You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dwight Gayle
November 16 2026 12.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dwight Gayle


Page 6 of 13 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
Icepick Tony Flag Chester 30 Apr 14 5.22pm

Quote Happiness Stan at 30 Apr 2014 4.29pm

And on 20k per week, how long do you continue to hold out for a players potential?

If he was a local lad thru the youth team on 5k pw then great, keep him at the club as back up and to provide a but of pace off the bench.

But given we have already paid 4.5m last Summer, and 1.5m this jan (got this on v good authority), plus approximately 1m in wages, it really does look like a shocking bit of business.p

If it is viable and within the structure of the club then I think 18 months - 2 years for him to settle and show us what he is capable of is not unfair. 10 months of fleeting appearances is very unfair.

How many players do we have on the books that play absolutely no game time but still take a wage home every week? Gayle plays, sporadically and mainly from the bench granted but that is far more than some others at the club and his goal that got us 3 points at Villa contributed to another season in the league.

Players generally peak at 26-27 so Gayle still has a lot of time to improve and if he nets double figures next season is he still going to be a shocking bit of business?

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 30 Apr 14 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Apr 14 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Icepick Tony Flag Chester 30 Apr 14 5.51pm

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.

I would imagine investing in a player that they knew full well could produce the goods in the Championship should we go down yet was young enough to potentially adapt to life in the Premiership should we stay there. I don't think giving Gayle 9 months and then tossing him onto the used pile is fair or reasonable.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Apr 14 5.57pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.51pm

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.

I would imagine investing in a player that they knew full well could produce the goods in the Championship should we go down yet was young enough to potentially adapt to life in the Premiership should we stay there. I don't think giving Gayle 9 months and then tossing him onto the used pile is fair or reasonable.


That's football. Same happened with Wright's replacement Gabbiadini. We were right to cut him loose early.

If we do sign a couple of strikers (proven at the higher level) then Dwight will be possibly 6th choice.

Unfair on the lad to keep him imo if that transpires.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Icepick Tony Flag Chester 30 Apr 14 6.12pm

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.57pm

That's football. Same happened with Wright's replacement Gabbiadini. We were right to cut him loose early.

If we do sign a couple of strikers (proven at the higher level) then Dwight will be possibly 6th choice.

Unfair on the lad to keep him imo if that transpires.

Of course but I doubt it will. I also think that Gayle would prefer to stay with us and actually benefit more due to feeling wanted and having a regular home instead of being shipped off again to 4th club in 3 years.

Comparing the two there is a bit strange, for 1 Gayle was not a replacement for anyone. Second, he was definitely bought as a rough stone to polish and Marco was the finished article replacing a very prolific striker.

None of us know what Pulis plans are for Gayle or if he rates him or not, I would say that judging by the fact he makes the bench and has got game time then he is still in his plans and he is slowly getting him used to life in the Prem.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Happiness Stan Flag Itchycoo Park 30 Apr 14 6.13pm

Quote coulsdoneagle at 30 Apr 2014 4.39pm

Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Apr 2014 4.17pm

One thing that's interesting is just how divisive Gayle is in terms of opinions. We have a few players whose popularity is somewhat "mixed" but with most of them -- KG for example -- many of us can see both sides of the coin. But where Gayle is concerned, most of us are firmly in one camp or the other (he'll develop or no, he won't). Not much point repeating what I've already said about my own view though I admire the faith of the pro-Gayle camp because there is certainly no real physical evidence to support the belief that he will become a Premiership striker at this point in time. Anyway, the summer will be revealing; I am genuinely fascinated to see whether we stick or twist.


Glen Murray played about 20 games this season including starts scored 0 goals from open play and 1 pen

Gayle Played about 20 games this season, all bit part appearences at the end of games scored 3 goals 2 open play and 1 pen

Scored against a top 4 side and scored the goal of the season for us

he clearly has ability but has been rushed from non league to the toughest league in the world.

Murray returned from a 9 month lay off with a truly horrific injury, into a side shy of goals in a division he's never played. Entirely wrong to judge him from those appearances. After a full pre season and a good run in the side, fair enough. Not worth mentioning til next November IMHO.

 


"How can I remember to keep it all together when half the moon is taken away?"

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 30 Apr 14 6.21pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 6.12pm

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.57pm

That's football. Same happened with Wright's replacement Gabbiadini. We were right to cut him loose early.

If we do sign a couple of strikers (proven at the higher level) then Dwight will be possibly 6th choice.

