You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a gay player
November 16 2026 1.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

We need a gay player


Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >
Seth Flag On a pale blue dot 17 Jan 14 12.53am

Quote rednblueblood at 16 Jan 2014 11.20pm

Quote Seth at 16 Jan 2014 1.17pm

Quote rednblueblood at 16 Jan 2014 1.14pm

Quote slubglurge at 16 Jan 2014 1.08pm

I dont care if we sign a player who is gay, straight bisexual, tranny, hermaphrodite or looks like Lily Savage. All i want is that he scores the goals that keep us up.


We have all the above in GM he will be back soon and "banging em in "

Are you saying GM is gay, straight bisexual, tranny, hermaphrodite and looks like Lily Savage?

Yep


In that case I have no problem, although his missus might want to have a word.

 


"You can feel the stadium jumping. The stadium is actually physically moving up and down"
FA Cup MOTD 24/4/16

Deano39666 Flag Whyteleafe 17 Jan 14 1.10am

As a openly gay palace season ticket holder ( and there are a good few of us ) I always find it amusing on here, when you guys say there is no homophobia at palace. The chants that come out of the holmesdale have often made me cringe. Most of it believe it or not comes from the younger kids in the lower holmesdale, which is surprising to me, as most say they are " gay friendly" or have gay mates. A gay player at palace or any other club can only be a good thing for sport in general. I have heard of some players who have not yet come out, but I do think its a matter of time.


 

Palace Pat Flag Adelaide 17 Jan 14 1.39am

Quote Deano39666 at 17 Jan 2014 1.10am

As a openly gay palace season ticket holder ( and there are a good few of us ) I always find it amusing on here, when you guys say there is no homophobia at palace. The chants that come out of the holmesdale have often made me cringe. Most of it believe it or not comes from the younger kids in the lower holmesdale, which is surprising to me, as most say they are " gay friendly" or have gay mates. A gay player at palace or any other club can only be a good thing for sport in general. I have heard of some players who have not yet come out, but I do think its a matter of time.


There's no homophobia at Palace, Deano, only "banter" under the guise of which any and all behaviour is acceptable in a football ground. Didn't you know that?

While I wouldn't suggest it as a priority consideration when looking for new signings, I would be very proud if the first openly gay Premiership player was a Palace player. Just like I was very proud that Palace got involved in the anti-homphobia in football campaign.

It's only a matter of time before a current player does come out. They'll have a rough ride of it too given the seemingly prevailing attitude that homophobic abuse is somehow acceptable in football.

If that did happen (a Palace player comes out as gay), I have a question for those that think homophobic "banter" is acceptable. When opposition team's supporters, or players, abuse that Palace player due to his sexuality - how would you react?

Edited by Palace Pat (17 Jan 2014 1.42am)

 


Sh*t. What? Rollers. No. Yeah. Sh*t.

Crystal Palace F.C. Adelaide Supporters Facebook group > [Link]

Crystal Palace FC Australia Network > [Link]

homes Flag New Eltham 17 Jan 14 5.43am

Quote Palace Pat at 17 Jan 2014 1.39am

Quote Deano39666 at 17 Jan 2014 1.10am

As a openly gay palace season ticket holder ( and there are a good few of us ) I always find it amusing on here, when you guys say there is no homophobia at palace. The chants that come out of the holmesdale have often made me cringe. Most of it believe it or not comes from the younger kids in the lower holmesdale, which is surprising to me, as most say they are " gay friendly" or have gay mates. A gay player at palace or any other club can only be a good thing for sport in general. I have heard of some players who have not yet come out, but I do think its a matter of time.


There's no homophobia at Palace, Deano, only "banter" under the guise of which any and all behaviour is acceptable in a football ground. Didn't you know that?

While I wouldn't suggest it as a priority consideration when looking for new signings, I would be very proud if the first openly gay Premiership player was a Palace player. Just like I was very proud that Palace got involved in the anti-homphobia in football campaign.

It's only a matter of time before a current player does come out. They'll have a rough ride of it too given the seemingly prevailing attitude that homophobic abuse is somehow acceptable in football.

If that did happen (a Palace player comes out as gay), I have a question for those that think homophobic "banter" is acceptable. When opposition team's supporters, or players, abuse that Palace player due to his sexuality - how would you react?

