You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch better than Wilf
November 16 2026 11.09am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Punch better than Wilf


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Gribbo Flag Bromley 01 May 14 10.52pm

Wilf great last season outstanding in the play offs and will always be loved for that.

Punch playing a division up, scoring goals for fun in key 1-0 3-point wins, and with the great TPs influence puts in a shift for the team when on the backfoot. Could never see Wilf doing that - didn't do it for Man U, not doing it for Cardiff.

Wilf has a lot to do to match JP's work rate, and JP never goes missing in the 90 minutes. Can remember towards the end of last season in Holloway's darkest days, you would sometimes forget Wilf was on the pitch.

JP always there and always a threat. Definitely in my starting 11 for next year.

Well done Jason - you proved a lot of people wrong.

 

Leecpfc Flag Praying for love in a lapdance... 01 May 14 11.10pm

I disagree. Strongly.

 


Raised on a diet of broken biscuits

TUX Flag redhill 01 May 14 11.12pm

Wilf run Utd ragged at OT 2YRS AGO in the League Cup. Wilf has an England cap.
Wilf beat the Seaweed.
Wilf got the penalty that KP buried.
Wilf is young, JP is in his prime.
Wilf/Punch are not the hardest workers in a team.....so what.

Why judge where Wilf is ATM let alone compare him to a seasoned pro who's had a decent last half season?
I guess you're young instead of deluded. Hopefully not both.

 

Eunectes Flag Aberystwyth 01 May 14 11.32pm

Either way, I wouldn't complain if both were in our squad.

 

We R Palace No 1 Flag 01 May 14 11.36pm


Bit harsh, some comments just hammering down Puncheon to Wilf. Both have done the business in different leagues. We are unable to judge Wilf in the prem as hes not had much game time at both United and Cardiff. When hes played for Cardiff he has been good in a few games, others he looks like hes not bothered. Moving on I think Punch this season has proven his worth.

Puncheon has a better final ball and a better finish than Wilf, the reason a lot of people like Wilf so much is because he can bring something special out of nowhere with his flair and pace. Overall I think Puncheon this season has been just as good as Wilf, the reason for this is Without Zaha we probably more than likely wouldn't be in the prem. BUT! Without Jason this season we would be easily down in the relegation scrap right now, hes scored and assisted crucial goals in our survival this season.

 

paulose17 Flag Sutton 01 May 14 11.50pm

Quote Gribbo at 01 May 2014 10.52pm

Wilf great last season outstanding in the play offs and will always be loved for that.

Punch playing a division up, scoring goals for fun in key 1-0 3-point wins, and with the great TPs influence puts in a shift for the team when on the backfoot. Could never see Wilf doing that - didn't do it for Man U, not doing it for Cardiff.

Wilf has a lot to do to match JP's work rate, and JP never goes missing in the 90 minutes. Can remember towards the end of last season in Holloway's darkest days, you would sometimes forget Wilf was on the pitch.

JP always there and always a threat. Definitely in my starting 11 for next year.

Well done Jason - you proved a lot of people wrong.


I presume this is you Jason? Thanks for the points mate but you could look like you gave a f*** sometimes and that's the difference between you and Wilf...he showed passion for the club and not just for himself.

 


Want a thread killed? Don't delay, special offer on two threads killed at the same time. Just contact paulose17 at the usual address.

Username Flag Horsham 01 May 14 11.56pm

They are very different players in my book.

Puncheon is like a much better (tricker, quicker, stronger) version of Ambrose. He can float in an out of games and then BANG, one moment of quality. He's never going to consistently beat his full back because he's quite predictable. He's at his most dangerous when he can drop in off the wing into a bit of space or when the defence is half asleep.

Wilf is a guy who, like Yannick, needs the ball as much as possible. Unlike JP he is the one who will consistently run a defence ragged and, if he doesn't do the damage himself, will open up gaps for others.

The prospect of all three in the same time, with either Punch or Wilf playing off Chamakh and running at central defenders is terrifying.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

indianapalace85 Flag Bromley 02 May 14 1.37am

Puncheon is a good player playing very well. Zaha is a brilliant player that hasn't been given a chance all season and is consequently unfit.

When Zaha is played all the time at whichever club he ends up at in the summer, he will be the better player and one of the best in the league, without a doubt.

Edited by indianapalace85 (02 May 2014 1.38am)

 

maddog Flag Wiltshire 02 May 14 7.11am

Let's get Wilf back and see who is really the better player.

 

jcreedy Flag 02 May 14 7.34am

Quote paulose17 at 01 May 2014 11.50pm

Quote Gribbo at 01 May 2014 10.52pm

Wilf great last season outstanding in the play offs and will always be loved for that.

Punch playing a division up, scoring goals for fun in key 1-0 3-point wins, and with the great TPs influence puts in a shift for the team when on the backfoot. Could never see Wilf doing that - didn't do it for Man U, not doing it for Cardiff.

Wilf has a lot to do to match JP's work rate, and JP never goes missing in the 90 minutes. Can remember towards the end of last season in Holloway's darkest days, you would sometimes forget Wilf was on the pitch.

JP always there and always a threat. Definitely in my starting 11 for next year.

Well done Jason - you proved a lot of people wrong.


I presume this is you Jason? Thanks for the points mate but you could look like you gave a f*** sometimes and that's the difference between you and Wilf...he showed passion for the club and not just for himself.

You're forgetting how Wilf went missing for a couple of months last winter, and unlike JP, who bought his family an executive box the day after signing for us, he isn't a Palace fan.


