You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic
October 29 2026 10.36pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

The Brexit Thread (LOCKED)


Page 6 of 1552 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >
rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 21 Feb 16 10.24pm

23rd June
Better make a note of that in case I forget and it passes me by!

 

becky Flag over the moon 21 Feb 16 10.25pm

Originally posted by Slimey Toad

Sovereignty? Sovereignty? What sort of enhanced sovereignty will the average Joe enjoy when we leave?

We can go back to our former elegant dark blue and gold passports perhaps........

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 22 Feb 16 9.21am

Be brave back Boris and leave the EU!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 9.47am

I think that if we vote out, there will be a lot of disappointed people, when the UK essentially leaves the EU but addresses none of the issues they have in regards to the EU.

We'll still be part of the European Convention on Human Rights, and have the European Court as a legal arbitrator.

We'll still have EU working migration because the benefits to the corporate entities that UK governments represent will still have the same influence (which was the case even before the EU or Common Market existed).

The UK will likely end up an EU Trade Partner with a series of agreements that essentially mean we're part of the EU.

It'll cause a schism in the Conservative party same as it did in the 80s and 90s.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Hoof Hearted 22 Feb 16 10.09am

Listened to Radio 4 Today's programme this morning.

First up was Nigel Lawson who confirmed the following FACTS when questioned about how we would cope economically if we voted to leave the EU....

The UK only exports 15% of it's total exports to other EU nations.... so not as significant as the stay in camp are claiming..... but we won't lose this 15% anyway because.... (*see below EDIT)

We import over £300 Billion pounds of goods from other EU nations more than we export to them. If they are going to play games and impose tariffs on trade when we leave or other sanctions, then loads of other countries will form a queue to fill this void... but can you imagine Germany, France etc cutting off their noses to spite their face and harming their own export trade?

Economically, the EU needs us more than we need them.

Michael Fallon was interviewed - very negative all round but kept coming back to his only defence of staying in as "Better to be in the EU and shape it's future, than outside not!".

Well didn't we think Cameron has been trying to do that for the last 2 weeks and failing miserably? The rest of the EU baulked at his very tame requests this time when they knew it will shape our vote on our continued EU membership. Imagine their future reaction to our requests after we've committed ourselves to the EU?

As Tom said earlier in this thread - the EU is only ever going to expand as a Euro State with Turkey and other countries coming on board which will mean even more potential long term visitors to the UK that we cannot keep out even if we want to!

EDIT: On reflection Lawson's 15% figure looks low, but that is what he said. I've seen graphs which show the figure more as 50%, but his 2nd point remains valid.

Anyone out there who can prove or disprove Lawson's 15% claim?

Here is the interview....

[Link]

Starts about 1 hour 8 mins in from the start.

I listened again he says our exports to EU represents 15% of our economy.... which I can believe.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (22 Feb 2016 10.27am)

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 10.23am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Listened to Radio 4 Today's programme this morning.

First up was Nigel Lawson who confirmed the following FACTS when questioned about how we would cope economically if we voted to leave the EU....

The UK only exports 15% of it's total exports to other EU nations.... so not as significant as the stay in camp are claiming..... but we won't lose this 15% anyway because....

We import over £300 Billion pounds of goods from other EU nations more than we export to them. If they are going to play games and impose tariffs on trade when we leave or other sanctions, then loads of other countries will form a queue to fill this void... but can you imagine Germany, France etc cutting off their noses to spite their face and harming their own export trade?

Economically, the EU needs us more than we need them.

Michael Fallon was interviewed - very negative all round but kept coming back to his only defence of staying in as "Better to be in the EU and shape it's future, than outside not!".

Well didn't we think Cameron has been trying to do that for the last 2 weeks and failing miserably? The rest of the EU baulked at his very tame requests this time when they knew it will shape our vote on our continued EU membership. Imagine their future reaction to our requests after we've committed ourselves to the EU?

As Tom said earlier in this thread - the EU is only ever going to expand as a Euro State with Turkey and other countries coming on board which will mean even more potential long term visitors to the UK that we cannot keep out even if we want to!

Thing is, this aspect is never going to change either, because the driving force behind cheap migrant labour are corporate interests of the UK. And the government isn't going to move to prevent companies taking advantage of this, through fear of overshoring (the UK is very dependent on foreign business and investment - as you point out with the import export figures).

