This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 4.37pm
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 3.59pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.58am
As for common and garden Islam, there is no such thing as Islamophobia. There are people who dislike Islam and will continue to dislike it no matter what fatuous legislation is enacted. They dislike it for perfectly good, rational, reasons: honour murders, female genital mutilation, Sharia courts, rampant postal vote fraud, trojan horse schools, hate preachers, anti-gay laws (including the death penalty), anti-women laws, anti-apostate laws (including the death penalty, anti-Semitism, etc.corrupt civil administration,
You can't compare the Terry incident with the Moazamm Begg one, particularly given that you are literally suggesting that the verdict of a court of law be subverted, presumably based on nothing. Terry was fined by the FA, but couldn't be charged by the courts because they lacked suitable evidence. My opinion? Of course Terry's a racist prick, but I respect the decision of the courts, who knew a lot more about the case than I did. And on the subject of disliking Islam (which, by the way, is the definition of Islamophobia), do you then also dislike Christianity, a religion which continues to massacre people, mutilate genitalia, regard women as second class citizens, is incredibly homophobic, has had priests convicted of paedophilia, is horribly corrupt, has justified terrorist atrocities, has been insular etc etc. or is Islam worse? Of course you can compare the Terry case with Begg's. Both were found not guilty of offences although many thought them guilty. You think Terry was guilty and a 'racist prick' for saying the word 'black'; I think Begg was guilty and attended a terrorist training camp and facilitated terrorism overseas. (The fact that Terry was fined and banned by the kangaroo court of the FA is neither here nor there.) A 'phobia' is a fear of something, not necessarily a dislike. I don't have much time for any religion, but find it hard to take seriously your comments on Christian genital mutilation (who/where?), women as second class citizens (women Bishops now!), homophobic (see many Christian priests and vicars!). As for them massacring people and justifying terrorism - it must be a strange place on planet Serial.
1. In Ethiopia, a Christian country, FGM affects around 85% of women. In other countries like Mali and Burkina Faso, where significant Christian minorities cohabit with Muslims, levels of FGM in those Christian communities is also worryingly high. FGM occurs all over Africa, whether Muslim, Christian or whatever. 2. Female clergy in one country in one strand of Christianity doth not equality make. Congo's civil war lead to the raping of tens of thousands of women in a Christian country, which is ranked, along with Christian Guatemala, as one of the top 10 worst nations to live in as a woman. Even in Western countries like Britain and America, women are dissuaded from work, and taught to be more docile than their husbands. 3. If you can't see homophobia in Christianity, you're beyond help. 4. Here is a list of 6 terrorist organisations who use Christian teachings and ideologies to justify their means, just as Al-Qaeda/IS do with Islam: [Link] Add to that the mass-murders of Anders Breivik, a radical Christian, and you realise that religious justification for atrocities is actually fairly prominent in Christianity! As a side note, I have nothing against religions. We all follow certain dogmas and superstitions, be they political, theistic, philosophical or nationalistic. Religion has done brilliant humanitarian work, brought solace to millions and provided spiritual guidance across the globe. This is as true of Islam as it is of Christianity. But what is equally true is every religion, from Scientology to Buddhism, has been manipulated for atrocious ends.
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
| derben |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 5.12pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 4.37pm
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 3.59pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.58am
As for common and garden Islam, there is no such thing as Islamophobia. There are people who dislike Islam and will continue to dislike it no matter what fatuous legislation is enacted. They dislike it for perfectly good, rational, reasons: honour murders, female genital mutilation, Sharia courts, rampant postal vote fraud, trojan horse schools, hate preachers, anti-gay laws (including the death penalty), anti-women laws, anti-apostate laws (including the death penalty, anti-Semitism, etc.corrupt civil administration,
You can't compare the Terry incident with the Moazamm Begg one, particularly given that you are literally suggesting that the verdict of a court of law be subverted, presumably based on nothing. Terry was fined by the FA, but couldn't be charged by the courts because they lacked suitable evidence. My opinion? Of course Terry's a racist prick, but I respect the decision of the courts, who knew a lot more about the case than I did. And on the subject of disliking Islam (which, by the way, is the definition of Islamophobia), do you then also dislike Christianity, a religion which continues to massacre people, mutilate genitalia, regard women as second class citizens, is incredibly homophobic, has had priests convicted of paedophilia, is horribly corrupt, has justified terrorist atrocities, has been insular etc etc. or is Islam worse? Of course you can compare the Terry case with Begg's. Both were found not guilty of offences although many thought them guilty. You think Terry was guilty and a 'racist prick' for saying the word 'black'; I think Begg was guilty and attended a terrorist training camp and facilitated terrorism overseas. (The fact that Terry was fined and banned by the kangaroo court of the FA is neither here nor there.) A 'phobia' is a fear of something, not necessarily a dislike. I don't have much time for any religion, but find it hard to take seriously your comments on Christian genital mutilation (who/where?), women as second class citizens (women Bishops now!), homophobic (see many Christian priests and vicars!). As for them massacring people and justifying terrorism - it must be a strange place on planet Serial.