Unfair on the lad to keep him imo if that transpires.

Of course but I doubt it will. I also think that Gayle would prefer to stay with us and actually benefit more due to feeling wanted and having a regular home instead of being shipped off again to 4th club in 3 years.

Comparing the two there is a bit strange, for 1 Gayle was not a replacement for anyone. Second, he was definitely bought as a rough stone to polish and Marco was the finished article replacing a very prolific striker.

None of us know what Pulis plans are for Gayle or if he rates him or not, I would say that judging by the fact he makes the bench and has got game time then he is still in his plans and he is slowly getting him used to life in the Prem.


Maybe.

I'm just an old cynic

Been following football way too long. I do hope it is one of those very rare occasions that I am wrong.

I'm not though.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Icepick Tony Flag Chester 30 Apr 14 6.22pm

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 6.21pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 6.12pm

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.57pm

That's football. Same happened with Wright's replacement Gabbiadini. We were right to cut him loose early.

If we do sign a couple of strikers (proven at the higher level) then Dwight will be possibly 6th choice.

Unfair on the lad to keep him imo if that transpires.

Of course but I doubt it will. I also think that Gayle would prefer to stay with us and actually benefit more due to feeling wanted and having a regular home instead of being shipped off again to 4th club in 3 years.

Comparing the two there is a bit strange, for 1 Gayle was not a replacement for anyone. Second, he was definitely bought as a rough stone to polish and Marco was the finished article replacing a very prolific striker.

None of us know what Pulis plans are for Gayle or if he rates him or not, I would say that judging by the fact he makes the bench and has got game time then he is still in his plans and he is slowly getting him used to life in the Prem.


Maybe.

I'm just an old cynic

Been following football way too long. I do hope it is one of those very rare occasions that I am wrong.

I'm not though.


 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

slubglurge Flag welling 01 May 14 10.32am

I still think Gayle can be nurtured to play the Jerome role. Forget the lack of height because we don't play the ball to Jerome in the air anyway. He will probably need to beef up a bit but he is clearly a better finisher and similar to him pace wise. As a counter attacking team he would suit that role particularly away from home ie, Villa and WBA(cup). With a good pre season under his belt he could come up trumps.

 

sydtheeagle Flag England 01 May 14 11.41am

Quote slubglurge at 01 May 2014 10.32am

I still think Gayle can be nurtured to play the Jerome role. Forget the lack of height because we don't play the ball to Jerome in the air anyway. He will probably need to beef up a bit but he is clearly a better finisher and similar to him pace wise. As a counter attacking team he would suit that role particularly away from home ie, Villa and WBA(cup). With a good pre season under his belt he could come up trumps.

I would say that Jerome's one great strength (holding the ball up and bringing others into play) is Gayle's biggest weakness (his pass completion percentage is appalling; half the time the only thing he brings into play is the opposition.) Not saying that Gayle might not have strengths as a striker, but I think the chances of him playing the Jerome role effectively are vanishingly small because the best of Jerome is the worst of Gayle and, quite likely, vice versa. If we are going to accommodate Gayle, it won't be using the approach we have now.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Esteban Flag Addiscombe 01 May 14 2.34pm

You're still a miserable s*d! and I stand by my comments about about Galyle's game time

Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Apr 2014 3.16pm

Quote Esteban at 29 Apr 2014 11.48pm

Jesus, you lot are a miserable bunch of bumsniffers! This has got to be our best season in the Loadsadosh league and all you can do is pick on a player who you possibly watched for an hour all season and then you decide he's no good based on what? Nothing intelligent!


You've got to be a troll because the reasons this is an unbelievably dim-witted post are about ten miles long starting with the fact that most contributors to this thread also contribute to hundreds of other threads too so they are hardly and picking on Gayle as the only thing worth talking about and secondly because -- (you seem unaware of this so let me allow you into a really big secret )-- this is the Internet and it actually exists as a forum for people to air their opinions about subjects like Gayle.

Like I said, troll.


 


Old Father Time

Aut insanit homo, aut versus facit

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 01 May 14 2.44pm

We wouldn't even be discussing Dwight if we had just paid £1.5mill for him. Just be another Dobbie or Kebe.