Edited by jcreedy (02 May 2014 7.35am)

 


It was my dream to play for Palace and to make my debut. I've always played for the club so if I'm playing here, I wouldn't want to be anywhere else.

- John Bostock (Nov 2007)

Sansbup Flag Norfolk 02 May 14 7.47am

If Wilf had a manager who actually managed him and gave him some confidence back you would see the star player we all knew we had sold to ManUre.

I don't like comparing players. Punch has been great lately and scored many of the goals that have kept us up. Wilf almost single-handedly got us up with his performances in the playoffs. Bring him home and he'll be a star again, he's a fantastic talent.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 02 May 14 8.08am

Punch is a good player, and TP is getting the best out of him no doubt, but wilf can be an exceptional talent, would like him back on loan to see if TP can get him back to his best, if he can then, he could be sensational!

 

Mstrobez Flag 02 May 14 8.13am

This is an absolutely ridiculous thread.

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 02 May 14 8.17am

Better still have both Wilf & Punch & really stick it to them next season

 


Red & Blue since 73'

miles18 Flag Telford 02 May 14 8.41am

Punch can do it in the Prem and Wilf can't yet. Punch at the moment is a better player.

 



.

EagleRider Flag Seasalter, Kent 02 May 14 8.52am

I'll repeat what a few people have said already:

Doesn't matter who's better. Let's have 'em both, then!

Puncheon, Jedinak, Ledley, Wilf in midfield would be a ghastly sight for any defense trying to clear the ball

 

miles18 Flag Telford 02 May 14 9.05am

Quote EagleRider at 02 May 2014 8.52am

I'll repeat what a few people have said already:

Doesn't matter who's better. Let's have 'em both, then!

Puncheon, Jedinak, Ledley, Wilf in midfield would be a ghastly sight for any defense trying to clear the ball


Bolasie deserves his place in our starting 11

 



.

paperhat Flag croydon 02 May 14 9.12am

Quote Gribbo at 01 May 2014 10.52pm

Wilf great last season outstanding in the play offs and will always be loved for that.

Punch playing a division up, scoring goals for fun in key 1-0 3-point wins, and with the great TPs influence puts in a shift for the team when on the backfoot. Could never see Wilf doing that - didn't do it for Man U, not doing it for Cardiff.

Wilf has a lot to do to match JP's work rate, and JP never goes missing in the 90 minutes. Can remember towards the end of last season in Holloway's darkest days, you would sometimes forget Wilf was on the pitch.

JP always there and always a threat. Definitely in my starting 11 for next year.

Well done Jason - you proved a lot of people wrong.

1) Wilf never got the chance for Man Utd. so how can you judge him on non existant performances? As for playing for Cardiff, that shower would make Ronaldo look sh1t.

2) you seem to forget how ineffective Puncheon ws at the start, how he couldn't control a football let alone score.

3) As for never going missing during 90 minutes, are you kidding me? see point 2 above. During his early tenure he was positively invisible at times.

4) Funnilly enough, now his confidence is up, Punch is a threat alot of the time, as was Wilf when he was on a high. Remeber the Playoffs Vs Brighton, thats right, Wilf was sh1t then wasnt he?


Edited by paperhat (02 May 2014 9.13am)

 


Clinton is Clinton. I have known him for a long time, I know his mother... Simon Jordan


ambrose7 Flag Croydon 02 May 14 11.09am

Quote paulose17 at 01 May 2014 11.50pm

Quote Gribbo at 01 May 2014 10.52pm

Wilf great last season outstanding in the play offs and will always be loved for that.

Punch playing a division up, scoring goals for fun in key 1-0 3-point wins, and with the great TPs influence puts in a shift for the team when on the backfoot. Could never see Wilf doing that - didn't do it for Man U, not doing it for Cardiff.

Wilf has a lot to do to match JP's work rate, and JP never goes missing in the 90 minutes. Can remember towards the end of last season in Holloway's darkest days, you would sometimes forget Wilf was on the pitch.

JP always there and always a threat. Definitely in my starting 11 for next year.

Well done Jason - you proved a lot of people wrong.


I presume this is you Jason? Thanks for the points mate but you could look like you gave a f*** sometimes and that's the difference between you and Wilf...he showed passion for the club and not just for himself.

That's very, very harsh and quite unfounded on Puncheon's part. On Wilf's part, you could very easily argue that once he secured his United deal, he put his feet up until about April and suddenly decided to wake up again for the play-offs. I'm not sure that's true, and it seemed he was carrying an injury, but I certainly wouldn't be putting Wilf in the Aki/Hughes class or Punch in the Julian Gray class. Much of a much.

 


26th January 2010 - Enter Administration
2nd May 2010 - D-Day 1 - Survival at Hillsborough
1st June 2010 - D-Day 2 - Survival at Lloyds
7th June 2010 - CPFC2010 exchange contracts.

adrianjacob Flag bournemouth 02 May 14 11.19am

Quote miles18 at 02 May 2014 9.05am

Quote EagleRider at 02 May 2014 8.52am

I'll repeat what a few people have said already:

Doesn't matter who's better. Let's have 'em both, then!

Puncheon, Jedinak, Ledley, Wilf in midfield would be a ghastly sight for any defense trying to clear the ball


Bolasie deserves his place in our starting 11


Must keep Bolasie in the starting

 


I first went to palace when I was 4 a wooden box to sit/stand on and monkey nuts at half time, now 46 years later come on you Eeeeeagles,I

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Punch better than Wilf