1. In Ethiopia, a Christian country, FGM affects around 85% of women. In other countries like Mali and Burkina Faso, where significant Christian minorities cohabit with Muslims, levels of FGM in those Christian communities is also worryingly high. FGM occurs all over Africa, whether Muslim, Christian or whatever. 2. Female clergy in one country in one strand of Christianity doth not equality make. Congo's civil war lead to the raping of tens of thousands of women in a Christian country, which is ranked, along with Christian Guatemala, as one of the top 10 worst nations to live in as a woman. Even in Western countries like Britain and America, women are dissuaded from work, and taught to be more docile than their husbands. 3. If you can't see homophobia in Christianity, you're beyond help. 4. Here is a list of 6 terrorist organisations who use Christian teachings and ideologies to justify their means, just as Al-Qaeda/IS do with Islam: [Link] Add to that the mass-murders of Anders Breivik, a radical Christian, and you realise that religious justification for atrocities is actually fairly prominent in Christianity! As a side note, I have nothing against religions. We all follow certain dogmas and superstitions, be they political, theistic, philosophical or nationalistic. Religion has done brilliant humanitarian work, brought solace to millions and provided spiritual guidance across the globe. This is as true of Islam as it is of Christianity. But what is equally true is every religion, from Scientology to Buddhism, has been manipulated for atrocious ends. So weak. You pick a few isolated examples, most of which have nothing directly to do with Christianity, and try to compare it with the worldwide defects of Islam.
|
|
|
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 5.12pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 4.37pm
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 3.59pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 9.58am
As for common and garden Islam, there is no such thing as Islamophobia. There are people who dislike Islam and will continue to dislike it no matter what fatuous legislation is enacted. They dislike it for perfectly good, rational, reasons: honour murders, female genital mutilation, Sharia courts, rampant postal vote fraud, trojan horse schools, hate preachers, anti-gay laws (including the death penalty), anti-women laws, anti-apostate laws (including the death penalty, anti-Semitism, etc.corrupt civil administration,
You can't compare the Terry incident with the Moazamm Begg one, particularly given that you are literally suggesting that the verdict of a court of law be subverted, presumably based on nothing. Terry was fined by the FA, but couldn't be charged by the courts because they lacked suitable evidence. My opinion? Of course Terry's a racist prick, but I respect the decision of the courts, who knew a lot more about the case than I did. And on the subject of disliking Islam (which, by the way, is the definition of Islamophobia), do you then also dislike Christianity, a religion which continues to massacre people, mutilate genitalia, regard women as second class citizens, is incredibly homophobic, has had priests convicted of paedophilia, is horribly corrupt, has justified terrorist atrocities, has been insular etc etc. or is Islam worse? Of course you can compare the Terry case with Begg's. Both were found not guilty of offences although many thought them guilty. You think Terry was guilty and a 'racist prick' for saying the word 'black'; I think Begg was guilty and attended a terrorist training camp and facilitated terrorism overseas. (The fact that Terry was fined and banned by the kangaroo court of the FA is neither here nor there.) A 'phobia' is a fear of something, not necessarily a dislike. I don't have much time for any religion, but find it hard to take seriously your comments on Christian genital mutilation (who/where?), women as second class citizens (women Bishops now!), homophobic (see many Christian priests and vicars!). As for them massacring people and justifying terrorism - it must be a strange place on planet Serial.
