presume innocence and to presume some very powerful people want him put away for a very long time. But not for rape. Yes he is in the UK, I suggest you read the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic relations. Enjoy: [Link] Not a good argument against being extradited from the UK to Sweden when you stand more chance of what you're fighting against, by staying where you are. Who said he'd been found guilty? I want him to go and face trial but more specifically to f*** off and stop costing us money. Wonder why u complain about any money being saved by the government as you'll never personally gain from it, probably redirected to Kabul, so u' d rather have someone unfairly locked up for money u ll never ever spend? Says a lot about u mate Edited by binchaud (27 Feb 2013 9.25am)
|
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote Stuk at 28 Feb 2013 5.41pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 6.05pm
Quote Stuk at 26 Feb 2013 5.35pm
Quote jamiemartin721 at 26 Feb 2013 12.01pm
Quote Stuk at 26 Feb 2013 10.50am
Quote banksy at 26 Feb 2013 12.59am
I couldn't agree more with Jamiemartin721. He has made it very clear that Assange should not be in any way terrorised for simply disclosing the dirty secrets of the US and other governments. As such he is doing the world a huge public service. There is a difference between genuine issues of national security and nasty cover ups of wrong doings. What horrified me a few days ago was reading a number of comments on these boards that vilified Assange and made him out to be the villain of the piece. I hope those fans in due course realize how he is doing them and all of us a service by shining light on evil acts. A brave man indeed!
All he really is, is a serial law breaker hiding being a fake political stance. Isn't that what governments have done in their pursuit of him and the consequent media coverage? I'd never really paid much attention to wikileaks or Assange prior to the 'gulf war' revelations, and increasing persicution by assorted embrassed governments. I'd suggest that since its inception in 2006, Wikileaks has served the public interest.
I'd suggest they're no more a public service than the other hackers. They're not hackers, they commit no crime in the obtaining of information, its hosted by them online. They don't actually steal the information, they rely on others to provide it for them. Much in the way news media operates with leaks and informants.
Not really the same, as the exercise there is the theft for profit. Its no different than how every newspaper in the country operates (except for the stings and paying for stories). It strikes me that people who have an issue with wikileaks deflect away from the idea that it serves the public interest in an era where newsmedia companies have become very 'cosy' with government and the state.
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.