People seem to be tied into this idea that 'leaving the EU' will result in the UK 'taking back its borders', sending back 'foreign migrant workers' and 'stopping people coming here' - which simply isn't the case. This migration hasn't been because 'everyone wants to live here' its very cost effective for business on wages, a massive boost for private landlords and financially attractive to residents in the poorer EU countries.

That won't change. Especially given that the UK is dependent on international corporations in terms of employment.

The problem is that the membership of the EU in terms of economy, trade and migration aren't really going to be affected, at least in the short term, by an exit or stay vote (other than impacts on the stock market) - for the most part it'll make no recognisable difference - Companies will still exploit cheap labour markets and negotiate trade on the basis of mutual best interests.

Voting exit, because you want 'less foreigners long term in the UK' is as stupid as the idea that suddenly business between the EU and UK will cease. Same as the ideas on 'sovereignty'

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Feb 16 10.34am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Listened to Radio 4 Today's programme this morning.

First up was Nigel Lawson who confirmed the following FACTS when questioned about how we would cope economically if we voted to leave the EU....

The UK only exports 15% of it's total exports to other EU nations.... so not as significant as the stay in camp are claiming..... but we won't lose this 15% anyway because.... (*see below EDIT)

We import over £300 Billion pounds of goods from other EU nations more than we export to them. If they are going to play games and impose tariffs on trade when we leave or other sanctions, then loads of other countries will form a queue to fill this void... but can you imagine Germany, France etc cutting off their noses to spite their face and harming their own export trade?

Economically, the EU needs us more than we need them.

Michael Fallon was interviewed - very negative all round but kept coming back to his only defence of staying in as "Better to be in the EU and shape it's future, than outside not!".

Well didn't we think Cameron has been trying to do that for the last 2 weeks and failing miserably? The rest of the EU baulked at his very tame requests this time when they knew it will shape our vote on our continued EU membership. Imagine their future reaction to our requests after we've committed ourselves to the EU?

As Tom said earlier in this thread - the EU is only ever going to expand as a Euro State with Turkey and other countries coming on board which will mean even more potential long term visitors to the UK that we cannot keep out even if we want to!

EDIT: On reflection Lawson's 15% figure looks low, but that is what he said. I've seen graphs which show the figure more as 50%, but his 2nd point remains valid.

Anyone out there who can prove or disprove Lawson's 15% claim?

Here is the interview....

[Link]

Starts about 1 hour 8 mins in from the start.

I listened again he says our exports to EU represents 15% of our economy.... which I can believe.

Edited by Hoof Hearted (22 Feb 2016 10.27am)

I think it's roughly 50% EU and 50% non EU on imports and exports, exports more invisible.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Feb 16 10.36am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Thing is, this aspect is never going to change either, because the driving force behind cheap migrant labour are corporate interests of the UK. And the government isn't going to move to prevent companies taking advantage of this, through fear of overshoring (the UK is very dependent on foreign business and investment - as you point out with the import export figures).

People seem to be tied into this idea that 'leaving the EU' will result in the UK 'taking back its borders', sending back 'foreign migrant workers' and 'stopping people coming here' - which simply isn't the case. This migration hasn't been because 'everyone wants to live here' its very cost effective for business on wages, a massive boost for private landlords and financially attractive to residents in the poorer EU countries.

That won't change. Especially given that the UK is dependent on international corporations in terms of employment.

The problem is that the membership of the EU in terms of economy, trade and migration aren't really going to be affected, at least in the short term, by an exit or stay vote (other than impacts on the stock market) - for the most part it'll make no recognisable difference - Companies will still exploit cheap labour markets and negotiate trade on the basis of mutual best interests.

Voting exit, because you want 'less foreigners long term in the UK' is as stupid as the idea that suddenly business between the EU and UK will cease. Same as the ideas on 'sovereignty'

Jamie - with respect this response is nonsense.

Just like when you go on holiday, your kids have a party and it gets out of hand, you return and turf out the gate crashers and restore order.

For the last 20 years, the UK has been acting like the above analogy.

If we vote out I will be surprised if we don't adopt the same strategy as Australia... a points based immigration system which we will be able to control, just like Australia does. We will be able to control our borders.... we cannot now because of EU law.