1. In Ethiopia, a Christian country, FGM affects around 85% of women. In other countries like Mali and Burkina Faso, where significant Christian minorities cohabit with Muslims, levels of FGM in those Christian communities is also worryingly high. FGM occurs all over Africa, whether Muslim, Christian or whatever. 2. Female clergy in one country in one strand of Christianity doth not equality make. Congo's civil war lead to the raping of tens of thousands of women in a Christian country, which is ranked, along with Christian Guatemala, as one of the top 10 worst nations to live in as a woman. Even in Western countries like Britain and America, women are dissuaded from work, and taught to be more docile than their husbands. 3. If you can't see homophobia in Christianity, you're beyond help. 4. Here is a list of 6 terrorist organisations who use Christian teachings and ideologies to justify their means, just as Al-Qaeda/IS do with Islam: [Link] Add to that the mass-murders of Anders Breivik, a radical Christian, and you realise that religious justification for atrocities is actually fairly prominent in Christianity! As a side note, I have nothing against religions. We all follow certain dogmas and superstitions, be they political, theistic, philosophical or nationalistic. Religion has done brilliant humanitarian work, brought solace to millions and provided spiritual guidance across the globe. This is as true of Islam as it is of Christianity. But what is equally true is every religion, from Scientology to Buddhism, has been manipulated for atrocious ends. Since when was Scientology a religion?
|
|
|
Since when was Scientology a religion?
|
|
|
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 6.10pm
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 6.03pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 5.27pm
See this view, in my mind, is hypocritical. When Egypt genitally mutilate women, it's because of Islam. Yet when Ethiopia do it, it's 'nothing directly to do with Christianity'. When Breivik massacres people, writing directly Islamophobic sentiment and calling for radical Catholicism, his religion remains out of the limelight, whereas when Muslims commit similar crimes, their religion is not only the basis for why they did it, but a virulent characteristic which inherently leads people to violence. When Congolese Christians rape women, it's 'nothing directly to do with Christianity'. When IS do similar, it is everything to do with Islam. Why? And more importantly, why do I even need to waste my time explaining that all religion is used for vicious ends, some to even greater extents than Islam has ever done (the Borges and Crusades killed more than IS ever will)? Islamic society has given us Maths, the guitar, coffee, soap, chemistry etc etc. Islamic nations like Indonesia and Turkey continue to boast some of the most incredible cultures on the planet, far more tolerant and inclusive than ours. If Islam is so evil, why are these countries so wonderful? Like I say, what follows scapegoating is ignorance, and what follows ignorance is panic. If you are afraid of something, learn more about it and you'll realise that it really isn't that bad after all. Derben, why not pop down to your local mosque and see what they have to say to your criticisms of their religion? I'm sure they'd be willing to discuss it with you. LOL. Death penalty for being an apostate from Islam, death penalty for being gay. Women stoned to death for sex 'crimes'. Authors and cartoonists threatened with death. People hung from cranes in public. So tolerant and inclusive!
Ok, maybe I was being a tad hyperbolic in the claim you highlighted, but these are just two examples of free and open Islamic democracies which share many of our moral understandings. In Turkey, which has had severe issues with gender discrimination, the TKP ran an all-women shortlist at the recent elections. Senegal has higher numbers of women in Parliament than Britain. Indonesia have independent human rights and media organisations, something many Christian countries across the world lack. Of course these countries also have many issues: homosexuality is outlawed in Senegal, the death penalty is in practice in Indonesia (but not for apostasy) and Turkey continues to oppress Armenians and Kurds. But these aren't issues specific to Muslim societies in any way shape or form, and actually these major Islamic nations are far more progressive than many of their Christian or secular neighbours. Reza Aslan is a particularly brilliant writer on this subject, I strongly recommend taking 12 minutes out of your day and listening to this: [Link] I also find your defence of LGBT groups particularly laughable given that you said in another thread that you oppose same-sex marriage!