Edited by Palace Pat (17 Jan 2014 1.42am)


Personally I think the "homophobic" chanting will stop once the first player comes out.

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 17 Jan 14 7.21am

Quote Deano39666 at 17 Jan 2014 1.10am

As a openly gay palace season ticket holder ( and there are a good few of us ) I always find it amusing on here, when you guys say there is no homophobia at palace. The chants that come out of the holmesdale have often made me cringe. Most of it believe it or not comes from the younger kids in the lower holmesdale, which is surprising to me, as most say they are " gay friendly" or have gay mates. A gay player at palace or any other club can only be a good thing for sport in general. I have heard of some players who have not yet come out, but I do think its a matter of time.


Without trying to belittle your views on this or disrespect them - you are right - I think that the homophobia you hear, as with a lot of football supporter vocalisation over the years, is not really a fear or intolerance or rabid hatred of something but more the immature voice of the mob and individual.

The insecure people who sing such stuff in the street and on their own I bet don't really care about peoples sexuality. But put them in a crowd and they want to make an impression - good or bad. Attention seeking basically.

I think if there was genuine and real deep-set homophobia at Palace a la Zimbabwe you wouldn't go.


 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Deano39666 Flag Whyteleafe 17 Jan 14 7.31am

Pat, Holmes, Kermit
I couldn't have written a better reply than you guys. I take my hat off to you.

 


[Link]

ProudAndPalace LGTB

subbuteoeagle Flag Uckfield 17 Jan 14 7.31am

Neatly put by Kermit. Its like we all called stuff, and other kids, gay at school but when one of your closest mates tells you he's on that side of the street, you shut up a bit and don't go along with the mob anymore. Must have happened to a few of us down the years.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 17 Jan 14 8.34am

Quote Palace Pat at 17 Jan 2014 1.39am

Quote Deano39666 at 17 Jan 2014 1.10am

As a openly gay palace season ticket holder ( and there are a good few of us ) I always find it amusing on here, when you guys say there is no homophobia at palace. The chants that come out of the holmesdale have often made me cringe. Most of it believe it or not comes from the younger kids in the lower holmesdale, which is surprising to me, as most say they are " gay friendly" or have gay mates. A gay player at palace or any other club can only be a good thing for sport in general. I have heard of some players who have not yet come out, but I do think its a matter of time.


There's no homophobia at Palace, Deano, only "banter" under the guise of which any and all behaviour is acceptable in a football ground. Didn't you know that?

While I wouldn't suggest it as a priority consideration when looking for new signings, I would be very proud if the first openly gay Premiership player was a Palace player. Just like I was very proud that Palace got involved in the anti-homphobia in football campaign.

It's only a matter of time before a current player does come out. They'll have a rough ride of it too given the seemingly prevailing attitude that homophobic abuse is somehow acceptable in football.

If that did happen (a Palace player comes out as gay), I have a question for those that think homophobic "banter" is acceptable. When opposition team's supporters, or players, abuse that Palace player due to his sexuality - how would you react?

Edited by Palace Pat (17 Jan 2014 1.42am)


It took 9 pages but finally we get back to my point. Although you guys have made it more eloqently than I did.

Can we get ready for what I hope is inevitable and pave the way for someone to feel comfortable to be openly gay and a Premiership player. Let it be us, let's be that club, the one that gets a minor comment in the history books because we bucked the trend, stood up to the childish people and supported someone doing something really brave.

And if we get comments like 'Dozens of people on here are taking the piss out of you and hundreds of others are laughing at you' I, for one, couldn't care less. Because we are Palace, we do things we want to do.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 17 Jan 14 8.39am

Quote subbuteoeagle at 17 Jan 2014 7.31am

Neatly put by Kermit. Its like we all called stuff, and other kids, gay at school but when one of your closest mates tells you he's on that side of the street, you shut up a bit and don't go along with the mob anymore. Must have happened to a few of us down the years.

I have a Gay Nephew and Cousins and will join in with the we scored three song. I am not homophobic and its more an anti Brighton song than about gays, I will also call someone a Queer,Bender,Faggott ect in banter but doesn't mean I hate gays. We have at least 1 gay player possibly 2,This wouldn't stop me singing any song at Selhurst. Even the gay fans amongst probably sing the same songs.