 

Hoof Hearted 22 Feb 16 10.38am

Originally posted by chris123

I think it's roughly 50% EU and 50% non EU on imports and exports, exports more invisible.

Thanks Chris.

See the last line of my EDIT.... and listen to the interview...

Lawson actually says our exports to EU represent 15% of our economy.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 22 Feb 16 10.47am

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Thing is, this aspect is never going to change either, because the driving force behind cheap migrant labour are corporate interests of the UK. And the government isn't going to move to prevent companies taking advantage of this, through fear of overshoring (the UK is very dependent on foreign business and investment - as you point out with the import export figures).

People seem to be tied into this idea that 'leaving the EU' will result in the UK 'taking back its borders', sending back 'foreign migrant workers' and 'stopping people coming here' - which simply isn't the case. This migration hasn't been because 'everyone wants to live here' its very cost effective for business on wages, a massive boost for private landlords and financially attractive to residents in the poorer EU countries.

That won't change. Especially given that the UK is dependent on international corporations in terms of employment.

The problem is that the membership of the EU in terms of economy, trade and migration aren't really going to be affected, at least in the short term, by an exit or stay vote (other than impacts on the stock market) - for the most part it'll make no recognisable difference - Companies will still exploit cheap labour markets and negotiate trade on the basis of mutual best interests.

Voting exit, because you want 'less foreigners long term in the UK' is as stupid as the idea that suddenly business between the EU and UK will cease. Same as the ideas on 'sovereignty'


With respect – your post is utter rubbish.
Entire neighbourhoods have changed massively since the Eastern European countries joined the EU.
There are now over 1 million Poles alone who have moved to the country in the past 12 years. (let alone all the other nationalities).
That’s 1 million people who were not living here before 2004.

Get it? These Polish weren’t here before Poland joined the EU, they are here now!

So to say that by leaving the EU will make no difference to the amount of people who move here is possibly the most ridiculous thing I have heard on this site Jamie.

Years ago people used to say that in London the streets were paved in gold. Now people say the streets are paved with Poles!

As for cooperate interests – if you asked a large corporation if they wish to pay tax – they would say no! if you asked a large corporation if they wanted to adhere to paying the minimum wage – they would say no! what’s in the interests of large corporations is not always in the interests of the British people.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

chris123 Flag hove actually 22 Feb 16 10.54am

Originally posted by Hoof Hearted

Thanks Chris.

See the last line of my EDIT.... and listen to the interview...

Lawson actually says our exports to EU represent 15% of our economy.

ok - didn't see that, seems a daft way to express something that drives the balance of payments, but he's the ex Chancellor I guess!

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 10.55am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


With respect – your post is utter rubbish.
Entire neighbourhoods have changed massively since the Eastern European countries joined the EU.
There are now over 1 million Poles alone who have moved to the country in the past 12 years. (let alone all the other nationalities).
That’s 1 million people who were not living here before 2004.

Get it? These Polish weren’t here before Poland joined the EU, they are here now!

So to say that by leaving the EU will make no difference to the amount of people who move here is possibly the most ridiculous thing I have heard on this site Jamie.

Years ago people used to say that in London the streets were paved in gold. Now people say the streets are paved with Poles!

As for cooperate interests – if you asked a large corporation if they wish to pay tax – they would say no! if you asked a large corporation if they wanted to adhere to paying the minimum wage – they would say no! what’s in the interests of large corporations is not always in the interests of the British people.

What I'm saying is regardless of the vote, in or out, without radical change in government, there will be no change. Corporate interests drive the EU, and they drive the UK.

Oddly, if I thought it would result in an outcome that reduced the competition for wages in the lower working classes, I'd be first in line to vote 'out'.

I don't disagree that the EU Freedom of Movement resulted in a massive disruption in the flow of migration. Problem is that is a symptom of a problem, which benefits probably the most influential lobby group in the UK - Business interests - and these interests have just as much influence over the UK government as the EU, probably more.

Exiting the EU won't change those influences, and their ability to leverage government (bear in mind these interests are the economy and employment in the UK). All that will happen is 'more of the same' with a different name.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 22 Feb 16 11.21am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


With respect – your post is utter rubbish.
Entire neighbourhoods have changed massively since the Eastern European countries joined the EU.
There are now over 1 million Poles alone who have moved to the country in the past 12 years. (let alone all the other nationalities).
That’s 1 million people who were not living here before 2004.