The subtext is always the actual money we did pay. Was it a huge huge waste or not?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


sydtheeagle Flag England 01 May 14 2.45pm

Quote Esteban at 01 May 2014 2.34pm

You're still a miserable s*d! and I stand by my comments about about Galyle's game time

Quote sydtheeagle at 30 Apr 2014 3.16pm


1. When you start your post by calling people a bunch of "bumsniffers" you'll probably find they then often won't focus on the substance of what you said.

2. When you base your conclusion on something about which you have no idea (for instance, how do you know how many times I saw Gayle play for Peterborough last season? As it happens, I live a lot closer to Peterborough than I do to Palace) then you can reasonably expect not to be taken seriously.

Edited by sydtheeagle (01 May 2014 2.46pm)

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

jcreedy Flag 02 May 14 9.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.


We didn't pay half that amount for Dwight Gayle.

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 02 May 14 10.01am

Quote jcreedy at 02 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.


We didn't pay half that amount for Dwight Gayle.


4 year contract plus transfer fee = £10mill (£6 mill WAS the transfer fee according to Darren Ferguson and he should know)

Edited by Kermit8 (02 May 2014 10.03am)

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


sydtheeagle Flag England 02 May 14 10.01am

Quote jcreedy at 02 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.


We didn't pay half that amount for Dwight Gayle.

I think with regard to the above two things.

1. None of us knows exactly what we paid for Dwight, but you can take it as read that whatever it was, it was almost certainly less than the exaggerated amount reported in the Press.

2. I don't think we "got away" with anything. In our position, we had to take a gamble because we were unlikely to attract a proven Premiership scorer. Even if we'd gone down, Gayle wouldn't have been a bad gamble to take (at the right price). OK, thus far it hasn't really worked out but even if we'd been relegated, we'd not be badly off as we'd have a player far more suited to contributing next season in the Championship than will probably be the case in the Premiership.

 


Sydenham by birth. Selhurst by the Grace of God.

Plane Flag Bromley 02 May 14 10.22am

Quote Kermit8 at 02 May 2014 10.01am

Quote jcreedy at 02 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.


We didn't pay half that amount for Dwight Gayle.


4 year contract plus transfer fee = £10mill (£6 mill WAS the transfer fee according to Darren Ferguson and he should know)

Edited by Kermit8 (02 May 2014 10.03am)


Dunno but I'd trust the accounts that were filed by the club.

 

paperhat Flag croydon 02 May 14 10.32am

Quote Plane at 02 May 2014 10.22am

Quote Kermit8 at 02 May 2014 10.01am

Quote jcreedy at 02 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.


We didn't pay half that amount for Dwight Gayle.


4 year contract plus transfer fee = £10mill (£6 mill WAS the transfer fee according to Darren Ferguson and he should know)

Edited by Kermit8 (02 May 2014 10.03am)


Dunno but I'd trust the accounts that were filed by the club.


which show how much?

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


Plane Flag Bromley 02 May 14 10.39am

Quote paperhat at 02 May 2014 10.32am

Quote Plane at 02 May 2014 10.22am

Quote Kermit8 at 02 May 2014 10.01am

Quote jcreedy at 02 May 2014 9.21am

Quote Kermit8 at 30 Apr 2014 5.38pm

Quote Icepick Tony at 30 Apr 2014 5.27pm

Quote jcreedy at 30 Apr 2014 2.30pm

Some people forget how far he's come in such a short space of time. That improvement won't stop, and TP is looking forward to working on him in pre-season. He's going to be great for us.


This with bells on, running out infront of TV cameras and 25k + fans is a massive leap from 4k at Bishop's Stortford. Not to mention the caliber of players you are up against! All in 2 years....

Edited by Icepick Tony (30 Apr 2014 5.27pm)


Which again begs the question - what on earth were Crystal Palace Fc doing putting faith to the tune of nearly £10mill in such a player?

We've gotten away with it this time because we are staying up.


We didn't pay half that amount for Dwight Gayle.


4 year contract plus transfer fee = £10mill (£6 mill WAS the transfer fee according to Darren Ferguson and he should know)

Edited by Kermit8 (02 May 2014 10.03am)


Dunno but I'd trust the accounts that were filed by the club.


which show how much?

That show we spent £16.25m in summer transfers. Which leaves a total spend of £10.25m for the other 15 players and with what are perceived to be known about the other transfers, it doesn't add up. I do realise that several of those we got in were free.

What Kermit always forgets is that it's a fee of up to £6m but I'll always keep reminding him of the facts. It's akin to saying we got £15m for Wilf, we didn't.

 

Page 6 of 13 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dwight Gayle