 

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 17 Jan 14 8.44am

Quote subbuteoeagle at 17 Jan 2014 7.31am

Neatly put by Kermit. Its like we all called stuff, and other kids, gay at school but when one of your closest mates tells you he's on that side of the street, you shut up a bit and don't go along with the mob anymore. Must have happened to a few of us down the years.

Actually, it's probably my few gay mates who call stuff "gay" the most, and take the piss out of others for being "gay" with the most frequency. They're probably also the ones starting the majority gay chants at football - the younger generations (and I am in my 30's) like to appropriate this stuff and essentially take the piss out of all that old homophobia.


 

paperhat Flag croydon 17 Jan 14 9.16am

Quote Mapletree at 16 Jan 2014 9.02pm

Quote adrian b at 16 Jan 2014 6.12pm

Quote Mapletree at 16 Jan 2014 12.43pm

I was thinking how cool it would be to have the first openly gay Prem League footballer. Maybe even two.

I think we are uniquely placed to live with the consequences, a tight-knit supportive club and group of fans, based in a highly cosmopolitan place. And we don't give a monkey's what anyone else thinks.

Any views? I am sure there will be a range.

I am certain Palace have had many gay players. Like the other teams in the Prem I bet Palace already have at least two now. They just need the bravery to come out foe their own sake.

So what have we learned so far:

1 It doesn't matter if someone is openly gay, nobody cares
2 But we wouldn't want anyone to come out because they would get lots of stick
3 There is no need to consider whether we are gay friendly
4 If we were to try to make our club gay friendly then we wouldn't get any good players
5 We are already so gay friendly that we have a player who is gay in the first team
6 But nobody knows who it is - or at least nobody is saying
7 In any case we are all sure he wouldn't want to come out
8 And if he did we would have to immediately transfer him to Brighton
9 I must be gay

Did I get it all correct?

Doesn't anyone find it boring being so flaming predictable, can't we all try something a bit radical for a change?


Hand holding in the Holmesdale?

(sorry, couldnt resist it)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Deano39666 Flag Whyteleafe 17 Jan 14 9.30am

It's interesting that some of you guys think palace do have gay players, I for one would be very happy of course as this would be ground breaking if they came out. But in this climate at palace with the "chants" I don't think even if they were comfortable with there sexuality they would come out.

 


[Link]

ProudAndPalace LGTB

SE9 EAGLE Flag 17 Jan 14 10.02am

My feeling is that in a modern,liberal society like ours the vast majority of people are not homophobic,racist,anti disabled and the like.What we dont like is being told what we can laugh at and indeed what we should be thinking by Peter Tatchell,the Duggan family and the Muslim Council of Great Britain.Its also not suprising at football where we go to enjoy ourselves and have a few beers in a largely working class,blokey, anglo-saxon enviroment that we get a bit near the mark...

 

Hoof Hearted 17 Jan 14 10.15am

Quote Deano39666 at 17 Jan 2014 7.31am

Pat, Holmes, Kermit
I couldn't have written a better reply than you guys. I take my hat off to you.


Is that hat brown Deano?

Sorry mate........ old habits die hard

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 14 10.20am

It's only a matter of time before a current player does come out. They'll have a rough ride


Ouch.

A player will come out at the end, or towards the end of their career. Too much at stake.

 


COYP

sydtheeagle Flag England 17 Jan 14 10.32am

My own view is that most of us do and say a lot of things that are probably politically incorrect and, unfortunately, offensive to some people -- particularly the more thin-skinned among us. But with the exception of a small minority of genuine bigots that you'll find anywhere, I don't think many of the tongue-in-cheek "bender"-type comments are fuelled by genuine hate or even dislike or disrespect. If you want to live in a cosseted world where there really is nothing edgy, there are strict limits on humour, and where everything is treated with cut-glass respect and there is never a risk of causing offense then you can probably make a case for that but personally, I wouldn't want to live there. I'd rather step over the mark occasionally, secure in the knowledge that those people who know me can judge my character accurately and will forgive me if I do, occasionally, screw up. So I think, right now, the balance is about right. And if I ever offend you, don't be a bender. Just laugh.