Get it? These Polish weren’t here before Poland joined the EU, they are here now!

So to say that by leaving the EU will make no difference to the amount of people who move here is possibly the most ridiculous thing I have heard on this site Jamie.

Years ago people used to say that in London the streets were paved in gold. Now people say the streets are paved with Poles!

As for cooperate interests – if you asked a large corporation if they wish to pay tax – they would say no! if you asked a large corporation if they wanted to adhere to paying the minimum wage – they would say no! what’s in the interests of large corporations is not always in the interests of the British people.

350,000 Polish have moved on. 675,000 are here now. My oldest friend has married one of them.

NHS dentist. Looking after our nation's oral health. How dare they?

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


npn Flag Crowborough 22 Feb 16 11.43am

Originally posted by Kermit8

350,000 Polish have moved on. 675,000 are here now. My oldest friend has married one of them.

NHS dentist. Looking after our nation's oral health. How dare they?

With respect, Kerms, I think you're muddying the waters a bit there.

If we left the EU (though I have yet to see any detail on what would happen) I assume a qualified dentist would have no trouble getting in on a working visa in any case.

I think it's important to separate the "I hate foreigners" brigade (which exists, I fully admit) from the "I think they should not have an automatic right to come in and work" argument. I don't think (although, again, I've yet to see anyone actually make a bloody argument with some details) anyone is advocating locking the border and not allowing anyone in, more that the UK should have the right to accept or decline people entry as it sees fit, rather than being forced to accept people based on which country they come from.

Still firmly on the fence - I'll have an @rse full of splinters before June!

To put the tin lid on it, my best mate lives in Spain (and has done for years) and I don't know where a brexit would leave him and his family either.

Hopefully someone, at some point, will actually have some sort of debate that doesn't just end up as a "you're all racists" versus "you want to be ruled by Brussels" argument. I won't be holding my breath though

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 22 Feb 16 12.10pm

Originally posted by npn

With respect, Kerms, I think you're muddying the waters a bit there.

If we left the EU (though I have yet to see any detail on what would happen) I assume a qualified dentist would have no trouble getting in on a working visa in any case.

I think it's important to separate the "I hate foreigners" brigade (which exists, I fully admit) from the "I think they should not have an automatic right to come in and work" argument. I don't think (although, again, I've yet to see anyone actually make a bloody argument with some details) anyone is advocating locking the border and not allowing anyone in, more that the UK should have the right to accept or decline people entry as it sees fit, rather than being forced to accept people based on which country they come from.

Still firmly on the fence - I'll have an @rse full of splinters before June!

To put the tin lid on it, my best mate lives in Spain (and has done for years) and I don't know where a brexit would leave him and his family either.

Hopefully someone, at some point, will actually have some sort of debate that doesn't just end up as a "you're all racists" versus "you want to be ruled by Brussels" argument. I won't be holding my breath though

I get what you say and well said it is too.

I do believe, however, that without the foreign care workers, waiters, pub staff, labourers, fruit and veg pickers - and there must be many hundreds of thousands of them from the EU here- we will struggle to maintain our standards of living. Add the potential of lost jobs from the extra costs of trading and one or two other negatives of Brexit already mentioned it feels like the 'Out' campaign is very much using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

I don't see those workers being allowed into the country if we had a points based system or if they were red-tape would rear its ugly and expensive head.

Cameron and around 75% of the cabinet think it is wiser to stay. The others want to risk what we already have and roll the dice with fingers crossed hoping it comes up a '7'.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 22 Feb 16 12.24pm

Originally posted by npn

Hopefully someone, at some point, will actually have some sort of debate that doesn't just end up as a "you're all racists" versus "you want to be ruled by Brussels" argument. I won't be holding my breath though

And of course the cries of "Little Englanders" and all that hogwash.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 12.33pm

Originally posted by npn

With respect, Kerms, I think you're muddying the waters a bit there.

If we left the EU (though I have yet to see any detail on what would happen) I assume a qualified dentist would have no trouble getting in on a working visa in any case.

I think it's important to separate the "I hate foreigners" brigade (which exists, I fully admit) from the "I think they should not have an automatic right to come in and work" argument. I don't think (although, again, I've yet to see anyone actually make a bloody argument with some details) anyone is advocating locking the border and not allowing anyone in, more that the UK should have the right to accept or decline people entry as it sees fit, rather than being forced to accept people based on which country they come from.