If punk ever happened I'd be preaching the law, instead of listenin to Lydon lecture BBC4 |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote ghosteagle at 17 Jun 2015 6.30pm
Quote Mapletree at 17 Jun 2015 6.17pm
Same-sex sexual activity was legalized in the Ottoman Empire (predecessor of Turkey) in 1858 and in modern Turkey, homosexual activity has always been a legal act since the day it has founded in 1923. So a bit more liberal than good old Blighty eh? Apparently the Americans only declassified homosexuality as a mental illness in 1973. In a manner of speaking, the AMA and US Psychiatry had generally moved on from that some time before, but it was removed from the DSM (diagnostic statisticians model) with DSM-II, however it was moved to Sexual Disturbance Disorder, its not until DSM-IV (1987) that homosexuality disappeared completely (although in truth it was only really treated as a problem where individuals couldn't cope with being gay, and that was creating mental health problems).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| jamiemartin721 |
|
|---|---|
|
Turkey, among many listed above, are NOT Islamic countries, though they do have majority Muslim populations, Turkey for example is largely secularist (like pakistan, though both have increasing Islamist problems). Having a large, or dominant Muslim population doesn't make you Islamic, anymore than having a large Catholic or Protestant population makes you a Christian Country (even the US has separation of Church and State).
"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug" |
|
| derben |
|
|---|---|
|
Quote serial thriller at 18 Jun 2015 10.42am
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 6.10pm
Quote serial thriller at 17 Jun 2015 6.03pm
Quote derben at 17 Jun 2015 5.27pm
See this view, in my mind, is hypocritical. When Egypt genitally mutilate women, it's because of Islam. Yet when Ethiopia do it, it's 'nothing directly to do with Christianity'. When Breivik massacres people, writing directly Islamophobic sentiment and calling for radical Catholicism, his religion remains out of the limelight, whereas when Muslims commit similar crimes, their religion is not only the basis for why they did it, but a virulent characteristic which inherently leads people to violence. When Congolese Christians rape women, it's 'nothing directly to do with Christianity'. When IS do similar, it is everything to do with Islam. Why? And more importantly, why do I even need to waste my time explaining that all religion is used for vicious ends, some to even greater extents than Islam has ever done (the Borges and Crusades killed more than IS ever will)? Islamic society has given us Maths, the guitar, coffee, soap, chemistry etc etc. Islamic nations like Indonesia and Turkey continue to boast some of the most incredible cultures on the planet, far more tolerant and inclusive than ours. If Islam is so evil, why are these countries so wonderful? Like I say, what follows scapegoating is ignorance, and what follows ignorance is panic. If you are afraid of something, learn more about it and you'll realise that it really isn't that bad after all. Derben, why not pop down to your local mosque and see what they have to say to your criticisms of their religion? I'm sure they'd be willing to discuss it with you. LOL. Death penalty for being an apostate from Islam, death penalty for being gay. Women stoned to death for sex 'crimes'. Authors and cartoonists threatened with death. People hung from cranes in public. So tolerant and inclusive!
Ok, maybe I was being a tad hyperbolic in the claim you highlighted, but these are just two examples of free and open Islamic democracies which share many of our moral understandings. In Turkey, which has had severe issues with gender discrimination, the TKP ran an all-women shortlist at the recent elections. Senegal has higher numbers of women in Parliament than Britain. Indonesia have independent human rights and media organisations, something many Christian countries across the world lack. Of course these countries also have many issues: homosexuality is outlawed in Senegal, the death penalty is in practice in Indonesia (but not for apostasy) and Turkey continues to oppress Armenians and Kurds. But these aren't issues specific to Muslim societies in any way shape or form, and actually these major Islamic nations are far more progressive than many of their Christian or secular neighbours. Reza Aslan is a particularly brilliant writer on this subject, I strongly recommend taking 12 minutes out of your day and listening to this: [Link] I also find your defence of LGBT groups particularly laughable given that you said in another thread that you oppose same-sex marriage! Not sure I am 'defending' gay groups, merely pointing out that they are persecuted far more in Islamic countries than they are in non-Islamic countries. I don't think I have said I oppose same-sex marriage as such. I don't regard it as a true marriage, but that is another issue. The issue doesn't particularly bother me. What did bother me was that a bakery in Northern Ireland was prosecuted for declining to promote same-sex marriage on a cake - in a province where same-sex marriage is not even legal. What is laughable is you implying that women are treated well in Islamic countries - they aren't even allowed to drive a car in Saudia Arabia, apart from being stoned to death for 'sex-crimes'.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.