Edited by sydtheeagle (17 Jan 2014 10.33am)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Jan 14 10.33am

Quote paperhat at 17 Jan 2014 9.16am

Quote Mapletree at 16 Jan 2014 9.02pm

Quote adrian b at 16 Jan 2014 6.12pm

Quote Mapletree at 16 Jan 2014 12.43pm

I was thinking how cool it would be to have the first openly gay Prem League footballer. Maybe even two.

I think we are uniquely placed to live with the consequences, a tight-knit supportive club and group of fans, based in a highly cosmopolitan place. And we don't give a monkey's what anyone else thinks.

Any views? I am sure there will be a range.

I am certain Palace have had many gay players. Like the other teams in the Prem I bet Palace already have at least two now. They just need the bravery to come out foe their own sake.

So what have we learned so far:

1 It doesn't matter if someone is openly gay, nobody cares
2 But we wouldn't want anyone to come out because they would get lots of stick
3 There is no need to consider whether we are gay friendly
4 If we were to try to make our club gay friendly then we wouldn't get any good players
5 We are already so gay friendly that we have a player who is gay in the first team
6 But nobody knows who it is - or at least nobody is saying
7 In any case we are all sure he wouldn't want to come out
8 And if he did we would have to immediately transfer him to Brighton
9 I must be gay

Did I get it all correct?

Doesn't anyone find it boring being so flaming predictable, can't we all try something a bit radical for a change?


Hand holding in the Holmesdale?

(sorry, couldnt resist it)


I think you need a rethink on point 4, probably more.

How do you encourage coming out for footballers? Singing, 'Oh South London is wonderful, it's full of heterosexuals, homosexuals and bi-sexuals, oh South London is wonderful?' Or playing Jimmy Sommerville tracks, or a couple of boy dancers in The Crystals for the women and gays?

A serious point here, and some of what I've just said has some seriousness to it, maybe all this kind of encouraging coming out puts just as much pressure on a gay player as much as him keeping it PRIVATE for his limited time as a footballer, something he might just do without when trying to compete for his place, club, career, contract.... Probably why I couldn't give a sh1t which Palace player is gay or not. Leave him to it, his life and job.

 


COYP

thommo1 Flag Peckham 17 Jan 14 10.38am

The thing is Maple and with respect I think your missing the point no pun intended but I think what most people are saying on here is that IF we have or signed a openly gay player then the vast majority of the Palace fans would not give two hoots and get behind him, again no pun intended.

What you seem to be saying is that we should actively go out and find a gay player just so we can be regarded as cool and that is what people are finding a bit.. well .. not really how constructing a skillful sporting team is all about really.

 


DJ John Peel once said: "Supporting Palace has a certain cult value, like pretending that some Peruvian rock band is the best in the world."

Hoof Hearted 17 Jan 14 10.41am

Quote sydtheeagle at 17 Jan 2014 10.32am

My own view is that most of us do and say a lot of things that are probably politically incorrect and, unfortunately, offensive to some people -- particularly the more thin-skinned among us. But with the exception of a small minority of genuine bigots that you'll find anywhere, I don't think many of the tongue-in-cheek "bender"-type comments are fuelled by genuine hate or even dislike or disrespect. If you want to live in a cosseted world where there really is nothing edgy, there are strict limits on humour, and where everything is treated with cut-glass respect and there is never a risk of causing offense then you can probably make a case for that but personally, I wouldn't want to live there. I'd rather step over the mark occasionally, secure in the knowledge that those people who know me can judge my character accurately and will forgive me if I do, occasionally, screw up. So I think, right now, the balance is about right. And if I ever offend you, don't be a bender. Just laugh.

Edited by sydtheeagle (17 Jan 2014 10.33am)


I could kiss you syd for that clarification.

(Fuels suspicion that Hoof is gay)

 

SE9 EAGLE Flag 17 Jan 14 10.48am

Seems to me it not the gays,blacks or muslims that get upset but their lilly livered,bearded,sandal wearing,Guardian reading bed wetters that take offence.Not really sure the minorities appreciate their fawning interference.Call me a bluff old traditionalist my I would machine gun the lot of them....

 

Page 6 of 9 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > We need a gay player