Still firmly on the fence - I'll have an @rse full of splinters before June!

To put the tin lid on it, my best mate lives in Spain (and has done for years) and I don't know where a brexit would leave him and his family either.

Hopefully someone, at some point, will actually have some sort of debate that doesn't just end up as a "you're all racists" versus "you want to be ruled by Brussels" argument. I won't be holding my breath though

I quite agree with this, there is a necessity for the good of the nation to limit low skill migrant workers - and instead focus on shifting people already UK citizens into areas where the demand is such, that it cannot be filled locally.

The problem of EU Working legislation isn't so much the numbers, its that it increases competition for jobs, and that in turn reduces wages. A consequence of this means that its viable for someone from the EU, to work a minimum wage job in the UK, because they don't have the huge overheads that someone with a family has, and they have the capacity to move to areas where there is demand.

The other option is of course to subsidise the employment of UK Citizens into areas of employment demand from areas with high unemployment (which is more expensive for the state, but in long term goals results in increased employment).

But the problem is, that for the state and business its a better deal to use 'temporary migrant labour' (profit for the state and for business).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 12.35pm

Originally posted by Kermit8

I get what you say and well said it is too.

I do believe, however, that without the foreign care workers, waiters, pub staff, labourers, fruit and veg pickers - and there must be many hundreds of thousands of them from the EU here- we will struggle to maintain our standards of living. Add the potential of lost jobs from the extra costs of trading and one or two other negatives of Brexit already mentioned it feels like the 'Out' campaign is very much using a sledgehammer to crack a nut.

I don't see those workers being allowed into the country if we had a points based system or if they were red-tape would rear its ugly and expensive head.

Cameron and around 75% of the cabinet think it is wiser to stay. The others want to risk what we already have and roll the dice with fingers crossed hoping it comes up a '7'.

Well yes, if you suddenly removed 650,000 people from employment, inflation would likely go wild. Any transfer would need to be graduated over probably a decade, or subsidised by the state replacing workers from the unemployed on a one to one basis (with subsidisation for the worker).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 22 Feb 16 12.56pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

What I'm saying is regardless of the vote, in or out, without radical change in government, there will be no change. Corporate interests drive the EU, and they drive the UK.

Oddly, if I thought it would result in an outcome that reduced the competition for wages in the lower working classes, I'd be first in line to vote 'out'.

I don't disagree that the EU Freedom of Movement resulted in a massive disruption in the flow of migration. Problem is that is a symptom of a problem, which benefits probably the most influential lobby group in the UK - Business interests - and these interests have just as much influence over the UK government as the EU, probably more.

Exiting the EU won't change those influences, and their ability to leverage government (bear in mind these interests are the economy and employment in the UK). All that will happen is 'more of the same' with a different name.

You are broadly correct but what does change things is votes.
Any party who promises a reduction in immigrants will get votes. Any party who actually delivers it will likely remain in government.
The Tories have little power to do so at present but if we come out of Europe then they will have little excuse and neither will any other party. Yes business is the driving force but votes are what matter more to politicians. How much longer can they fool the public with with misdirection and propaganda?

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 22 Feb 16 1.33pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

You are broadly correct but what does change things is votes.
Any party who promises a reduction in immigrants will get votes. Any party who actually delivers it will likely remain in government.
The Tories have little power to do so at present but if we come out of Europe then they will have little excuse and neither will any other party. Yes business is the driving force but votes are what matter more to politicians. How much longer can they fool the public with with misdirection and propaganda?

Quite a bit, as we saw with Scottish Independence - in the run up to the referendum. Fear, nonsense and hyperbole will be bouncing around for the next four or five months, with both sides feeding on the paranoia, and ultimately, it'll result in zero change. Even if we do go 'out', in likelihood the actual reality will be minimal change, a few cosmetic gestures and business as usual.

I'm leaning more towards an out than an in. Whilst there are elements of the EU and membership that appeal to me, the EU exists primarily as a means of exerting Corporate pressure on other countries, including member states (things like TTIP, Tax sheltering, EU trade regulations and Freedom of Movement seriously concern me as they represent unaccountable interests).

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 6 of 1552 < 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 >

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Topic